Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how increasing interest rates will possibly help people?

42 replies

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 17/03/2022 16:03

I might be really dim in my comprehension of this, but my understanding of interest rates is that they are increased and reduced to help control inflation - and to temper people's over-optimism in luxury/optional spending.

How on earth does this work when a huge cause of inflation is gas, electricity (more huge rises still pending), petrol, diesel and food prices (not to mention the increase in NI contributions, although that's most probably not included in the calculations)?

How is this not just rubbing salt into the wound and deliberately kicking most of us to the ground - when the absolute basics on which most of us have very little leeway or choice but to pay for are rocketing and about to plunge many previously-managing households into poverty and the already-struggling deeper into it?

I get that it's rough for savers, but it's been like that for a very long time now - and even when interest rates are higher, most banks are extremely reluctant to pass them on to savers anyway.

Am I missing something here? How is increasing the cost of mortgages meant to encourage us to stop using gas and electricity or give up food? Either way, it's another way for those ruling over us to demonstrate their complete lack of knowledge or care about what life is like for the ordinary majority.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Belladonna12 · 18/03/2022 12:30

Increased interest rates only affect day to day disposable income spending as a knock on effect in that people are more encouraged by higher interest rates to save money instead of spend money. But we won’t see this we have a cost of living crisis so disposable incomes are dropping and banks are not passing on the interest % rises to the usual high street savings accounts.

Disposable incomes are dropping but that doesn't mean nobody can save. Some people can and some will save the money to buy stuff rather than borrowing money. It's not true that no banks are passing on the interest rate rises. If people shop around they will often get good rates and these are increasing.

EmpressCixi · 18/03/2022 11:23

@LakieLady hit it on the head

But what we have is not demand-pull inflation, but cost-push inflation.
Increasing interest rates will have negligible effect on that.

In addition, raising interest rates mostly affects one type of spending...the spending on credit or borrowing of money.

Increased interest rates only affect day to day disposable income spending as a knock on effect in that people are more encouraged by higher interest rates to save money instead of spend money. But we won’t see this we have a cost of living crisis so disposable incomes are dropping and banks are not passing on the interest % rises to the usual high street savings accounts.

Nothappyatwork · 18/03/2022 10:49

@lonelyapple

Interest rates should actually be far higher considering real inflation is probably something like 15%. Keeping interest rates low only helps those in debt (including companies) whilst punishing savers who have been frugal. The whole thing is a disincentive to "do the right thing" and has totally distorted the housing market amongst other things. Hopefully they will be at least 2% by the end of the year.
Well given the number of companies who are actually only still in business due to the government bounce back loans last year, there will be an absolutely enormous amount of small to medium size business is that go bust in the event of a raise it interest rates who will then default on the loans hence I really do not see any major raises being in the governments best interests .
lonelyapple · 18/03/2022 10:42

Interest rates should actually be far higher considering real inflation is probably something like 15%. Keeping interest rates low only helps those in debt (including companies) whilst punishing savers who have been frugal. The whole thing is a disincentive to "do the right thing" and has totally distorted the housing market amongst other things. Hopefully they will be at least 2% by the end of the year.

Belladonna12 · 18/03/2022 10:14

@DrManhattan

More interest on your savings, thats if the bank pass the increase on to their customers that is....
Some banks will.
beddygu · 18/03/2022 09:23

agree with @sst1234, the economy is fucked & I don't know how they fix it. Far too much reliance on QE which has inflated assets & devalued wages. No investment in economy so low productivity & with the backdrop of an ageing population.

DrManhattan · 18/03/2022 09:21

More interest on your savings, thats if the bank pass the increase on to their customers that is....

Belladonna12 · 18/03/2022 08:47

Are you suggesting that a rise in interest rates will encourage pepole to save?! Do you really think that after 2 years of a crap relatively joyless life during the pandemic that people are going to think "oh well, I think I'll keep that £10k in savings after all now as I'll get 200 quid a year from it at these rates!"??? I very much doubt it. Nearly everybody I know who is lucky enough to have a cushion of savings is thinking life is too short to be keeping that 10k locked away for the sake of 200 quid and are thinking about using it to have a bit of enjoyment in their life like going on the holiday of a lifetime.

I said that is the theory, not that it will definitely happen. No I don't think being able to make £200 will make those with 10k less likely to spend it. Interest rates are still very low though. I think this is just the beginning of interest rate rises and there may come a point where savings make a lot of money as in the late 80s/early90s

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 17/03/2022 22:57

The vast majority of these mortgages are fixed rate, leaving just the 1.1m on SVR and 0.8m on trackers as the only ones who will be affected by increased mortgage rates. This is not "most of us".

OK, then - 'only' about 3-4m adults. Will those fixed rates that most of the lucky others have last forever, then, and never be affected by increases that get going apace now?

OP posts:
Changechangychange · 17/03/2022 22:33

I don’t think the government or the Bank of England give a flying fuck about whether ordinary people can afford their gas bills. This is to keep down wage bills for employers.

OfstedOffred · 17/03/2022 22:16

It's not about individuals.

It's about the whole economy which includes corporates.

There is some doubt though that interest rate rises even work to limit supply inflation.

sst1234 · 17/03/2022 22:07

Raising interest right now is nothing short of desperation for central banks as they have run out of ideas. Traditionally, interest rates are used to dampen demand and reduce borrowing. That would be all well and good if that money that people are spending had come from increased productivity. It didn’t. It came from printing money like it was going out of fashion and it made it way into assets while production actually ceased because of pointless lockdowns. Production still hasn’t caught up, commodity prices have risen enormously and interest rates will cause people to spend less. That’s a recipe for the dreaded combo - stagflation.
Central bankers are officially out of ideas after 15 years of printing money like brain dead zombies.

Nothappyatwork · 17/03/2022 22:02

@mumda

Some landlords might out money into savings if bank interest rates were worthwhile.
They are hardly going to sell in a downturn are they 🤦‍♀️ Due to inflation as a first time buyer every single person I’ve been competing against to buy my House has been a landlord. And the turnaround has been spectacularly quick properties have been sold to completion within six weeks weeks seven it’s on the market for £400 more than I know the mortgage would’ve been if I put down 25% deposit they probably bought it for cash let’s be honest. And rented out by week eight £900 per calendar month for a two bed terrace.
jcyclops · 17/03/2022 22:01

Figures quoted are approx.
Of the 23m households in the country, 8.6m are rented, 8m are owned outright, leaving 6.4m with mortgages. The vast majority of these mortgages are fixed rate, leaving just the 1.1m on SVR and 0.8m on trackers as the only ones who will be affected by increased mortgage rates. This is not "most of us".

mumda · 17/03/2022 21:39

Some landlords might out money into savings if bank interest rates were worthwhile.

spudjulia · 17/03/2022 21:29

It will have an effect on house prices. It will be more expensive to borrow an amount of money.

spudjulia · 17/03/2022 21:21

not dim at all, OP. Interest rates do affect inflation because of the reason you said. It reduces demand and therefore puts a downward pressure on prices (in general) Higher interest rates do prompt some people to save rather than spend, and also makes borrowing more expensive so that people don't put a holiday on a credit card, or get a new sofa on tick, and reduces demand that way.

Like you say, though, the very products that are really driving inflation at the moment are inelastic - demand won't respond dramatically to price rises. We might take a few steps to reduce our energy consumption, but we can't avoid eating/heating our homes and there are no easy alternatives.

On the one hand, there are plenty of people who can afford the increased prices of energy, fuel, food and it might mean their demand for other goods has to reduce to compensate. So demand (in general, on average, over the whole spectrum of goods in the CPI basket) has fallen. On the other hand, some people wont be able to afford the increases and they'll really struggle and go without one thing or another - food or heat. People do that already, and the number is about to grow. As a PP mentioned, this isn't to help people. It's just a blunt tool to put downward pressure on prices.

Lockheart · 17/03/2022 20:27

@CurlyhairedAssassin part of the reason mortgages are so large now is because borrowing has never been cheaper, because interest rates are so low. People can now afford to borrow 5x their salary.

When interest rates are higher, banks will be wary of lending as much as they do now because people are less likely to be able to borrow e.g. 5x their salary and still afford the repayments. So higher interest rates could well reduce the amount buyers can borrow and we could potentially see a return to 2.5x or 3x mortgages.

The problem with that of course is that if buyers can't borrow, house prices will have to fall significantly from the over-inflated prices they currently are...

CurlyhairedAssassin · 17/03/2022 19:49

@Belladonna12

Money isn't just been spent on food and heating. Some people are buying other things and if interest rates rise they might save the money instead which in theory may reduce inflation.
Are you suggesting that a rise in interest rates will encourage pepole to save?! Do you really think that after 2 years of a crap relatively joyless life during the pandemic that people are going to think "oh well, I think I'll keep that £10k in savings after all now as I'll get 200 quid a year from it at these rates!"??? I very much doubt it. Nearly everybody I know who is lucky enough to have a cushion of savings is thinking life is too short to be keeping that 10k locked away for the sake of 200 quid and are thinking about using it to have a bit of enjoyment in their life like going on the holiday of a lifetime.

Others with savings are saving it not because they will make more money because of the higher interest rates but because they are worried about affordability of the basics of life, either for themselves or for their adult children for whom life is considerably worse than their own in terms of affordability and they want to be able to pay for university costs, or childcare costs for grandchildren etc, or give them money towards their first house because they are shocked that 2 people on fulltime professional salaries have to live in the same kind of house that when their own generation was buying, was bought by warehouse foreman and his wife who worked pt in Sayers.

What does need to happen is some kind of PROPER restriction on house prices based on income. At the moment, stress tests seem to be "how much can we get away with lending people so that they aren't going to default on the payments?" It shouldn't be the case that they take every last earned penny into account of both members of a couple, for example, and offer them a mortgage at the very top of what the lender thinks they can afford.

Years ago when we got our first mortgage in 1999 and looking at the maximum you could get everyone was guided by the formula of "3 times a single person's salary" or "2.5 times a couple's salary". What the fuck happened to that? Just why have lenders been allowed to get away with offering more and more money? Buyers have been forced to spend beyond their means on housing for far too long, and THIS is what has made housing costs spiral out of control. Together with buy to let mortgages which has had people buying second/third homes or whole porfolios as investments and not to live in.

But I guess the people in charge of the country have absolutely no interest in reducing the amount they can rake in in property price increases. There is no incentive to put any restrictions on mortgages, both for owner occupiers or landlords, no incentive to have a massive country-wide post-war style house-building scheme, as they know this would bring house prices down. Less profit for themselves.

LakieLady · 17/03/2022 19:46

@User76745333

It isn’t supposed to help people. The point is to curb demand
But what we have is not demand-pull inflation, but cost-push inflation.

Increasing interest rates will have negligible effect on that.

LikeALeadBalloon · 17/03/2022 19:20

Agree OP! OH convinced me to go for the variable mortgage offer late last year after years of fixed. I stupidly gave into his argument re the interest rates being low for so long and now I'm worried that they're going to keep rising and we'll have yet another big increase in our monthly outgoings.

Belladonna12 · 17/03/2022 19:20

Money isn't just been spent on food and heating. Some people are buying other things and if interest rates rise they might save the money instead which in theory may reduce inflation.

Lockheart · 17/03/2022 19:08

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

Even if they somehow don't include the cost of energy and food in their figures, the 'top experts' at the BoE must be very poor indeed at their job if they don't realise that the majority of people are going to be forced to spend far less on consumer goods very soon, whether they like it or not.

Then again, I suppose, if you're on £500K+ a year, it probably just doesn't enter your radar that ordinary people don't have anything like the same consumer choices as you do. You probably see it that the energy companies will take all of the trouble of calculating and adjusting the amount your direct debit for you, so what possible bother could it cause you?

Well not quite, it's more that they're operating on the level of managing the economy of an entire country and not just a single household. They have to think that way because they're dealing with billions of national debt and expenditure, and not my Tesco shopping list.

And it's not about encouraging people to spend less on heat and food, it's about encouraging less big borrowing, again, on the national scale.

Darley368 · 17/03/2022 19:05

Yes I agree OP. Interest rates have always been a very blunt instrument but in the current circumstances they are likely to be a fairly ineffective one too. They also fail to take account of the fact we don't live in a closed economy (wealthy individuals and businesses find it very easy to move). A lot of pain for very little gain.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 17/03/2022 18:32

Even if they somehow don't include the cost of energy and food in their figures, the 'top experts' at the BoE must be very poor indeed at their job if they don't realise that the majority of people are going to be forced to spend far less on consumer goods very soon, whether they like it or not.

Then again, I suppose, if you're on £500K+ a year, it probably just doesn't enter your radar that ordinary people don't have anything like the same consumer choices as you do. You probably see it that the energy companies will take all of the trouble of calculating and adjusting the amount your direct debit for you, so what possible bother could it cause you?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread