Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask school mum to leave my mum alone?

161 replies

Irritatedmum · 17/03/2022 15:58

There’s a mum at the school who’s DD is friends with mine.

She’s nice enough but for one reason or another she’s struggling. I haven’t got much in common with her, we’re not really friends.

When my mum takes my children to school she often chats with this mum, and they’re friends on social media.

But the school mum has started asking my mum for things. This has included borrowing things, lifts, and doing the school run for her when she can’t for whatever reason. And it winds me up. I feel like she’s taking the piss, she should be asking one of the other parents who live near to her, not a grandparent who is already doing someone a favour by being there. My mum is a softy and would ever say no to anybody. I feel sorry her struggles but I don’t want my mum to get sucked into them either.

AIBU to ask her nicely to leave my mum alone? Or is it none of my business?

OP posts:
Irritatedmum · 17/03/2022 17:20

@crispmidnightpeace I dunno, I guess they must, which is weird considering the age gap (40 ish years). But it happens I guess! And she probably feels maternal towards someone with problems which is understandable. And mum and I are very different, so she might bond with different people, I do get that. Maybe I’m just being suspicious for no reason (the person who said I was feeling protective got it spot on maybe)

OP posts:
LittleGwyneth · 17/03/2022 17:19

The reaction here is bonkers. I would feel equally protective of my mum, who is one of the best people in the world and would struggle to say no to someone who was in need. I would have a quiet word and say something like 'listen my mum is such a sweetheart, she's not always the best as setting boundaries. If you need something please ask me, but it's not really appropriate to ask her.'

Rosehugger · 17/03/2022 17:19

I wouldn't say anything but I'd talk to my mum about it regularly, keeping it casual, but finding out about their relationship to make sure she isn't being taken advatange of - particularly financially.

WonderfulYou · 17/03/2022 17:18

YABU because either your mum doesn’t want to do it and needs to be the one to say no or she does want to do it so will carry on regardless.

Nothing you will say is going to make this mum stop asking your mum to do things as she’s getting lots out of it - you would be better to encourage your mum to help less but putting it in a way that sounds like her helping less is actually beneficial to this other women.

crispmidnightpeace · 17/03/2022 17:15

@Irritatedmum

My mum’s bored, and lonely, and would do anything for anyone. I don’t think she’d know whether someone was taking advantage. I just don’t get why this mum won’t ask any of the other mums instead? There are mums who walk pretty much past her door, for my mum it means driving out of her way.
Maybe they just genuinely like each other's company?
Irritatedmum · 17/03/2022 17:15

@Cookiecrumble22 I didn’t say it to be nasty - I was just making the point that this isn’t a ‘normal family’ for want of a better word. There are issues.

OP posts:
Restlessrose · 17/03/2022 17:14

I wouldn't get involved if my mum was helping somebody out who was having a tough time.

What does somebody who looks like they have social services involvement look like? What a nasty thing to say.

You say your mum is too nice etc. Well with comments like that if wouldn't be hard to be seen as too nice by you, would it really?

Of course if she's being taken for a ride financially or whatever, get involved. But really, if it's a quid or two for some milk and bread, or a diversion in the car for a few pence of petrol, it doesn't sound like extortion.

If none of the other mums speak to her and your mum does, why wouldn't she reach out to the only person she can for help? It must be horrible to be ostracised by all the other mums and judged for no reason. Maybe that's why she doesn't ask anyone else, because even though they live closer to her they are horrible to her. People know when people are bitching about them, they know when they are being judged, when other people don't like them.

Maybe your Mum is more kind hearted, and this other Mum is just grateful to have a friend. Maybe she is taking advantage, it would depend what she's actually receiving. Helps with lift sometimes and a few quid when she's short? I couldn't get upset about that. Especially if your mum gives that freely.

Irritatedmum · 17/03/2022 17:13

I don’t have any sort of problem with the women personally, there’s no beef between us. She seems nice enough, but has very obvious issues. No, I’m not jealous about my mum’s time, that just wouldn’t happen. I’m concerned about my mum getting taken advantage of. I obviously don’t want to give details of what she’s lent out but at this point it’s not about value, it’s about how often it’s happening and my mum’s time. I’m sure I don’t know the half of it but she was asked to give a lift over 30 miles away - not to this woman, but to her brother. I know that was turned down but I don’t know what else has been asked for.

Thanks for calling me vile, faceless stranger. I’m not just saying they’ve got an untidy garden or their children have got stained clothes, I’m talking real troubling stuff about this family that I’m not putting into detail here. I only mentioned it to make the point that we aren’t talking about just an ‘ordinary family’. But I guess that’s irrelevant really.

I appreciate everyone taking the time to reply, I can see all points of view here (but wish some of you were a bit less rude). The majority seems to be to leave her to it, and I will, but I really do hope none of your parents are ever in the same position.

OP posts:
AngelinaFibres · 17/03/2022 17:10

@Irritatedmum

My mum’s bored, and lonely, and would do anything for anyone. I don’t think she’d know whether someone was taking advantage. I just don’t get why this mum won’t ask any of the other mums instead? There are mums who walk pretty much past her door, for my mum it means driving out of her way.
She has recognised that your mum is a soft touch. Cheeky fuckers have a special ability to do this. She knows that other people will happily say no.
ChateauMargaux · 17/03/2022 17:09

Instead, could you get some of the other school Mum's to get a rota together to help her out with the school run.. shoulder the burden as a community... including perhaps including your Mum in the rota if she is willing.

Porfre · 17/03/2022 17:07

Personally after what you say about your mum, I'd be getting involved.

I wouldn't have the same issue with my mum, she is way more confident than me, but if I was concerned then I'd get involved.

grapehyacinthisactuallyblue · 17/03/2022 17:04

Isn't that up to her to decide? She's an adult, and she became friends with her. It's a bit odd to dictate someone else's friendship, unless she actually said to you that she needed your help because she couldn't say no.

Meandthesky · 17/03/2022 16:56

Your mum is an adult who is clearly capable enough to do you favours.

If she’s happy to help this woman out then there’s no issue. If she’s not, then she needs to deal with it herself and say no to requests.

Cookiecrumble22 · 17/03/2022 16:54

Have you actually asked your mum how she feels? You said your mum gers a bit bored and lonely . So maybe she likes doing it. But if it is to much for your mum. Maybe she clubs say she's sorry but she won't be able to pick her kids up anymore with the cost of petrol on the up she can't afford it.

If you told her to leave your mum alone your mum may well feel very embarrassed.

There was no need for the social service comment that was pretty nasty. (If) she does need help from them them she's clearly struggling and needs help/support she may have no one.

If she is asking people on social media for money and things. It's down to then people to say no.

MalagaNights · 17/03/2022 16:54

I get why this bothers you.

But:

Have your mother and this women become 'friendly' and now your mother wants to help.

Or:

Is this women focusing on your mother as she seems like a push over and your mother would just do anything?

Does your mother lack boundaries to say no, be aloof etc?

If they're friendly back off it's non of your business.

If she's taking advantage talk to your mum.

Ultimately though if after all that I genuinely thought someone was taking advantage of my mother I'd say something to put some boundaries in place.

TopCatsTopHat · 17/03/2022 16:52

personally I would talk to my mum, and just give her some insight into the character she is dealing with (cf asking for money via social media), give her the heads up that the other mum might be the sort of person to take advantage of a giving nature and you wouldn't want to see that happen.
You can ask if she's comfortable with the level of favours being asked but suggest that she watches out for getting in too deep. You can caveat it with you could be wrong and the lady won't take a mile instead of an inch but given what you've seen on social media you would not be a caring daughter if you didn't offer a word of caution.
Then just keep an eye on it. Unless your mum admits she'd like to say no but doesn't feel she can, in which case come up with a strategy together

DisappearingGirl · 17/03/2022 16:52

I get where you're coming from OP, I wouldn't want my mum to be taken advantage of either, especially if she was a gullible sort (mine isn't!!).

But I think I would deal with it via your mum not via the school mum.

I would just say that if she wants to help her out then great, but not to feel obliged, and would definitely be advising her not to hand over money etc. If your mum is forewarned it might make it easier for her to say no to any requests she's not comfortable with.

pasturesgreen · 17/03/2022 16:48

@FloraFoxx

If your dm is lonely and happy to help out then what is the problem?
This. My dad is retired and bored and jumps at the chance to help neighbours or friends, it helps pass the time and makes him feel useful. Your dm might be perfectly happy to help out, talk to her first.
cherrysthename · 17/03/2022 16:46

You'd probably really embarrass your mum if you did this, not to mention its infantilising. It's fine if you're not as nice as she is, but she is the one who will be left dealing with the awkwardness and embarrassment of you being rude on her behalf.

TabithaTittlemouse · 17/03/2022 16:46

Your mum sounds quite capable, you trust her with your children? Why are you treating her like she’s incapable of making friends?

Social services being involved could mean literally anything and you sound vile for trying to use this to make her look bad.

I wouldn’t dream of telling my parents who they could associate with.

Kaleidoscope2 · 17/03/2022 16:46

@Irritatedmum hard as it is then I'd say that's my second point and you have to leave her to it. Probably not what you wanted to hear and it's hard not to feel like you want to step in especially if it's not in your nature to do the same as her but it might actually make your mum feel better knowing she's doing something to help this person rather than ignoring it if she feels she's in a position to help.

Hoghedge10 · 17/03/2022 16:45

You're jealous and its making you feel sniffy that your mother is helping someone else that isn't you.
While you can kid yourself you are doing it under the guise of your poor old mum being too kind and being taken advantage of, that's not actually true is it?

I'm sure she is fully capable of either asking you to have a word or talking to the women herself. She has not done either which would lead you to believe she is happy helping for now.

Squeezita · 17/03/2022 16:45

My mum’s bored, and lonely, and would do anything for anyone. I don’t think she’d know whether someone was taking advantage. I just don’t get why this mum won’t ask any of the other mums instead?

You answered your own question - she’s lonely and generous and this was picked on.

statetrooperstacey · 17/03/2022 16:43

Depends on what your mum wants, if she’s not happy and asked you to intervene then yes.
However my mum has done lots of school runs over the years and always properly threw herself into the whole school gate thing. She knew all the mums and my sc friends, used to go the park with them and things and would often pick up a friend if asked by one of the other mums. So if she’s happy to stay out of it. She might be gaining a whole new social life ! Or notGrin

Hankunamatata · 17/03/2022 16:43

Yabu. Your mums a grown women. If I was you would have a chat with your mum about healthy boundaries about money and lending things. I'd also discuss how this impacts your dd

Swipe left for the next trending thread