Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if veganism really is the answer?

357 replies

RubyFruitSunday · 17/03/2022 09:17

Lots of my friendship circle have transitioned to be vegan/vegetarian recently. I'm not, but we do choose to include very few animal products in our diet and eat a predominantly plant based diet. But sometimes I have a hankering for a steak or some nice cheese and so I indulge. However my friends think this means I'm part of the problem and it should be all or nothing.

I have a few issues with this but I dont know if I'm just clinging to them as justification to keep my animal based treats.

  1. Animals eat other animals and we are animals. So I dont think eating meat is morally wrong from this perspective. I do object to factory farming and animals living miserable lives though. But its hard to tell what comes from where sometimes.

  2. What would become of the English countryside without farming? I'm guessing a lot of the land currently used to graze animals wouldnt be suitable to grow other foodstuffs so would end up being built up? I'm not sure I like the idea of that either.

I'd love to know others thoughts!

OP posts:
EricCartmansMagicalUnderpants · 18/03/2022 10:15

The fact is that most vegans have better weight management and the few studies suggest that being vegan seems to correlate with better health

I'm not sure that's entirely true. People have lost loads of weight by shifting to a meat only diet. Dropping pounds that were never possible on a carby vegan diet.

Hellorhighwater · 18/03/2022 09:06

Also, everyone wants a label. I’m not vegan, and I’m not veggie, but I don’t eat much meat. Mostly due to cost at the moment, but usually for welfare reasons. Maybe two or three times a week as a rule. My kiddo hardly eats meat at all. When I did eat it it was locally farmed by traditional methods, not industrial farming (which I agree is much more of an issue) and I think this is better than buying ‘plant based’ meat subs in every possible way. We drink a lot milk (which used to be local etc etc) and eggs (which used to be from our hens, but it was a bugger to keep them free range and keep the foxes off them) and small amounts of cheese most days. Its not doable on my current £20 a week shipping budget, but I don’t suppose being vegan is either)

I consist myself to have a plant based diet. Which to me, means MOSTLY plants. But not entirely. It seems to be have been appropriated to mean ‘Vegan processed stuff’.

Newgirls · 18/03/2022 09:04

@BarbaraofSeville

The biggest benefit will be if everyone makes a moderate change.

In populations where the norm is to eat meat 6 days a week (and many might eat more than that, eating meat every single day, possibly more than once) everyone cutting down to 3 days a week will reduce overall consumption by 50%.

If theyall cut down to one day a week, that reduces overall consumption by nearly 85%.

Further reductions will also be achieved by reducing the amount of meat in any particular meal. So don't eat meals that include an entire chicken breast or similarly sized steak or chop per person, but have this amount of meat between 2-4 people and include pulses or eggs, as well as vegetables and grains to make it into a filling meal.

That would all reduce overall meat consumption by well over 90% and have a far bigger benefit than 5-10% of people cutting out meat consumption completely, while others continue to eat it most days, which is where we probably are currently in countries like the UK or US.

Completely agree.
BarbaraofSeville · 18/03/2022 08:54

Forgot to say that then there would be far less demand, which would allow less intensive farming and have a much lower impact on the environment.

BarbaraofSeville · 18/03/2022 08:53

The biggest benefit will be if everyone makes a moderate change.

In populations where the norm is to eat meat 6 days a week (and many might eat more than that, eating meat every single day, possibly more than once) everyone cutting down to 3 days a week will reduce overall consumption by 50%.

If theyall cut down to one day a week, that reduces overall consumption by nearly 85%.

Further reductions will also be achieved by reducing the amount of meat in any particular meal. So don't eat meals that include an entire chicken breast or similarly sized steak or chop per person, but have this amount of meat between 2-4 people and include pulses or eggs, as well as vegetables and grains to make it into a filling meal.

That would all reduce overall meat consumption by well over 90% and have a far bigger benefit than 5-10% of people cutting out meat consumption completely, while others continue to eat it most days, which is where we probably are currently in countries like the UK or US.

user3837313202 · 18/03/2022 08:44

Logically halving your meat consumption will provide half the benefits. It doesn't have to be all or nothing - and I say this as a vegetarian of over 20 years.

If I were to eat meat again I'd buy from my local farmer's market where you can actually speak to the people who've reared the animal in question - and known it, as they like to say, when it was "on the hoof". If you don't want to cut it out altogether, less meat of a higher quality is the way to go.

VeganSeason · 18/03/2022 08:40

Eat local and seasonal foods.
That's the answer. It reduces food miles and land is used to produce food with the best yield.

It’s not the answer to animal exploitation and slaughter.

Newgirls · 18/03/2022 07:57

@MangyInseam

If veganism was actually the most efficient way to eat, all the animals would do it. And so would all the societies that are on the edge of sustainability.

Instead what you see is that when you have vegetarian groups in traditional societies, they are almost always the elite or well off. The poor eat whatever, and so do the farmers.

The most sustainable farming is mixed. Most western people eat far too much meat to be sustainable, but veganism and vegetarianism isn't all that great in the end either, because it cannot make use of all the synergies of a complete ecosystem.

If you look at industrial farming models, it is true that animal based ones are worse than plant based ones. But the problems with that are that they are both unsustainable; they are both dependent of fossil fuels to a significant degree; and they are also very intertwined so you can't really separate them out anyway.

For sustainability your best bet is to look at the kinds of farms around you that practice sustainable agriculture, and then buy what you can afford from them. You will find their meat products are relatively expensive so chances are you won't eat a ton of them anyway. And you will also be able to feel like their plant products are sustainably produced, or as close to it as possible.

That’s factually wrong. India for example is mostly vegetarian across all demographics.

The UK and US eat far more meat than most European countries.

Briony123 · 18/03/2022 07:55

Will nobody think of the bees?!?
Veganism is terrible for bees. Intensive monoculture is wrecking huge swathes of the ecosystem around the globe. On a par with those horrific cattle farms with no grass for mile after mile.
Our destruction of bees will be our downfall (if Putin doesn't push the button).
Eat British; eat organic.

Newgirls · 18/03/2022 07:55

@londonmummy1966

I read a very interesting article by a scientist that works for the Soil Association recently. His view was that an element of organic stock farming was better for the environment alongside organic produce farming. His main concern was that if we ditched the animals altogether then all fertilisers would be chemical which would be a disaster for the soil. His other main point was that stock farming can take place on land that is not suitable for arable and that land often also lends itself to environmental planting/wilding etc.
Most animals raised for food don’t live on soil - they are in vast metal sheds.

We are going to need a lot of fields for all those chickens the uk want to eat

Newgirls · 18/03/2022 07:52

@SucculentChalice

Its also easy enough to buy locally and ethically produced high quality meat e.g. from your local farm shop, or farmers' market, or similar. But thats a lot less convenient than Tesco. But to suggest that there are no sources of higher quality ethically produced meat in this country is ridiculous. I've got a free range pig farm near me, and those pigs seem to lead quite an idyllic life, outdoors all the time with lots of shelters and space to move about and socialise with others.
Do you think the 60 million meat eaters in the UK all buy from local farms?!

That every animal eaten in the UK lives in a pretty field full of blossom trees and potters about happily? Where are they all?!! 1 billion chickens get eaten every year - do you have a lovely field near you full of chickens?

Ylvamoon · 18/03/2022 07:50

Eat local and seasonal foods.
That's the answer. It reduces food miles and land is used to produce food with the best yield.
The real issue is erosion of fretile land to feed the ever increasing human population.

TheCurrywurstPrion · 18/03/2022 07:47

I haven’t read the full thread, but if I was happy with what I was doing, and so-called friends were trying to shame me, I’d find some new friends who respected me.

Really, people who think they’re morally superior to me for any reason are probably crashing bores, and really not very nice.

Cloudsarebright · 18/03/2022 07:42

No one said eating animals products is morally equated to rape.

But the argument is that animals do all sorts of behaviours including eating animals should not have any baring on human actions based on what is ‘natural’.

TheEarthIsNotFlat · 18/03/2022 06:43

@Fr0thandBubble

On your first point OP, animals do lots of things that we wouldn’t do because we have the intellectually ability to know that if a human were to do them it would be morally abhorrent. For example, a male animal will have sex with a female animal whether that female wants to or not. We, as humans, know that that would be entirely wrong, so we don’t do it. For me, it’s the same with eating meat. Yes, animals do it but they don’t know any better - we do (or at least should).
Yes, animals do it but they don’t know any better - we do (or at least should)

You feel it’s wrong to eat meat but not everyone else does. That’s your opinion, and like the OP’s friends, you’re basically admonishing her for something she has every right to do. I think you’re missing the point of the thread.

@RubyFruitSunday You do what you think is right. Look at it this way, your vegan/veggie friends are eating the way they choose so why shouldn’t you? Eat organic if it makes you feel better but you aren’t doing anything wrong.

SilverSplitsTheBlue · 18/03/2022 06:39

At the very centre of this argument (and both sides hold water) there is a victim. And that victim ends up on you plate. It's a personal choice definitely but I dislike hear people reason with words such as humane etc.

SilverSplitsTheBlue · 18/03/2022 06:37

97% of pigs are barned.

Carpy899 · 18/03/2022 03:48

@SucculentChalice

Its also easy enough to buy locally and ethically produced high quality meat e.g. from your local farm shop, or farmers' market, or similar. But thats a lot less convenient than Tesco. But to suggest that there are no sources of higher quality ethically produced meat in this country is ridiculous. I've got a free range pig farm near me, and those pigs seem to lead quite an idyllic life, outdoors all the time with lots of shelters and space to move about and socialise with others.
Ethical Grin Those pigs had a reasonable 6 months so the blade through throat is cancelled out?

Don't kid on there's anything ethical about raising an animal only to kill it.

garlictwist · 18/03/2022 03:12

In terms of grazing land, sheep and cattle have massively changed the landscape, at least in the north of England where there are a lot of upland farms. There are much fewer trees as they were cleared for grazing and this has an effect on flooding and biodiversity.

If animal farming stopped the land could be managed to rerun to its original form.

However, I love a good steak so fuck the trees Grin

WhistlersandJugglers · 18/03/2022 02:22

Talking about vegan vs. omnivore diets is also a bit pointless if you don't consider global food security. At the moment Ukrainian farmers can't get their seeds in the ground. We are very lucky to have all the options we currently have.

navydear · 18/03/2022 02:11

I came to your thread to read about veganism but all I could read was how strange your friend group is. Do you all follow each in everything you do!
Can you have your own opinion without being subjective to pressure from the group ?

WhistlersandJugglers · 18/03/2022 02:03

At the moment if you wanted to change from dairy or beef farming to cereal or vegetable production in the UK or Ireland you would have problems. You'd need Russian fertiliser and a lot of heavy machinery that runs on fossil fuels.

I think a big part of the problem is that people will pay a lot for anything marked 'Vegan' at the moment but still expect meat to be cheap. If people were willing to pay the real cost for ethical meat and eggs then there would be a natural move towards a healthier diet.

MangyInseam · 18/03/2022 01:21

However, it is very easy to say veganism is unhealthy and has a greater environmental impact. Yet no one is in the same breath saying the same thing about non-vegans and those who live off processed foods and are wildly unhealthy. The fact is that most vegans have better weight management and the few studies suggest that being vegan seems to correlate with better health…although the evidence for this is still very limited. And of course flying in almond milk or avocados has an environmental impact, but the impact of animal farming is significant - the amount of water required for beef, and the amount of feed that cows require is shocking compared to the amount of food that is actually produced.

So this water thing:

It would be an issue in a place like California, where they are in a drought, and draining their aquifer for agriculture. And places like California send out large amounts of water in the form of all kinds of agricultural products. Similarly Israel, IIRC. It's a problem because it is affecting the local ecosystem.

But if you live in a place with lots of water, and a cow drinks it, that is not necessarily a problem. The water doesn't disappear from the world, it's just being held in a body, the same as with plants that suck up water. And the ecosystem isn't being impacted significantly by the cow drinking that water.

It's when you have certain regions that are exporting so much food to other places, especially in fragile ecosystems, or things like big feed lots where there is so much water needed and also so much organic waste, that you run into trouble. But even growing things like oranges for export in places like that can be very problematic. It's asking more of the land than it can really give.

People disparage the idea of food miles, but it's not as straightforward as many seem to think. It's also about the reality that you have some regions that end up being seriously over-farmed, or places in far off countries where you really can't see the farming or labour practices, or affect the regulations.

Casamento · 18/03/2022 01:14

@SucculentChalice

Branleuse did you really just ask "what on earth is a cow farm"?

Well, yes. Because I live on a farm, surrounded by farms, and I have yet to hear anyone talk about a "cow farm". Cattle farms, yes, but single sex reproducers, no. Not without AI.

Surely its clear she means a farm where farmers raise cows, either for dairy or for meat

No, its not. Its mainly bullocks, which are immature males, which are raised for beef.

Have you just been dropped here from another planet where you’re not aware that ‘cow’ is colloquially used to refer to both male and female cattle? Or do you think your faux naïveté makes you sound superior?
MangyInseam · 18/03/2022 01:06

If veganism was actually the most efficient way to eat, all the animals would do it. And so would all the societies that are on the edge of sustainability.

Instead what you see is that when you have vegetarian groups in traditional societies, they are almost always the elite or well off. The poor eat whatever, and so do the farmers.

The most sustainable farming is mixed. Most western people eat far too much meat to be sustainable, but veganism and vegetarianism isn't all that great in the end either, because it cannot make use of all the synergies of a complete ecosystem.

If you look at industrial farming models, it is true that animal based ones are worse than plant based ones. But the problems with that are that they are both unsustainable; they are both dependent of fossil fuels to a significant degree; and they are also very intertwined so you can't really separate them out anyway.

For sustainability your best bet is to look at the kinds of farms around you that practice sustainable agriculture, and then buy what you can afford from them. You will find their meat products are relatively expensive so chances are you won't eat a ton of them anyway. And you will also be able to feel like their plant products are sustainably produced, or as close to it as possible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread