Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if veganism really is the answer?

357 replies

RubyFruitSunday · 17/03/2022 09:17

Lots of my friendship circle have transitioned to be vegan/vegetarian recently. I'm not, but we do choose to include very few animal products in our diet and eat a predominantly plant based diet. But sometimes I have a hankering for a steak or some nice cheese and so I indulge. However my friends think this means I'm part of the problem and it should be all or nothing.

I have a few issues with this but I dont know if I'm just clinging to them as justification to keep my animal based treats.

  1. Animals eat other animals and we are animals. So I dont think eating meat is morally wrong from this perspective. I do object to factory farming and animals living miserable lives though. But its hard to tell what comes from where sometimes.

  2. What would become of the English countryside without farming? I'm guessing a lot of the land currently used to graze animals wouldnt be suitable to grow other foodstuffs so would end up being built up? I'm not sure I like the idea of that either.

I'd love to know others thoughts!

OP posts:
FullBush · 18/03/2022 23:30

Ahh the shaky moral high ground of new vegan /eco zealots. No doubt it’s hard to see your face over their Chinese manufactured mobiles, Vietnamese clothing, multitude of cheap plastic shite gatherering dust in their homes. Not to mention apples from New Zealand, soy from Chile, grapes from South Africa and beans from Kenya… Sooooo virtuous they aren’t.. Grin

SquirrelG · 18/03/2022 20:56

Rather like women 'bang on' about female rights? Or any other equality rights issue. This is no different. It's about an abuse of power.

I am a proud banger-on-er. Seriously the world needs more people banging on about what's right.

I can't be bothered with people who "bang on" about anything, female rights included. I'm quite capable of making up my own mind on any subject and will not be lectured to about my choices by anyone. Also, what gives you the idea that what you "bang on" about is right - it's only your opinion.

SquirrelG · 18/03/2022 20:50

No-one refers to "cow farms". I have never, ever heard the phrase before. If you talked like that around here, the wave of laughter would literally carry on your little gust of superiority so far that you would end up in the sea.

I agree. I'm in NZ and I have never heard anyone say "cow farm" and was a bit taken aback to see it here. People either farm cattle, or they have dairy farms. Cow farm might be something a particularly ignorant city dweller would say, but no-one else would use that term

iamusuallyright · 18/03/2022 20:28

@SquirrelG

An alien reading this thread to learn about Earth eating habits would think that only vegetarians/vegans eat processed foods or food flown from overseas, while meat-eaters always stick to locally sourced food and cook every meal from scratch

However in my experience meat eaters aren't the ones lecturing all and sundry about the environment and food. The point the poster was making was that some vegans bang on about how their eating choices are better for the environment simply because they aren't eating meat, when often they actually aren't.

Rather like women 'bang on' about female rights? Or any other equality rights issue. This is no different. It's about an abuse of power.

I am a proud banger-on-er. Seriously the world needs more people banging on about what's right.

Hyenaormeercat · 18/03/2022 20:05

I guess a person's motivation for going vegan is the key. Animal welfare, totally get it. A varied diet can be achieved but it does require effort. As far as I can see this will involve products produced from a wide range of environments.

If vegans are also environmentally conscious I imagine it's a bit more complicated.

How do you eat a varied fully nutritional diet from only local produced foods using seasonal products only that is vegan? I'd actually buy a book that shows how to do this, does one exist?

SquirrelG · 18/03/2022 20:01

An alien reading this thread to learn about Earth eating habits would think that only vegetarians/vegans eat processed foods or food flown from overseas, while meat-eaters always stick to locally sourced food and cook every meal from scratch

However in my experience meat eaters aren't the ones lecturing all and sundry about the environment and food. The point the poster was making was that some vegans bang on about how their eating choices are better for the environment simply because they aren't eating meat, when often they actually aren't.

kikisparks · 18/03/2022 20:00

Everyone always talks about food miles on these threads without actually looking at the data. Most emissions from food come from the production, not transport, stage and imported plants are better than animal products from animals raised and killed locally:

pubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.1021/es702969f

“, “buying local” could achieve, at maximum, around a 4−5% reduction in GHG emissions due to large sources of both CO2 and non-CO2 emissions in the production of food. Shifting less than 1 day per week’s (i.e., 1/7 of total calories) consumption of red meat and/or dairy to other protein sources or a vegetable-based diet could have the same climate impact as buying all household food from local providers.”

www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/10/181023110627.htm

“A new study provides a more comprehensive accounting of the greenhouse gas emissions from EU diets. It shows that meat and dairy products are responsible for the lion's share of greenhouse emissions from the EU diet.”

“The study found that meat and dairy account for more than 75% of the impact from EU diets. That's because meat and dairy production causes not only direct emissions from animal production, but also contributes to deforestation from cropland expansion for feed, which is often produced outside of the EU.”

“"People tend to think that consuming locally will be the solution to climate change, but it turns out that the type of product we eat is much more important for the overall impact," says IIASA researcher Hugo Valin, a study coauthor and Sandström's YSSP advisor. "Europeans are culturally attached to meat and dairy product consumption.”

Eylis · 18/03/2022 19:52

Not vegan....less meat probably but not vegan and I say that as a vegan

iamusuallyright · 18/03/2022 19:51

@berlinbabylon

An alien reading this thread to learn about Earth eating habits would think that only vegetarians/vegans eat processed foods or food flown from overseas, while meat-eaters always stick to locally sourced food and cook every meal from scratch

no, it's because vegans say that being plant-based is better for the planet, but actually getting dairy milk from the UK (down the road in many cases) is better than getting oat or almond milk from overseas

it's not arguing that people all buy lovely organic milk

It's not better for the cows I'd wager.

And really, there's no need for 'milk' of any sort unless one is an infant.

iamusuallyright · 18/03/2022 19:45

@RubyFruitSunday

Lots of my friendship circle have transitioned to be vegan/vegetarian recently. I'm not, but we do choose to include very few animal products in our diet and eat a predominantly plant based diet. But sometimes I have a hankering for a steak or some nice cheese and so I indulge. However my friends think this means I'm part of the problem and it should be all or nothing.

I have a few issues with this but I dont know if I'm just clinging to them as justification to keep my animal based treats.

  1. Animals eat other animals and we are animals. So I dont think eating meat is morally wrong from this perspective. I do object to factory farming and animals living miserable lives though. But its hard to tell what comes from where sometimes.

  2. What would become of the English countryside without farming? I'm guessing a lot of the land currently used to graze animals wouldnt be suitable to grow other foodstuffs so would end up being built up? I'm not sure I like the idea of that either.

I'd love to know others thoughts!

Veganism really IS the answer.
berlinbabylon · 18/03/2022 19:37

An alien reading this thread to learn about Earth eating habits would think that only vegetarians/vegans eat processed foods or food flown from overseas, while meat-eaters always stick to locally sourced food and cook every meal from scratch

no, it's because vegans say that being plant-based is better for the planet, but actually getting dairy milk from the UK (down the road in many cases) is better than getting oat or almond milk from overseas

it's not arguing that people all buy lovely organic milk

gogohm · 18/03/2022 19:34

There are many issues with the default plant = better narrative because the devil is in the details. A local omnivore diet could have a smaller carbon footprint than a vegan diet and can be far less processed.

Today I had lamb from 15 miles away grazed on land unsuitable for any other form of farming plus vegetables grown within 5 miles of my house ... this is far better than many vegan options that people fawn over

WhistlersandJugglers · 18/03/2022 19:31

I remember reading years ago that the last time humans were consuming goods, energy and food at a pace that was renewable for the planet was 1950. I don't remember where I read it but it has the ring of truth about it.

DdraigGoch · 18/03/2022 19:27

Cutting out meat and dairy is the best thing you can do for the environment
Actually @MargotMoo the best thing you can do for the environment is to use contraception. Followed by selling the car and not flying. Even an electric car is still responsible for twice the annual emissions of its owner's meat consumption.

MyPretttyRedDress · 18/03/2022 19:24

@silverspacesuit

Can a vegan please answer this for me as I struggle to understand.

Why do we have canine teeth if we are not meant to eat meat?

I'm not trying to be funny and/or goady but would love the answer

Mine are useful for ripping apart tofu steaks.

But they are nothing compared to my pretty-much-vegan chum Gary Goriila's.

To wonder if veganism really is the answer?
scottishnames · 18/03/2022 19:16

That's fine Whistles - I did not mean to sound aggressive, so my apologies if it came across that way. Urbanisation does pose specific (and big) problems, but I do think, though, that we can learn at least a bit from the past. For example, it's within living memory, just about, when people kept just a few cows in relatively decent surrounding in towns, for fresh milk.

DdraigGoch · 18/03/2022 19:15

@DepthOfTheAbyss

Yeah dairy farming can go. Cheese is fab but it’s just weird to be consuming milk from other mammals. Most people would be disgusted if you offered them some human milk but other mammals milk is fine. It just seems bizarre to me.
And yet plenty of animals will drink cow milk if given the chance (whether it's good for them or not). My dad had a glass of milk on a side table next to him, turned his back for ten seconds and the cat was stealing it.
WhistlersandJugglers · 18/03/2022 19:14

People then would have been using the manure from their one cow and hens to fertilise their vegetable patches too so it was a much more closed system.

WhistlersandJugglers · 18/03/2022 19:10

Sorry, @scottishnames, I worded my post badly. You are totally correct about how people ate then. I meant to agree with you but point out that the fact that the population is so much bigger now and also much more urbanised and that means there isn't any way to feed people the same diet now without much more intensive farming using a lot of fertiliser.

scottishnames · 18/03/2022 18:52

Whistlers I replied because someone up thread specifically asked. You have a problem with me doing that?

Actually, anyway, I think it is relevant. As another previous poster said, we've all got used to consuming far too much. Even in the mid/late 20th cent, expectations about food in the UK were vastly lower. If we're to save the planet, I suspect that our expectations are going to have to be lowered once again.

WhistlersandJugglers · 18/03/2022 18:45

@scottishnames, I'm glad that you made the point about artificial fertiliser and Russia. I said much the same thing earlier in the thread and it's so important to understand this.

WhistlersandJugglers · 18/03/2022 18:39

The population of the UK in 1850 was around the 18 million mark so how people ate then isn't particularly relevant.

scottishnames · 18/03/2022 18:17

Two things:

  1. Most fertiliser used on arable farms is made from natural gas (yes, the stuff exported by Russia) www.fertilizerseurope.com/fertilizers-in-europe/how-fertilizers-are-made/ Animal manure is used by only a small proportion of (organic) farmers.
  1. Someone up thread asked how did people in the UK survive in the past. For ordinary people, their diet was based on (wholemeal) bread and porridge-type wheat dishes and/or oatmeal (depending on region), supplemented by veg (onions, garlic, leeks, cabbage family, carrots etc if lucky (swedes not introduced until 17th/18th cent) and herbs) plus legumes (field peas mentioned by previous poster and other peas/beans). People kept hens for eggs and if lucky had a cow for milk and butter and perhaps cheese. (Yields were much lower then; cheesemaking is not easy in primitive circumstances.) They might also have a pig, kept as a pet on scraps etc for a year and then - alas - butchered. A famous old saying records how 'every bit of the pig was used, apart from the squeal'. A lot of the pig-meat was salted and smoked to preserve it for use - in small quantities - almost as a flavouring. Pig fat was rendered and carefully stored. People planted apple and pear trees, and gathered (or if clever) 'developed' cultivated versions of wild berries - brambles, strawberries, raspberries. If even more clever, they kept bees for honey. They foraged for mushrooms and nuts, in season. By the coast, people ate fish, but it was never cheap. A lot of fish, even in medieval times, was smoked or salted or pickled to be sold at even higher prices at inland markets.
In other words, ordinary people in the past were mostly ominvores - but they ate much, much, much less animal produce than today.

Posh people in the past ate much more meat; it was a status-symbol but it was very unhealthy. (Am not making this up - just think of the digestive consequences of a diet with very little fibre ....)

FWIW - I agree with posters saying that the term 'cow farm' (I am sorry) betrays a woeful ignorance of how our food is produced. At the very least, if we are going to eat meat, we need to understand where it comes from, and from which type of animal.

HangingOver · 18/03/2022 17:44

An alien reading this thread to learn about Earth eating habits would think that only vegetarians/vegans eat processed foods or food flown from overseas, while meat-eaters always stick to locally sourced food and cook every meal from scratch

I think it's because when people think of "vegan food" they think of the tiny shelf in the supermarket with the fake meats on, not the fruit and veg aisle. I love the occasional vegan burger or sausages but I certainly don't eat them any more often than I did the meat equivalent so I can't get all that worked up about the processedness.

Peasock · 18/03/2022 16:40

[quote 2orangey]@Newgirls totally agree! An alien reading this thread to learn about Earth eating habits would think that only vegetarians/vegans eat processed foods or food flown from overseas, while meat-eaters always stick to locally sourced food and cook every meal from scratch 🤔[/quote]
As is always the case with these threads, it's bizarre.