Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if veganism really is the answer?

357 replies

RubyFruitSunday · 17/03/2022 09:17

Lots of my friendship circle have transitioned to be vegan/vegetarian recently. I'm not, but we do choose to include very few animal products in our diet and eat a predominantly plant based diet. But sometimes I have a hankering for a steak or some nice cheese and so I indulge. However my friends think this means I'm part of the problem and it should be all or nothing.

I have a few issues with this but I dont know if I'm just clinging to them as justification to keep my animal based treats.

  1. Animals eat other animals and we are animals. So I dont think eating meat is morally wrong from this perspective. I do object to factory farming and animals living miserable lives though. But its hard to tell what comes from where sometimes.

  2. What would become of the English countryside without farming? I'm guessing a lot of the land currently used to graze animals wouldnt be suitable to grow other foodstuffs so would end up being built up? I'm not sure I like the idea of that either.

I'd love to know others thoughts!

OP posts:
harmoniadream · 17/03/2022 10:56

Lots of my friendship circle have transitioned to be vegan/vegetarian recently. I'm not, but we do choose to include very few animal products in our diet and eat a predominantly plant based diet. But sometimes I have a hankering for a steak or some nice cheese and so I indulge. However my friends think this means I'm part of the problem and it should be all or nothing

I'd say your biggest problem is your friends. I'm vegetarian, so is one of my siblings, my parents eat mostly plant-based but sometimes fish/meat, and my friends are a mixture of vegan/veggie/omni. None of us ever try to tell the others what they should or shouldn't eat or that their choice of diet is a problem.

BarbaraofSeville · 17/03/2022 10:45

@DepthOfTheAbyss

If we look at other omnivores in the animal kingdom, they eat plant based most of the time and occasionally meat or bugs. I think that’s how we should be eating but not processed stuff. I dont think eating all the plant based pretend meat is particularly healthy either.
I agree with this. Years ago, Michael Pollan said 'Eat food, mostly plants, not too much' as a basis for health, and maybe also environmental/sustainability reasons. Nothing more is needed really, or fancy labelling.

People can be vegan if they want to be, but most people don't. But what will benefit most for animal welfare, health and environmental reasons is that if everyone significantly cuts down the amount of animal produce they eat rather than a few people insisting that it has to be done 100%, but then a lot of those reducing the benefit by eating a lot of food that is either massively processed, or flown from the other side of the world after being grown in environmentally damaging ways and also threatening the food security of people in poorer countries.

Comedycook · 17/03/2022 10:34

I'm very sceptical that veganism is better for the environment. I'm not sure eating fake meat made in a factory and tropical fruit flown across the world is a better choice necessarily. It's probably better to eat as much locally produced food as possible be it animal or plant

SucculentChalice · 17/03/2022 10:34

I live in a big arable farming area OP. The land here is ideal for growing the typical British arable crops of wheat, rape, oats, and winter barley, peas, beans, with some others. Its hideous.

To maximise yield per acre, all the farming is contracted out to agricultural contractors who have giant machinery. Said giant machinery doesn't do anything but straight lines so all the corners are just left to do nothing and that means they are sprayed to death with pesticides and weedkillers. The hedgerows were dug up years ago to maximise yield and most of the traditional footpaths/bridleways were ploughed over or diverted to the most inconvenient spots so they are no longer used because they are so overgrown.

No wildlife is permitted to live here. There used to be deer but they have been shot. All "pests" are shot regularly, such as pigeons. Theres also trapping going on, illegal or permitted, it happens. I think that theres some arrangement whereby people are allowed to shoot or trap for sport and are permitted to do it free of charge or for a small payment. Its all quite secretive. Anyway, nothing lives here.

Its like living in an arable desert. There are individual farms but the owners don't farm themselves any more, except for a few historical leases to people who rent the land for their own sheep. There were literally two fields where that went on and last summer one of those was ploughed up and the other is unused and full of weeds now. There is one local farmer who farms his own land (by some miracle its a mixed arable and grazing farm) and I am friends with his farm labourer, and I often think he is the last of a dying breed. He has lived in his tied cottage and worked on that farm all his life and will retire there. He isn't being replaced.

The monotony of the scenery here is actually dreadful and quite depressing. The land is in crops all year round with I think every 3rd winter off. Every last ounce is got out of the land here, and its pumped full of fertiliser and additives and weedkillers to do so.

I know if you live in a modern housing estate, veganism sounds like some kind of great solution but in reality it isn't. The UK has a high population because it lies in the middle of a climate zone which pre-disposes to mixed farming and can produce a lot of food than drier or colder areas. It has good, mixed soils and prime beef can be reared on those areas and sheep and deer on its higher land.

What I'd actually support is more forestation and public access of non-animal farmed areas for recreation because much of upland Britain isn't a natural environment by any means and the lack of tree cover increases soil loss and acidity, meaning nothing can grow. Theres a farming initiative to encourage young people into farming and smaller farms, because the trend is increasingly towards mega farms farmed by contractors who do it as a job and who have little relationship with the land because they don't live on it.

The UK isn't that bad for farming animals compared to most countries because we tend to keep them in for shelter and food over winter and turn them out in summer. In many countries, cattle, sheep and pigs are in all year round.

Also bear in mind that not all arable land is suitable for all arable crops. Potatoes for instance require a very particular climate and soil type to grow well and can't be grown everywhere. So a smallholding looking to be self sufficient would likely be deficient in certain nutrients from certain crops and would have to trade with others IYSWIM.

The UK's best naturally growing crop by far is grass. The UK produces wonderful, nutritious grasses that can easily be made into enough hay to sustain grazing animals kept indoors over winter or supplement outdoor grazing.

Pedallleur · 17/03/2022 10:33

No doubt if the these people owned farms they would see things differently. prob still have 2 x cars and go on long haul holidays. better have a plan if we decide to decimate the farming/dairy industry which I agree needs to be remodelled but flying mung beans from the Andes or Kelp from California isnt great either

Hanooooooo · 17/03/2022 10:25

I don't think everyone being totally vegan is necessarily the answer, at least not now (and I am vegan). But I do think everyone needs to drastically reduce their consumption of meat, fish and dairy in order reduce carbon emissions and mass extinction.

I agree that commercial farming is unethical and personally I would feel a lot more comfortable with meat consumption if it was on a smaller scale with animals treated with dignity.

Regards to farming, we urgently need to reduce the amount of land we use for farming and turn it over to rewilding before we lose even more precious species. Have a look at this www.rewildingbritain.org.uk/

Also I don't think it's okay to moralise on others' diet choices and it's not helpful either! Everyone follows their own moral compass, individual impact is minimal and it's for the government to step up and act with the evidence in front of them.

EricCartmansMagicalUnderpants · 17/03/2022 10:18

I don't think much of the vegan food is particularly healthy, good for the environment etc. It's just vegan virtue signalling, part of the trend these days. I think if the meat you eat is sourced carefully, then I don't see a problem. I'd struggle to have friends that told me I was part of the problem though. I'd probably get rid of them, but then there's no room in my life for virtue signalling.

MichelleScarn · 17/03/2022 10:17

Isn't it @RockinHorseShit
'Hey lion you don't know any better that's why you eat meat..., have some tofu'...
I don't think that these animals would be very well if some virtue signalling amateur nutritionists came along and altered their diet!

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 17/03/2022 10:16

@Onthetoadagain

I think there are some issues, environmentally/ ethically speaking, with the current form of veganism (and other diets), including highly processed food, food miles, reliance on crops such as almonds, soya and avocados, that make it not as morally sound as its proponents believe. I have been vegetarian for 25 years or so, and think that those who are hugely enthusiastic recent converts to veganism are missing the point somewhat.
I agree.
RockinHorseShit · 17/03/2022 10:15

Greta can sod right off :-)

I love her, but she's so obviously wrong on this & you just have to look at her face to see that she is deficient due to a vegan diet, so yellowish pale with dark circles & is exactly how my DD looked pre treatment & she has pernicious anaemia

ukborn · 17/03/2022 10:11

I agree that we could all cut down our meat and diary consumption. But I'm not giving it up entirely. I eat mainly chicken or lamb several times a week and I eat eggs every day. I also eat fish most days. One day a week no meat or fish.
And you are right about the countryside - a lot if it looks the way it looks due to farming and gaming. The most efficient methods of growing food are not always compatible with protecting wildlife or encouraging biodiversity.
Cutting down is a good move. Your vegan friends are wrong.

RockinHorseShit · 17/03/2022 10:10

a2 male animal will have sex with a female animal whether that female wants to or not. We, as humans, know that that would be entirely wrong, so we don’t do it. For me, it’s the same with eating meat. Yes, animals do it but they don’t know any better - we do (or at least should).

What a bizarre thought process Confused

Animals eat what they biologically need to stay well. We need to do that too, or supplement what our diet lacks

Propagandalf · 17/03/2022 10:10

It's ok to be vegan.
It's ok not to be vegan.

You have to make that decision yourself.

Greta can sod right off :-)

MichelleScarn · 17/03/2022 10:07

a2 male animal will have sex with a female animal whether that female wants to or not. We, as humans, know that that would be entirely wrong, so we don’t do it. For me, it’s the same with eating meat. Yes, animals do it but they don’t know any better - we do (or at least should).

Are you equating eating meat with rape? This along with friends think this means I'm part of the problem and it should be all or nothing. is part of the issue for me, the zealot-y 'you're evil' that is spouted with the bizarre expectation that this will convert people to their cause!

Comedycook · 17/03/2022 10:06

Personally I think it's perfectly normal to crave animal products and meat. I know if I don't eat red meat for a while, I really crave it. I eat bog standard supermarket meat because it's what I can afford but I think factory farming is appalling really.

parietal · 17/03/2022 10:02

Strict veganism is difficult to maintain and is not always good for your health (vitamin deficiencies) or the planet (almond milk & flying in veg). But a 95% veggie diet is certainly better than eating lots of steak.

Ignore people who are over-strict about diet or obsess about it. That is very dull.

Eat more plants, but do keep the milk and eggs in your diet too. Eggs are great - very healthy and without the carbon footprint of milk / beef farming.

Giggorata · 17/03/2022 10:00

@Onthetoadagain

I think there are some issues, environmentally/ ethically speaking, with the current form of veganism (and other diets), including highly processed food, food miles, reliance on crops such as almonds, soya and avocados, that make it not as morally sound as its proponents believe. I have been vegetarian for 25 years or so, and think that those who are hugely enthusiastic recent converts to veganism are missing the point somewhat.
Agree with this, apart from still being vegetarian. I stopped being vegetarian partly because of some of these factors, especially the factory made, over produced foods and vast food miles involved. I don't agree that it is morally repugnant to eat animals but factory farming and transporting animals miles to vast slaughterhouses, and some of the mechanised methods are awful.
RockinHorseShit · 17/03/2022 09:41

If we look at other omnivores in the animal kingdom, they eat plant based most of the time and occasionally meat or bugs. I think that’s how we should be eating but not processed stuff. I dont think eating all the plant based pretend meat is particularly healthy either.

I'm not a meat eater, haven't eaten it since I was a small DC, but I absolutely agree with this

mibbelucieachwell · 17/03/2022 09:41

British beef has a less harmful impact on the environment than imported beef as it hasn't travelled as far and comes from grass cows. Buying British meat will minimise the environmental effects.

Scientists are working on dietary supplements for cows to reduce the methane they produce to lower their environmental impact.

Meat doesn't need much cooking, unlike pulses and beans.

Alfredsothermistress · 17/03/2022 09:40

@Fr0thandBubble

On your first point OP, animals do lots of things that we wouldn’t do because we have the intellectually ability to know that if a human were to do them it would be morally abhorrent. For example, a male animal will have sex with a female animal whether that female wants to or not. We, as humans, know that that would be entirely wrong, so we don’t do it. For me, it’s the same with eating meat. Yes, animals do it but they don’t know any better - we do (or at least should).
Why do you think eating meat is morally abhorrent?
RockinHorseShit · 17/03/2022 09:39

No, definitely not, not unless you want the NHS overwhelmed with slow growing "mystery" illness & disability, which is what happens if you don't get enough vitamin B12.

Onthetoadagain · 17/03/2022 09:37

Sorry, last sentence was incomplete. Those recent converts who believe they are doing a hugely good thing but seeking to replicate a meat eating diet, or do not consider the impact of their diet other than 'is it plant based?' Are missing the point. Not that they're not doing, in my view, essentially a decent thing.

Thatswhyimacat · 17/03/2022 09:37

@DepthOfTheAbyss is right. People say 'we are omnivores' as if it is natural to eat meat at every meal, but all of our anatomy and closest animal relatives point to us being a predominantly fruit eater with the occasional bit of bird or bug. Animals that aren't exclusive carnivores don't eat anywhere near as much meat as humans now do, nor did we for most of our history.

DepthOfTheAbyss · 17/03/2022 09:37

Yeah dairy farming can go. Cheese is fab but it’s just weird to be consuming milk from other mammals. Most people would be disgusted if you offered them some human milk but other mammals milk is fine. It just seems bizarre to me.

BIWI · 17/03/2022 09:37

Human beings are omnivores. Back when we were hunters, we would have been eating primarily meat/fish, supplemented with berries/vegetables when available/in season.

We are now in a position where we can choose to be omnivore, carnivore (some people are!) or a vegetarian/vegan.

It's entirely up to you what you want to eat - and there are arguments from all sides as to what is 'best' for you and/or the environment.

Swipe left for the next trending thread