Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if veganism really is the answer?

357 replies

RubyFruitSunday · 17/03/2022 09:17

Lots of my friendship circle have transitioned to be vegan/vegetarian recently. I'm not, but we do choose to include very few animal products in our diet and eat a predominantly plant based diet. But sometimes I have a hankering for a steak or some nice cheese and so I indulge. However my friends think this means I'm part of the problem and it should be all or nothing.

I have a few issues with this but I dont know if I'm just clinging to them as justification to keep my animal based treats.

  1. Animals eat other animals and we are animals. So I dont think eating meat is morally wrong from this perspective. I do object to factory farming and animals living miserable lives though. But its hard to tell what comes from where sometimes.

  2. What would become of the English countryside without farming? I'm guessing a lot of the land currently used to graze animals wouldnt be suitable to grow other foodstuffs so would end up being built up? I'm not sure I like the idea of that either.

I'd love to know others thoughts!

OP posts:
JanisMoplin · 17/03/2022 14:02

I agree that people reducing their meat consumption- even if only once a week- is a good thing. All or nothing is a bad idea. Nobody should tell anyone else what to eat or be sanctimonious about it.

I don't agree that vegetarianism requires you to eat avocados or excessive imported food or soy products. I also do not believe meat is essential. Unless you don't know how to cook veggies.

Newgirls · 17/03/2022 14:01

High Carbon emissions foods

Newgirls · 17/03/2022 14:00

@silverspacesuit

Can a vegan please answer this for me as I struggle to understand.

Why do we have canine teeth if we are not meant to eat meat?

I'm not trying to be funny and/or goady but would love the answer

Historically we wouldn’t have eaten meat every day. It would a rare thing for hunter gatheing communities.

But you know we are meant to evolve and learn. We don’t die in childbirth so much now. We live on an over populated island and we need to reduce our impact. So let’s take the advice and eat less meat and other carbon dense foods.

Newgirls · 17/03/2022 13:57

@WhatsMyNameGonnaBeNow

The truth is we are all part of the problem by reason of our very existence. The “all or nothing” approach of your friends and so many of the recent converts to veganism always makes me think of that saying about perfection being the enemy of good enough.

People choosing to reduce meat, fish and dairy and being more conscious of their environmental impact is a good thing. It’s an improvement. If large numbers of people “improve” it will absolutely have an impact and I think many people are making positive changes. Most people can’t and many don’t want to choose the “all” option but that doesn’t mean their efforts are “nothing”

IMO the “all or nothing” types are those who have lost sight of what they’re trying to achieve. Their focus has switched to how they wish to see and present themselves rather than the issue they claim to feel passionate about. It’s the I’m a better person than you competition we see so much of on MN but smug, self congratulatory, judgmental bullshit doesn’t actually fix the environment!

I agree - everyone reducing is the way forward. That’s going to be more effective long term.
grey12 · 17/03/2022 13:56

We should all reduced the amount of meat we eat 🤷🏻‍♀️ in my opinion that doesn't mean you necessarily have to never eat another steak again!!! (If you are comfortable with/want to be doing it)

Palmfrond · 17/03/2022 13:53

Personally I think there are enough pulses roots and green veg grown year round in the U.K. to sustain (along with the odd tin of tomatoes) a very healthy, mostly plant based, low impact diet, but personally I think the judicious addition of meat (again, British origin and where possible local and/or organic) is essential, especially in our northern, gloomy environment.
I’ve tried veganism for about 6 months, just to try it out really, but found myself scrabbling for ideas for what to eat, and always ended up eating weird vegan foodstuffs made from imported nuts or soy that I couldn’t really get behind except out of desperation.

Newgirls · 17/03/2022 13:53

@Hellorhighwater

One thing I’ve never seen addressed is the question of fertiliser. Plants don’t just need water, they need fertiliser. Usually composted animal manure. If we don’t keep animals, where will that come from? This is not to say we should eat as much meat as is considered normal, just that mixed farming is a thing for a reason.

Also, I wonder if vegans consider their carbon footprint. I imagine you can do both low and high carbon footprint for both meat and vegan diets, so neither is the answer in isolation. Vegan stuff is often heavily processed, imported protein, grown in a pretty unsustainable way, and not automatically better than local grass raised beef. Vegan shoes, for example, are generally plastic.

Vegan monoculture is just as bad as any other monoculture. And pests still have to be kept off vegan food. I don't suppose anyone cares about various insects, rats or pigeons, but fluffy bunnies, cute deer and so on in the country will be being killed to keep you vegan diet, well, yours. And in other countries it’s likely to be more exotic animals. Elephants still need to be kept off your sugarcane, don’t they? Veganism isn’t automatically cruelty free.

As always, with any straightforward solution, it isn’t that simple. I think the move towards eating less meat is a really good thing, but Veganism on its own is not going to save the planet. I personally don’t believe it’s even possible for the world to become vegan, much less actually desirable.

Fertiliser, feed, transport etc - these are issues in meat farming too

Recently due to lack of packaging gases carcuses from uk farms had to go to mainland Europe and back for processing. Road miles, chemicals, packaging etc. imagine the processes going in to making nuggets, burgers, plastic prawn rings. People only seem to care when that happens with ‘vegan’ foods?!

EricCartmansMagicalUnderpants · 17/03/2022 13:52

@Gowithme

It's not meat eaters we need to reduce, it's the world's population. Too many people in the world is literally the root cause of every single problem there is.
Well this is true.
silverspacesuit · 17/03/2022 13:51

Can a vegan please answer this for me as I struggle to understand.

Why do we have canine teeth if we are not meant to eat meat?

I'm not trying to be funny and/or goady but would love the answer

WhatsMyNameGonnaBeNow · 17/03/2022 13:48

The truth is we are all part of the problem by reason of our very existence. The “all or nothing” approach of your friends and so many of the recent converts to veganism always makes me think of that saying about perfection being the enemy of good enough.

People choosing to reduce meat, fish and dairy and being more conscious of their environmental impact is a good thing. It’s an improvement. If large numbers of people “improve” it will absolutely have an impact and I think many people are making positive changes. Most people can’t and many don’t want to choose the “all” option but that doesn’t mean their efforts are “nothing”

IMO the “all or nothing” types are those who have lost sight of what they’re trying to achieve. Their focus has switched to how they wish to see and present themselves rather than the issue they claim to feel passionate about. It’s the I’m a better person than you competition we see so much of on MN but smug, self congratulatory, judgmental bullshit doesn’t actually fix the environment!

Hellorhighwater · 17/03/2022 13:48

One thing I’ve never seen addressed is the question of fertiliser. Plants don’t just need water, they need fertiliser. Usually composted animal manure. If we don’t keep animals, where will that come from? This is not to say we should eat as much meat as is considered normal, just that mixed farming is a thing for a reason.

Also, I wonder if vegans consider their carbon footprint. I imagine you can do both low and high carbon footprint for both meat and vegan diets, so neither is the answer in isolation. Vegan stuff is often heavily processed, imported protein, grown in a pretty unsustainable way, and not automatically better than local grass raised beef. Vegan shoes, for example, are generally plastic.

Vegan monoculture is just as bad as any other monoculture. And pests still have to be kept off vegan food. I don't suppose anyone cares about various insects, rats or pigeons, but fluffy bunnies, cute deer and so on in the country will be being killed to keep you vegan diet, well, yours. And in other countries it’s likely to be more exotic animals. Elephants still need to be kept off your sugarcane, don’t they? Veganism isn’t automatically cruelty free.

As always, with any straightforward solution, it isn’t that simple. I think the move towards eating less meat is a really good thing, but Veganism on its own is not going to save the planet. I personally don’t believe it’s even possible for the world to become vegan, much less actually desirable.

Gowithme · 17/03/2022 13:48

It's not meat eaters we need to reduce, it's the world's population. Too many people in the world is literally the root cause of every single problem there is.

Newgirls · 17/03/2022 13:48

Most of meat eating IS industrialised.

A billion chickens eaten every single year in the UK. A BILLION! They are not raised on idyllic Scottish farms enjoying sunshine and fresh air. Yet the packaging says ‘happy’ chickens and adverts show fields.

The meat industry has pushed for ever increasing sales and profits and this is where we are today - aisles full of yuk processed meat products. Cafes/pubs/take outs selling cheap meat products. And ‘farmers’ are supplying them

OutsideVoice · 17/03/2022 13:44

The whole vegan/omnivore issue has become divisive and toxic.

Much of the research uses skewed data and is funded by those who stand to make a fortune out of vegan supplements and plant-based-anything.

Studies vilifying meat are pointless as they include processed meat (burgers, sausages) and the crap that often goes alongside those - chips, burger buns etc.

Production of vegan foods contribute to depleting the planet of resources, where animal farming (high quality farming, not industrial scale farming) encourages a balance - animals eating the parts of plants that are inedible to humans, their poo nourishing the soil and plants, even the action of hooved mammals trampling grass is an essential part of its healthy growth within an ecosystem.

Industrialised farming is the issue here, not meat eating.

Calphurnia88 · 17/03/2022 13:40

I would consider myself a dirty vegan. So eat a lot more plant based meals these days but with meat and cheese etc thrown in from time to time.

So... Not in the slightest bit vegan then? Grin

EricCartmansMagicalUnderpants · 17/03/2022 13:33

By stuffed you mean a couple of 60cm shelves 🤣🤣. There are aisles full of animal junk food and hardly any vegan junk food. And even the junk food is pretty good stuff mixed together. And most vegans I know, including myself rarely have it.

There's a huge amount of vegan food in recent years compared to even 5 years ago. I suppose it depends on where you live though. I'm in a busy area. And it's far more than just a couple of shelves. Maybe a check of the ingredients list might be in order rather than assuming it's all good stuff.

Yet despite a booming market in vegan food, according to the Mumsnet massive, no vegans are eating it. Goodness. Well I guess if that's the case, the supermarkets must be throwing in out every week due to lack of demand.

Not that I give a shit what anyone eats personally. If people want to eat meat. Fine. If people want to eat vegan food, fine. As long as they keep their purity spirals to themselves rather than dictate to other people then it's all good

Newgirls · 17/03/2022 13:30

Eat locally sounds great but the UK is densely populated. We import HALF our food. Scientists have told us that eating plant based diet will help with that massive issue.

Raising meat is un-eco due to their feed, transport etc

Newgirls · 17/03/2022 13:28

@WeirdlyKind

It absolutely isn't. Shipping vegan food products across the world is terrible for the environment. Not to mention trendy stuff like tofu and quinoa are often produced by horribly exploited people. And stuff like almonds/soya bean/ avocado's are horribly water intensive.

The best thing anyone can do is eat as locally as they can to reduce food miles.

Prawns? Coffee? Bananas? All shipped across the world. 50% of meat too.
WeirdlyKind · 17/03/2022 13:27

It absolutely isn't. Shipping vegan food products across the world is terrible for the environment. Not to mention trendy stuff like tofu and quinoa are often produced by horribly exploited people. And stuff like almonds/soya bean/ avocado's are horribly water intensive.

The best thing anyone can do is eat as locally as they can to reduce food miles.

EricCartmansMagicalUnderpants · 17/03/2022 13:25

@MargotMoo

EricCartmansMagicalUnderpants - that’s just hyperbole though - there is still far more non-vegan processed food. And I suspect non vegans must be eating it too to cut down their meat consumption which is very likely a good thing environmentally, for health and for animal welfare. I’m sure there are also vegans with unbalanced unhealthy diets - many people do it for animal welfare not for health and since most people in this country are unhealthy I don’t see why it’s such a big deal. It’s not the “gotcha” that meat eaters think it is.
Yes of course there is. Because there's more meat eaters. And meat processed ready meals are pretty grim too. But having observed it over the last 30 years when there was virtually nothing on the shelves for vegans or vegetarians, it's clear that the market has grown massively. There's not much vegetarian stuff on the shelves either particularly, I guess the vegetarians still lose out as it's easier for manufacturers to produce vegan food which vegetarians can eat, even though they may not want to.
Newgirls · 17/03/2022 13:24

Meat industry in the uk is very problematic. I think if most people stuck to a roast on a Sunday and leftovers, maybe fish if they live near a coast and plant protein and plants the rest of the time we wouldn’t be in this eco crisis.

Meat and dairy farming isn’t eco. The UK imports 50 % of its meat and the Uk eats almost a billion chickens each year. How many of those do you see running around fields being ‘free range’. There is so much spin around meat production and people so close their eyes to it.

Eating meat should be a rare thing rather than the casual thing it’s become - burgers, chicken sandwiches, pork tacos, M&S chicken salads - it’s grim

InkySquid · 17/03/2022 13:22

Historically, there aren't any populations that are vegan. Even Jains eat dairy products. The healthiest populations, e.g. Japan eat mostly vegetables with small amounts of meat, fish and dairy

RockinHorseShit · 17/03/2022 13:17

Compromise, I would consider myself a dirty vegan. So eat a lot more plant based meals these days but with meat and cheese etc thrown in from time to time.

EhConfused

Crikey dietary labels are starting to trump the never ending list of gender/sexuality labels Grin

& you're an omnivore, just as you were born to be

vitahelp · 17/03/2022 13:11

@RubyFruitSunday I think your friends are part of the problem with veganism. By making it so strict and stating that eating a non-vegan food even just once a year is unacceptable, they are making veganism feel very inaccessible.
I feel by making it more flexible, more people are likely to do it. And surely a nation of half vegans, is better than 5% hardcore vegans.

Cloudsarebright · 17/03/2022 13:03

If you look at the food chain logically, energy is lost at every stage.

So by obtaining energy from animals, energy is wasted as opposed to getting energy from crops.

Of course it’s not always that simple, when the infrastructure/type of crops that exist already are suited for animal consumption.

So it may waste some energy in order to transition to vegan farming but in future the energy saved and reduce in gas emissions will counteract that. Also the crops most livestock are fed on are generally flown in soy/corn based dry feeds which requires a vast amount more energy than all this ‘grass fed’ narrative so many people seem to believe.

There’s so many other issues with eating animals aswell, such as antibiotic resistance, zoonotic disease, high doses of hormones (lactating mammals), ethics to both the animals and people whose only option of work is in abattoirs, breeding these animals so they are no longer able to exist in the wild.