Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend copies everything... even DCs name?!

191 replies

Bakeacake131 · 17/03/2022 00:05

Long story short. I have a friend who, in other people’s words, is besotted with me/borderline obsessed. They’re lovely as a person but over the years I’ve seen my engagement ring copied, my watch copied, and now my DCs name...

Received a message asking if they would mind if they selected DCs name for their own DC even though when we announced DCs name they noted that they thought it was odd, sneered at it and said they weren’t a fan.

What would you do? I want to say I think it’s too much and they should probably find another name that’s their name, but I’m not sure how to phrase it.

They are seeing a health professional for underlying MH issues so I want to be sensitive but feel this is just getting too much now...

Thoughts?

OP posts:
GrendelsGrandma · 17/03/2022 15:18

I don't think I'd even notice the ring or watch. It's just jewellery, who gives a toss? The name - it would depend if it was fairly common like Elizabeth etc it wouldn't be an issue.

It doesn't sound as if you like her that much though?

SeasonFinale · 17/03/2022 15:04

*me not never

SeasonFinale · 17/03/2022 15:04

I would reply "You had never going for a minute there. As if you would choose (name). For a second I thought it was 1 April. What Re you calling them really?"

JudyGemstone · 17/03/2022 14:59

RosiePosieDozy
“I have read on here before that some people copy a friend like this because they're struggling mentally, questioning every decision they make and so making the same decisions as a friend means that they can be confident that they're doing things right.

Re the name, I wouldn't name my child the same name as a friend's child unless I was in love with the name. As a pp said, no one owns a name and friends come and go. She might well love the name or she might be doing this because of her mental illness. She has asked you what you think so now is your opportunity to be honest in a sensitive way.”

That’s probably true, but it’s still irritating and not very thoughtful of others. Definitely say yes you would mind, I would mind!

Bakeacake131 · 17/03/2022 14:07

Thank you everyone for your input with this - although the poll results firmly agree that this is moving into a weird and uncomfortable friendship zone the different perspectives and approaches in how to respond have really helped.

I'll message her later drawing on the 'you didn't like it / it's special to us - find something special to you / I don't own it, but it is weird' and see what I get back.... Will update in due course

OP posts:
Bakeacake131 · 17/03/2022 14:04

@SilverDoe

Call me sexist but the copying baby names and engagement rings makes the friend sound distinctly female.
They are female - sorry, I agree with you and thought it was clear and didn't intentionally leave their sex out of it.
OP posts:
EdithRea · 17/03/2022 14:04

I'd just say whatever and stop seeing them. They sound dull and annoying.

Bakeacake131 · 17/03/2022 14:01

@RosiePosieDozy

I have read on here before that some people copy a friend like this because they're struggling mentally, questioning every decision they make and so making the same decisions as a friend means that they can be confident that they're doing things right.

Re the name, I wouldn't name my child the same name as a friend's child unless I was in love with the name. As a pp said, no one owns a name and friends come and go. She might well love the name or she might be doing this because of her mental illness. She has asked you what you think so now is your opportunity to be honest in a sensitive way.

This is a really interesting take. I think she falls firmly in this camp - anxiety is a huge issue for her
OP posts:
Bakeacake131 · 17/03/2022 13:59

@Easterbunnyiswindowshopping

Aren't you getting a huge tattoo this week end op? Garish and obvious?
Loved this - thanks for the laugh amongst this Grin
OP posts:
Whatever00 · 17/03/2022 12:20

I would say...

I think it would be confusing if both kids have the same name because we will all be spending so much time together.

SilverDoe · 17/03/2022 11:50

Call me sexist but the copying baby names and engagement rings makes the friend sound distinctly female.

Rosehugger · 17/03/2022 11:46

I'd say that I don't mind, it's their free choice. But I'd start distancing myself from this person further and block them on social media.

DropYourSword · 17/03/2022 11:38

[quote MurmuratingStarling]@Bakeacake131 are THEY male or female? You keep saying THEY, and you haven't said he or she at any point. Is this friend male or female?

It must be much harder to keep saying they, and them, and their, and they're, than it is to just say him, her, she, or he.

Hard to advise when people are so ambiguous about someone's gender. Why do people DO this?[/quote]
What difference does it make in this particular situation?

amusedbush · 17/03/2022 11:31

I know everyone on MN says "nobody owns a name" but I find copycats to be really irritating. If it was just an isolated incident where she happened to like the same name for her child then fine, lots of people have the same name as someone they know. However, this person is blatantly copying every aspect of your life and it's weird.

I had a friend who was like this and it got old quickly. I'd get new glasses and she would buy the same ones. I'd get a fringe cut in, so would she. One time I showed her a picture of a dress I had ordered and she immediately (as in, right there in front of me) found it online on her phone and pulled out her bank card to buy it for herself Confused

I would tell your friend that you're not comfortable with it. Even if she goes ahead and uses the name, you'll have made it clear that you're unhappy about it and you can start to pull away from her.

WineGetsMeThroughIt · 17/03/2022 11:31

Also just thought I'd say that I used to have a friend who copied everything I did & bought. She did the same with another friend. It got so annoying that I started lying and saying I liked something or bought something that I actually hadn't just to see if she would do the same. She did. Anything I actually did buy I'd not tell her about. Annoying, but it gave me a bit of relief to know she was wasting her time & money buying stuff I finally had no interest in

MurmuratingStarling · 17/03/2022 11:22

@gamerchick

Hard to advise when people are so ambiguous about someone's gender. Why do people DO this

Because it irritates people.

Grin
WineGetsMeThroughIt · 17/03/2022 11:22

@Incognito32

Maybe message back - I thought you didn't like the name and I think it would be best if you chose something different, otherwise it's going to be very confusing. Do you need some help thinking of names?

This is exactly what I was thinking. Remind them and point out at the fact they made it known to you that they didn't even like the name at first and encourage them to choose something different

gamerchick · 17/03/2022 11:20

Hard to advise when people are so ambiguous about someone's gender. Why do people DO this

Because it irritates people.

MurmuratingStarling · 17/03/2022 11:16

@Bakeacake131 are THEY male or female? You keep saying THEY, and you haven't said he or she at any point. Is this friend male or female?

It must be much harder to keep saying they, and them, and their, and they're, than it is to just say him, her, she, or he.

Hard to advise when people are so ambiguous about someone's gender. Why do people DO this?

Gilead · 17/03/2022 11:03

I knew someone like this. We got to the point where I would cut labels out of my children’s clothes. When she started harassing me for their Christmas list I cut all ties.

GatoradeMeBitch · 17/03/2022 10:47

I would gently remind them that they didn't like it when you announced it for your child.

It sounds like they look up to you. Maybe if you can think of a few similar names they might pick one. Or if you say "I wish I'd named them Finn/Heather/Thomas/Roman/Chester and that will be the name if I have another" they will think that's the superior name and take it!

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 17/03/2022 10:47

I'd just send a message back saying that might be a touch confusing whenever you're together, as you'd need to find a way to differentiate between the 2 kids.
I might also add that it's a bit surprising that they want to use it, given their negative reaction to it when you called YOUR child that name.

But in all honesty, unless this is your only ever friend and you can't bear to lose her, I'd dump her as a friend.

BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 17/03/2022 10:39

I think you are confident in your choices and she is not, so she copies you in order not to have to make a choice that she will regret. So stop being confident, when you get back to her with an answer say something along the lines of slightly regretting the choice of name and wishing you'd gone with something more mainstream/starting with a different letter/different number of syllables/easier to spell. Put the choice on her "well, it's up to you of course, but I wouldn't if I was choosing a name again". That way she will decide without you forbidding it.

You can use this method of slight regret all the time. Engagement ring - I love it for it's symbolism but I wish I'd gone for a solitaire/trilogy/colourful stone. New clothes - I'll wear it to get the value out of it but it's a pain to iron/the seams rub my skin/it's not the silhouette that I was hoping for. She'll probably find someone more confident than you to copy.

Marvellousmadness · 17/03/2022 10:34

Nobody owns a name op.
But her behaviour sounds like you need to stop being friends with her. I would

Ariela · 17/03/2022 10:33

'Absolutely not, imagine the confusion! And everyone will think you are copying. But I thought you really didn't like the name anyway. '

Swipe left for the next trending thread