Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Homes for Ukrainians - Issues

36 replies

PercyGoat · 16/03/2022 20:31

DF & her DH foster "children refugees".

They currently have a male who is "just 17". He arrived on an inflatable boat. He has no passport or any verifiable background. He speaks little English.

DF went through extensive training to deal with trauma etc. Their house was assessed and they had to make some changes to their house to make it "child friendly".

Loads of my friends are announcing on Facebook that they are providing a room for refugees.

I worry about the lack of vetting on both sides!

DF has some boundaries in place into what placement she is willing and not willing to have. I don't think that people are aware of boundaries!!!

I've seen someone saying that they can convert their living room into a bedroom if needed. Others have one spare room and considering hosting a family. Why is no one concerned about overcrowding?

£350 does not cover the costs of housing someone.

What happens after 6 months???

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 04/04/2022 14:21

@MangosteenSoda

I think it’s hugely open to abuse in its current incarnation. Too slow to centralise everything and not enough safeguards. Completely unsurprising that large numbers of single middle aged men are looking to host 20-30 year old women. Poor great granny Ludmilla with her bunions and 3 chins doesn’t seem to get a look in.

Having said all that, huge kudos to the legitimate hosts who are going out of their way to support the refugees.

A lot of the people in the group I am and on Twitter in are hosting older people. I hate the Facebook adverts and if I was running the scheme everyone would have to go through an existing charity. The charities have proved themselves agile and efficient so I don’t think it would cause hold ups. Even people like me who are doing it through Ukrainian friends would have to explain our connection (which would be easy enough-in our case DH and his Ukrainian colleague could show they work together and his Ukrainian colleague used to be at the institution our prospective guest works at). It wouldn’t be failsafe, nothing is, but it would help deter the more obvious predators. And you would set the DBS in motion at the very start of the process. But the refugee charities have rightly complained about not being brought on board from the start. They have so much experience settling refugees, it is such a pity.
nopuppiesallowed · 04/04/2022 11:01

Those who are pointing out the obvious dangers in hosting and the myriad things that can go wrong are quite right. But as I see it, for the Ukrainian women and children, remaining in Ukraine is hugely dangerous and problematic. Surely the best way to make sure that they don't fall into abusive hands is to open up our safe homes if at all possible? We're waiting to be allocated a family - and I'd be lieing if I said I'm not apprehensive. We've had people stay with us before for a few months (in one instance with toddler, dog and boxes of their possessions). They were absolutely lovely (and I'd have them again in a heartbeat if necessary) but I really wanted my home back at the end and I'm quite certain they wanted to have their own place, too. It must be so difficult to live in someone else's home. But if it was my child and grandchildren needing refuge I really hope that someone would give up a short period of their comfortable lives to help them. Lots of people can't do it (no judgement here) and some people shouldn't do it, but we all need to examine our hearts here. If we would be willing to accept refuge in someone's home if war came to Britain shouldn't we also be willing to give a safe place to stay for these refugees?

YawnAndTheyWillYawnToo · 04/04/2022 10:55

He is 17
He’ll be scared in a place he knows nothing about with people who are strangers

MangosteenSoda · 04/04/2022 10:27

I think it’s hugely open to abuse in its current incarnation. Too slow to centralise everything and not enough safeguards. Completely unsurprising that large numbers of single middle aged men are looking to host 20-30 year old women. Poor great granny Ludmilla with her bunions and 3 chins doesn’t seem to get a look in.

Having said all that, huge kudos to the legitimate hosts who are going out of their way to support the refugees.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 04/04/2022 10:18

Obviously anything in a language you don’t speak is hard to impossible Confused

That’s why the sponsor generally does it.

Visaquestions · 04/04/2022 09:53

@TheCountessofFitzdotterel actually I’d say the form filling is awful if you aren’t an English speaker.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 03/04/2022 21:25

You mean the form filling? It’s not crazily long, just an hour or so if you have all the info. The complication is that both parties need to fill it together with more on the guest side than the host (but in English) so there’s a certain amount of information sharing needed. There are also some pieces of documentation demanded which can be hard for a person fleeing war to provide.

However they are taking bloody ages to be approved. There are people who applied on the first day with no obvious complications who have not yet been approved. I hardly know anyone whose guests have arrived. Meanwhile, for people whose would be guests are in dangerous situations , it is extremely difficult to have to tell them day after day that the visa is not yet approved and you don’t know how long it will be.

There are also some other problems such as the Home Office helpline giving out contradictory advice and documents disappearing from the system after being uploaded.

The system is a mess, unfortunately. If you are thinking of applying now it may be sorted out by the time you have matched with sponsees or the backlog may have grown to months rather than weeks.

goingtotown · 03/04/2022 21:20

What is DF thought it was Dear Father.

QuertyQuordle · 03/04/2022 21:18

@DFOD my family application was a few days less than a whole month as a guide

Visaquestions · 03/04/2022 21:17

I do worry a bit about the ‘what ifs’. It is not easy sometimes. I now have my own Ukrainian family here. We are currently 5 adults and 3 children in a a 3 bed house. We are related and it’s still not easy, using the bathroom/ kitchen and generally getting on. I’ve even lived like this many times before too. I think some British will see the reality of a busy house, funny food smells absolutely general culture differences and struggle a lot. It’s not all rosy. It’s all so unstable for the people coming here.

My aunt is already returning to Ukraine (to the west though, with other relatives with a bigger house) after struggling with overcrowded hosts.

DFOD · 03/04/2022 21:10

Any updates from anyone hosting or who knows someone hosting?

How long does the visa application take?

SquashedSquashes · 18/03/2022 21:46

Hi all

Sorry I’m resurrecting a thread, but I have some questions about the visa form.

I have completed it on behalf of the family we’ve connected with, and have sent them a form. They all have valid passports.

They want to know if they have to go to a biometric centre, as well as completing the form. Does anyone know the answer to this?

Thanks!

Alexandra2001 · 17/03/2022 10:04

I thought everyone has to be vetted? thats what the Govt website says if you are not related.

Those arriving will have met standard security checks. Sponsors will also be subject to checks

Those in the sponsoring households will also be subject to security checks and may be subject to safeguarding checks too. Checks may be carried out on a rolling basis

Of course, this means further delays before any refugee actually arrives here with no family connections.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 17/03/2022 09:51

I worry about them exploited and modern slavery. There seems to be very little by way of protection from people who do not have refugees best interests at heart.

SallyLovesCheese · 17/03/2022 09:48

We've expressed interest to have an adult and child. At the moment it's just so we can get updates and make a more informed choice later. There is a lot to think about, as people have said. I can only hope that the background checks are done thoroughly and that councils do go and look at properties before decisions are made. I'm a teacher and we're both DBS checked already and have no problems being further checked out. But people here are right that it could potentially be terrible for some refugees.

AlternativePerspective · 17/03/2022 09:44

And this is exactly what it is. A way to import cheap labour. And government sanctioned it. Clever isn’t it? The public are being made fools out of. ffs. If the government don’t let in refugees they’re accused of not doing enough. If they do let them in, and let’s be honest here we don’t have space for an unlimited number of refugees unless the public become involved, then the public are being made fools of.

How exactly do you propose we deal with a potential influx of refugees while under pressure to take in more and more and do it now?

I agree that taking in refugees is fraught with potential issues, but there is no right or wrong answer here.

MumsMetHer · 17/03/2022 09:42

I totally understand most of the concerns expressed here.

But why would it be overcrowding to use the one spare/guest bedroom?

Presumably that would be used for a single person, or mother and child, rather than for a family of four?

EvilPea · 17/03/2022 09:33

I agree completely. I live in a place rife for slavery. I can see them rubbing their hands with glee at the prospect of getting paid for their new free labourers.

Nicholethejewellery · 17/03/2022 09:30

People who do offer rooms need to be very careful to make sure they inform the necessary people.

Insurance company needs to be informed because your premium will be partly based on who is living at the property.

Mortgage provider or landlord need to be informed.

If you're a leaseholder like me, your lease may prevent you taking a refugee and therefore you risk losing your home. Mine states the flat can only be occupied by "professional people of good character" - I would have no way of telling in advance whether the refugee(s) I got were "professional people" or "of good character" so risk breaching the lease.

TempName01 · 17/03/2022 08:50

People offering their homes are very generous but I fear they are not thinking it through. There is so much that can go wrong, we always see on here people posting complaining about unwanted visitors and guests, how stressful it is having people staying. Yet people are willing to potentially have a family staying with them long term, what do they do if it simply isn’t working out?!

Meadmaiden · 17/03/2022 02:26

Op, I would say, are they even sure this 17 year d is a minor? There are cases of asylum seekers posing as children, who are much older, in order to make them harder to deport.

This is a less than ideal solution out of necessity. We don't have enough empty properties to house everyone arriving. It also has the potential to work well, with host families helping Ukrainians to learn the language and access local services and employment, as well as a cultural exchange.

Zapx · 17/03/2022 02:18

I think the issue is the sheer scale of the number of people currently displaced. No country will be able to cope, and help, to anything like the numbers required without doing less-than-ideal schemes, a bit like this imo. We could say no one comes until background checks, desire for helping checks, property checks, no overcrowding checks, full safeguarding etc but realistically these people need helping now... I worry too about exploitation. I think the potential is massive. But I equally don't really see another way of doing it, to the numbers that will be required.

PercyGoat · 17/03/2022 00:10

@BourbonVanilla

He arrived on an inflatable boat? Are you sure he's from Ukraine?
No, they foster as a career. The refugee was from somewhere else long before the Ukraine war. My point is that he has no verifiable background.
OP posts:
BourbonVanilla · 17/03/2022 00:02

He arrived on an inflatable boat? Are you sure he's from Ukraine?

sst1234 · 16/03/2022 23:42

@MsFogi

My growing concern is that the three people who have told me they have put themselves forward to 'host' are the last people who I would expect to do so. However, after further conversation all of them seem to see the arrangement to be one where they are getting cheap/free, skilled labour (there seem to be various groups that are organising for particular 'skilled' people to come over eg gardening, building etc). They all seem to see this a way to plug the gap that has been left by covid/Brexit with foreign workers leaving the country.
And this is exactly what it is. A way to import cheap labour. And government sanctioned it. Clever isn’t it? The public are being made fools out of.