Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do you want to work here?

234 replies

LottyD32 · 16/03/2022 12:14

AIBU to detest this question and find it completely pointless?

Why do they still ask it?
What do they hope to glean from your answer?

We all know the answer mostly is 'I couldn't care less, just give me the job and pay me' so why do they insist on making people jump through these ridiculous hoops?

OP posts:
ChocolateDigestivesMmm · 16/03/2022 21:57

In non profits and vocation type jobs, yes. But your big standard office/corporate job...why would a candidate need to "align themselves with the values"? What does that even mean? Unless you're hiring a CEO then this is meaningless, you simply need someone to be able to do the job and be reasonably personable. Which a good recruiter should be able to spot without asking a vague question that no one really answers honestly. Perhaps it should be re worded...you could ask something specific like "Which aspects of the job description appeal you?" or "Which project of ours interests you the most?"

Hawkins001 · 16/03/2022 21:56

@CapMarvel

I appreciate your perspectives, and you have very good points about the issue.

TheHateIsNotGood · 16/03/2022 21:55

Seems like it Havanna. Anyways, after dipping my toe in that murky pond, I'll be sticking to self-employed and freelance rather than have some no-mark, self-professed expert on eye-rolling and little else, decide how good at my work I am.

And even a shelf-filling night-job at at ASDA to a temp job at my Local Council, seems to rely on some wierd recruitment practices.

Rather than add any more meat to the grinder that Recruiters rely on to keep themselves in work, I'd rather just jump through the other hoops involved with earning a living.

If we all did that, then many Recruiters would be out of a job themselves and have to go look for a 'proper job' to earn their living.

CapMarvel · 16/03/2022 21:47

@Havanananana

... given the options of someone who took an interest to research the company and know more about the company, vs someone who just wants the £ without a hoot about the company, I know which candidates I would be considering more.

So the Duracell-bunny who knows how to play the game, does a bit of research and gushes about whatever the corporate website has deemed to be the fad of the year gets the job? While the steady, well-qualified and reliable candidate who is up-front about his/her reasons and promises to do an honest day's work for an honest day's pay doesn't get a look in?

Exactly this.

It's really easy to fake interest in a company. It's much harder to be good at a job, which ultimately is all that matters.

CapMarvel · 16/03/2022 21:46

@Hawkins001

For me it would give some kind of perspectives as to the attitudes of the candidate, yes to some it's just £ but given the options of someone who took an interest to research the company and know more about the company, vs someone who just wants the £ without a hoot about the company, I know which candidates I would be considering more.
It's easy to fake an interest in a company. Most tuned in candidates for jobs know to spend 30 minutes browsing around the company on the internet, looking at linkedin etc.

Mostly it's just a means to gather a few things to say in the interview. Honestly, I think the idea that people should have passion and excitement for a job hopelessly naive.

For the vast majority of people the only reason they go to work is for the money. That's it. Secondary, honest answers to the question are things like "because you are on the bus route" and "because you are next door to a nice gym".

And that doesn't reflect on their ability to do a job well at all. I'm really good at my job but if the company stopped existng I would shrug and find another one. If they didn't pay me, I would stop working. If I won the lottery I would stop working. If another company wants to pay me more money I would go to them. Employees owe companies nothing beyond what the job requires.

Hawkins001 · 16/03/2022 21:44

@Havanananana

... given the options of someone who took an interest to research the company and know more about the company, vs someone who just wants the £ without a hoot about the company, I know which candidates I would be considering more.

So the Duracell-bunny who knows how to play the game, does a bit of research and gushes about whatever the corporate website has deemed to be the fad of the year gets the job? While the steady, well-qualified and reliable candidate who is up-front about his/her reasons and promises to do an honest day's work for an honest day's pay doesn't get a look in?

I understand your perspectives and fair point, I would give the ones who did research more credibility and points, but it would not be the overall deciding factor, just that it gives the candidate who did research more of an advantage, but then as you pointed out, I would need to distinguish weather they just did a quick Google and jotted some notes, vs actual research, e.g. Company house, the publication of stock reports if we were a public company listed on the stock exchange ect.
Havanananana · 16/03/2022 21:37

... given the options of someone who took an interest to research the company and know more about the company, vs someone who just wants the £ without a hoot about the company, I know which candidates I would be considering more.

So the Duracell-bunny who knows how to play the game, does a bit of research and gushes about whatever the corporate website has deemed to be the fad of the year gets the job? While the steady, well-qualified and reliable candidate who is up-front about his/her reasons and promises to do an honest day's work for an honest day's pay doesn't get a look in?

wordler · 16/03/2022 21:31

[quote ChocolateDigestivesMmmm]@KleineDracheKokosnuss Haha yeah sure they do. If you're the boss they're simply boot licking in the hope of a promotion/pay rise. I see this in my work and it's so transparent. No sane person truly cares about vague corporate bullshit.
You can definitely see the divide between employers and employees on this thread though, and how deluded/up their own arse employers are.[/quote]
Most of us are both though - if we are in charge of teams we still have bosses, and still have to be interviewed ourselves. Very few people on this thread appear to be company owners.

If you have 20 candidates who all look equally great on paper, and all would be paid the same amount so the hiring budget isn't an issue either, you've got to go with the candidate who comes across the best in the interview. And at least making a small effort to align yourself with the vision of the company, or showing how you would be a good fit for the team with your enthusiam etc.

And if you've worked in non-profit sectors you often do really care about the organisation in general above what your job simply does for you in terms of wages etc.

Hawkins001 · 16/03/2022 21:23

For me it would give some kind of perspectives as to the attitudes of the candidate, yes to some it's just £ but given the options of someone who took an interest to research the company and know more about the company, vs someone who just wants the £ without a hoot about the company, I know which candidates I would be considering more.

AnneLovesGilbert · 16/03/2022 21:19

I’ve never asked that specifically but I have asked what interested them about the role and that’s definitely worthwhile because the number of times someone has described a completely different job and skill set needed is astounding. One woman said she wanted a change from her current role while involved xyz and apparently bored her to death, and had to explain the role she was interviewing for would involve much the same type of work. Her poor face Confused but equally she was wasting everyone’s time and the following half hour was awkward as arse.

ChocolateDigestivesMmmm · 16/03/2022 21:14

@KleineDracheKokosnuss Haha yeah sure they do. If you're the boss they're simply boot licking in the hope of a promotion/pay rise. I see this in my work and it's so transparent. No sane person truly cares about vague corporate bullshit.
You can definitely see the divide between employers and employees on this thread though, and how deluded/up their own arse employers are.

wordler · 16/03/2022 21:13

@TheHateIsNotGood

Having rediscovered the marvels of current recruitment practices and the multi-hoops a candidate has to jump through prior to even being invited to an Interview.

I am rather bemused by those many pps here claiming that asking this question because it 'weeds out' weak candidates.

Surely all those multi-hoops that HR/Recruitment 'professionals' require candidates to jump through prior to Interview should be enough?

Or, maybe the HR/Recruitment 'profession' is a big non-job for people that don't know what else to do.

Well, the HR process should pick the candidates with the best skills and experience from the total applicants. If you consider that some jobs have hundreds of applications for one job, you need someone to reduce the pile to a more manageable number before the interviews. I've held interviews for a job which had over 500 applications - we interviewed 20.

By the time you get to the interview person or panel the candidates are usually fairly evenly matched in terms of what their skills and experience look like on paper. The interview is working out if this person in front of you will fit well within the team.

Questions like "why do you want this job" are also sometimes used as an easy starter question to break the ice, get someone talking, let them feel confident with a good start. Because it's such a common question it's an easy one to practice and think about.

How people react non-verbally to these common questions also tells you a lot about them. Looks of panic, sighs of boredom, eye rolling, open confident smile etc. Honestly, if you can't be bothered to make a little bit of effort for five minutes in an interview are you going to be rolling your eyes and huffing with boredom when the job gets a bit tedious every now and then, no one wants that on their team.

TheHateIsNotGood · 16/03/2022 20:54

Having rediscovered the marvels of current recruitment practices and the multi-hoops a candidate has to jump through prior to even being invited to an Interview.

I am rather bemused by those many pps here claiming that asking this question because it 'weeds out' weak candidates.

Surely all those multi-hoops that HR/Recruitment 'professionals' require candidates to jump through prior to Interview should be enough?

Or, maybe the HR/Recruitment 'profession' is a big non-job for people that don't know what else to do.

KleineDracheKokosnuss · 16/03/2022 20:40

@ChocolateDigestivesMmmm my colleagues do actually care about the ESG and they take pride in the reputation for excellence. They’re forever going on about it. Ad nauseum.

And frankly, we have a website with about 100 pages on myriad issues, achievements and general news items. A candidate should be able to find something that piques their interest.

wordler · 16/03/2022 20:30

People who say the question is pointless are missing the point that the way a candidate answers a question is part of the assessment.

And of course there are some roles, jobs and companies that it would not be particularly necesssary. But for many roles it's a potential insight into how a candidate is planning their career progression, and what the mutual exchange of benefit is between the candidate and the company - and in some cases why this particular team within a company.

If you're hiring an office manager for your fashion design business and you have two candidate equally skilled, and equal experience in running an office, the one who has a long standing interest in fashion design and sales is going to be a more enthusiastic team member and better at interacting with clients and suppliers than the one who doesn't see it as any different than running the office at a building supplies company.

ChocolateDigestivesMmmm · 16/03/2022 20:21

@KleineDracheKokosnuss But no one does give a damn about ESG credentials or "reputation for excellence". The training programme, maybe.

Most people pick companies because of pay and other factors like location...so actually the "bad" answer was the truthful one, that most candidates think but don't say, because they just tell the interviewer what they want to hear. This is probably why so many corporate places are toxic to work in, because the people who get hired are the ones who can bullshit the most, rather than the honest ones!

ChocolateDigestivesMmmm · 16/03/2022 20:07

@PineappleWilson
But when job hunting, a candidate will likely have applied to lots of other companies, why would yours be any more special?

@FTEngineerM
I have never in my life had a company's best interests or goals at heart, only mine. Companies don't care about you, no matter what they say. Don't get me wrong, I turn up, do the job to the required standard, keep on good terms with my colleagues and boss. I care about doing the job to a good standard, because that's what they're paying me for and I do take pride in my work.
But if I didn't need the money I wouldn't be there. The exception would be if it was a charity whose cause I believed in.

I agree OP, it's a pointless question for most jobs, unless the job in question is a vocation, like nursing or teaching or a charity, and they want to know what attracted you to that field of work. But for a bog standard office job, not so much.

CapMarvel · 16/03/2022 19:14

I don't think that's necessarily true at all, and it's very role dependent in any case.

And even if it's true, that doesn't stop the honest, most important answer being "for the money" - but we have to play this little game that we all are giving up 8 hours of our day because we can't think of anything better to do.

FrangipaniBlue · 16/03/2022 19:09

Because people who are passionate and enthusiastic about their jobs perform better.

If you aren't at least a little bit enthusiastic about the job/company then I don't want you working for me.

CapMarvel · 16/03/2022 19:05

"They don't seem to care much about anything related to their job besides the money."

... which is true for most people, and I fail to see why that is a problem as long as they show up on time and can perform their duties as required.

Nobody who works in a shop has a passion for selling you fruit, but as long as they do it, does it matter?

CapMarvel · 16/03/2022 19:03

The honest answer to that one is usually "because you are recruiting and competitor isn't" or "I've applied to both and I don't really care who I work for and I'm just going to go with whoever pays the most".

Most people are working solely to fund their lives outside of work. Let's not pretend otherwise.

HowIsItMarchAlready · 16/03/2022 19:02

@StepAwayFromGoogling

With that attitude, I wouldn't want to employ you, OP.
I couldn't have said it better. Although I'm pretty sure the OP will say that they don't care. They don't seem to care much about anything related to their job besides the money.
HowIsItMarchAlready · 16/03/2022 18:55

@MajorCarolDanvers

As an employer its the most important question.

I want to know why you want to work here. It tells me about your level of enthusiasm, your motivation, your passion, how much thought you have put into your application, how much research you have done about the job and the organisation.

It won't be a question I will be dropping any time soon.

So true. Because this tells an employer why, if they were offering the same money/benefits as a competitor, the candidate would pick them over the competitor. What made the candidate choose to apply there as opposed to somewhere else?
museumum · 16/03/2022 18:55

I think it’s not an unreasonable question.
It’s very rare that a job is literally the only job available in a whole town / area or that someone has genuinely applied to every vacancy in the region so there’s clearly some selection process in choosing where you are applying.

CapMarvel · 16/03/2022 18:50

@MajorCarolDanvers

As an employer its the most important question.

I want to know why you want to work here. It tells me about your level of enthusiasm, your motivation, your passion, how much thought you have put into your application, how much research you have done about the job and the organisation.

It won't be a question I will be dropping any time soon.

Why is it the most important question when in reality the top answer is "because you are going to pay me?"

I don't really care if the people I work with etc have a passion for the job or have looked over the companies last 10 years accounts. If they are reliable and can do the work, that's more than enough. Let's be honest, none of your employees would stay if you stopped giving them money.

Swipe left for the next trending thread