Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do you want to work here?

234 replies

LottyD32 · 16/03/2022 12:14

AIBU to detest this question and find it completely pointless?

Why do they still ask it?
What do they hope to glean from your answer?

We all know the answer mostly is 'I couldn't care less, just give me the job and pay me' so why do they insist on making people jump through these ridiculous hoops?

OP posts:
Ilkleymoor · 17/03/2022 07:52

My current.place always asks why are you leaving current role. I always thought this was a really stupid question until the last time I was recruiting and a candidate basically told me because they were unmanageable. So maybe there is more to these weeding out questions than I thought.

Havanananana · 17/03/2022 07:03

As an interviewer I do want to know why you've chosen my company, my specific team etc rather than the one down the road.

  1. Your company might be the only one currently looking for staff.

  2. Your company might have the reputation of being a poor employer, with a high staff turnover and difficulty in attracting and retaining staff - but my two best mates work for you, you're desperate for staff and the pay is not bad so for the next 12 months or so, I'll put up with that.

  3. You don't know that I might also have sent a speculative application to the company down the road and I'm just hedging my bets

wordler · 17/03/2022 02:48

@DimebagDarrell

I agree OP. It’s particularly ridiculous in smaller industries where there’s only a few organisations. I work in a niche area connected to academia and there’s maybe 6 or so organisations in the UK where I can do my job.

But in an interview it would come across badly if I replied to that question with the honest “because you’re advertising the job role that I’m interested in and have years of experience doing”. Instead I have to come up with some waffle about loving their new flagship initiative or EDI strategy or whatever. (And which is most likely near identical to the other competitor organisations anyway.)

But it wouldn't come across badly if your answer was like that - you don't have to gush about the company - it would sound totally fine if you answered that by saying “because you’re advertising the job role that I’m interested in and have years of experience doing”

It's a bit short though and I imagine the other candidates you are competing against are also being interviewed because they are interested in the role and have years of experience too.

So you flesh it out a bit to say why this is a job role you are interested in and remind them of the experience by connecting some of the details of that experience.

How you answer questions like this is just as important as what you say. Your tone, expression, enthusiasm.

If there's one role and 12 candidates and the top six have fairly identical levels of experience, skill and great references/reputations then all the interviewers have to go on is the impression you make when you are talking to them.

Questions like this one are a gift for making a good impression.

And @ChocolateDigestivesMmmm

Perhaps it should be re worded...you could ask something specific like "Which aspects of the job description appeal you?" or "Which project of ours interests you the most?"

Of course you can word it differently and sometimes it will be but it's exactly the same question. So if you practice an answer to "Why do you want to work here" you'll be ready for the same question worded slightly differently throughout the whole interview. 'Why is this a good fit for you? Why are you a good fit for us?' All the interview questions are getting to the same point.

And for the people who keep saying no one would work if they didn't need the money - again that's the whole point - if we have to work then it makes sense to aim to work at places your are interested in, where you'll enjoy the culture, fit in with your colleagues. As an interviewer I do want to know why you've chosen my company, my specific team etc rather than the one down the road.

MangyInseam · 17/03/2022 01:30

But if you pay well and treat people like human beings you will retain skilled staff. That's really what it comes down to.

Yeah. Corporate values being in alignment is always going to be secondary to don't be a dick.

MangyInseam · 17/03/2022 01:28

For when humans enter space and depending on what's out there, we need earth to have the best defensive and offensive capabilities as best as possible, don't forget everyone, we are just a drop in the ocean, when it comes to the vastness of the galaxies.

Ooo, I wonder how that would go over?

LondonQueen · 17/03/2022 01:07

Hate this question and never asked it when conducting interviews.

CapMarvel · 16/03/2022 23:40

@catinboots123

It's a fucking stupid question but it's a bit of a test Grin

Of course no one is going to say it's closer to home, better pay and better holidays (even though that's the truth)

One of the main reasons I took my current job was because my old role involved having to travel, and I hate travelling for work. I was completely open about that when interviewing because I wanted to set expectations right from the start, and it didn't do me any harm.

I honestly think that if people were open in interviews about this sort of thing recruitment would work better.

CapMarvel · 16/03/2022 23:36

@Hawkins001

Plus from a corporate perspectives, why spend time, effort, resources training and investing in people, if the person wants to jump ship as soon as possible just because they get a bit more £ ?
Well, that's the risk you take, isn't it?

But if you pay well and treat people like human beings you will retain skilled staff. That's really what it comes down to.

catinboots123 · 16/03/2022 23:21

It's a fucking stupid question but it's a bit of a test Grin

Of course no one is going to say it's closer to home, better pay and better holidays (even though that's the truth)

mrsmacmc · 16/03/2022 23:18

Why do you want to work here is a 🤨 question at interview (along with tell us about yourself, too ambiguous IMO) however it allows the interviewers to see which candidates have done research into the company pst the home page of the website / person spec. A good one to try and weave in past the corporate stuff is if the company have done a recent fundraiser activity & shared it on their social media. It opens up the conversation around corporate responsibility and gives the candidate an insight into the company culture too.

Hawkins001 · 16/03/2022 23:15

@mangnseam

For when humans enter space and depending on what's out there, we need earth to have the best defensive and offensive capabilities as best as possible, don't forget everyone, we are just a drop in the ocean, when it comes to the vastness of the galaxies.

Plus the same on earth, for if war breaks out, our troops and various other people that contribute to the defence of the realm, we hope to provide and equip them to the highest standards possible.

Hawkins001 · 16/03/2022 23:11

@RobotValkyrie

What do you say when an arms manufacturer asks why you want to work for them?

Beats me! Am a shit hot computer programmer too, but all my jobs have been in fields like medical research or safety systems.
Not cynical enough to play that game (and therefore a lot poorer than programmers working in finances/gambling/military/etc.)

For when humans enter space and depending on what's out there, we need earth to have the best defensive and offensive capabilities as best as possible, don't forget everyone, we are just a drop in the ocean, when it comes to the vastness of the galaxies.
RobotValkyrie · 16/03/2022 23:08

What do you say when an arms manufacturer asks why you want to work for them?

Beats me! Am a shit hot computer programmer too, but all my jobs have been in fields like medical research or safety systems.
Not cynical enough to play that game (and therefore a lot poorer than programmers working in finances/gambling/military/etc.)

gingerhills · 16/03/2022 23:04

I just don't agree that it's pointless for entry level jobs or because we all need to earn and wouldn't work if we won 6 mill. that might be a given, but we don't all apply for the same jobs, do we, even at entry level. DS1 really genuinely wanted to work in a coffee bar. He has no desire to work long term in the hospitality industry , he wants to do law, but he loves coffee, and was excited at being trained how to fluff the milk properly.

DS2 has never applied to work in cafe. He wants to work in a shop as he's interested in a career in retail buying or quality control and wants to get a feel for the shop floor first. So even their choices of entry level jobs are driven by specific desires. When I started out I loved waitressing but filing in an office made me want to fall asleep.

Someone who applies to work as a supermarket cashier might have a very different personality or skillset form someone who wants the night shift stacking shelves in an empty shop.

Dazedandconfused10 · 16/03/2022 23:04

To show you've researched the company. Then when they ask if you have any questions, you say ' why should I want to work here' you're selling yourself and should ask the company to do the same. An interview is a 2 way street.

RobotValkyrie · 16/03/2022 23:04

It gives the candidate a chance to show they've "done their homework"...

You don't have to gush over the company, you can just say you think your skills are a good fit for the role and you've got lots to offer to the company, and why you like working in this industry because reasons, and how the company is just the right size and a perfect fit for your future career plans, and how it's close to your home so you can commute by bike and save money and the environment, whatever rocks your personal brand, really. It's just yet another opportunity to sell yourself and demonstrate soft skills.
There's no right or wrong answer, just try not to sound like a dick (or maybe do sound like a dick, if you think that's what they're into. It is about "cultural fit", and some recruiters may well appreciate a bold cynical answer about simply needing the money)

MangyInseam · 16/03/2022 22:50

@Hawkins001

Plus from a corporate perspectives, why spend time, effort, resources training and investing in people, if the person wants to jump ship as soon as possible just because they get a bit more £ ?
Part of the problem with this is that for all corporate bodies spout about their values in the end they typically also have one, which is making money. The days when people expected real corporate loyalty and spend an entire carer in one company are largely gone.

Most people have funded their own education and training, too, sometimes creating a fair bit of debt.

So of course there isn't real loyalty in that sense. People do consider QOL which includes things beyond the money, for sure. But what are you going to say when you interview at a place that is likely to kind of suck? You can repeat their mission statement BS, or talk about how innovative they are at what they do, and get into a lot of depth about it. But the fact is that if they want the job they will tell you what you want to hear.

It reminds me of a friend of mine who used to be a shit-hot computer programmer. He worked for all the big evil companies (big ag, arms, banking) and made scads of money. And when he had enough, he quit and went off to pursue his passion writing.

What do you say when an arms manufacturer asks why you want to work for them?

Bouledeneige · 16/03/2022 22:49

I get asked this question a lot. I'm a CEO in the public and charity sector and I guess if you can't answer it credibly you won't be able to represent the organisation with confidence and influence. I've just started in a new role and I'm being asked this by lots of people including the trade press.

For the types of organisation I've worked in it really helps if people care about the cause. But I guess it's not true everywhere.

DimebagDarrell · 16/03/2022 22:44

I agree OP. It’s particularly ridiculous in smaller industries where there’s only a few organisations. I work in a niche area connected to academia and there’s maybe 6 or so organisations in the UK where I can do my job.

But in an interview it would come across badly if I replied to that question with the honest “because you’re advertising the job role that I’m interested in and have years of experience doing”. Instead I have to come up with some waffle about loving their new flagship initiative or EDI strategy or whatever. (And which is most likely near identical to the other competitor organisations anyway.)

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/03/2022 22:24

@Hawkins001

Plus from a corporate perspectives, why spend time, effort, resources training and investing in people, if the person wants to jump ship as soon as possible just because they get a bit more £ ?
If the candidate is that cynical they will just lie anyway.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/03/2022 22:23

@OneGoodTurn

Maybe to weed out the people who couldn’t care less about the job or the organisation and just want to get paid? Confused
You have just described my entire working life. I am 59.
ChocolateIsAlwaysTheAnswer · 16/03/2022 22:23

Agreed. Majority of people wouldn't work if they didn't have to. I certainly have no burning career dreams. If it was an option I would jack it all in and spend my time travelling or enjoying hobbies. Most of us would.

Hawkins001 · 16/03/2022 22:21

Plus from a corporate perspectives, why spend time, effort, resources training and investing in people, if the person wants to jump ship as soon as possible just because they get a bit more £ ?

SucculentChalice · 16/03/2022 22:21

@Havanananana

... given the options of someone who took an interest to research the company and know more about the company, vs someone who just wants the £ without a hoot about the company, I know which candidates I would be considering more.

So the Duracell-bunny who knows how to play the game, does a bit of research and gushes about whatever the corporate website has deemed to be the fad of the year gets the job? While the steady, well-qualified and reliable candidate who is up-front about his/her reasons and promises to do an honest day's work for an honest day's pay doesn't get a look in?

But quite possibly the interviewer asking these questions, or the manager who told them to put in these questions, is the same type that is better than sounding good than actually doing a good job.
Hawkins001 · 16/03/2022 22:19

@ChocolateDigestivesMmm

In non profits and vocation type jobs, yes. But your big standard office/corporate job...why would a candidate need to "align themselves with the values"? What does that even mean? Unless you're hiring a CEO then this is meaningless, you simply need someone to be able to do the job and be reasonably personable. Which a good recruiter should be able to spot without asking a vague question that no one really answers honestly. Perhaps it should be re worded...you could ask something specific like "Which aspects of the job description appeal you?" or "Which project of ours interests you the most?"
"One of the most important elements to consider when hiring is whether or not the potential candidate aligns with the values of the company. Why? Because when people are passionate about what they do and connect with a mission, the more likely they are to stay at the company and thrive"
Swipe left for the next trending thread