Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do you want to work here?

234 replies

LottyD32 · 16/03/2022 12:14

AIBU to detest this question and find it completely pointless?

Why do they still ask it?
What do they hope to glean from your answer?

We all know the answer mostly is 'I couldn't care less, just give me the job and pay me' so why do they insist on making people jump through these ridiculous hoops?

OP posts:
CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 12:03

If it's the difference between having a job or not, of course "work culture" is bullshit.

It's only really a consideration as a tiebreaker beyond that.

And btw, I like my job but I'm also honest about my motivations. Money first, that's the truth of it for me and for most people.

MasterBeth · 17/03/2022 11:53

Sure - and if I was interviewing someone for a part-time job in a supermarket, I don't need to believe that the applicant wants to pledge their life and future for the glory of Tesco. I just need to know that they're smart enough to answer an interview question in an appropriate way.

In your nephew's circumstances, "I want to work for a big store like Tesco because I hope it may give me the opportunity to take on more shifts and you're just round the corner" is a perfectly reasonable answer.

In my line of work, yes, people do choose the style of the company they work for. I'm an employee too. Of course I work because they give me a paycheque at the end of the month, but I also fit the informal, entrepreneurial culture of the company.

"Work culture" is not just bullshit. Would you rather work in a place where someone gives you a long list of what you have to do and when and how you have to do it, or somewhere where you're left to get on with things on your own? That's two different work cultures and different people choose differently.

It's a shame that your work life appears to have been so unfulfilling. Some of us like our jobs and try and find ones that suit us.

CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 11:45

"What's the point in lying"?

.... to get the job, fairly obviously, so they can pay the mortgage and pay for food/heating/the odd trip to the cinema.

Anything else is way, way down the list.

FTEngineerM · 17/03/2022 11:40

that most people will tell the interviewer what they want to hear

Isn’t that why companies have a high attrition rate though?

I’m mostly honest with interviewers, what’s the point in lying, it soon comes out. Like I said in a PP you can tell the colleagues who care about the company/what we do and the ones who are solely in it for the cash. There is definitely a difference. Someone who is invested in the company and what they’re about is more likely to develop things/start projects/improve the business using their own initiative ime.

jessy100 · 17/03/2022 11:17

I'm astonished at the naivety of employers on here! I"m so g!ad that I'm coming to the end of my working life and no longer have to put up with this shit. Nobody gives a shi t about your work culture, and your corporate values.
We all just play the game and tell you what you want to hear!

jessy100 · 17/03/2022 11:12

@masterBeth It's you who is missing the point!.That point is that most people will tell the interviewer what they want to hear. It's a box ticking exercise for both sides.

T he ultimate aim is to get offered the the job. It doesn't mean that we believe what we are saying to get it.
My nephew doesn't care which supermarket he works for. He couldn't care less If he's packing find a of beans on to shelves in Tesco or m&s.
He wants the job because he has a very expensive holiday planned that he had to fund!

CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 11:02

@MasterBeth

The words might sound like bullshit, but the concepts are sound.

"Will this person fit into the kind of company we are?" is the question I'm asking myself when I recruit. We have quite a flat structure, you're not micro-managed and have to take a lot of initiatives on your own. Some people are good at that, some people struggle.

Not being able to answer this question displays a lack of imagination, for me. I might not ask it in quite this way, but I'd be put off by someone who thought "because I need a job" is the only valid answer.

The fact is "because I need a job" is the real answer for most people.

People lie and bullshit in interviews about how wonderful the company looks and how interesting the job is, but the truth is they would have applied to all of your competitors and really they don't give a crap about your culture.

MasterBeth · 17/03/2022 10:51

@jessy100

It's an utterly pointless question! I always think the company and people interviewing want to be flattered and told how amazing g they are. In reality, most of us work because we need to pay the bills!

A few examples of bullshittery recently. Nephew who is a student went for two p/t super.markets jobs. It was two of the 'big four' He was asked this question, and answered it exactly the same way for both, just obviously tweaking very minor details.
Got offered both jobs!

In reality, his mate works in one of the jobs , and told him it's not a great place to work, and he is only there because he's a penniless student! SmileMy dn is in exactly the same position and will take pretty much anything for six months, so he can save for a massive holiday he has planned in September.

My friend went for two interviews on the same day to rival insurance companies. She parrotted the same bullshit answers to this question. Got offered both jobs. She took the one with the slightly better annual leave allowance.

I've been for a few interviews recently. My main criteria is that it's a job I can do on set days ( so that I can bugger off for long weekends in our campervan) and go home and not think about it. Should I tell the interview that?Wink Well of course I wont. just like my dn and df I will make up some bullying and tell them what they want to hear. The whole interviewing process needs to get fucking real!!

'

This shows a misunderstanding of what the question's asking.

Yes, there's probably not a massive difference between working part-time for Sainsburys and Tesco, so giving the same response is fine - I liek the idea of working for a well-known national brand, working as part of a big team, working where my family has always shopped.

But you wouldn't give the same answers if you were applying for a part-time job at the local chip shop.

MasterBeth · 17/03/2022 10:36

The words might sound like bullshit, but the concepts are sound.

"Will this person fit into the kind of company we are?" is the question I'm asking myself when I recruit. We have quite a flat structure, you're not micro-managed and have to take a lot of initiatives on your own. Some people are good at that, some people struggle.

Not being able to answer this question displays a lack of imagination, for me. I might not ask it in quite this way, but I'd be put off by someone who thought "because I need a job" is the only valid answer.

jessy100 · 17/03/2022 10:20

@Tink626

I'm HR and always ask this question (or a variation of it). I want to employ someone who has bothered researching the company and wants to work for us. Team culture and fit is important.
'team culture and fit' jesus, do you really believe this bullshit?😀
Tink626 · 17/03/2022 10:10

I'm HR and always ask this question (or a variation of it). I want to employ someone who has bothered researching the company and wants to work for us. Team culture and fit is important.

LottyD32 · 17/03/2022 10:09

Exactly. You are there to make them money. Why they think you care any more than them continuing to do so, so you continue to be employed and paid, is beyond me.

OP posts:
Satsumaeater · 17/03/2022 10:06

@OneGoodTurn

Maybe to weed out the people who couldn’t care less about the job or the organisation and just want to get paid? Confused
Erm, don't we all work to get paid? I agree OP it's a complete nonsense, like so many ridiculous application form questions.

Employers need workers, they are not doing you a favour by employing you.

ToiletPoster · 17/03/2022 09:41

There's always a reason why you applied to that job or spoke to that recruiter over the other possible available jobs.
The misconception is that you need to say "I've dreamed about this since I was a child" or something. I often say something along the lines of I have the skills to do it and I can see it leading to me being paid more in the future (worded more nicely). If there is something beyond that I'll say that too but it works fine for the most part.

LottyD32 · 17/03/2022 09:31

@EdgeOfSeventeenAndThreeQuarter

Lotty too right. I applied for the role I “got” mid-December, I’m still waiting for HR to sort their shit out. Lowest paying job I’ve had since the 90s…

I also told one to fuck off when they wanted 3 months of bank statements and to speak to my accountant for an EIGHT hours a month job!

What the actual fuck. 😲😲😲

That's insane.

OP posts:
gingerhills · 17/03/2022 09:19

@EdgeOfSeventeenAndThreeQuarter

Lotty too right. I applied for the role I “got” mid-December, I’m still waiting for HR to sort their shit out. Lowest paying job I’ve had since the 90s…

I also told one to fuck off when they wanted 3 months of bank statements and to speak to my accountant for an EIGHT hours a month job!

That's ridiculous. So invasive.
EdgeOfSeventeenAndThreeQuarter · 17/03/2022 09:16

Lotty too right. I applied for the role I “got” mid-December, I’m still waiting for HR to sort their shit out. Lowest paying job I’ve had since the 90s…

I also told one to fuck off when they wanted 3 months of bank statements and to speak to my accountant for an EIGHT hours a month job!

WellNotReally · 17/03/2022 08:50

I turn it round and ask the panel why they work for the organisation and what makes it a good place to work. It's fascinating to hear the responses.

LottyD32 · 17/03/2022 08:47

I also find the hoops are more ridiculous the lower down the payscale you go.

For my last 46k job, it was basically 'we like your cv, start on monday'. In my industry, and level, that's what I'm used to. Or people calling me asking if I want to move, they have such and such available.

Now I'm applying for anything and everything admin based, that is remote, and the hoop jumping and box ticking is ridiculous.

Some even want references and your NI number on the application form, which I think is far more than a bit of a pisstake.

OP posts:
jessy100 · 17/03/2022 08:30

If I won money tomorrow I would never work again. Work is completely overrated, particularly the older you get, and no matter what you do! I would spend my time travelling. I can dream grin]

jessy100 · 17/03/2022 08:22

My niece told me about an interview she had for a fixed term teaching assistant role recently. She wants to earn some money to fund further study. She has worked in the school on a supply basis occasionally and knows some of the staff. It has a toxic culture and a bad reputation for dealing with bullying.

It has a big turnover of staff , especially non teaching.
She said the interview was pure fantasy land and if she didn't already know different, she would have thought it was the best school ever to work in and she should feel humbled for the opportunityGrin.

LottyD32 · 17/03/2022 08:17

[quote ChocolateDigestivesMmmm]@KleineDracheKokosnuss Haha yeah sure they do. If you're the boss they're simply boot licking in the hope of a promotion/pay rise. I see this in my work and it's so transparent. No sane person truly cares about vague corporate bullshit.
You can definitely see the divide between employers and employees on this thread though, and how deluded/up their own arse employers are.[/quote]
Not necessarily, I've been an employer and never gone in for this bollocks. I don't see the point and I don't want to work with corporate waffle bullshitters that live outside the box while aiming for the sky 🙄 or whatever the latest buzz speak nonsense is.

OP posts:
jessy100 · 17/03/2022 08:00

It's an utterly pointless question! I always think the company and people interviewing want to be flattered and told how amazing g they are.
In reality, most of us work because we need to pay the bills!

A few examples of bullshittery recently. Nephew who is a student went for two p/t super.markets jobs. It was two of the 'big four' He was asked this question, and answered it exactly the same way for both, just obviously tweaking very minor details.
Got offered both jobs!

In reality, his mate works in one of the jobs , and told him it's not a great place to work, and he is only there because he's a penniless student! SmileMy dn is in exactly the same position and will take pretty much anything for six months, so he can save for a massive holiday he has planned in September.

My friend went for two interviews on the same day to rival insurance companies. She parrotted the same bullshit answers to this question. Got offered both jobs. She took the one with the slightly better annual leave allowance.

I've been for a few interviews recently. My main criteria is that it's a job I can do on set days ( so that I can bugger off for long weekends in our campervan) and go home and not think about it. Should I tell the interview that?Wink Well of course I wont. just like my dn and df I will make up some bullying and tell them what they want to hear. The whole interviewing process needs to get fucking real!!

'

antisocialsocialclub · 17/03/2022 07:59

😂

Why do you want to work here?
Ratatoo · 17/03/2022 07:53

My favourite question is what motivates you?

Spite Grin