Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do you want to work here?

234 replies

LottyD32 · 16/03/2022 12:14

AIBU to detest this question and find it completely pointless?

Why do they still ask it?
What do they hope to glean from your answer?

We all know the answer mostly is 'I couldn't care less, just give me the job and pay me' so why do they insist on making people jump through these ridiculous hoops?

OP posts:
bigbluebus · 17/03/2022 16:12

DS was asked this question when bring interviewed for a supermarket job. He replied that he didn't necessarily want to work there, he had applications in with all the other local supermarkets too. At the time, supermarkets were crying out for staff. They offered him the job on the spot!

wordler · 17/03/2022 16:06

@ChocolateDigestivesMmmm

Okay, fair enough, maybe my experience is unique to my main career industry (which is a creative one but fairly broad in scope) - although I've found the techniques I've described above have worked for me and others in other fields too.

Also, I've never turned up to an interview only having read the company website - I assumed most people would do a lot more research - including if possible a informational pre-interview chat, visiting the company and talking to other employees, reading reviews on glassdoor, researching the background and resumes of the interview panel etc. If you've been in a particular field for a few years you can usually find someone in your network who used to work with the place and find out the insider info.

Your application and any tests your do before the interview showcase your skills and experience. So by the time you get to the interview both sides are simply confirming what they already know about a candidate. In your last interview I suspect they knew they already wanted you based on your application.

MasterBeth · 17/03/2022 16:02

@CapMarvel

I think you are, if you are asking the question "why do you want to work here" and expecting an honest answer, or would judge someone who does answer honestly in a negative way.

There are better ways to find out whether a person is a good fit without basically asking them to lie.

Are you always such a literal person, @CapMarvel?

No-one's asking anyone to lie. Is it so difficult to answer a potentially useful question with a relevant answer?

FTEngineerM · 17/03/2022 15:58

I’m starting to agree with you @CapMarvel if the person has no job at present it’s probably a shit question. In that scenario it’s definitely a ‘well I need to eat..’.

ChocolateDigestivesMmm · 17/03/2022 15:53

@wordler It is literally a test though, your answers are being scored. For my last job, it was made clear that you needed a certain score to "pass" the interview. The person with the highest score gets the job.
It's not a real conversation, because neither side are being entirely truthful. The candidate gives whatever spiel is needed to get the job, because they need to earn a living.
And the interviewer is hardly going to say "our culture is a toxic one of pettiness, passive aggression and management bullying", which is true for probably 90% of the type of corporate jobs that ask these types of questions. I've never got an accurate feel for the real culture of a place from an interview or a company website, because these only showcase the best bits and embellish the truth.

My most recent interview, which led to an offer, was a breath of fresh air because they didn't ask pointless questions or try to psychoanalyse me to see if I'd be a "good fit for the team" (which is really subjective and often disadvantages minority groups), instead they focused on objective metrics like the results I achieved at my previous job, my skills and qualifications.

I think if many job seekers are saying they're put off by certain questions or hiring practices, recruiters need to take note, not get defensive. No wonder many places are struggling to recruit.

Havanananana · 17/03/2022 15:32

I'm HR and always ask this question (or a variation of it). I want to employ someone who has bothered researching the company and wants to work for us. Team culture and fit is important.

Wrote no HR professional ever - or certainly not in the 21st century - unless they wanted to open up a can of worms around discrimination based on race, gender, disability, nationality, sexual orientation, age, religion etc. and leave the company open to legal action.

Quite apart from that there is also the issue of replacing a member of staff who has left with a clone - which can result in a team of people all with the same skills and attitudes ("team culture and fit") but also with the same weaknesses and possibly the same unwanted traits and attitudes.

wordler · 17/03/2022 15:24

[quote ChocolateDigestivesMmm]@wordler Ok, but the truth for most people is that they chose your company for one, or a combination of, several reasons:

  1. Pay
  2. Location
  3. Other benefits like longer annual leave, enhanced maternity pay, health insurance etc
  4. They've applied to multiple jobs in their field, including your competitors, you happened to be hiring at that particular time and you happened to offer them an interview.

But none of these are considered a acceptable answers. You can see that from the outrage of some recruiters on here, when a candidate has naively answered the question truthfully. So really, it's a test of how well a candidate can say what the interviewer wants to hear.
[/quote]
The interview is a conversation which boils down to "are you a fit for us? Are we a fit for you?"

If HR do their part properly the candidate shouldn't get to the interview stage without the required skills and experience.

The candidates need for pay and a suitable location are a given too - as people have pointed out they wouldn't be applying without the job meeting those two needs. And extra benefits are nice but they are the icing.

The cake is the job itself because we spend such a significant part of our week dedicated to it.

The 'fluffy' questions some people seem to hate are just vehicles for chatting which allow both sides to get a measure of the candidates' attitude and on the other side of the table the attitude of the company and the team culture.

I've been most successful as a candidate when I've stopped thinking about it being a 'test' I have to bluff through and practice talking about my real interests and motivations (beyond pay etc - my feelings about my career path etc) When you approach the interview and a 2-way thing it can help you make better decisions about whether to accept or turn down the job when it's offered to you.

I've been most successful as a recruiter / interviewer when I've considered the team and where this person in front of me will fit, and how they will enhance the whole rather than just fill a gap.

It is a test of how well you communicate but if you're only aiming for bluffing the interviewer you may be missing the point that it's not the right fit for you.

I really started enjoying being interviewed when I shifted my perspective from it being a 'test' to a conversation.

CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 15:02

I was, admittedly, being a bit flippant.

Culture is important of course, but I think that is more something for the company to present to the interviewee rather than the other way round. You can't really research what a company is like to work for on a day to day basis.

I think the question is basically a trap. The honest answer is, in most cases "for the money", but interviewers don't like that. So the interviewee is basically forced into inventing some nonsense, and the interviewer has to pretend to buy it. And then the interview will ask a technical question that does demand the candidate not bullshit their way though it, having been asked to do just that. I just feel it leads to an interview process that doesn't really benefit anyone.

ChocolateDigestivesMmm · 17/03/2022 14:54

@wordler Ok, but the truth for most people is that they chose your company for one, or a combination of, several reasons:

  1. Pay
  2. Location
  3. Other benefits like longer annual leave, enhanced maternity pay, health insurance etc
  4. They've applied to multiple jobs in their field, including your competitors, you happened to be hiring at that particular time and you happened to offer them an interview.

But none of these are considered a acceptable answers. You can see that from the outrage of some recruiters on here, when a candidate has naively answered the question truthfully. So really, it's a test of how well a candidate can say what the interviewer wants to hear.

FTEngineerM · 17/03/2022 14:43

Whether the company has a nice coffee machine and offers half price gym membersip is irrelevant

Ah - I think this is where we’re misunderstanding each other 😂. I don’t care if somewhere gives me free coffee.

What are they like when employees make suggestions? How do management/directors interact with their teams? How much autonomy does each employee have? Do they fund development of the staff?

That’s the ‘culture’ imo. Those questions are relevant to most careers/jobs.

I had a job once at a massive corp; I told them about a problem with their system and provided evidence. My manager said ‘knowledge is knowing there is a problem, wisdom is knowing whether to bother doing something about it’ I’ve never wanted to tell someone to FUCK OFF more in my whole entire career.

CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 13:03

I think you are, if you are asking the question "why do you want to work here" and expecting an honest answer, or would judge someone who does answer honestly in a negative way.

There are better ways to find out whether a person is a good fit without basically asking them to lie.

jessy100 · 17/03/2022 13:03

@DimebagDarrell

A lot of people in higher-level high status job where people often profess a ‘passion’ for their job also think it’s a bullshit question.

My academic-related profession includes a lot of people with PhDs, passion, drive, determination etc. But just like the teenager mentioned above applying to a number of different supermarkets and having to say at interview why supermarket x is amazing, my contemporaries and I are applying to a number of different universities and research institutes and then having to bullshit at interview about why we’ve applied to that particular university. And we live in a work culture where telling the truth - that you’ve applied for 10 roles but this one happened to be the one that offered you an interview - is seen as unacceptable!

Absolutely spot on!!
Hrpuffnstuff1 · 17/03/2022 13:02

It is a bullshit question for most.
I just asked DW the question she works as a head buyer-they do try to have 'Values'. But it's just bollox.
It is a means to make sure the person being hired will basically sacrifice all for the company.
Same with perk box.
'Give your people the tools they need to be happier and healthier, with carefully curated wellbeing content that caters for all needs'.Grin

Haha corp speak.

MasterBeth · 17/03/2022 12:55

Maybe it is a minority. Doesn't mean anyone who considers their job as more than just a paycheque is "naive" to the realities of life or work.

DimebagDarrell · 17/03/2022 12:54

A lot of people in higher-level high status job where people often profess a ‘passion’ for their job also think it’s a bullshit question.

My academic-related profession includes a lot of people with PhDs, passion, drive, determination etc. But just like the teenager mentioned above applying to a number of different supermarkets and having to say at interview why supermarket x is amazing, my contemporaries and I are applying to a number of different universities and research institutes and then having to bullshit at interview about why we’ve applied to that particular university. And we live in a work culture where telling the truth - that you’ve applied for 10 roles but this one happened to be the one that offered you an interview - is seen as unacceptable!

CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 12:36

@MasterBeth

No, not everyone. Some people.
I would suggest it's a minority.
CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 12:35

"There are plenty of jobs available; why this particular one? Most low level jobs can be done with transferable skills. "

Not everyone is in a position where they can pick and choose where they work or take the time to search out the perfect role.

If someone is in the position where they just need to pay the bills of course they will take anything, hence the need to bullshit their way through interviews having sent off 100 CVs to all and sundry. It's naive to think that is not the reality of the situation.

MasterBeth · 17/03/2022 12:35

No, not everyone. Some people.

CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 12:31

@MasterBeth

Yeah, but it’s not always the difference between having a job or not. I wouldn’t do my job if they didn’t pay me but if more than one organisation will pay me, I want to be able to judge which one suits me.
More often than not it is. Not everyone is in the (nice) position to pick and choose. They send out 50 applications and if they get an offer that is what they take. Whether the company has a nice coffee machine and offers half price gym membersip is irrelevant.
lostoldname · 17/03/2022 12:28

It's an easy opener to help someone settle into an interview and shows who hasn't done their homework or reread their application form.

MasterBeth · 17/03/2022 12:11

@jessy100

How have you concluded that my work life has been unfulfilling? You know nothing about me! Typical HR speak. 😃 I'm just older and wiser and can see through all the bullshit!
Because you’re glad to coming to the end of your working life and not having to put up with all this shit. Or is that you being positive?
FTEngineerM · 17/03/2022 12:10

@CapMarvel

"What's the point in lying"?

.... to get the job, fairly obviously, so they can pay the mortgage and pay for food/heating/the odd trip to the cinema.

Anything else is way, way down the list.

There are plenty of jobs available; why this particular one? Most low level jobs can be done with transferable skills.

Has anyone said it’s not money first? I haven’t seen it if they have.

Nobody is a volunteer and probably rings HR pretty damn sharpish if their pay is wrong, as they should. But any job will pay you. There is a difference, in my company at least, between the people who are more invested in the company long term and the ones who aren’t.

MasterBeth · 17/03/2022 12:10

Yeah, but it’s not always the difference between having a job or not. I wouldn’t do my job if they didn’t pay me but if more than one organisation will pay me, I want to be able to judge which one suits me.

whatisforteamum · 17/03/2022 12:05

In my creative industry it shows you have passion and care about your work environment as the hours are v long it would weed out anyone who didn't care and showed they did research

jessy100 · 17/03/2022 12:04

How have you concluded that my work life has been unfulfilling? You know nothing about me! Typical HR speak. 😃 I'm just older and wiser and can see through all the bullshit!