Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do you want to work here?

234 replies

LottyD32 · 16/03/2022 12:14

AIBU to detest this question and find it completely pointless?

Why do they still ask it?
What do they hope to glean from your answer?

We all know the answer mostly is 'I couldn't care less, just give me the job and pay me' so why do they insist on making people jump through these ridiculous hoops?

OP posts:
Darbs76 · 17/03/2022 21:40

I always ask as a warm up (competency based interviews) something like what attracted you to the role and what skills do you think you could bring

Satsumaeater · 17/03/2022 21:39

Not being able to answer this question displays a lack of imagination, for me. I might not ask it in quite this way, but I'd be put off by someone who thought "because I need a job" is the only valid answer

and you don't think that the answer people give is likely to be complete bollox? Oh dear.

As for work culture, you aren't exactly going to put on the website that you are micro-managing arseholes even if you are, are you? So how does that work?

Satsumaeater · 17/03/2022 21:35

@Tink626

I'm HR and always ask this question (or a variation of it). I want to employ someone who has bothered researching the company and wants to work for us. Team culture and fit is important.
How does a bit of website research give you any evidence that they will fit into your team?

I am also a bit concerned about your D&I policies if you recruit on that basis. Team fit and culture usually means recruiting in your own image which is bad for diversity and inclusion.

wordler · 17/03/2022 21:34

As I've tried to explain - the why of someone's application choice is relevant to many recruiters in many industries when choosing between candidates and it's also the perfect question to use to answer the question "why should we employ you?"

Even if you don't think it makes a difference to your particular circumstance it's a gift of a question if they ask it because it's one you can easily prepare for.

What field are you in @LottyD32?

LottyD32 · 17/03/2022 20:59

@wordler

So to turn it around to the people who really hate this question - and are only doing the job for the money - no personal fulfillment, no future career strategy for the application.

What question would you like to be asked that would give you a chance to show the interviewer what sets you above the other candidates? Assuming your fellow candidates have similar levels of skill and job experience.

Exactly that: "What sets you above the other candidates? Why should we employ you?"

Stop with all the beating about the bush questions and pseudo psychology. Just be straightforward and ask what you want to know, in plain English.

Stop with all the bollocks.

OP posts:
wordler · 17/03/2022 19:30

@CapMarvel

Preferences? Sure.

The reality of needing a job however will result in most people compromising those preferences. If you are a hotel manager with a choice between one hotel with a job and no job, the size of that hotel will have no bearing on the decision whatsoever.

So if you are desperate for a job when you are unemployed you may only be able to focus on that aspect but the interview is catering for a variety of people some of whom may already have a job, or have lots of job options to choose from. And for fairness you have to ask the same questions to everyone.

In the dozens of interviews I've held - nearly all of the candidates were already employed often by our competitors or were internal candidates from a different department within the organisation. 'why this team?' was a really useful question.

MasterBeth · 17/03/2022 19:27

@CapMarvel, have you only ever had the possibility of a) this one job or b) no job?

gwenneh · 17/03/2022 19:24

*"I like the value the company put on their employees" is a bit of a reach.

Are you HR? Do you come up with bollocks mission statements and values and all the rest of it?

But who cares how connected HR are? At the end of the day, you go there, do your work, get paid*

No, I don't work in HR. Not even close.

The value the company puts on the employees is literally displayed in how much they pay them. It is a way to say "I like what you pay." as an answer to that question. In this case value is literally monetary.

Whether or not HR or any other interviewer is connected to the company will tell you exactly what the company culture is really like. You can determine whether people are genuinely happy to work there, whether departments work well together, and pretty critically whether there are any red flags through both the answers (or lack) and the body language.

At the end of the day yes I do go to work, do my work, and get paid -- but I also like working where I do, and working with a bunch of people I can get along with helps. Asking questions helps a candidate make an assessment of the company culture beyond "free lunch Friday" or a fancy coffee maker.

CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 19:19

Preferences? Sure.

The reality of needing a job however will result in most people compromising those preferences. If you are a hotel manager with a choice between one hotel with a job and no job, the size of that hotel will have no bearing on the decision whatsoever.

wordler · 17/03/2022 19:04

@CapMarvel It's very rare for anyone to specifically want to work for one company beyond the reason of "because they have jobs going".

While not many would work without being paid I can't believe that the majority of people have no preferences when choosing where they work.

Teachers - no preference at all for a type of school, a specialism, a school with a specific ethos, small class sizes, a specific school within several in an area

Office Managers - can transfer those skill to numerous industries - no preference at all to type of company, size of office?

Copywriters - can write well across a variety of genres - no preference at all to the content they are creating?

Sous Chefs - no preference to food type, size of restaurant, who their boss is going to be

Civil Servant - no preference to type of office, local benefits agency to city tax office?

Police officer - no preference for specific police force, department, future career advancement,

Climate change non-profit - no preference for location, size of non-profit, success of team projects

Flight attendant - no preference for route opportunities, shift options?

Executive assistant - no preference to the type of boss you'll be working with or the field of work they work within?

Massage therapist - no preference to the type of salon, the type of client?

Engineer - no preference to the size of company, the types of projects?

Charity fundraiser - no preference for the type of charity you are working for?

Veterinary nurse - no preference for the size of practice, small animal vs large animal, vs exotic animal?

Hair stylist - no preference for size of salon, shift times, autonomy of own client management, prestige of salon name?

Marketing assistant - no preference for the type of marketing you are going, the type of company you work for, the products you are selling

Hotel manager - no preference for size of hotel, options for being located to somewhere exciting within a chain

CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 18:42

@wordler

So to turn it around to the people who really hate this question - and are only doing the job for the money - no personal fulfillment, no future career strategy for the application.

What question would you like to be asked that would give you a chance to show the interviewer what sets you above the other candidates? Assuming your fellow candidates have similar levels of skill and job experience.

Don't assume that because people are honest enough to say that their primary motivation to work is money that such people don't enjoy their jobs or have no career plan.

I like my job, I'm good at it and I've progressed up the ladder, but I'm still in it primarily for the money - if I wasn't being paid or I won the lottery I would be out of the door like a shot - just like about 99% of people who ever turned up for an interview.

And to answer @wordler the answer to "why this company" is pretty obvious as well - because your company is recruiting and the person has responded to the ad. Your competitor might not be recruiting or if they are it's likely that person has applied to them as well. It's very rare for anyone to specifically want to work for one company beyond the reason of "because they have jobs going".

My problem with the question "why do you want to work here" is that the honest answer is frowned upon, so you are encouraging the interviewee to lie straight off the bat. You'll then go on and ask them an actual relevant question and you expect an honest answer. It's not consistent and it just results in an interview the end result of which you have no idea what was bullshit and what was the truth.

Mamapep · 17/03/2022 18:25

@OneGoodTurn

Maybe to weed out the people who couldn’t care less about the job or the organisation and just want to get paid? Confused
I.e Most reasonable people
wordler · 17/03/2022 18:03

So to turn it around to the people who really hate this question - and are only doing the job for the money - no personal fulfillment, no future career strategy for the application.

What question would you like to be asked that would give you a chance to show the interviewer what sets you above the other candidates? Assuming your fellow candidates have similar levels of skill and job experience.

wordler · 17/03/2022 17:58

@CapMarvel but what about the career moves you make which are about making the daily work more interesting for yourself, or are part of a larger long-term strategy for moving up within your particular field?

I've done three or four interviews for jobs where the money is not going to be any different but the job content was going to be very different - or I wanted to work for a particular organisation for a couple of years for the experience and benefit it would bring for future career moves.

Ted27 · 17/03/2022 17:43

I dont't think I've ever said 'its my dream job'

but even when I had the most pressing financial reasons for applying for a particular role there was always other job related things I could refer to - even if was I wanted to return to the sector and the role was a good for my skills/experience and I could see potential for future development

iwantcurry · 17/03/2022 17:42

I interviewed someone a few years ago and had to ask that ( half the questions were pre set by HR) and the man said "because I've been made redundant, have a mortgage and a family to support and I really need a job!" He did go on to say why he felt he would be a good fit for the role. I appreciated his honesty and he was the best candidate by far and is still with us 😀

wordler · 17/03/2022 17:38

[quote CapMarvel]@MasterBeth

How is it literal to just want an interview to be based on honesty and openness?

The simple truth of the matter is that for the vast, vast, vast majority of people the answer to the question "why do you want to work here" is "for the money".

If you don't like that answer you need to ask better questions.[/quote]
But if all jobs are about the money (and you're applying for different jobs where the money is fairly similar) then the question "why here in particular" is important (to both you and the recruiter).

Like a PP said if it's a job in a supermarket stacking shelves you absolutely can be honest and say something simple like "it feels like a good fit for me because of location, I'm also applying to similar jobs elsewhere"

If you're an admin assistant applying for two different companies - for the same pay and benefits, then you're going to look past the money aspect and start thinking about other things which will make you happy at work.

If one is a construction company and the other one is a big hotel chain - you might prefer the hotel chain as there are lots of chances for promotion. The smart answer to "why do you want to work here?" explains what you would get out of the role + what they get from you.

"I'm interested in starting my career here in xyc hotels because I know you deal with a lot of corporate business from France and I recently passed an advanced French language course and this seems like a good opportunity to put that skill to you [what they are getting from you] and I'm interested in pursuing a career in corporate hospitality and I know from research I've done about your company that there are lots of opportunities here [what's in it for you]"

I said it before every question in an interview is a vehicle for the three main questions in the interviewer's mind.

  1. Can you do the job - skills
  2. Will you do the job - commitment and reliability
  3. Will you be someone that works well in our team - likability/easy to work with

Number 3 mainly comes into play if there are loads of great candidates who are all very similar in skills and (apparent) commitment and reliability. Everyone is working for money but why wouldn't an employer want to choose the candidate who brings something extra to work everyday whether that's enthusisam for the core work, to a five-year career plan which means they are going to work their socks off for you so that you get them to the next place they want to go.

But also, sometimes they ask that question early on to put people at their ease a little because it's the one question that should be easy to practice before hand and helps get people over their nerves and get into the conversation. Similar to "tell me a little about yourself' - which is the one I personally hate because it's so open ended it's hard to not waffle.

LottyD32 · 17/03/2022 17:33

@gwenneh

The simple truth of the matter is that for the vast, vast, vast majority of people the answer to the question "why do you want to work here" is "for the money".

Of course, the pay is sometimes a huge motivator. But it always translates well into "I like the value which [company] places on their employees."

And the interviewer is hardly going to say "our culture is a toxic one of pettiness, passive aggression and management bullying", which is true for probably 90% of the type of corporate jobs that ask these types of questions.

I've always asked questions when the interviewer opens up the chance -- what do you like about working here, etc. I find that you can sometimes accurately get a feel for a company this way. It works best if you are interviewing with a potential direct team member, but it can also provide worlds of information into how connected HR is with the actual employees, something that speaks volumes about an employer.

"I like the value the company put on their employees" is a bit of a reach.

Are you HR? Do you come up with bollocks mission statements and values and all the rest of it?

But who cares how connected HR are? At the end of the day, you go there, do your work, get paid 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
jessy100 · 17/03/2022 17:23

Also, all the arse kissing and slavish devotion to the company, keeps most HR people in jobs😀

jessy100 · 17/03/2022 17:20

@CapMarvel

For most people pay is the only motivator, let's be honest.

How many people would continue to work if they didn't need to?

People who suffer with a lack of imagination, and have all their self worth attached to their job.
AllOfUsAreDead · 17/03/2022 17:09

I just lie. The business doesn't actually care, they just want someone doing the job. Dunno why they bother.

CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 17:05

For most people pay is the only motivator, let's be honest.

How many people would continue to work if they didn't need to?

gwenneh · 17/03/2022 17:02

The simple truth of the matter is that for the vast, vast, vast majority of people the answer to the question "why do you want to work here" is "for the money".

Of course, the pay is sometimes a huge motivator. But it always translates well into "I like the value which [company] places on their employees."

And the interviewer is hardly going to say "our culture is a toxic one of pettiness, passive aggression and management bullying", which is true for probably 90% of the type of corporate jobs that ask these types of questions.

I've always asked questions when the interviewer opens up the chance -- what do you like about working here, etc. I find that you can sometimes accurately get a feel for a company this way. It works best if you are interviewing with a potential direct team member, but it can also provide worlds of information into how connected HR is with the actual employees, something that speaks volumes about an employer.

CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 16:53

@MasterBeth

How is it literal to just want an interview to be based on honesty and openness?

The simple truth of the matter is that for the vast, vast, vast majority of people the answer to the question "why do you want to work here" is "for the money".

If you don't like that answer you need to ask better questions.

ChocolateDigestivesMmm · 17/03/2022 16:28

@wordler Yes it sounds like we're in very different industries, I've never heard of anyone doing these things for an interview, except maybe reading the Glassdoor reviews.
For the job I mentioned I wasn't even told who would be interviewing me and it's a secure building with lots of confidential work being done...it would have been a bit odd if I turned up asking to look around when I wasn't actually an employee yet. I don't know if they necessarily knew who they wanted to hire already...the ethos behind their hiring process is that they wanted to make it as fair and objective as possible, and to eliminate unconscious bias which inevitably creeps in when people start talking about "fitting into the team".

Swipe left for the next trending thread