Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do you want to work here?

234 replies

LottyD32 · 16/03/2022 12:14

AIBU to detest this question and find it completely pointless?

Why do they still ask it?
What do they hope to glean from your answer?

We all know the answer mostly is 'I couldn't care less, just give me the job and pay me' so why do they insist on making people jump through these ridiculous hoops?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LottyD32 · 25/03/2022 11:23

.

Why do you want to work here?
Why do you want to work here?
OP posts:
antisocialsocialclub · 18/03/2022 16:23

@Thewindwhispers

I got asked this over and over in an interview for a very junior events role. I kept replying showing my research of their website and showing how my skills were a fit for the role, etc. I could tell they hated my answer, but didn’t understand why.

Didn’t get it. Found out later that the team were heavily into the party scene - booze, drugs, casual sex etc - and wanted an answer that was less about the website and more “It looks loads of fun!”

They were quite right not to hire me I would have been a terrible fit. So, I do think it can be a useful question even at junior level. Even for check out supermarket in which case the question can check that the candidate isn’t over-ambitious and is looking for what the job offers.

Eww makes their question seem really groomy. Checking you out to see if you’d be into drugs and casual sex 🤢 You we’re best out of there!
MajorCarolDanvers · 18/03/2022 12:27

@MRex

Posters seem to be talking across each other in comparing professional role interviews with kids shelf stacking in one or another supermarket. I agree there is no point in the question for basic retail, admin or other low skill roles. It isn't surprising that people doing those roles think the only answer is "for the money".

In professional roles hoeever there's huge differences in motivation between people targeting a step up including training, extending skills in a particular industry, having old colleagues they want to rejoin in a different company, interest in a particular new code base, interest in the USP of that company's product, interest in travel to certain markets etc etc etc. It's relevant and interesting in those cases, and money is not the only motivator for people doing those jobs.

Posters seem to be talking across each other in comparing professional role interviews with kids shelf stacking in one or another supermarket

I agree - that is very apparent after reading the thread.

Thewindwhispers · 18/03/2022 11:12

(Agree it’s a hideous question to answer though.)

Thewindwhispers · 18/03/2022 11:12

I got asked this over and over in an interview for a very junior events role. I kept replying showing my research of their website and showing how my skills were a fit for the role, etc. I could tell they hated my answer, but didn’t understand why.

Didn’t get it. Found out later that the team were heavily into the party scene - booze, drugs, casual sex etc - and wanted an answer that was less about the website and more “It looks loads of fun!”

They were quite right not to hire me I would have been a terrible fit. So, I do think it can be a useful question even at junior level. Even for check out supermarket in which case the question can check that the candidate isn’t over-ambitious and is looking for what the job offers.

jessy100 · 18/03/2022 10:57

I like my current job. I don't love it, but I like the people an d the role, and I'm lucky I only have to work part time at this stage of my life!I

I'm always on time. I do the work to the best of my ability. I get on well with my co worker's, but the best time of the day for me is when I walk out the door at home time.
That"s when my real life takes shape. I don't give work a second thought.
All this corporate bollox is just plain ludicrous. Those of us who have been in the workforce for years see straight through it and know it for what it is.!!

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 18/03/2022 08:04

Attitudes to this question depend on an individual's value on work and the workplace.
The utility of work. I think for some the workplace and work are part of their intrinsic identity, and employers asking this question need to know whether a potential employee's identity matches the company.

Personally, work for me, is where I earn money, outside interests that are separate from work, and the workplace fulfills my needs.
As long as the customers are happy and my invoices are paid, work has fulfilled its function.
One of the issues with the modern UNI-educated workforce is the lack of character, everyone sounds like an identikit homogenous mass-produced robot.
Corporate values certainly shape and socialize people.

Satsumaeater · 18/03/2022 07:35

Has everyone forgotten that the corporate bollocks, psychologically manipulative, deliberately obscure, technically demanding, linguistically complex, impossible to answer truthfully question we are talking about is "Why do you want to work here

yes but it's masking other things that they want to know. For example, a more honest question might be "how do you deal with being micromanaged" or indeed "how do you feel about a flat structure with lots of individual responsibility".

CoverYourselfInChocolateGlory · 18/03/2022 07:15

We always ask that question in interviews, but then our company is quite unusual in its set up so it can be very illuminating to hear people's answers.

FTEngineerM · 18/03/2022 06:58

your employers, in most cases, don't actually care about you and will get rid of you without a second thought if it suits them

Hmm that’s also not true for where I work. And probably why I’m coming from the angle that I can tell when someone doesn’t give a shit/just there for the cash.

If you don’t like your job, you can just tell someone and then have a chat about where else you fit/learn something new and change jobs. It’s a tech company though so the variety is there. They cling onto good people and yeah some have been let go because they were crap.

MasterBeth · 18/03/2022 06:48

@LottyD32 Stop with all the beating about the bush questions and pseudo psychology. Just be straightforward and ask what you want to know, in plain English. Stop with all the bollocks.

Has everyone forgotten that the corporate bollocks, psychologically manipulative, deliberately obscure, technically demanding, linguistically complex, impossible to answer truthfully question we are talking about is "Why do you want to work here?"

MRex · 18/03/2022 06:47

Posters seem to be talking across each other in comparing professional role interviews with kids shelf stacking in one or another supermarket. I agree there is no point in the question for basic retail, admin or other low skill roles. It isn't surprising that people doing those roles think the only answer is "for the money".

In professional roles hoeever there's huge differences in motivation between people targeting a step up including training, extending skills in a particular industry, having old colleagues they want to rejoin in a different company, interest in a particular new code base, interest in the USP of that company's product, interest in travel to certain markets etc etc etc. It's relevant and interesting in those cases, and money is not the only motivator for people doing those jobs.

SquirrelG · 18/03/2022 05:59

Can I ask in a general way what your job is? And if you have a general career plan?

I'm currently working in a casual office role - for the best place I have ever worked in my life - but am counting down the days until retirement! Previously I worked in administration. I have been made redundant twice, and my ex-DH numerous times - it soon teaches you not to invest too much of yourself into work. I never had a general career plan, never wanted one. I work to live, if I didn't have to work I most certainly wouldn't.

1forAll74 · 18/03/2022 04:51

You had better be on the ball,if you wan't to work for Alan Sugar, and reach the interview round., thats always fun to witness.

wordler · 18/03/2022 03:45

@SquirrelG

I have never in my life had a company's best interests or goals at heart, only mine. Companies don't care about you, no matter what they say. Don't get me wrong, I turn up, do the job to the required standard, keep on good terms with my colleagues and boss. I care about doing the job to a good standard, because that's what they're paying me for and I do take pride in my work. But if I didn't need the money I wouldn't be there. The exception would be if it was a charity whose cause I believed in.

That's exactly how I approach a job. I do the job as best I can, get along with everyone - and then go home and forget about it until the next time I get to the office. I have been in the workforce long enough to know that your employers, in most cases, don't actually care about you and will get rid of you without a second thought if it suits them - so it's a bit rich to expect their employees to have their best interests at heart.

Can I ask in a general way what your job is? And if you have a general career plan?
wordler · 18/03/2022 03:42

@MangyInseam sorry stupid phone posting issues

I’m sorry you think this type of interview question is invasive. It’s actually a very mild personal question. At a job interview you should expect intensive questioning about your experience skills life situations. You prep to make the most of it.

wordler · 18/03/2022 03:37

@MangyInseam -

SquirrelG · 18/03/2022 03:27

I have never in my life had a company's best interests or goals at heart, only mine. Companies don't care about you, no matter what they say. Don't get me wrong, I turn up, do the job to the required standard, keep on good terms with my colleagues and boss. I care about doing the job to a good standard, because that's what they're paying me for and I do take pride in my work.
But if I didn't need the money I wouldn't be there. The exception would be if it was a charity whose cause I believed in.

That's exactly how I approach a job. I do the job as best I can, get along with everyone - and then go home and forget about it until the next time I get to the office. I have been in the workforce long enough to know that your employers, in most cases, don't actually care about you and will get rid of you without a second thought if it suits them - so it's a bit rich to expect their employees to have their best interests at heart.

FrangipaniBlue · 18/03/2022 02:31

The fact is "because I need a job" is the real answer for most people.

It's not though is it? Majority of the time the person being interviewed already has a job which they are prepared to resign from to take up this new one.

That's basically what the question is asking.

"why are you prepared to leave your current role, in a familiar company, with no doubt accrued service..... for this brand new one in an unknown entity where you'll have little to no employment rights for at least 2 years?"

MangyInseam · 18/03/2022 02:06

@wordler

As I've tried to explain - the why of someone's application choice is relevant to many recruiters in many industries when choosing between candidates and it's also the perfect question to use to answer the question "why should we employ you?"

Even if you don't think it makes a difference to your particular circumstance it's a gift of a question if they ask it because it's one you can easily prepare for.

What field are you in @LottyD32?

By "gift of a question" you seem to be saying, a question you can bs about in a potentially effective way.

Which is one reason why people don't like it. I think also people feel it's a bit invasive.

MangyInseam · 18/03/2022 02:02

I wonder if people realize how many jobs are actually filled, it's not about some kind of discussion about who they like best or even think would be best fit. That kind of thing is very actively discouraged.

In all of the areas I have worked in it's designed to take all of taht out. Everyone has identical questions. Follow up questions have to be limited and specific in order to assure that. Answers are scored on a simple system. The person with the highest score gets the job, and if they don't the reason has to be clear and serious or they are opening themselves up to serious accusations of bias.

If there is this kind of question, where the real answer would be "because you are the only people that do this type of thing in a 50 km radius and so it's you or digging ditches even though I have some serious misgivings about your current management" you just can't say that. Because all the other candidates are likely to say something more gushy.

I'm willing to lose out on a job offer because someone else has more experience than I do or has done something spectacular in a previous position. But not because their reasons for applying are seen as better.

MangyInseam · 18/03/2022 01:46

[quote jessy100]@masterBeth It's you who is missing the point!.That point is that most people will tell the interviewer what they want to hear. It's a box ticking exercise for both sides.

T he ultimate aim is to get offered the the job. It doesn't mean that we believe what we are saying to get it.
My nephew doesn't care which supermarket he works for. He couldn't care less If he's packing find a of beans on to shelves in Tesco or m&s.
He wants the job because he has a very expensive holiday planned that he had to fund![/quote]
I think any question where there is a real liklihood that the person will lie is one that should be reconsidered, maybe reframed.

Not in the sense of someone outright fabricating their experience or education or something like that, which is an ethical violation.

But we know that when asked this, the real answer in many cases won't sound impressive, and I think many people feel instinctively that they do not ow the employer that kind of wholly truthful information about their internal motives.

CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 22:10

@wordler

As I've tried to explain - the why of someone's application choice is relevant to many recruiters in many industries when choosing between candidates and it's also the perfect question to use to answer the question "why should we employ you?"

Even if you don't think it makes a difference to your particular circumstance it's a gift of a question if they ask it because it's one you can easily prepare for.

What field are you in @LottyD32?

Sure, but you have to be prepared to accept that people know that the honest answer (for the money) is one most recruiters will get uppity about so what interviewers will actually do is waffle some bullshit about company values, how the firm is a leader in the field blah blah blah. What does that tell you?

That's why I don't like questions like that - they are never answered truefully so the answers are worthless.

CapMarvel · 17/03/2022 22:03

[quote MasterBeth]@CapMarvel, have you only ever had the possibility of a) this one job or b) no job?[/quote]
No.

But I know what the reality is for most people, and so I know how utterly pointless asking people "why do you want to work here" and expecting an answer other than "for the money".

Satsumaeater · 17/03/2022 21:41

the perfect question to use to answer the question "why should we employ you

it isn't. Why should you employ me? Because I have the right skillset for the job. Which may mean spending hours researching your website. In fact for my line of work it might as I do lots of research. But not for most jobs.