Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that buying a puppy is NOT like having a baby.

430 replies

annoyedfr · 16/03/2022 11:35

After TTC, 9 months of a difficult pregnancy, a traumatic 48 hour labour which ended with me having sepsis and baby in SCBU, 2 weeks inpatient stay, 2 years of developmental worries, all this on top of the entirely normal unbelievable stress/responsibility/cost of having a baby and child ... WIBU to tell my (wonderful but in this instance thoughtless) friend that getting a puppy is not like having a baby? Because she has not suffered birth injuries to have her 'child', a dog is not a lifelong commitment in any sort of the same way as a baby (if it were as ill as my daughter they probably would have put it down tbh rather than watch it so ill for so long and wonder if it would live and if so what quality of life it would have), and dogs do not need anywhere the sort of attention and input as an actual human child?

I didn't bite the first time she said it. I bit the third time.

It's not the only time I've heard it and it's become a bit of a bugbear.

AIBU?

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 16/03/2022 15:48

@mam0918

It's something I will never understand... a pet is nothing like having a child.

You can rehome a pet, they only live a short time, you can lock them in a room with food, water, and the radio on and go out for hours with your friends, etc... it's in NO WAY comparable to the hard work and sacrifice of children.

On the flip side, dogs for instance live in a perpetual state of having a 3-year-old mentality, so it is half like having a toddler.

While they aren't as hard to care for because how you care for them far more lapsed (SS aren't going to take your dog if you go to work and leave it home alone) they do forever act like toddlers when they destroy things, don't talk, run around like nutters, need their shit cleaning and never gain self-sufficiency.

That's why I'm always baffled by my 'childfree by choice' friends all having 'fur babies'.

They claim they don't have kids because they are 'too selfish' but you just give yourself a pre-schooler to look after for 12-16 bloody years the only plus is you can put it in a crate or if you really must drop it at the shelter (and that's the crux of it really, it's not being too selfish it's a lack of true commitment to see it through and knowing you have the option to bail).

I'd much rather go through a hard time of having a baby and watch it blossom into a great self-sufficient person who I cant chat to and watch their long life journey until my death (which is how most child-rearing goes).

Rather that than pick up the shit from a drooling slowly deteriorating furball that limits my ability to have a free and spontaneous life for a decade and a half then being sad when I inevitably have to make the choice to kill it because it has no quality of life left.

That’s the thing though, you don’t have to understand. I mean, it genuinely does help to have a base understanding that different people have different preferences, desires and priorities, but of course you don’t ‘need’ to have that.

I don’t have children, not because I’m too selfish, but because I don’t want them. I’m not maternal and there’s nothing about childbearing and rearing that I consider to be an attractive proposition. I have animals though, and I’m quite happy with sacrificing for them. I can respect that this is alien to a lot of people, and that’s fine. My choices don’t validate their, but neither do theirs invalidate mine.

whumpthereitis · 16/03/2022 15:41

The article sums up an opinion already shared in this thread, which is already established as not a universal one.

And what’s the alternative to ‘agreeing to differ’? Telling someone they’re wrong isn’t going to make them agree with you, and it’s not going to make anyone say, think, or feel anything different.

It’s offensive to some parents. Okay. And? No one has the right to not be offended. It’s on you to cope with it.

TatianaBis · 16/03/2022 15:41

But then it’s offensive to me to be offended by something that wasn’t involved in the comparison - pregnancy, birth, ICU etc.

And if this woman can’t have kids, it’s super thoughtless and insensitive to make a thing of it.

StolenYourStollen · 16/03/2022 15:38

People that honestly think that puppy = fur child have no idea about the parenthood. It is much more than being able/unable to leave your house when you want or staying up all night. And as someone said upthread - it is offensive to mothers.

Kanfuzed123 · 16/03/2022 15:34

But it IS offensive to some mothers that’s the point, if you’ve had a traumatic delivery (that clealry impacts on your newborn experience)/ has a baby in the NICU/ had a baby with health problems/ baby that became jaundiced/ struggled with feeding/ had a baby that just didn’t sleep/ suffered with severe pnd.

For a straight forward newborn then yeah it’s still not the most linear comparison but yeah I see it but for someone like OP, myself and many other women who’ve not had a straight run at it, it is an offensive comparison.

Now don’t get me wrong I actually think the way to think before getting a puppy is along the lines of they are like an extra child, but if you know someone has struggled, like OPs friend does, then it’s a thoughtless and insensitive comparison to make

Momijin · 16/03/2022 15:33

Well, my partner has a dog that is high maintenance. He can't leave her on her own because she destroys the house. She limits what she can do a lot more than his children who are both adults now.
So it is a silly comparison because it depends on the age of the child/dog. How your child is and how much help you have. The temperament of the dog, how much help you have and what you work as.
You can easily work from home with your dog but very difficult with a young child. But it is easier to work outside the home when you have kids as there is childcare and schools.

ToCaden · 16/03/2022 15:33

@Clarabe1

There are mums who have babies who couldn’t give a toss about them. There are people who have dogs where that animal is there everything. You can’t compare the depth of people’s love or grief because it depends on the person, their life experiences and support network. I knew someone who committed suicide after his pet cat died because it was literally his world. To me love is love and if someone says they are grieving whether it is for a human or an animal I believe them.
I think this is a good point. Some people just bond with animals more than others. One person might be complete mental breakdown wreck for life after losing a pet, and another might shrug it off.

The one who wasn't as emotionally attached to their pet won't understand why the other person is acting that way, but that doesn't stop the first person's feelings about it.

I suppose we're all different. Smile

StolenYourStollen · 16/03/2022 15:33

@canicross

You are projecting. I have raised 2 babies and 2 puppies. The puppies were the most exhausting, hardest work, and most destructive to my mental well being . I would never get another puppy, but I'd be open to another baby.

Your friend has every right to share her view, as have you, but on this you have to agree to differ and move on. Neither of you are 'right' as such.

But OP is right. Dog can never be your child. It seems like anyone can say anything bonkers these days and you have to 'agree to differ'. And it is minimising the experience of motherhood. This article sums it up well www.thecut.com/2016/10/pets-are-not-children-so-stop-calling-them-that.html
canicross · 16/03/2022 15:27

You are projecting. I have raised 2 babies and 2 puppies. The puppies were the most exhausting, hardest work, and most destructive to my mental well being . I would never get another puppy, but I'd be open to another baby.

Your friend has every right to share her view, as have you, but on this you have to agree to differ and move on. Neither of you are 'right' as such.

GirlsTalk250 · 16/03/2022 15:24

Oh OP, you clearly don’t have a dog.

And 100% definitely don’t have a spaniel! Grin

AryaStarkWolf · 16/03/2022 15:21

@Kanfuzed123

Sorry Arya but the part of my original post was specifically talking about that degree of comparison which I and another poster up thread have sadly experienced. You called this the offended olympics. That degree of comparison is obviously offensive.

I also said there are some mild comparisons to be made.

You mentioned a child dying and a puppy dying in the 2nd part of that post, I was NOT commenting on that. Your "its offensive" comment came directly after you said there were some similarities. It's quite clear from the OP and from most peoples comments in this thread that "having a puppy is like having a baby" refers to looking after their needs being similar. That is in no way offensive to mothers and it's ridiculous to suggest that it is.
LightDrizzle · 16/03/2022 15:20

It's just a loose analogy that is used partly to try and reinforce or forge the bonds of fellowship and commonality. It may sound the opposite of empathetic but the impulse probably is empathetic; an "I know just what you mean!" thing. I really think you should respond to the impulse and not actual verisimilitude.

I sometimes describe having my bean-to-cup coffee machine as like having a pet. It's just a wry comment on its many and varied demands for maintenance and care, and the endurance of my love for it. I've had pets and obviously there is no real comparison.

Londoncallingtothefarawaytowns · 16/03/2022 15:16

Puppies are more annoying.
Eventually your child will listen to you ....

PourSomeLove · 16/03/2022 15:14

After 12 months a dog is self sufficient.

Lol.

Clarabe1 · 16/03/2022 15:14

There are mums who have babies who couldn’t give a toss about them. There are people who have dogs where that animal is there everything. You can’t compare the depth of people’s love or grief because it depends on the person, their life experiences and support network. I knew someone who committed suicide after his pet cat died because it was literally his world. To me love is love and if someone says they are grieving whether it is for a human or an animal I believe them.

SerendipitySunshine · 16/03/2022 15:14

Having had both, some puppies were harder than my DD. But then others have been easier. But I'd say it's the closest thing to each other.

rosesinmygarden · 16/03/2022 15:13

Having a puppy is very very hard work. I've done it twice. I will not do it again (current dog is basically a hairy ninja terrorist intent on ruling my life).

For me it was hard and draining but not as difficult as the baby phase with dd.

DDog is like my second child. We have a really close bond and I have spent many many hours, cuddling her, bathing her, cleaning up after her, hand feeding her when she is sick and apologising for her behaviour. But, she isn't a child, not like my actual dd is. If I had not had an actual baby, I might feel like it's a similar experience though. Not comparable with what you describe of course, but then everyone's experience of motherhood is different.

There are some elements which are similar to having a baby and both our puppies have been very different with varying battles and problems.

However, and this is the big thing.... You can put a puppy in its crate and go out shopping. You cannot do that with a baby! Also, having a puppy might keep you up at night and bruise your bank balance but it will not have anywhere near the physical and emotional effects that having a baby does on you, your body and your relationships.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 16/03/2022 15:11

I think it is the early days when babies and puppies are similar.
After 12 months a dog is self sufficient.
Babies are only starting the fun, years of sleepless nights, worrying about them, constantly striving to enrich their life, develop a good person but not a pushover.
Listening to their worries, saving for the future.
Those parts don't compare.

MintyGreenDream · 16/03/2022 15:11

I had a traumatic birth and that part of having a baby you can't compare with getting a puppy but the sleepless nights etc is very similar.My puppy is 4.5months and it took me right back to the baby days

Kipperandarthur · 16/03/2022 15:09

Of course it’s a silly comment, but a friend of mine who has had three children compares her puppy to looking after a baby!

Thumpkin · 16/03/2022 15:07

You’re making it about yourself and your need to be recognised as someone who had a difficult time. Baby care and puppy care have plenty in common, including impact on sleep, need to supervise, difficulty working, feeding routines, toilet routines, check ups, bathing, grooming, need to change and adapt routines, limits on social life etc etc.

Not every pregnancy and birth is the same as yours so there’s no point in trying to make sweeping blanket statements comparing your situation to hers. I mean, I had one puppy that kept me awake as much as a baby, couldn’t be left alone for over a year and cost more in vet bills in one year (which exceeded insurance) than it cost to have a baby.

Just sounds a bit mean of you to be effectively saying ‘you can’t possibly understand motherhood and compare your dog to my difficult birth.’ I think your friend knows a baby and a dog are not exactly the same. I think they also know that there are some similar ‘parental’ aspects to both. I think you need to just let it go.

sqirrelfriends · 16/03/2022 15:05

I think they can be similar in terms of sleepless nights in the beginning but the level of commitment is completely different.

Also your friend is being really insensitive, knowing what you've been through.

Kanfuzed123 · 16/03/2022 15:04

Sorry Arya but the part of my original post was specifically talking about that degree of comparison which I and another poster up thread have sadly experienced. You called this the offended olympics. That degree of comparison is obviously offensive.

I also said there are some mild comparisons to be made.

Womeninblack · 16/03/2022 15:03

You sound mean 😢

AryaStarkWolf · 16/03/2022 15:00

[quote Kanfuzed123]@AryaStarkWolf please don’t @ me, i have 0 desire to carry on a pointless conversation with someone who thinks a pet dying is akin to losing a child.[/quote]
@Kanfuzed123 what the fuck?? Stop making shit up, I never said that. I have no idea why the conversation became about a child dying is the same as a puppy dying but that was not what the OP was about. And a hot top for you, if you don't want someone @ ing you maybe don't do it them.........

Swipe left for the next trending thread