Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that buying a puppy is NOT like having a baby.

430 replies

annoyedfr · 16/03/2022 11:35

After TTC, 9 months of a difficult pregnancy, a traumatic 48 hour labour which ended with me having sepsis and baby in SCBU, 2 weeks inpatient stay, 2 years of developmental worries, all this on top of the entirely normal unbelievable stress/responsibility/cost of having a baby and child ... WIBU to tell my (wonderful but in this instance thoughtless) friend that getting a puppy is not like having a baby? Because she has not suffered birth injuries to have her 'child', a dog is not a lifelong commitment in any sort of the same way as a baby (if it were as ill as my daughter they probably would have put it down tbh rather than watch it so ill for so long and wonder if it would live and if so what quality of life it would have), and dogs do not need anywhere the sort of attention and input as an actual human child?

I didn't bite the first time she said it. I bit the third time.

It's not the only time I've heard it and it's become a bit of a bugbear.

AIBU?

OP posts:
StolenYourStollen · 16/03/2022 17:18

@Notanotherwindow

Technically they ARE babies...

I think what people are referring to is the getting up multiple times per night, safety proofing the house, can't be left alone, getting into everything and making a mess, the seemingly endless supply of poo... not to mention the constant having to repeat oneself and unbridled glee at being naughty.

Yes, but they are not YOUR BABIES. There is a word for an animal that you keep at home for company and care for - pet. So why do you have to use the word that's reserved for a human baby? Calling an animal what it is - a pet, isn't offensive.
woody87 · 16/03/2022 17:09

YANBU

I am sick to the back teeth of people who compare having dogs to having children. I had two dogs before I had kids, I still have a dog as well as two kids.

IT IS NOT REMOTELY THE SAME.

At least people who have dogs but no kids have nothing to compare it to so I just roll my eyes.

Folk that have both and STILL SAY that it is the same I think are marginally insane. There is something seriously wrong with you if you say you love your child and your dog the exact same.

Disclaimer : I love my dog - but she is not a child.

AskItaliano · 16/03/2022 17:04

@Notanotherwindow

Technically they ARE babies...

I think what people are referring to is the getting up multiple times per night, safety proofing the house, can't be left alone, getting into everything and making a mess, the seemingly endless supply of poo... not to mention the constant having to repeat oneself and unbridled glee at being naughty.

I have a human toddler and have had a puppy in the past, and honestly, there's so much similarity isn't there haha. Potty training and puppy training for starters. Finding those puddles of wee around the places. Your whole schedule being dictated by them. Having to get up early every day for them. Being responsible for meeting their every need when they're entirely dependent on you. Teaching them, loving them, etc.
AskItaliano · 16/03/2022 17:03

Also: friend might be trying to connect with you. You never answered whether she has children. If not, she might be trying to meet you on a level and share something she thinks is similar about your lives. Maybe she feels left out if she doesn't have kids and most of her friends do, so to her acknowledging that her puppy feels like a baby is the closest she gets to joining in. A friend of mine suffered with infertility and never ended up able to have children, she calls her three dogs 'my girls' and treats them like her children. To her, they are, and I get it. What kind of a cruel POS would turn around and snottily point out 'ackshually, they're not real children'?

Notanotherwindow · 16/03/2022 17:03

Technically they ARE babies...

I think what people are referring to is the getting up multiple times per night, safety proofing the house, can't be left alone, getting into everything and making a mess, the seemingly endless supply of poo... not to mention the constant having to repeat oneself and unbridled glee at being naughty.

AskItaliano · 16/03/2022 17:01

People that honestly think that puppy = fur child have no idea about the parenthood. It is much more than being able/unable to leave your house when you want or staying up all night. And as someone said upthread - it is offensive to mothers.

Lol. Plenty of mothers to humans on the thread are saying that puppies are fur kids.

You mean it's offensive to you/some mothers. Not mothers in general. I can't imagine being offended because someone else has said that their puppy is like having a baby. I mean, it's a baby animal, so is a baby human, jesus.

AskItaliano · 16/03/2022 16:59

YANBU to say it here. And YANBU to say it to her. If your friendship is a strong one then just bloody say your piece, share your view. It's okay to do that! It's okay to say 'haha, I wish having a baby was like getting a puppy!' or whatever you want. Better than bottling it up and exploding. And you can't stop her saying it, but maybe you'll feel less aggro about it if you've said something back.

I'm on her side though, as someone who has had a baby and a puppy, they're remarkably similar. Obviously the process of pregnancy and birth doesn't correlate, and I doubt your friend would say it does. I suspect she's saying that having a puppy is like caring for a baby, or conveying that to her her puppy IS her baby.

PourSomeLove · 16/03/2022 16:55

People that honestly think that puppy = fur child have no idea about the parenthood. It is much more than being able/unable to leave your house when you want or staying up all night. And as someone said upthread - it is offensive to mothers.

Again, it depends what sort of person you are. I feel just as much responsibility and love for my children as I do my dogs. Lots of people seem to just use their dogs when they want entertaining or some company on a walk, then they’re an inconvenience the rest of the time. My dogs are my family, decisions are made with them in mind, just like with other family members. People could be offended by you saying they have no idea about parenthood. I’m a good mum and have brought up 2 lovely children although I’m not offended as I don’t really care what others think of my way of doing things. It’s works for us.

Sailorsusan · 16/03/2022 16:52

I don't have a dog and I won't be having one until I feel I have at least the same amount of energy and commitment as I mustered to have a baby. Whereas a cat I'd have any old day. So I see her point.

OP, I think that the reason you feel so sensitive about the comment is because you feel nobody understands what you have been through, so a comment like this feels insulting and thoughtless, even though your friend is probably trying her best to empathise. After your birth trauma, did you talk to anyone, or did people just expect you to ecstatically commence parenthood?

ThinWomansBrain · 16/03/2022 16:48

Your choice to have a baby
She chose a puppy - or did she?
Do you know 100% that puppy is not a substitute for not being able to have children?

juneybean · 16/03/2022 16:44

Haha fair enough!

AryaStarkWolf · 16/03/2022 16:43

@juneybean

It's similar in that you forget how bad it is, and that's why people get a second! we're 10 months in with our second cockerpoo, the first slept through straight away, this one doesn't sleep, he throws tantrums on every walk, and we don't get maternity leave for dogs Grin
No I haven't forgotten how bad house training is and my dog will be 11 this year! If I get another dog it will definitely be a dog and not a puppy!
PourSomeLove · 16/03/2022 16:42

And also, I do actually know a couple of people who found the puppy stage harder than the newborn stage.

I haven’t found kids or dogs particularly hard but for me, parenting my kids has been easier on the whole.

juneybean · 16/03/2022 16:38

It's similar in that you forget how bad it is, and that's why people get a second! we're 10 months in with our second cockerpoo, the first slept through straight away, this one doesn't sleep, he throws tantrums on every walk, and we don't get maternity leave for dogs Grin

Smellyporcupine · 16/03/2022 16:32

I have two babies. And yes a puppy massively changes your life, they get you up in the night, put things in their mouth they shouldn't and they need constant supervision, so in that sense it is the same.

I think you are being a bit over sensitive. I train my kids like the dog. Stop. No. Drop. Wait. They get treats if they are good too 😂

implantreplace · 16/03/2022 16:30

And when you say you disagree

Are you saying you love your dogs as much as your children? Presumably so if you disagree with me?

implantreplace · 16/03/2022 16:29

@Momijin

You “disagree” with the fact that I would love my children very very much more than any puppy and respond accordingly

Or do you mean that YOU feel DIFFERENTLY to ME?

ouch321 · 16/03/2022 16:28

You sound unpleasant toward your friend.

I don't have either dogs or kids but even I know that as puppies for example you have to take them outside for bathroom purposes every 30 mins when you get them. It's very disruptive. There are a lot of similarities.

You sound as though you've joined the "She doesn't have children so she is lesser than me" school of thought.

Mreggsworth · 16/03/2022 16:28

I don't get why you are bothered.

Obviously people know having a dog isn't like having a baby, people are aware they didn't birth their dog. But to a lot of people their dog is THEIR baby.

I know someone who couldn't have a baby, and she calls her dog her baby. She would have loved a human baby. She has now found something (a dog) that she can treat and love like her baby and it brings her joy and comfort...why does it make you feel any better to deny her that feeling ?

And also, I do actually know a couple of people who found the puppy stage harder than the newborn stage.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 16/03/2022 16:28

@Everydaydayisaschoolday Your poor sister has had a very harsh time.
There is no harm in loving her DD and her pet, she has a lot of love and loss to deal with.

Momijin · 16/03/2022 16:26

@implantreplace

The love I would have for a puppy would be teeny tiny teeny compared to the ocean of my love for my children

So hassle, picking up dog shit and training etc would feel like such a chore and hardship.

The same for my children can be a bit…. Sigh. But certainly not a hardship

I disagree with that. I have kids and a dog and I absolutely think of my dog as almost another child. And pre kids, my pets were my babies.
implantreplace · 16/03/2022 16:21

The love I would have for a puppy would be teeny tiny teeny compared to the ocean of my love for my children

So hassle, picking up dog shit and training etc would feel like such a chore and hardship.

The same for my children can be a bit…. Sigh. But certainly not a hardship

Everydaydayisaschoolday · 16/03/2022 15:55

My sister used to do this when I had DC and she 'only' had a dog. We fell out about it (although we are always falling out so if it hadn't been over that it would have been something else). I put it down to her ignorance of TTC, labour, parenting etc.

That was decades ago. Since then she has had a horrendous time with TTC, miscarriages etc. She eventually had a daughter quite late in life who has significant special needs. She requires 24 hour care and will do for the rest of her life. And then DS became a single mum when her DH couldn't cope. So she has experienced pressures and aspects of parenting I have zero knowledge of. And with all that she still compares being a pet owner to being a parent and devotes the same emotional attention and care to her current dog as she does to her now teenage daughter.

I have had to conclude that her attitude wasn't due to ignorance of the realities of being a parent but that she and I just disagree on this.

Namechangestimes100 · 16/03/2022 15:52

@TatianaBis

But then it’s offensive to me to be offended by something that wasn’t involved in the comparison - pregnancy, birth, ICU etc.

And if this woman can’t have kids, it’s super thoughtless and insensitive to make a thing of it.

But OP did have a tough time didn’t she, it seems as though she doesn’t like the direct comparison between her experience which was a tough one and that of getting a dog. That seems to be the trend with people who are saying they don’t like the comparison, they’ve had significant difficulties in one way or another that’s either affected them or their DC and as a result the comparison to them seems like it’s dismissive. It seems not the be the general vague comparison that dog = huge responsibility somewhat similar to a child, but the direct ‘I’m really struggling with my child because of xyz quite serious circumstances’ for it to be met with oh ‘yeah that was the same as when I got my puppy’. But tbh that’s just person b being dismissive in general.

Just my observation from reading umpteen pages

AryaStarkWolf · 16/03/2022 15:49

@TatianaBis

But then it’s offensive to me to be offended by something that wasn’t involved in the comparison - pregnancy, birth, ICU etc.

And if this woman can’t have kids, it’s super thoughtless and insensitive to make a thing of it.

Exactly. People are coming along now trying to make out that the friend said that a child and a puppy are exactly the same thing when what she actually said was having a puppy is LIKE have a child, clearly meaning I have a lot of looking after/cleaning up after/getting woken up happening.
Swipe left for the next trending thread