Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is teaching really that bad?

441 replies

Cremeegg456 · 15/03/2022 22:39

I did a secondary PGCE and gained a pass with Merit, and 'outstanding', that was 6 years ago and I've never completed my nqt year.
I know the PGCE isn't representative of what actual teaching is like though but I remember it being what seemed like a lot of unnecessary paperwork, but we also had the assignments on top.

I've done various work with young and elderly people since which I've enjoyed, but I've never made a lot more than minimum wage. Had zero hours contracts, agency work etc.

I did enjoy teaching but I am just not prepared to work evenings and weekends as well, it's just not worth having no life for me. Not prepared to work more than 45 hours a week.

But truthfully if I want a higher and more stable income I think I would have to go into it, if I'm thinking of buying a house, children etc in the next few years.

Would be interested to hear from people as to what their work life balance really is.

OP posts:
Thewindwhispers · 17/03/2022 22:08

Not a teacher! But I thought it interesting that on the “If you love your job, what do you do” thread, there were several teachers.

Crikeyalmighty · 17/03/2022 21:43

I think part of the problem it seems reading this post is the constant changing of goalposts and the fact the job is now it seems part teacher/part social worker/part admin manager. I’m not a teacher but my mum was and she was incredibly unsuited to the job but liked the idea of long holidays and being home by 4.30 which clearly now isn’t the case. I do think it’s a hard job to combine with young kids— probably more suited to those with none or with kids in double figures . I also think it’s very poorly paid for the first few years— my 23 year old son works at a decent level in tech without a degree (he did apprenticeship) and is on 32k (in London) — There are young women earning 40k in recruitment or estate agents , to be frank I dont like sales and I do enjoy plenty of variety , so would rather be a teacher , but a lot of bright young people early 20’s will look at starting salary in teaching and think ‘no thanks’ especially if placements are in a very challenging school. I do think we need to consider too why so many young kids and teens are so poorly behaved and out of control because it’s clearly not helping with teacher retention . My sons behaviour improved rapidly with 2 years from 11 to 13 at state boarding school (Royal Alexandra) and loads of ex army type teachers and house masters plus compulsory prep before tea etc. About killed us financially but was worth it .

bubblegumunicorn · 17/03/2022 21:06

@Cremeegg456

Do you think a PGCE would lend itself to other roles? I have a friend who's a head of department and says she never does any work outside of school of stays late which is incredible
Get on prospects they have loads of great careers You could apply your PGCE too! What about learning mentor? Or you could go in to something else working with children or have you thought about FE teaching or private schools they don't follow the national curriculum so I've heard it's a bit more relaxed! There's definitely a few options
WonderfulYou · 17/03/2022 20:58

I’m planning on leaving teaching this year.
I simply cannot cope with the hours - I go to work and very often don’t get a break, then come home and in the evening fo more work and then also do work on the weekend and I’m still barely keeping my head above the water.

I absolutely love being in the classroom which the kids - but I can’t stand everything else that goes with it.

Have you thought about a TA position or something that allows you to be in the classroom but not have to do all of the extra work right now so you can get a feel of if it’s right for you or not.

I think this meme sums up the job brilliantly.

Is teaching really that bad?
JudgeJ · 17/03/2022 20:44

I retired from teaching a few years back, and my take on this question is fairly unchanged.
The teaching is wonderful, seeing the lightbulb moment is very rewarding.
However, it's the other stuff that's the problem, teaching being a political football, irrespective of the party in power, parents who think they always know better, I wonder if they are the same with their childs' doctors, dentists? Schools having to fill in as social workers, police, marriage guidance, parking wardens (!!), resolvers of out-of-school disputes between children, the list is almost endless.
Lack of parental support generally, too many parents only ever speak to the school to nit-pick, the motto for many parents is Discipline is what other people's children need. When you accept a school place you are accepting the school standards, if you don't like it, try elsewhere, don't take you saddo face to the papers.
Lack of decent salary progression, I knew of people who resigned senior jobs for a regular teaching role and the drop in salary was almost compensated for by the reduction in stress.

whytcvv · 17/03/2022 20:38

@NovaMN

And add the academy system...parents are just not bothered or disregard the fact that education, as part of a democratic system is being disbanded.
Do parents even fully understand what being an academy means? To them it's the same school I think.
NovaMN · 17/03/2022 20:30

And add the academy system...parents are just not bothered or disregard the fact that education, as part of a democratic system is being disbanded.

whytcvv · 17/03/2022 20:18

@noblegiraffe

How would parents even know? It's like the best kept secret only known within the inner workings of education.

What would you like to know about, whytcvv? The huge cuts to funding? The redundancies? The critical shortage of teachers? The critical shortage of headteachers? The govt failure to meet recruitment targets every year? That the school estate needs basic repairs costing £11.4 billion? That there's a bulge of kids heading towards secondary which will mean a shortage of secondary school places?

Happy to explain anything you're not sure about.

Thank you for your kind offer of information and awareness.

I was speaking from what I perceive in school from parents. Dropping off and collecting their children each day with no regard to the issues highlighted within your post.

Do they realise but either do not care enough or don't know where to start to do anything about it? Or perhaps they just don't comprehend just how bad it is.

whytcvv · 17/03/2022 20:13

@howtomoveforwards

How would parents even know? It's like the best kept secret only known within the inner workings of education

Seriously? The state of education as a parent is something you really should have an active interest in. In fact, as a citizen of this country with a vested interest in our country’s long term future, you should have an active interest in education. If you have missed the shit show that is GCSE reform under Gove plus years of austerity, pandemic, and now war, you really aren’t very interested in anything at all. Educate yourself. Take some bloody responsibility and listen to what is being said. Our education system is in crisis and has been for some time. It is not a secret.

Ok thank you for that, much appreciated.

I am a volunteer in a school so I do have an awareness of the themes noted within this thread.

My observation was based on what I see in school from parents. Maybe it isn't such a secret, but maybe the parents are not around long enough to care, in and out of primary within 6 years and by the time they grasp what's going on it is no longer important to them to actually do anything about it.

Anyway thanks for jumping over my post. Apologies accepted.

sorryforswearing · 17/03/2022 19:30

There’s a Facebook group called ‘ Life After Teaching’. Join and read the posts. It will answer your question. Not everyone on there has left. Lots are trying to escape. I’m recent retired and missing the positives in the job. Just reading it reminds me why the negatives outweigh the positives by a mile. I worked in a great school with an understanding head and relatively small class sizes. Despite this work/life balance was impossible to achieve.

Knittingchamp · 17/03/2022 19:16

I was a secondary teacher for a long time. I loved the students, my heart went out to them, and that there is why IMO teachers are always exploited - they do so much because they care and management take advantage of that. And teachers get so much criticism thrown at them by some parents despite an insanely difficult work environment. I've seen a new teacher crumble and walk out before their first day was out.

There was no work life balance, so much stress, I mostly drowned under pointless admin and paperwork and am so glad to be out of it. I still work with young people but in different but rewarding ways and with a far more stress free life.

Sleepingonmyfeet · 17/03/2022 18:56

That wasn’t my teachers - my parents (dad) taught me to both read and write.

Kite22 · 17/03/2022 18:53

@Sleepingonmyfeet

That’s the issue though *@Fairislefandango*. It was pot luck whether you were taught well or not. I can honestly say I learned nothing at primary school, really, honestly, nothing.
I find that incredibly unlikely. After all, here you are reading posts and writing posts on an internet forum.
OnceuponaRainbow18 · 17/03/2022 18:52

@Fairislefandango

Yea same, we’ve currently got 6 years 10s and 5 year 11s in isolation room for uniform breaches they’ve been in there missing all exam classes for about 18 school days. Neither party will budge. Surprised it’s not made the news yet!

cigarettesNalcohol · 17/03/2022 18:14

No no and no. Parenting your own kids is hard enough let alone picking up the pieces for a full class. The pressure of knowing some of them aren't getting what they need etc... it's just too much. Long hours. Pressure. Disrespect. Low pay. Absolutely not.

Fairislefandango · 17/03/2022 18:13

Hear Hear to all that, @ThrallsWife. I hate uniform.

Sleepingonmyfeet · 17/03/2022 18:12

It's worse because lack of funding means that many SEND students who would, years ago, have had individual support are just being thrown in with the rest of a large class

Believe me, this happened when I started teaching, in 2002.

Fairislefandango · 17/03/2022 18:12

That’s the issue though@Fairislefandango. It was pot luck whether you were taught well or not.

It still is. It always will be. The problem with the current system is that it doesn't stop bad teachers from being bad, but it stops virtually all teachers from being as good as they could be, by overloading them with bullshit. Not to mention edging out and alienating experienced teachers in favour of young, cheap cannon fodder.

ThrallsWife · 17/03/2022 18:11

I work in a subject that is usually perceived as one of the most difficult at secondary level.

We have a department which requires 8 teachers at all times. This year alone, in this department, 2 were walked off site (frankly not fit to teach), 1 quit because they were deceived into essentially working for free under the cover of "training", 2 have been off with work-related stress for several weeks each, 3 quit within days of starting because of behaviour and now we have 2 definitely leaving and almost everyone else looking to leave.

Behaviour has got worse and more parents feel entitled to our time at all hours - thanks remote learning.

Behaviour is worse because a large minority of students admit to doing no work over either lockdown and therefore can't access the curriculum. It's worse because lack of funding means that many SEND students who would, years ago, have had individual support are just being thrown in with the rest of a large class. It's worse because there is NO support for EAL students (last time I had a TA specialising in EAL was more than 12 years ago) and the only thing we can rely on is poor translations via PowerPoint in the hope the kids know the highly technical words in their own language (hint: they don't, why would they?)
It is also worse because the Mikaela school model of zero tolerance and insistence on perfect uniform, work and behaviour is one-size-fits-all and doesn't take into account that, on many days, Johnny is lucky if he finds a half-chewed pencil in his bag.

And then there is pointless paperwork. I was in a meeting today doing data analysis of an exam and pointed out that there are systes out there that could export this and complete the analysis for me. I was told this was in the name of "ownership" of my classes (which, funnily enough, I share). So what could be a 5min read-and-take-action plan will take a total of 3 hours of inputting data from two different sources and bullshitting about how Amy will achieve better if only (she had a consistent teacher) she was moved to the magically-expanding front of the class and not distracted by Jack, who is spitting gum into her hair every lesson, but I can't do anything about it as anything more than talking to him would upset him and he'd never produce work again: it's in his plan.

On that note, a colleague got pulled into the head's office the other day because a student was upset he used the wrong pronoun and is now traumatised.

I just wish
-we could do away with uniform (believe me, having lived in a country without, it makes no bloody difference)

-all students could bring the very basic materials to lessson (I used to have to take all of my own, including text books) - just a pen, pencil, ruler and calculator would be grand

-there was some reason applied to data analysis, i.e. Lucy is never going to achieve a 9 in her GCSEs despite her KS2 SATs data because she is looking after her baby brother while mum is out working shifts and then she's too tired to complete revision work - and that's fine, no amount of ringing home and changing seating plans will make that any better

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 17/03/2022 18:05

Covid defo hasn’t helped that’s for sure.

I feel pretty broken most days, I would stop if I didn’t love the kids I teach so much; each year I think I’ll see these exam classes through and then the next lot etc

Sleepingonmyfeet · 17/03/2022 18:04

That’s the issue though @Fairislefandango. It was pot luck whether you were taught well or not. I can honestly say I learned nothing at primary school, really, honestly, nothing.

Fairislefandango · 17/03/2022 18:01

Well, from my memory those things started happening in earnest about 15-20 years ago. As far as my experience goes, I was generally taught well at school (1980s).

I started teaching in 1996. It was great. Absolutely loved it. I worked with lots of good teachers, who were much more free to teach in their own way, and were not overloaded with admin and hoop-jumping tasks. There were a few crap teachers, as there still are and always will be but, just like there are a few crap people in any job. Scrutiny and league tables have not made teachers better, though they might have made teachers, and certainly schools and their senior leaders, more savvy about how to look as though they are better.

refraction · 17/03/2022 18:00

@maddy68

Actually you have to complete your induction within 4 terms of completing a pgce ((unless that has changed ) so sadly I don't think you can teach now
I did mine 10 years after my PGCE.
Sleepingonmyfeet · 17/03/2022 17:49

But when those things didn’t happen, what was the result?

Fairislefandango · 17/03/2022 17:48

So what do we do? All attempts so far to make state education brilliant have not been successful.

I haven't ever seen any attempts to make state education brilliant. I've seen people pushing agendas which suit them. Tweaking superficial things because they know it will be difficult and expensive to fix what really needs fixing. Constantly and pointlessly moving the goalposts. Adding things to teachers' workloads just to look as if they are improving something. Setting schools in unhelpful competition with each other through league tables.