Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is teaching really that bad?

441 replies

Cremeegg456 · 15/03/2022 22:39

I did a secondary PGCE and gained a pass with Merit, and 'outstanding', that was 6 years ago and I've never completed my nqt year.
I know the PGCE isn't representative of what actual teaching is like though but I remember it being what seemed like a lot of unnecessary paperwork, but we also had the assignments on top.

I've done various work with young and elderly people since which I've enjoyed, but I've never made a lot more than minimum wage. Had zero hours contracts, agency work etc.

I did enjoy teaching but I am just not prepared to work evenings and weekends as well, it's just not worth having no life for me. Not prepared to work more than 45 hours a week.

But truthfully if I want a higher and more stable income I think I would have to go into it, if I'm thinking of buying a house, children etc in the next few years.

Would be interested to hear from people as to what their work life balance really is.

OP posts:
Notellinganyone · 01/02/2023 20:25

I think it takes time to learn and gain confidence and it also depends on you and the school. I work in a very academic, busy day school but am confident and very experienced so enjoy it a lot. I don’t work much during holidays or evenings but do work sometimes at weekends.

Lancrelady80 · 01/02/2023 20:21

And good luck when you hit MP6 and then have to get through the threshold onto the Upper Pay Scale. It's not supposed to require anything other than experience but many of us have to take on extra things and justify why we deserve it. If not, on MP6 you stay.

And if you move schools, pay portability is no longer a given. I returned to teaching after a couple of years out with my children and had to drop from UP1 to MP3, and that was negotiated up from them wanting to pay me MP1.

Piggywaspushed · 01/02/2023 20:18

EmmaDilemma5 · 01/02/2023 20:14

I don't think it's always as bad as people make out. I work in a school. Our experienced early years teachers earns £40k. Lots of years of experience means she doesn't have to do much planning outside of schools hours. She admitted to not doing much over the Summer.

I work in the office and I'm always in earlier than everyone and leave later (except senior leadership team).

I think it's long hours in the early years while finding your feet but once settled, it's a pretty good salary for the work.

Also, teachers salaries increase every year irrespective of performance. And it's quite easy to take on additional responsibilities for more money. One of our teachers in 26 and on £43k as a Y3 teacher and head of key stage.

Its a responsible job and you work hard. But it's not thankless and it's not badly paid in my opinion.

How do you know how much people earn??

Vgbeat · 01/02/2023 20:18

I do 70 plus hours a work. On average 12 to 14 hour.days and then all day Saturday.

Lancrelady80 · 01/02/2023 20:17

Also, teachers salaries increase every year irrespective of performance

Bollocks do they!!!!

They used to, when on main pay scale.

Not now. Academies tend to follow that, although don't have to. But it absolutely is dependent on performance management targets.

EmmaDilemma5 · 01/02/2023 20:16

PyjamaFan · 01/02/2023 12:47

What a nasty comment.

How is that a nasty comment?!

EmmaDilemma5 · 01/02/2023 20:14

I don't think it's always as bad as people make out. I work in a school. Our experienced early years teachers earns £40k. Lots of years of experience means she doesn't have to do much planning outside of schools hours. She admitted to not doing much over the Summer.

I work in the office and I'm always in earlier than everyone and leave later (except senior leadership team).

I think it's long hours in the early years while finding your feet but once settled, it's a pretty good salary for the work.

Also, teachers salaries increase every year irrespective of performance. And it's quite easy to take on additional responsibilities for more money. One of our teachers in 26 and on £43k as a Y3 teacher and head of key stage.

Its a responsible job and you work hard. But it's not thankless and it's not badly paid in my opinion.

Whoneedsleep · 01/02/2023 20:06

Yes.

Awful management.
Constant threat of being managed out of a job.
Completely target and ofsted driven.
Awful kids.
Kids being failed and watching it happen knowing you can’t do a thing because it’s above you.
Entitled parents moaning about said awful kids being disciplined (often plastering it all over social media, how dare little Jonny be told off 🙄)
Minimal staff meaning no free lessons to catch up, no breaks as supervising kids while on ‘lunch’, having to go in early and stay late almost every day.
Drowning in marking and paperwork but no time at all to do it other than at home.
The stress of making a mistake making you ill to the point you can’t sleep, knowing how easy it is to be got rid of (especially as a more experienced teacher, NQTs are much cheaper therefore more desirable than experience)

Its not so easy to say just leave. We have 3 kids to pay for, retraining would take a huge drop we just can’t afford.

Lancrelady80 · 01/02/2023 19:59

Ofsted is responsible for a huge, huge amount of workload and stress. One of the big things at the moment is inspectors coming in to do a deep dive into certain subjects - always English and Maths, plus one other. The level of detail and info they want is enormous, including lots of justification around the content and sequencing of the curriculum for each subject - intent; then what is actually happening and how, cross-checking it's all as per the plans -implementation; then how well the ch are learning - impact. A subject leader is expected to be thoroughly knowledgeable about everything in their subject in all classes and all breakdowns of groups in the school, right down to the content of that day's lesson in any given class, and to know the pedagogy behind it all.

That might be a reasonable expectation for a head of department at secondary school, where that subject is their specialism and what they mostly teach, and where they receive increased pay for that responsibility. I'll leave that to secondary staff to agree/disagree.

But now transfer those same expectations to primary, where teachers teach all curriculum subjects and subject leaders are generally paid no more, given little or no curriculum time, and tend to be whoever is there regardless of knowledge or interest. And then put that in the context of smaller schools where members of staff don't have just one subject responsibility but 3 or 4, and might also be the SENDCO. What impact does that have on workload and morale, I wonder?

Ofsted was bad enough before all of this.

noblegiraffe · 01/02/2023 19:48

If you scrapped (or seriously reformed Ofsted) and cut back on lesson observations, learning walks and book scrutinies and a few other bits, I could personally name at least ten ex colleagues (excellent teachers) who would probably return!

I think a few years back Ofsted’s Myths documents about what they didn’t want to see, including triple marking and lengthy lesson plans was really helpful in cutting some of the crap.

Unfortunately since then the whole ‘focus on curriculum’ and deep dives have just cranked up all the ‘we have to do this for Ofsted’ bullshit again, particularly in primary.

maddy68 · 01/02/2023 19:48

If you don't want a life outside teaching and you are prepared to be battered from Ofsted , kids, parents , line manages daily and work ridiculous hours just to keep your head above water. And still never be finished teaching is wonderful.

There are some brilliant moments sadly the negatives now outweigh the positives. It's so sad. I used to love it.
I now have a minimum wage job and I've never been happier. I was a good teacher with great results but the pressure!!!

KAYMACK · 01/02/2023 19:43

Shinyandnew1 · 01/02/2023 11:44

why do they simply not ask existing teachers want they want to stay in their jobs? Or at least make SOME sort of tweaks?

Absolutely! There was a workload survey a few years back but I don’t think anything changed as a result of it. We have had countless Education secretaries since then though-all with their own agenda and none seemingly responsible for their party’s Ed policies.

If you scrapped (or seriously reformed Ofsted) and cut back on lesson observations, learning walks and book scrutinies and a few other bits, I could personally name at least ten ex colleagues (excellent teachers) who would probably return!

Interesting, who is it who makes up the employees of Ofsted? Former teachers? Bureaucrats? Or just interfering no-clue people?

PyjamaFan · 01/02/2023 12:47

Yazo · 01/02/2023 12:45

My mum is a teacher, she retrained from nursing and it's given her a stable, well paid career where she doesn't actually have to do that many hours. Although she's not worked in mainstream schools for many years, when she did she was hardly working 60 hour weeks, more like a usual 40 hour working week. What she didn't enjoy was the culture and other teachers, she found it difficult to start at 40 having worked in other places. It can be a really good job, but I think there is a lot of peer pressure to do it in a certain showy way, when ready you can just keep your head down and help the kids to great results.

What a nasty comment.

Yazo · 01/02/2023 12:45

My mum is a teacher, she retrained from nursing and it's given her a stable, well paid career where she doesn't actually have to do that many hours. Although she's not worked in mainstream schools for many years, when she did she was hardly working 60 hour weeks, more like a usual 40 hour working week. What she didn't enjoy was the culture and other teachers, she found it difficult to start at 40 having worked in other places. It can be a really good job, but I think there is a lot of peer pressure to do it in a certain showy way, when ready you can just keep your head down and help the kids to great results.

Piggywaspushed · 01/02/2023 12:14

The people they listen to are largely execs at large MATs whose 'workload and workforce' ideas are often deeply flawed.

Shinyandnew1 · 01/02/2023 11:44

why do they simply not ask existing teachers want they want to stay in their jobs? Or at least make SOME sort of tweaks?

Absolutely! There was a workload survey a few years back but I don’t think anything changed as a result of it. We have had countless Education secretaries since then though-all with their own agenda and none seemingly responsible for their party’s Ed policies.

If you scrapped (or seriously reformed Ofsted) and cut back on lesson observations, learning walks and book scrutinies and a few other bits, I could personally name at least ten ex colleagues (excellent teachers) who would probably return!

KAYMACK · 01/02/2023 11:17

I thought I would bump up this thread, as I keep seeing calls being issued by the government to recruit teachers, offers of bursaries, etc.

But when things are so bad, why do they simply not ask existing teachers want they want to stay in their jobs? Or at least make SOME sort of tweaks?

Thehousetrap · 23/03/2022 21:35

Haven’t rtft, but my answer is : yes, yes it is.

frenchie4002 · 23/03/2022 21:02

@OnceuponaRainbow18 really! We are in a three tiered area so I should have said upper school not secondary, sorry. It’s annoying you don’t gain back the free time but nice change of pace I guess?

LizzieAnt · 23/03/2022 20:26

@FoodieToo

Another Irish teacher here ! Teaching is so different in Ireland . I work at primary level and earn 78 k ( euro and teaching 28 years with a minor promoted post ) . I do about an hour extra at home for the month of September.

That's more or less it. Otherwise I am in school for half eight and leave around half two/ quarter to 3 .
I do some research/ send a few emails at home but that's it .
Planning is a fortnightly scheme that takes half an hour but I normally get that done in school time. I don't know any teacher that does much after hours.

Mentioned this to a friend who's a teacher in Ireland and he was staggered.

He says he usually leaves work about 4.30 to 5 pm (sometimes later) and often works at home too. He rarely has a completely free weekend during term time as there's always planning to do.

He said it probably does depend where you teach. Lots of rural schools have split classes (he's in a 3-teacher school), so you have to plan for two or three classes rather than one. It's a Catholic school as most rural schools are, so he needs to prepare his class for Confirmation too. All organisation for the school is split between fewer people. Any extras - for example involvement in school competitions in sport, drama, science etc - are again shared by a few.

My friend is a teacher but the situation is worse for principals of smaller Irish schools. They must teach in addition to their other responsibilities (principals in larger schools don't teach), and the amount of work is overwhelming them to the extent that many are leaving the profession. To quote an Irish Times headline from last September) there is now a crisis in their 'recruitment and retention'.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 23/03/2022 20:13

@frenchie4002

We get sent to local primary schools to do induction work with the kids in year 6 moving to us in sept during the time we usually teach double gcse or a level

frenchie4002 · 23/03/2022 19:45

I’m in my third year of secondary English. The first year is hard as others have said - making resources and learning how to efficiently mark/plan etc is time consuming. It’s levelled out now - I get in at 8 and have left by 4.30 every day. Some weekends I do a couple of hours planning. Very occasionally parents’ evenings etc are late stays. Also at our school when year 11 and 13 leave we gain lots of free PPA time so have time to scheme and prepare for September which helps - I imagine it’s similar in most secondaries? It’s not a job I envision myself having the energy for forever but in the right school there is scope to climb the pay scale quickly and have an ok work/life balance. Good luck with whatever you decide :)

SenoraMiasma · 23/03/2022 18:41

@Shinyandnew1

Someone mentioned this is another thread about teaching in Ireland.

I think that most schools were governed by the church for a long time. Contrary to what most seem to think about RC (the majority) and education, in Ireland it was always a really well organised system (imv). Educational methodologies are challenged, examined and discussed and integrated into a framework that complements the students learning - we seem to do the opposite in England. I only saw it here in private schools - where everything is centralised somehow.

I have also heard many reasons as to why this doesn’t happen here - mostly based on a fear ( I think) of what it involves. It’s an ongoing conversation within the second gen Irish community here as we have some insight into both systems and can see the merits and limitations of them.

I also think having so many different types of schools in England skewers things. Free schools/church/ comprehensive all exist here.

Burgoo · 23/03/2022 17:57

I have to admit you couldn't get me to do it. I've worked in professional jobs for years and I realised over time that none of it actually matters. I now go in, do my job, go home and get paid. I still work in professional settings but my limits are MUCH narrower than they were 20 years ago.

Shinyandnew1 · 23/03/2022 17:55

[quote FoodieToo]@Shinyandnew1

What’s your assessment/marking load like? None as I do it as I go ( SET )
Is writing/sticking in Learning objectives a thing?! Not for teachers after their first year . IF class teachers do them they just copy them .
Lesson observations? Only for NQT
Expensive teachers being managed out? No, state system.
Performance management targets? No.
Tracking data? No.
Subject leads in primary having to create curriculum progression maps from scratch despite having no qualification in the subject and getting no extra pay!? No !![/quote]
The crazy thing is that England could solve the retention crisis in teaching overnight by going to visit some schools in ireland who function like this and implement similar systems. It would save hours and hours of time and I would imagine make many people not want to leave and many more happy to return.

Why don’t they?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread