Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is teaching really that bad?

441 replies

Cremeegg456 · 15/03/2022 22:39

I did a secondary PGCE and gained a pass with Merit, and 'outstanding', that was 6 years ago and I've never completed my nqt year.
I know the PGCE isn't representative of what actual teaching is like though but I remember it being what seemed like a lot of unnecessary paperwork, but we also had the assignments on top.

I've done various work with young and elderly people since which I've enjoyed, but I've never made a lot more than minimum wage. Had zero hours contracts, agency work etc.

I did enjoy teaching but I am just not prepared to work evenings and weekends as well, it's just not worth having no life for me. Not prepared to work more than 45 hours a week.

But truthfully if I want a higher and more stable income I think I would have to go into it, if I'm thinking of buying a house, children etc in the next few years.

Would be interested to hear from people as to what their work life balance really is.

OP posts:
whytcvv · 16/03/2022 06:57

@WithRosesAroundTheDoor

A friend of mine was ranting about this the other day and it's just hitting me how right she is. The whole culture around teaching is wrong and really takes advantage of the emotional connection that we have with pupils. In no other job would you be expected to put in so much unpaid overtime. There are no other roles where you would be considered failing and put through capability without hours of unpaid overtime. It's so bloody wrong and is reliant on us being afraid to let the side down.

This this and this screamed from the rooftops where nobody can hear and nobody cares.

Instafreak231 · 16/03/2022 06:55

On the other side I actually enjoy teaching!

OutlookStalking · 16/03/2022 06:52

Yes it is. Hope that helps!

Basilthymerosemary · 16/03/2022 06:51

It’s doable. I’m full time with toddlers from choice. Yes they go to nursery during term time but I have all the holidays with them. Apart from a handful of pinch points throughout the year I do not bring any work home. However, family admin is completely shared with husband 50/50. He does drop off, I do pick ups. We take turns being off if little ones are I’ll. Having that equal share makes the biggest difference.

springflowerss · 16/03/2022 06:51

Also, Jesus Christ I’ve just read the thread and I’d like to throw into the ring that I regularly have times when I think “I can’t believe this is my job”/“I can’t believe I get paid for this”/“I can’t believe anyone would want to do anything other than this.”

I’m sure I’ll get tons of people being like “just wait until you’ve been teaching for 500 years THEN you’ll hate it!” but it’s really not true that all teachers hate their jobs. And I have a really challenging class this year too.

feelingdizzy · 16/03/2022 06:47

Sadly it is pretty bad I be been a teacher( primary ) deputy head and HT and have loved it (mostly) . But over the last few years things have got progressively worse . I've had enough I just don't want the stress anymore . I like working with the kids and am a good teacher but it consumes too much of my life . I'm out as soon as I can !!

springflowerss · 16/03/2022 06:46

I don’t work in the evenings but I am in work from 7:30-6. I live very close to work, though, so I still get a good evening.

I try not to work too much on the weekends and I often don’t. We are a 4 form entry and share the planning but the marking is about as heavy as it’s possible to be and we always have 8 million other things on. I also have subject leadership. It’s very, very busy but if you force yourself into a routine where you do everything as soon as it’s given to you and use every single tiny bit of time in the work day then it’s sort of doable.

I don’t think it’s the type of job you can go into unless you really love it, though. However I still think it’s an easier gig than hospitality.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 16/03/2022 06:39

Move to Ireland? We're crying out for teachers and there is nothing like the extra paperwork and long hours. Yes I have to do my planning etc but never work on a weekend or during our (longer?) holidays.

Sleepingonmyfeet · 16/03/2022 06:31

The biggest problem in teaching is the insecurity. You’re only one bad obs away from losing your job.

echt · 16/03/2022 06:10

@MarieG10

A friend on mine left teaching last year after 10 years. Described it as working every weekend and most nights. Wasn't helped by Covid but she said it was pretty much like it before.

She left and changed career and marvels now at spending weekends and evenings with the family. Like many, she has work she does at home but nothing like teaching.

She did admit that part of the problem is how teaching is structured in that teachers being pretty much term time workers, it isn't easy to spread the load out wider beyond the terms apart from those who are super organised and can plan lessons months ahead.

It sounds to be like the whole school terms and days need reviewing but in the meantime, I wouldn't be a teacher. She said those teachers that are shit, don't do the work required and don't care as there isn't much schools do to get rid of crap teachers. That is of course unless OFSTED arrive and they get an inadequate.

Teachers don't work term time. They work weekends and "holidays". none of which they are paid for.

Bollocks to not being able get shut of poor teachers. It's never been easier. I've never seen an effort to get rid of the shite that wasn't down to mismanagement by management.

Oh hang on...you're not a teacher, it's your friend Hmm

CheesecakeAddict · 16/03/2022 06:02

I think the mantra that the hard work is just for the first few years doesn't hold true. Yes, you get faster at planning, but I've been teaching 7 years and in that time my curriculum has completely changed three times. This means every couple of years, I am starting from scratch again.

The results of the pandemic has massively increased the number of students with MH issues. They need our love and support, and the school tell you this, but they also want you to get their predicted results despite all this and it's your fault if not. The school I'm at now is definitely one of the better ones, in that it will come up in my evaluation but I doubt it would hinder me. I know of lots of teacher friends who do not get their pay rise if at least a certain number of students don't get their predicted grade (based on a computer algorithm that was created in Yr7). Lots of year 7s have come up to use after 2 years of computer use during lockdown, unable to write properly. Which makes sense because the first lockdown would have been prime pen license time, which they never had to work for. A good chunk of the class have a reading age between 7 and 9 years old because they did no workover lockdown, which means they are struggling to access secondary text books, which means extra work on the teacher to differentiate.

There's a massive exodus of headteachers at the moment, this is going to massively change the dynamics of schools. And the retention and recruitment issues means that many kids are going years without a qualified teacher. Again, when you get hold of that class, you've got all those gaps to plug, so lessons you planned years ago aren't going to help.

I love working with the kids but if you want to do the job properly, the workload is massive and the hours are leading to teachers to burn out. The pay is a red herring because you start off well, earn just enough to get you a nice lifestyle, but the progress pay is tiny with frequent pay freezes.

Isaidno22 · 16/03/2022 05:48

I have been a teacher for 22 years. It is beyond dreadful, and I now work in a really good school. I don’t know anyone who doesn’t work weekends and evenings. We are officially paid for 30 hours a week which is pro rata over the year to cover holidays. We get 5 hours a fortnight ‘free’ to plan, prepare and assess which is the minimum that the government say we can do our job in. We are led by the donkeys in government who have no school experience. If your heart was in it, you’d have continued after your PGCE. TBH most schools would wonder why you didn’t continue and you may find it difficult to get employment.
Join the Facebook group ‘Exit Teaching and Thrive.’ This is a huge group with 54k members (which should tell you something) and has great advice on how to use your teaching skills in other areas. It’s run by 2 ex-teachers.

loopylindi · 16/03/2022 05:47

I taught for over 30yrs. Took early retirement (15yrs ago) and managed to get my pension with a 25% drop but it was worth it - or I would be in prison!! My last few years were awful and I know it hasn't got any better since. Lack of respect from students, parents and SLT. Shit, shit,shit. Work/life balance....forget it

Whattodoniw · 16/03/2022 05:41

@SoftwareDev

It's not as bad as you think - it's worse.

There is a reason hundreds of us are leaving the profession!

Yep
CrunchyCrump · 16/03/2022 05:39

@Cremeegg456 complete your NQT abroad, accommodation, flights, health insurance paid for and no tax (country dependent). Better work/life balance but you’ll still need to put work in for your first year or two resources wise and then you’re set. Students are on the whole so much better behaved abroad, teaching in the UK is horrific at the moment. Will give you a chance to save for a house deposit, although you might never want to return!

MarieG10 · 16/03/2022 05:35

A friend on mine left teaching last year after 10 years. Described it as working every weekend and most nights. Wasn't helped by Covid but she said it was pretty much like it before.

She left and changed career and marvels now at spending weekends and evenings with the family. Like many, she has work she does at home but nothing like teaching.

She did admit that part of the problem is how teaching is structured in that teachers being pretty much term time workers, it isn't easy to spread the load out wider beyond the terms apart from those who are super organised and can plan lessons months ahead.

It sounds to be like the whole school terms and days need reviewing but in the meantime, I wouldn't be a teacher. She said those teachers that are shit, don't do the work required and don't care as there isn't much schools do to get rid of crap teachers. That is of course unless OFSTED arrive and they get an inadequate.

malificent7 · 16/03/2022 05:32

Yes it is that bad and yes i left ages ago.

60Chevy · 16/03/2022 05:23

@WithRosesAroundTheDoor

A friend of mine was ranting about this the other day and it's just hitting me how right she is. The whole culture around teaching is wrong and really takes advantage of the emotional connection that we have with pupils. In no other job would you be expected to put in so much unpaid overtime. There are no other roles where you would be considered failing and put through capability without hours of unpaid overtime. It's so bloody wrong and is reliant on us being afraid to let the side down.
This post has hit the nail on the head. I got an unrealistic request relating to a timescale last night and it took every fibre of my being to not do it. Instead, I politely replied and explained my realistic timescale for completion, rather than just sitting up until gone midnight doing it, which is what I may have done two or three years ago. Thankfully it was fine, but it didn't stop me feeling pathetically guilty and like I'd let someone down, though.
60Chevy · 16/03/2022 05:17

Morning OP - I'm up now because I'm about to start some work. It's the only time of day I have any control over what I do, such is the unpredictability and volume of it all.

DP won't be up as early as me, but as a second in department, he was working until 9 last night. He's currently a mentor for an ECT and is angry at the unnecessary admin for the member of staff and feels it is a significant workload inconvenience at a time when they should be focusing on basics of pupil relationships, subject knowledge, classroom management and marking/feedback.

As a member of SLT I feel frustrated knowing there's only so much I can do to protect staff from the system. Less is getting done on time, more are going part time or taking early retirement, and it doesn't take a genius to work out why. Poor pupil behaviour, the expectation that schools will also be social workers/counsellors, parental demands, constant changing of goalposts, post-Covid recovery and the constant threat of Ofsted have made much of the job untenable. Of course, this has led to a recruitment crisis, but this in turn simply perpetuates all of the issues I've highlighted.

DP and I are (by choice) child free, so can mitigate long hours through a careful combination of deliberately blocking out time at weekends/holidays, lie-ins and lots of outdoor walks in the area we live, but I cannot imagine our lives if we had children. I would not recommend this profession to anyone right now. It is so poorly understood and valued.

PupInAPram · 16/03/2022 04:38

@maddy68

Actually you have to complete your induction within 4 terms of completing a pgce ((unless that has changed ) so sadly I don't think you can teach now
This is wrong. Out of date information.
Winter2020 · 16/03/2022 04:36

When my husband was a full time teacher (primary) the hours were incompatible we family life. We hardly saw him and led to stress/burn out.

He has been 3 days for years now and that is pretty good for family life. Long days on his three working days (He's in school 7:30 am until they close at 5:45) and a bit of work at home probably totalling another working day over the rest of his week. Hours in sync with school hols.

If you are happy earning 21k ish (after a few years) for 3 days it provides a nice work life balance.

You could dig deep for a full time post for a few years to get mortgage etc and then go part time when you have kids.

PulseFinger · 16/03/2022 04:28

I’ve taught for eight years and have just gone on maternity leave with my first baby, and it’s extremely unlikely I’ll be returning to the profession. I love teaching, I love my students, I’ve found this to be the most fulfilling career imaginable in so many ways (having done a number of other office-based/academic jobs before retraining in my 20s), but the hours are long, the extra demands on your time constant and unforgiving, and the job increasingly challenging in the face of a lack of trust between management and staff. Added to which, students need and deserve 100% commitment from you, and with the added pressure of behaviour/lack of mental health support/exams, etc. that means giving a lot of your time outside of the classroom, too. For me, it’s a choice between being the best teacher I can and being the best parent for my own child - working full time would mean being able to do neither, though many in my school do seem to manage by working extremely long hours in the evenings and weekends.

Unfortunately, in your position, you’ve missed the boat on completing your ECT years - not sure what the route forward would be if you wanted to get back into teaching, but if you’re determined not to work long hours for at least a few years, then I would say the profession is not for you. I’ve worked with and managed PGCE students/NQTs with a similar outlook and they haven’t lasted long.

SarahBellam · 16/03/2022 04:13

I have a teacher friend who’s always on Facebook talking about how hard she works and how tired she is, though I suspect she’s in the wrong job.

Mummy1608 · 16/03/2022 03:58

Teacher here, I work in an independent school, shortage subject. It is a doddle tbh a very cushy number. Don't be put off by all the naysayers - I've worked in a couple of dreadful schools and burnt out, but once you find a nice school that prioritises teacher well being, it's a really nice job. Also once you've been teaching a few years, you spend virtually no time planning. I only work late about once a month when there are reports, and I very rarely work weekends. I'm prt time now with a toddler but the same was true when I was FT before I had her

Mellowyellow222 · 16/03/2022 03:26

Speak to some teachers.

In my experience they are a fairly unhappy bunch. I have never come across a teacher who is happy with their job.