Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In this scenario, does it make sense to pay uni fees upfront?

135 replies

enseehammer · 15/03/2022 21:08

DC1 is heading to uni later this year, and DC2 will go in 2 years. I know the prevailing wisdom is that it's unwise to pay uni fees upfront - I've read the Martin Lewis advice on this. However, my mum died recently and I'm about to inherit a lump sum from the sale of her house. There is enough to pay off our own mortgage (when my current low fixed rate ends), and also cover uni fees for both DC's, rather than them taking out student finance and paying the above-inflation interest rate (at a time of rising inflation).

The alternative is to invest the money, either in a rental property or the stock market, in the hope that it grows. But rental yields are being squeezed, and the stock market could be a dangerous bet in these uncertain times - so I'm not sure that either option can be relied on to make a good enough return. (Yes, I know the stock market is generally a good bet in the long term, but if ww3 is about to begin, all bets are off!).

Another argument against paying upfront is that DCs may not have to pay back the full amount if they have a low income, but we live in London where wages are a lot higher than average, and the DC's are both wanting to go into high earning jobs after graduating, so I think its most likely they will both pay back the full amount and a lot more besides.

Aibu to think paying the fees upfront might be a good bet in this scenario?

OP posts:
enseehammer · 16/03/2022 08:34

@Bagelsandbrie

We were in this position and chose not to. Mainly because it encourages dc to work for their degree as they see it as their own investment which I think is really important. It’s very easy to not take it so seriously when it’s someone else’s money you’re spending (and yes I know it’s still someone else’s money if it’s a government loan etc but you pay it back rather than inherit it).
Yes, this is a persuasive argument.
OP posts:
enseehammer · 16/03/2022 08:33

Do you invest at all yourself currently? We have been investing for 25+yrs, so have seen a number of peaks and troughs over that time, but we have still made huge gains overall.

Only small amounts. I know that rises happen over time, but investing a lump sum in uncertain economic times is a different beast to drip-feeding into an isa over time. If Nato enters the conflict a lump sum could easily make a big loss that would take many years to recover, and may not recover in time for when it is needed. Your current losses are only bearable because you've got several years of growth behind you.

OP posts:
Bagelsandbrie · 16/03/2022 08:28

We were in this position and chose not to. Mainly because it encourages dc to work for their degree as they see it as their own investment which I think is really important. It’s very easy to not take it so seriously when it’s someone else’s money you’re spending (and yes I know it’s still someone else’s money if it’s a government loan etc but you pay it back rather than inherit it).

BertiesShoes · 16/03/2022 08:07

We had this exact position, but in our case the inheritance had gone straight to children from a distant relative, just under 100k.

We never contemplated DS using it for his fees/loan, but instead he has drip fed it monthly into a S&S ISA and LISA, across a number of funds to lessen the risk.

Over the 6 yrs since he got it (at 18, now 24) his investments had gone up 50% to start of this year. Yes they have dropped in the last few weeks, but still gained 35% plus.

He is in yr 2 of a grad job, earning a few K over the starting salary for repayments. He currently pays a few pounds monthly to his student loan. He has another job offer that will pay ~10k more, so that will rise but…. he is also relocating (based at home currently) and knows that he will be able to buy a house, with his invested inheritance providing a large deposit. Yes, that deposit will be lower than it was a few weeks ago, but still allow him onto housing market with a low mortgage, and save him paying out rent for years.

Do you invest at all yourself currently? We have been investing for 25+yrs, so have seen a number of peaks and troughs over that time, but we have still made huge gains overall.

I think the general advise from Martin Lewis is - if you can afford to pay both fees and a house deposit, then do it. Otherwise, save your money for house deposit.

WorkingItOutAsIGo · 16/03/2022 08:07

I did pay most upfront but deliberately made sure my DC took out some loan as I wanted them to be properly aware of the value of money, and knowing they had to pay it back was an important litmus test for their decision to spend or not spend. It’s all too easy to waste money if they feel it’s free. But my DC did expect they would be earning enough to pay it back anyway, so it definitely made sense.

AngelinaFibres · 16/03/2022 08:05

@mocktail

Get them to go to the same uni. Buy a house that they can live in and be in charge of renting the other rooms to pay for upkeep, bills, cash.

Does anyone really "get" their adult children to go to the same uni?! And share a house together? 😆

Ridiculous idea
AngelinaFibres · 16/03/2022 08:02

@bakebeans

Definitely not! have you looked how much they would need to pay back monthly? It’s relatively low amount and is not taken into account when obtaining a mortgage or financial agreement .
This. Plus you have absolutely no idea what jobs they will get. Once they get to university they may feel it is not for them. If they actually graduate they may go off travelling for years. They may decide to go into a job that is worthy but low paying ,in which case they will never pay any of it back. My NDN did the whole private school,Oxford route. He got a first. He now works at a care farm up the road, teaching children with school attendance difficulties and emotional problems. His parents and sister are London lawyers. He was supposed to be one. Once he got to University and met people with different views and different lives he went down a different path.
enseehammer · 16/03/2022 07:59

You can only put £4k a year into a LISA, so its good for regular savings, and worth doing, but only scratches the surface.

OP posts:
enseehammer · 16/03/2022 07:52

@enseehammer

I think investment ISA's and LISA's are great for regular investing (which spreads the risk) or small lump sums, but to put a large one-off lump sum at risk in very uncertain economic times is a more difficult prospect. Only a relatively small part of it can be invested tax free, which means gains would need to beat inflation + x% after tax.
Where x depends on income, but is 3% from £49k, again, not a high wage in London.
OP posts:
HardbackWriter · 16/03/2022 07:47

I would absolutely save it for deposits - even if that means it loses a little of its value because you can't find a way to invest that beats inflation. Looking at my friends the student loans repayments have had a fairly minor impact (you just get used to it from the off so it's not money you miss) but whether or not they had parental help with buying a property has made an enormous difference, in that it's pretty much the determining fact in whether or not they own - even the high earners. If you had the money to do both then I can see the argument for paying the fees but if it's either/or I'd go for the deposit every time.

Bunnycat101 · 16/03/2022 07:36

enseehammer You could get it sheltered by putting in some this tax year and some next: if you didn’t want to buy stocks and shares, it could be in a Stocks and shares ISA in cash until you’re ready to invest or put some in premium bonds.

PiccoloMaud · 16/03/2022 07:30

As someone in their late 20s with 2x student loans, I would have found money set aside for a significant deposit much more useful than not making SFE repayments each month. If they are going to be high earners and living in London, they will need a significant deposit to purchase property that their salaries could afford them.

enseehammer · 16/03/2022 07:27

I think investment ISA's and LISA's are great for regular investing (which spreads the risk) or small lump sums, but to put a large one-off lump sum at risk in very uncertain economic times is a more difficult prospect. Only a relatively small part of it can be invested tax free, which means gains would need to beat inflation + x% after tax.

OP posts:
ShipwreckSunset · 16/03/2022 07:21

I agree that the £27k threshold seems very close in compared to the typical graduate starting salary for professional jobs, and likewise think a lot of people will therefore pay off the whole cost plus interest. I know there is more to uni than earning a high salary, but I would expect graduates going into professional jobs to be earning this quite quickly and therefore be saddled with loan repayments plus a relatively high rate of interest.

enseehammer · 16/03/2022 06:34

@fallfallfall

speak to an advisor (but remember how they get paid...they make money on you investing with them). my dh and i paid over time (x amount spread over the 12 months vs 8 or what ever uni consists of). while a chunk stayed in the bank invested (so we drew down monthly on invested money). for lots of reasons it was the right thing for us to do. does it make sense? it did to us and that's all that matters. btw all three of the kids were very grateful that they left school with no debt.
I did speak to an advisor. They gave the prevailing view that the stock market is likely to outperform anything else over time. But that was before Russia invaded Ukraine. I think we're in uncharted waters now. Inflation is also high, and the minimum wage for paying back the loan is not rising with it. It's currently £27k which is a fairly typical graduate starting salary in London. If your wages rise quickly there's a point at which you end up paying back much more than you ever borrowed. I know there's a calculator for all this stuff on MSE, but once DS has flown the nest, I doubt he will discuss his finances with me at all, never mind inform me of his annual pay rises.
OP posts:
BasiliskStare · 16/03/2022 05:33

I agree that if you are not going to have a highly paid job the loans stack up because you will never pay them back.

I am like @mjf981 & if you think DCs will be somewhere in the middle - being debt free could be a good thing - but again I say Martin Lewis I believe ( well certainly used to ) has a table which shows what earningsvs loan repayments make sense

Of course it only works if you are able to pay the fees / accommodation etc. & dependent on what kind of a deposit would make a meaningful difference. Personally I would never encourage all DCs to go to the same university because you could buy a flat for them - for a number of reasons

But everyone needs to make their own choices.

mjf981 · 16/03/2022 05:08

I'd pay the uni fees. Not having that debt around their neck when starting out in life would be great. And I don't think now is the time to be 'investing' in property. But I'm risk averse, and value being debt free.

Bunnycat101 · 16/03/2022 04:34

I would invest the money as house deposits. Now is potentially a good time but given losses in the stock market.

Having a lump sum is so valuable. On 50k they’d be paying around £2k a year for the loan. If that money was diverted to saving for a deposit it would take 13 years to save the equivalent lump sum of £27k. There is a value in and of itself of having a lump sum.

I wouldn’t buy a flat for students to live in. Halls is good fun and the second should be able to choose what university is best for them and not feel guilt tripped into following the first because of a property. The period would be too short for safe investing as well.

Usingit · 16/03/2022 04:26

I just see, high earning jobs so I would probably pay it especially with the new rules. We didn't as DS is on plan 1 (pre 2012 so his loan is a lot lower).

Usingit · 16/03/2022 04:21

Depends what sort of career they are likely to have, not all graduate jobs pay loads, if it's at the low end they may not pay much back.

fallfallfall · 16/03/2022 03:39

speak to an advisor (but remember how they get paid...they make money on you investing with them).
my dh and i paid over time (x amount spread over the 12 months vs 8 or what ever uni consists of). while a chunk stayed in the bank invested (so we drew down monthly on invested money).
for lots of reasons it was the right thing for us to do. does it make sense? it did to us and that's all that matters.
btw all three of the kids were very grateful that they left school with no debt.

Movingonup22 · 16/03/2022 03:09

In the meantime buy the investment property now? If you buy in your name you would have to pay stamp duty or sell and cgt when they want the money - but I’m sure there is a way of putting it in their name on trust if they’re under 18?

BasiliskStare · 16/03/2022 03:07

We paid eldest DC university fees. The money would not be enough to buy a flat and we weren't in a position to take out a second mortgage, I know the prevailing wisdom is to take out the loans but if DCs may get job which is higher paying I think it isn't a bad idea - I think Martin Lewis has a post where he works out what a DC has to earn where up front payments are OK or not. The other thing is - which I recognise is not necessarily the right thing to look at it - if you can afford to let your DC leave university without that debt - is that something worth having ? Probably more psychological than financial

Saracen · 16/03/2022 02:08

A tricky point is that the answer could be different for DC1 than for DC2. DC1's loan will be written off after 30 years, and unless they're a high earner, they won't have come close to paying it all back by then. So taking the loan makes sense.

The rules will change for new starters from autumn 2023. DC2 has to pay for 40 years. There's a much greater chance they will end up paying it all. That extra decade (what's more, a decade which is nearer the end of their working life, when they'll probably be a higher earner than they were when young) make a huge huge difference to the total outlay.

MurmuratingStarling · 15/03/2022 23:40

60 OR 70 grand (not 60 of 70!)