Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In this scenario, does it make sense to pay uni fees upfront?

135 replies

enseehammer · 15/03/2022 21:08

DC1 is heading to uni later this year, and DC2 will go in 2 years. I know the prevailing wisdom is that it's unwise to pay uni fees upfront - I've read the Martin Lewis advice on this. However, my mum died recently and I'm about to inherit a lump sum from the sale of her house. There is enough to pay off our own mortgage (when my current low fixed rate ends), and also cover uni fees for both DC's, rather than them taking out student finance and paying the above-inflation interest rate (at a time of rising inflation).

The alternative is to invest the money, either in a rental property or the stock market, in the hope that it grows. But rental yields are being squeezed, and the stock market could be a dangerous bet in these uncertain times - so I'm not sure that either option can be relied on to make a good enough return. (Yes, I know the stock market is generally a good bet in the long term, but if ww3 is about to begin, all bets are off!).

Another argument against paying upfront is that DCs may not have to pay back the full amount if they have a low income, but we live in London where wages are a lot higher than average, and the DC's are both wanting to go into high earning jobs after graduating, so I think its most likely they will both pay back the full amount and a lot more besides.

Aibu to think paying the fees upfront might be a good bet in this scenario?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 16/03/2022 16:06

The only issue would be tax @jb7445. You pay tax on rental income. Whereas buying a student house would mean they could live rent free and let a room to another student for £7k tax free.

jb7445 · 16/03/2022 15:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

HardbackWriter · 16/03/2022 15:53

I think you're seriously overestimating how low-paid you have to be to not pay off your student loan, @MurmuratingStarling - the current estimate is that 81% won't. Lots of those will be working in graduate professions (nursing, teaching, social workers - are these people that lack ambition and should never have gone to university?). It's not like you have to get a job scrubbing toilets to not pay back your student loan as you seem to assume.

LittleGwyneth · 16/03/2022 15:47

Absolutely not. Student debt is the 'best' debt you can get. Lots of wealthy people get their kids to take out a student loan and then invest it for them as a way to make some money. Also you never know what might happen, they might hate university or want to transfer to another one, just so much better not to commit it all up front.

Blossomtoes · 16/03/2022 15:37

And if people are not 'motivated by money' then why not get a basic, minimum pay job? Why spend 3 years at university, accruing, masses of debt, if you aren't arsed about earning much?

Because you want to expand your mind, learn interesting stuff, be a well educated rounded person. You may want to do a badly paid job for which a degree is essential - most academics are poorly paid.

MurmuratingStarling · 16/03/2022 15:32

And you don't need a degree for just about ANY job these days. That's nonsense!

MurmuratingStarling · 16/03/2022 15:32

@Blossomtoes

WTF is the point in borrowing potentially £50,000 of public, taxpayers money, to get a University degree, just to go get a job that you could do with no higher education?!

Because you wouldn’t get those jobs without a degree. It’s pretty much a minimum requirement to get just about any job these days. Particularly if you work in the public sector, the starting salary for nurses and paramedics is well below the threshold but you need a degree for those jobs.

You’re also assuming that everyone is motivated by money. They’re not.

You're missing the point. Some people on here are cheerily announcing how their adult DC is in a basic bog standard job that they would never have needed a degree for. And they are happy with that.

So they have borrowed £50,000 of public/taxpayers money, for fuck-all, and they will never pay any of it back, (or very little anyway!) It's almost like some people only went for the 'university experience,' for the fun and games of being at uni, and 3 extra years of not having to live in the real world. Hmm

And if people are not 'motivated by money' then why not get a basic, minimum pay job? Why spend 3 years at university, accruing, masses of debt, if you aren't arsed about earning much? Yeah, some jobs require degrees, but not the basic bog standard jobs some posters are on about. We're not talking paramedics/nurses/police etc.

But you probably knew that.

Blossomtoes · 16/03/2022 15:21

WTF is the point in borrowing potentially £50,000 of public, taxpayers money, to get a University degree, just to go get a job that you could do with no higher education?!

Because you wouldn’t get those jobs without a degree. It’s pretty much a minimum requirement to get just about any job these days. Particularly if you work in the public sector, the starting salary for nurses and paramedics is well below the threshold but you need a degree for those jobs.

You’re also assuming that everyone is motivated by money. They’re not.

Movingonup22 · 16/03/2022 15:16

@jeanne16 the main point is that she can probably get a better return investing somewhere else - and in particular using it got get them a property if that’s a feasible option

Blossomtoes · 16/03/2022 15:05

It’ll be like a monthly gift to them from their grandmother every month for the whole of their working life

And get frittered away without them noticing it. Buy somewhere for them to live while they’re at uni and sell it for a deposit on a house when they graduate.

They might well assume they’re going to get very highly paid jobs but it might well not turn out that way. You plan and God laughs.

MurmuratingStarling · 16/03/2022 14:58

@AngelinaFibres

You have absolutely no idea what jobs they will get. Once they get to university they may feel it is not for them. If they actually graduate they may go off travelling for years.

They may decide to go into a job that is worthy but low paying ,in which case they will never pay any of it back. My NDN did the whole private school, Oxford route. He got a first.

He now works at a care farm up the road, teaching children with school attendance difficulties and emotional problems. His parents and sister are London lawyers. He was supposed to be one. Once he got to University and met people with different views and different lives he went down a different path.

What a HIDEOUS waste of time and public money. Confused

Why are some people on here celebrating the fact that after completing a University degree, their adult DC (or some adult DC they know,) are on such low salaries, with such basic, bog standard jobs, (that you probably only need GSCEs for,) that they will pay hardly anything back? That's nothing to be celebrating!

It's like a race to the bottom. Hmm WTF is the point in borrowing potentially £50,000 of public, taxpayers money, to get a University degree, just to go get a job that you could do with no higher education?!

Like a few pps, I absolutely WOULD be paying off my DC's student/uni debt. Who wants a life with £50,000 hanging around your neck, that you know you will have til you retire, and will be paying for til you retire. Unless of course, you pick some bog standard low-tier job so you don't have to pay anything back! In which case, what the fuck was the point of doing a University degree in the first place?! Hmm

MurmuratingStarling · 16/03/2022 14:58

Oops posted twice!

MurmuratingStarling · 16/03/2022 14:57

@jeanne16

I also find it astonishing when people say it’s just a graduate tax so it doesn’t matter. I don’t know anyone who would be happy to pay an extra 9% tax.

I agree that if you never intend to work or earn much, then take the loan. However to pay an extra 9% over the 27k threshold for 30 years (increasing to 40), is a massive millstone. It will affect your take home money particularly in your 30s when mortgages and childcare costs will be onerous too.

This. ^
MurmuratingStarling · 16/03/2022 14:57

@jeanne16

I also find it astonishing when people say it’s just a graduate tax so it doesn’t matter. I don’t know anyone who would be happy to pay an extra 9% tax.

I agree that if you never intend to work or earn much, then take the loan. However to pay an extra 9% over the 27k threshold for 30 years (increasing to 40), is a massive millstone. It will affect your take home money particularly in your 30s when mortgages and childcare costs will be onerous too.

This ^
jeanne16 · 16/03/2022 11:41

I also find it astonishing when people say it’s just a graduate tax so it doesn’t matter. I don’t know anyone who would be happy to pay an extra 9% tax.

I agree that if you never intend to work or earn much, then take the loan. However to pay an extra 9% over the 27k threshold for 30 years (increasing to 40), is a massive millstone. It will affect your take home money particularly in your 30s when mortgages and childcare costs will be onerous too.

Lazypuppy · 16/03/2022 11:26

@TrippinEdBalls ok, well the people i know do moan about it. I think they kind of forgot about student loan, thought it would be a really small amount, when in reality it isn't,and they just look at is as something else they have to pay back, which if they had done it differently they wouldn't have to. Everyone knows you have to pay tax and NI, but paying another thing out just reduces your take home pay even more.

I just think why take out a loan at high interest rate that OPs children don't need to?

Avocadobacardi · 16/03/2022 09:26

@Bagelsandbrie 100% agree with you. This x 100

TrippinEdBalls · 16/03/2022 08:53

@Lazypuppy

I would and did avoid student loans,and my colleagues when i started work all moan about having to pay their student loan back every month, not seeing all of theit bonus/payrises etc. I have no student debt, and its great!
I honestly have never heard anyone moan specifically about their student loan - it comes out of your paycheck alongside tax and NI and they're both much bigger chunks. I've never heard people single out the student loan as why they're not getting to keep all 'their' money.
BertiesShoes · 16/03/2022 08:46

@TheBigDilemma

You have your figures wrong, 20k is total for S&S ISA and LISA, but the LISA is 4K max, plus another 1k from govt, so 5k total. The other 16k can go into a normal ISA, but with no govt top-up.

Lazypuppy · 16/03/2022 08:43

I would and did avoid student loans,and my colleagues when i started work all moan about having to pay their student loan back every month, not seeing all of theit bonus/payrises etc. I have no student debt, and its great!

BertiesShoes · 16/03/2022 08:43

If Nato enters the conflict a lump sum could easily make a big loss that would take many years to recover

But you don’t need to invest a lump sum? We have always drip fed monthly, both our money (including inheritances and windfalls) and the kids inheritances. We have usually kept the current years ISA allowance in an instant access ac, with remainder of lump sum invested in the highest paying savings ac available, usually notice accounts, so 1/2/3 yr notice ac.

Many people advise Premium Bonds to hold cash too.

gogohm · 16/03/2022 08:40

I would consider paying it off after they graduate. We did pay up front, dd dropped out and she couldn't get a loan for her second degree despite not claiming student finance. Once they graduate and aren't doing a masters or PhD that needs funding you can clear their debts

Bunnycat101 · 16/03/2022 08:39

“You can only put £4k a year into a LISA, so its good for regular savings, and worth doing, but only scratches the surface.”

But you can have a Lisa and an isa. I’d put £4k in now and another £4k in April and open a S&S isa in parallel and transfer into a Lisa each year.

TheBigDilemma · 16/03/2022 08:37

@enseehammer

You can only put £4k a year into a LISA, so its good for regular savings, and worth doing, but only scratches the surface.
No, you can get up £4000 a year from the government (25%) if you put the money into a LISA, as far as I remember you can put up to £20,000 a year which is a good starting point, you then can wait to the end of the year (or later) before investing if you are wary about the markets at this time.
BertiesShoes · 16/03/2022 08:34

The thing is Op, as a pp pointed out, you have no idea what careers your DC will do, or where! They may hate uni and drop out, may decide on lower paid roles, there is a lot of water under bridge between now and when they start their careers.

My DC had a career in mind at 17, completely changed his mind to a niche role at 18, at its top it pays well over £100k, but money wasn’t his driver, the role is. He had a Yr In industry job in the company providing that service in UK. He went back to uni planning to apply for the role the following summer, after he graduated.

6 mths into final year, along came COVID and decimated that industry. He took a job in a different industry. The new job he has just been offered will be within his preferred industry but still not the niche role that he has aimed for since 18, as it is not yet recruiting again.

It is interesting looking at his school cohort at 24. Some, whom I thought would be high fliers, have done nothing, others have done more than expected.