Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In this scenario, does it make sense to pay uni fees upfront?

135 replies

enseehammer · 15/03/2022 21:08

DC1 is heading to uni later this year, and DC2 will go in 2 years. I know the prevailing wisdom is that it's unwise to pay uni fees upfront - I've read the Martin Lewis advice on this. However, my mum died recently and I'm about to inherit a lump sum from the sale of her house. There is enough to pay off our own mortgage (when my current low fixed rate ends), and also cover uni fees for both DC's, rather than them taking out student finance and paying the above-inflation interest rate (at a time of rising inflation).

The alternative is to invest the money, either in a rental property or the stock market, in the hope that it grows. But rental yields are being squeezed, and the stock market could be a dangerous bet in these uncertain times - so I'm not sure that either option can be relied on to make a good enough return. (Yes, I know the stock market is generally a good bet in the long term, but if ww3 is about to begin, all bets are off!).

Another argument against paying upfront is that DCs may not have to pay back the full amount if they have a low income, but we live in London where wages are a lot higher than average, and the DC's are both wanting to go into high earning jobs after graduating, so I think its most likely they will both pay back the full amount and a lot more besides.

Aibu to think paying the fees upfront might be a good bet in this scenario?

OP posts:
fluffedup · 16/03/2022 19:29

@MurmuratingStarling

I agree with you. All those parameters (interest, length of payment, minimum amount earned) can be changed by the government. And why does it have to be a greater rate of interest than a mortgage? It's not like the graduate can escape paying it. Young people are signing up for this because they think they won't be screwed. I don't have that faith.

And it's a terrifying amount of debt. And unlike buying a house, you can't sell the house to pay it off. I am advising my children to go for degree apprenticeships unless they want a career that requires a degree and no substitute would do, and only then if it is a relatively well paid career.

WombatChocolate · 16/03/2022 18:06

It depends…..like most things.

If you have plenty plenty of cash and can afford to pay your kids’ fees and help them get on the housing ladder….great, do both.

If you can’t do both, which is ‘best’ probably partly depends on where they might live.

Lots of graduates in LOndon and the south-east and elsewhere too find it very very difficult to get on the housing ladder, even with good graduate jobs. Even if their fees have been paid off, many will still struggle to accumulate the size of deposit necessary. This is becaue rents are high and saving is difficult ….regardless of student loan payments. By the time they are 30 many won’t have accumulated enough if they have to do it fully on their own.

What about with parental help? Well £30-60k won’t buy a house outright these days. In LOndon, the upper end might only provide 10% deposit on a £600k property….but the key point is that £30k-£60k with whatever they have saved up and a graduate job (especially with 2 earners) will be enough to get something. It won’t stretch to the £600k flat becaue earnings for most still still won’t be high enough, but it will be a big help in buying a property for £250k-£300k and you can get this everywhere. In some areas that’s a 1 bed flat and in others it’s a decent sized house. And crucially, it’s being on the property ladder which might not have been possible without the help, even with a big salary and no student debt.

If you can give the £60k of fees and then you can give your kid another £100k towards property, well fine…do both. But lots can’t do both. Most are pleased to do one or part of one and offer £20k or £10k or whatever they can afford. It’s all a help.

In the end, to get property you HAVE to have the deposit and the earning power. Parents can help with the former. Many people without that parental help have ZERO other way to get on the ladder.
To get a degree, you have to fund it and there are loans available.

To me, it seems there is one available to all and there is help outside of parental spheres. The other (property) will always needs a deposit. That’s where people all down and that’s wheee parents can help. For most, it will be the best use of the money. That could be property bought (with a mortgage) for a student or a deposit given later.

Lots of graduates will never be big earners. They will be solid earners. If their parents help them buy at 30 and avoid another 10-30 years of rent, they’ve done them a huge favour. Having had their fees paid off means they could still be renting in their 40s…and that’s a greater millstone round the neck.

EmpressCixi · 16/03/2022 17:48

From Intergenerational Foundation:
www.if.org.uk/2022/02/25/regressive-student-finance-plans-will-punish-low-and-middle-earners-the-most/

“For example, a graduate who earns a starting salary of £30,000 will see their lifetime student loan repayments increase from £29,000 under the current system to £68,000 under the new system, using the following assumptions: 3% annual pay increase; a repayment threshold increase of 2% annually; 3% RPI; and a student loan debt of £45,000 at the time of graduating.

Under the same assumptions, someone with a starting salary of £50,000 would have their lifetime repayments almost halved under the new system, from £109,630 under the current system to £61,743 after the reforms.”

£30k is slightly below average U.K. wage of £31k....so a middle earner will pay back more than they borrowed and thousands more than a high earner over their working life.

And we know that if you take out full tuition (£9,250) and full maintenance (£9,706 outside London to £12,667 inside London) loans your debt will closer to £60k not the £45k in the example and with the interest, you’ll be paying back much more than the above. Especially since tuition won’t be frozen forever. It will start to increase at some point in near future.

Blossomtoes · 16/03/2022 17:41

Maybe you @Blossomtoes should stop watching The Martin Lewis Money Show

Never watched it in my life 😂

BlueRabbitWasNaughty · 16/03/2022 17:39

Another one to go against the grain.... if you can afford it, why wouldn't you pay their tuition fees? The rules have changed and many will pay it back (plus much more) so if you expect them to be high earners, and not even that high, it will save them an absolute fortune.

My ds (going to Uni in September) has just had a talk today on student finance. He's come home saying 'can we pay the fees and he will pay us back?' Interest (at a high rate) starts accruing as soon as you take the loan so it builds up quickly.... many may never pay it back but plenty will pay much more back than the original amount borrowed.

EmpressCixi · 16/03/2022 17:37

We will be paying the uni fees and living costs up front. House deposit they can save for once working. There are so many schemes to help first time buyers and owning a house isn’t the end all and be all. Prior generations of my family never could own but always rented their entire lives. It’s not a necessity to own a home.

The student loans are debt and every few years the government changes the rules to cause graduates to pay more. This is in the T&Cs that they can actually do this to current students and graduates....so you can’t assume the loan repayment terms will be the same ten, twenty years after you borrowed the money.

The interest is eye wateringly high the repayment threshold is being lowered to £25k from £27k...which is actually lower than the average wage in the U.K. of £31k. They want lower earners to pay back more. Probably because there is clear evidence of abuse of the system of people going to Uni and then deliberately taking BS low skill jobs to avoid repayments. The taxpayer is investing in students to gain skills to benefit society..not to work at Tesco’s and claim UC.

The loss of 9% on all earnings over the threshold will hamper their ability to save for retirement.

Middle earners are actually hit hardest by the student loan as they end up paying far more than they borrowed and more in total than high earners as high earners higher payments pay off the loan well before the full 30/40yrs. Middle earners often don’t quite pay off the loan in full due to the interest constantly accruing, but they pay the most in total and for the full 30/40 years. And most graduates go on to be middle earners...not low or high earners.

MurmuratingStarling · 16/03/2022 17:37

And no-one HAS to accept my financial advice. I will do what's best for my DC - if others don't want to, that's their choice. Giving them less than a fifth towards a house, (as a deposit) is no WAY as good or helpful as paying off their entire student debt.

As for Martin Lewis saying 'do not pay the student debt off' well HIS advice has been prove to be less than brilliant recently. Maybe you @Blossomtoes should stop watching The Martin Lewis Money Show. Same advice to a few others here.

WombatChocolate · 16/03/2022 17:34

The thing that strikes me, is that so many people advise OP to invest the money or buy property.

Doing either of these things requires a level of financial confidence and knowledge that lots don’t have or don’t want the burden of. Many have never invested before and fear the value of their investment dropping drastically. Others have never had a buy to let and worry about rogue tenants, high taxes on sale and other legislation to fall foul of. So these alternatives for the money are not simple alternative money-makers for the average person.

Personally, I’m putting away the full fees of as close as possible. We will take the loans and we will the. Be reserving judgement and seeing how things turns out. At some point in late 20s or early 30s it is likely DC will want to buy property. By that stage we will have an idea of their careers and if they are buying with another person or solo. We will also know if they are on a trajectory to high earnings or it’s unlikely. This will inform whether we choose to pay off the loans for them at that point or give the decent deposit. This will be a conversation to be had with them and in light of their financial situation. But there will be a sizeable gift of perhaps £60k for each DC at some point and possibly more if any grandparents leave them money. It might be that they have a wealthy spouse by then who earns well and doesn’t really neeed our £60k towards their house and it’s better used to end the student loan. It could be that by then they have inheritance money or other stuff. By late 20s the picture for many is becoming clearer and a more informed decision about what to do with the cash can be made. At 18, who really knows the future - there are so many unknowns.

This £60k - it’s lovely, but it’s not going to buy them a flat in London, or even provide a really hefty deposit. But of course it would take most 20s a good while to save £60k. In other parts of the country it’s going to be a big help.

What I read with most interest is the comments from those a few years on, in their late 20s and early 30s. Most of them point to the difference getting family help onto the property ladder makes. I think it’s a key point. Yes, in your 30s student loans bite hard when you’re already paying childcare, facing new and big mortgages….but if you’re on the property ladder, you can usually weather that. It’s those who have kids and still haven’t got on the property ladder and have no chance if of accumulating a deposit so they can buy pretty much anywhere that have the real problem. The decent parental contribution to housing (instead of Uni fees - because most won’t be able to do both) seems to be the thing which makes the biggest practical on the ground difference, at the point it matters most.

Perhaps the ultimate thing isn’t the cost of the loan. Those compound interest rates look bad and of course no-one wants to think about them. But the thing that matters for most is being able to live your life and do the things you want to and need to, when you need to. The degree sets the career off. The housing gives you stability. People need both.

MurmuratingStarling · 16/03/2022 17:33

@Blossomtoes

And you pay back more than you owe - because of interest! So you will end up paying back way more than you borrowed!

Like when you buy a house.

It's not even REMOTELY the same. WTF are you on about?

It’s precisely the same. You borrow £x and you pay interest on it in both cases. If you’re seriously unable to see that, there’s no hope for you and nobody with any sense would accept your financial advice.

There's no hope for YOU. It makes FAR more sense to pay off the student debt for your DC. What's the point in them having £40K paid of a house (that will probably be £150K plus anyway,, so they will STILL have over £100K mortgage,) when they have the £50,000 DEBT hanging over them for LIFE. And the more they earn, the more of this debt they pay. And the interest on this £50,000 DEBT could make it many 1000s more.

Can't believe you don't see this. Confused

LunaNova · 16/03/2022 17:22

Also another thing to consider is would it come with conditions to pay off the debt - would you feel cheated if one of your children decided not to go (or to stay) at uni or what if they moved somewhere else in the country with lower wage expectations?

I'm definitely projecting here but I hated university, hated my course, hated being away from home. It was easy for me to make the decision to leave because noone else had "staked" money on me as an investment - if my parents had given me money for that purpose I would have felt obligated to stay and get a career in that field. For me, it would have been a lot of misery. (I'd just like to point out my parents are the chillest and wouldn't have judged me anyway but I'm that kind of anxious person that I would put that pressure on myself).

Only you know yourself and your children and how this will impact on you/them.

Movingonup22 · 16/03/2022 17:22

Cripes there are people on here who don’t understand the basics of leverage

Blossomtoes · 16/03/2022 17:20

And you pay back more than you owe - because of interest! So you will end up paying back way more than you borrowed!

Like when you buy a house.

It's not even REMOTELY the same. WTF are you on about?

It’s precisely the same. You borrow £x and you pay interest on it in both cases. If you’re seriously unable to see that, there’s no hope for you and nobody with any sense would accept your financial advice.

notagain29 · 16/03/2022 17:19

Are you just talking about the tuition fee loan or also about the maintenance loan/parental contribution.

MurmuratingStarling · 16/03/2022 17:16

@NeedleNoodle3

I inherited 100k a year ago and it didn’t even cross my mind to clear my DC’s uni debts. I’ve put money in stocks and shares isa’s for a deposit on a property for each of them.
Oh dear. Sad
MurmuratingStarling · 16/03/2022 17:15

@Blossomtoes

And you pay back more than you owe - because of interest! So you will end up paying back way more than you borrowed!

Like when you buy a house.

I would do it in a heartbeat if I came into a six figure sum. Or even just 70 or 80 grand

Even though they’d gain far more financially by having it as a house deposit?

murmuratingstarling

And you pay back more than you owe - because of interest! So you will end up paying back way more than you borrowed!

@blossomtoes

Like when you buy a house.

It's not even REMOTELY the same. WTF are you on about? Confused

@Blossomtoes

Even though they’d gain far more financially by having it as a house deposit?

Says who? You don't know that. You're just assuming.

You're just being deliberately obtuse now.

Pretty telling that you would let your DC wallow in debt though, whilst you galivanted around with your 10s of 1000s of £££.

NeedleNoodle3 · 16/03/2022 17:06

I inherited 100k a year ago and it didn’t even cross my mind to clear my DC’s uni debts. I’ve put money in stocks and shares isa’s for a deposit on a property for each of them.

Blossomtoes · 16/03/2022 17:05

And you pay back more than you owe - because of interest! So you will end up paying back way more than you borrowed!

Like when you buy a house.

I would do it in a heartbeat if I came into a six figure sum. Or even just 70 or 80 grand

Even though they’d gain far more financially by having it as a house deposit?

MurmuratingStarling · 16/03/2022 16:58

[quote fallfallfall]@LittleGwyneth, debt is debt there is no "good" debt.
it is still on the books and hanging over your head.
wealthy individuals access accountants and take advantage of laws and regulations in such a way that benefits them but they also pay their bills. and a student loan is a bill.[/quote]
This. There is no such thing as GOOD debt. As I said, who the F wants £50,000 of DEBT hanging over them for 40 years/virtually until they retire? And you pay back more than you owe - because of interest! So you will end up paying back way more than you borrowed!

And a new government could bring in new rules at any time (or the existing government even.) They have changed the rules enough before, and done dozens of U-turns. They could change the % you pay after £27,000 (or whatever they decide,) from 9% to 12% or 15%, or more, any time they wish. They make the rules.

The fact that someone would have a 6 figure sum to spare, and would not pay off their adult DC's £50,000 student debt out of it, boggles my mind. I would do it in a heartbeat if I came into a six figure sum. Or even just 70 or 80 grand.

I feel massively for the younger generation who have these monstrous debts, and Martin Lewis can say whatever he F he wants, I would absolutely be paying my DD's uni debts.

Me and DH have ZERO debt, apart from £45 on a catalogue, £125 on a credit card, and £80 on an Argos card. We also have some savings, so it's not debt really, as we could pay it off tomorrow. We are mortgage free too.

We have been in debt before (some years ago,) quite a high amount actually, and it's HORRIBLE being in debt. (I mean like, thousands!) You never really sleep properly at night, and you never fully relax. Never been happier since we have been totally debt free.

LunaNova · 16/03/2022 16:58

One thing I would factor in when thinking about this would be the differences in rental prices to mortgage costs (although noone can predict the future).

I have a student loan from one year at university (I dropped out because I hated my course - I then did an open university degree which I self funded by working full time at the same time) and I consider it a small amount that I pay back on a monthly basis (I'm on the old rules of £15k and over I pay and I earn considerably more than that - in a field I did not do my degree in and instead have done further studying). For me, especially in the area where I live, my parents giving me some money towards a house deposit was far more beneficial, in terms of my starter home I would have been looking at an increase of 50% of my monthly mortgage payment to rent a house like that, in terms of my current house the rental cost would be 150% higher than my mortgage. I "save" a lot more on a monthly basis by being a homeowner than if I were "debt-free" but had to rent because I didn't have the funds for a deposit.

StiggyZardust · 16/03/2022 16:52

I've set up an ISA for DS which will hopefully cover the debt once he's finished university. The money came from an inheritance.

ThisSucksBananas · 16/03/2022 16:44

I am from a 9k tuition fee cohort. It absolutely sucks. I'm from a low income family and took out max tuition fee and maintenance loan. I left uni in about 45k of debt and because THE INTEREST RATES ARE SO RIDICULOUS I've paid around 10k towards my debt over the years and my outstanding debt is HIGHER than when I left.

I'm a high earner now and have hundreds coming out my payslip every month for this bullshit and my outstanding debt is barely being affected because of the interest rates. I'm just covering the interest I get on my debt every year.

Can you contribute some towards it and invest the rest elsewhere(not sure how big this lump sum is)? I'm going to be paying off far more than I ever borrowed over the 30 years because God forbid you come from a poor background and end up with a high salary. Even if they just have tution fees as loan and maintenance costs covered by you that would be a great benefit because they wouldn't have the giant blow of big loan + HUGE interest rate.

MindfulMarch · 16/03/2022 16:35

Do they know you are thinking about this?

I would invest the money, probably in property, depends how much it is. I might split it over 2 properties so you could sell at different times, or half into a property & half into stocks & shares.

You keep saying it might not (if it drops in value) bounce back in time - in time for what? It won't hurt them to wait & save up part of the deposit themselves or whatever.

I wouldn't pay fees upfront because you just don't know which way things will go re them changing what their ambitions are. Better not to have paid upfront. Also, no matter how 'mature' you think they are, they're still young & having a student loan like everyone else is no bad thing and might make them more responsible about their choices.

NeedleNoodle3 · 16/03/2022 16:29

I don’t think it’s the best use of your money OP.

fallfallfall · 16/03/2022 16:26

@LittleGwyneth, debt is debt there is no "good" debt.
it is still on the books and hanging over your head.
wealthy individuals access accountants and take advantage of laws and regulations in such a way that benefits them but they also pay their bills. and a student loan is a bill.

Blossomtoes · 16/03/2022 16:07

£7k a year, obviously!