Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In this scenario, does it make sense to pay uni fees upfront?

135 replies

enseehammer · 15/03/2022 21:08

DC1 is heading to uni later this year, and DC2 will go in 2 years. I know the prevailing wisdom is that it's unwise to pay uni fees upfront - I've read the Martin Lewis advice on this. However, my mum died recently and I'm about to inherit a lump sum from the sale of her house. There is enough to pay off our own mortgage (when my current low fixed rate ends), and also cover uni fees for both DC's, rather than them taking out student finance and paying the above-inflation interest rate (at a time of rising inflation).

The alternative is to invest the money, either in a rental property or the stock market, in the hope that it grows. But rental yields are being squeezed, and the stock market could be a dangerous bet in these uncertain times - so I'm not sure that either option can be relied on to make a good enough return. (Yes, I know the stock market is generally a good bet in the long term, but if ww3 is about to begin, all bets are off!).

Another argument against paying upfront is that DCs may not have to pay back the full amount if they have a low income, but we live in London where wages are a lot higher than average, and the DC's are both wanting to go into high earning jobs after graduating, so I think its most likely they will both pay back the full amount and a lot more besides.

Aibu to think paying the fees upfront might be a good bet in this scenario?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
alwayslearning789 · 26/03/2022 18:51

"It’s really a question of where money can be best targeted, rather than purely about avoiding the interest payments."

"That saving of a hundred or possibly a couple of hundred quid a month won’t make a massive difference to them if they can’t afford to buy."

@WombatChocolate you make some really good points, particularly for those who are "middling" rather than confortably rich.

Food for thought - Thank You

WombatChocolate · 18/03/2022 17:57

Yes, but the alternative could be 20 years of paying rent because you can’t afford to buy as you never accumulate the necessary deposit. That’s a much bigger bill!

No-one wants to pay the debt interest. The question is whether that is a bigger evil than not having enough money to buy property - see my comments upthread about the possible impact of this when in 20s but also when in 30s having a family.

At what are do people imagine young adults can save towards a deposit in a monthly basis? At what point and after how long do people imagine they will have sufficient to put down a deposit and buy? It’s really a question of where money can be best targeted, rather than purely about avoiding the interest payments. That saving of a hundred or possibly a couple of hundred quid a month won’t make a massive difference to them if they can’t afford to buy. Given house prices are so high in many areas, even those with good degrees and decent paying jobs struggle to get the deposit together. Those extortionate rent payments which aren’t helping to pay off their own house can be far more than the loan repayments.

Badbadbunny · 18/03/2022 17:48

@TrippinEdBalls

If someone won £50K on a lottery ticket, and put it down as a deposit on a £200K house, and left their £45-50K student debts and loans owning (for which they'd be paying for 40 years, and have hanging over them everywhere they went, and which would increase to potentially £60K to £70K or more,) I'd think they were batshit.

I would be open mouthed with astonishment if someone chose to keep renting so that they could pay off their student loan. I would honestly wonder if they'd lost the plot a bit.

Thing is that the interest is ridiculous on student loans, so if you're going to earn a decent amount of say £50k per year, you'll pay a shed load of interest on top of the amount borrowed and probably still never pay it all off, although you'll have paid off the amount borrowed plus lots of interest. The illustrations of how much you'd end up repaying on incomes of £40k, £50k, £60k, £70k are sobering!
Badbadbunny · 18/03/2022 17:45

We're in a similar situation. What we're doing is paying for the rent and living costs and DS taking the loan just for the tuition fees. So a kind of half and half. Then once he qualifies, review what job he gets and what kind of financial needs he has at that time, i.e. deposit for house etc., and if possible, start to pay off lump sums of the student loan just to stop the interest getting out of control. Pointless paying 4/5/6% interest but only earning 1% on a savings account.

woulducouldushouldu · 18/03/2022 17:35

Thé rate of interest FROM DAY 1 for new loans starting this September will be over 10%. Personally I wouldn't want to enter into a loan at this rate.

valerianaofficiana · 18/03/2022 08:44

We are not there yet as DC have some years to go, but we will pay the fees for both as, quite frankly, expect them to start their careers on the higher side of the university graduate pay scale.🤓

WombatChocolate · 18/03/2022 08:25

This is the thing….some people seem only able to think about this in terms of the debt interest. Of course no-one likes the significant interest and fact they will pay much more than they borrowed back. To some degree though, this a red herring if not looked at in context of the alternatives that could be done with the money.

Yes, you will pay debt interest. Yes, in some ways it is like going up a tax bracket…although of course you only remain in the higher bracket if and when earning above the threshold. BUT, the crucial thing is to see it in context of other expenditure.

Someone renting as a single person or young couple in many areas of the country will be paying well well over £1k per month for a small flat. They might be saving for a deposit, but with high rents, even their tiny property, which might also mean large communing costs, might mean they save at best a few hundred each month. With other costs and the life of a young person, by 30 many have only accumulated a few £k or perhaps the amounts needed to get onto a help to buy scheme in a cheaper area of the country. They might not be paying debt interest, but at the point of starting a family, many of these will still be in rented accommodation. Needing a bigger home for kids, resent rise even more, often earnings take a dip or childcare costs are high snd the capacity to save is even less. The house deposit recedes into the distance as a hope, even for lots of decent earning graduates. So yes, they dint pay the 9% month in and month out, but lots also don’t get on the property ladder, or if they do, their minimum deposit keeps them in their starter d flat well beyond when it’s suitable. So the parents have enabled them to have more in their pocket on a monthly basis due to paying Uni fees, but the crucial thing is that the building of the deposit is still interminably slow and not enough.

What difference does that £50k make at maybe 27 or 28? Someone is probably 3 or 4 years into their job. They have an idea of where their lives will be and possibly who with. They have saved a tiny bit and they are finding it hard to save more because rents are so high. They can buy a small property for £275k. Their salary means they could have it if they buy with their partner but they can’t get it as they don’t have the deposit. They calculate it will take 10 years to save it….and what if house prices rise faster than wages? It will be longer still. BUT if the parents then gift the £50k it can happen. Yes, mortgage payments will still be high, but they will have housing security and a foot on the ladder. And then for the next 6 years they live in the flat, paying their mortgage and their student loans which add an extra hundred quid to the monthly outgoings. And their flat creeps up in value.

Then at 34 it’s time for a family. They can stay in their flat, or because they’ve gained equity and had some pay rises, they can move to a house. It might even be possible for one of them to drop down to 4 days a week for a couple of years. They will be continued student loan repayments, but a bit less whilst earning less.

This person is better off than the person who continually had an extra £100 per month because they weren’t paying a student loan, but who never managed to buy, because that £100 a month just never accumulated enough to build the deposit.

When families can give the fees and a £50k or more deposit, we’ll brillliant…of course 2 handouts is nicer and more effective than 1. But many middling and doing well families can scrape together a few tens of thousands as a gift …and that’s quite a sacrifice. It’s a lot of money, given families might still be paying their own mortgages or supporting younger kids or simply not have huge savings of their own. So for the vast majority, it really is an either/or situation and a choice of where the money is most effective is relevant.

A young adult getting £50k from their family for either Uni fees or for housing is extremely fortunate. Some people start to see this as entirely usual and an expectation and actually small fry, because in light of hosue prices £50k doesn’t buy a huge chunk. But that deposit doesn’t have to pay for 50% of a house for it to be worthwhile. Even most from very affluent backgrounds expect to take a mortgage and to be paying a sizeable chunk each month, especially in the early days. Those looking at having tiny ir no mortgages will be looking at parental gifts or inheritance if several hundred £k, not the £60k student fees.

The key is that house deposit. It’s a sum which most young graduates would take many many years to save even when on excellent graduate salaries (which most aren’t) and even without student loans. Those who say use the money for fees seem to think their offspring will quickly amass the vast amount needed for a deposit and the fact the money was spent on Uni fees instead won’t be a detriment.

My question to those thinking if that plan, is exactly how and by when do you imagine your graduate child will have amassed their house deposit if you and no-one else gifts them any money? At what rate will they be able to save and how much will they need and how long will it take?

And if people start then referring to other pots of me ones they can draw on, well the goal palsy’s are changing, because this thread is about having money for either/or Uni fees or housing.

TrippinEdBalls · 17/03/2022 22:00

If someone won £50K on a lottery ticket, and put it down as a deposit on a £200K house, and left their £45-50K student debts and loans owning (for which they'd be paying for 40 years, and have hanging over them everywhere they went, and which would increase to potentially £60K to £70K or more,) I'd think they were batshit.

I would be open mouthed with astonishment if someone chose to keep renting so that they could pay off their student loan. I would honestly wonder if they'd lost the plot a bit.

TrippinEdBalls · 17/03/2022 21:56

And I cannot emphasise enough how much losing 9% of income over threshold impacts long term savings for house deposits and retirement. It’s essentially going up an income tax bracket.

You know what really, really impacts on saving for a house deposit? Being given a house deposit. If OP could do both then that would be lovely but personally I think it's a no brainer to use the money for a deposit not fees.

EmpressCixi · 17/03/2022 17:32

@Blossomtoes

Am I being really stupid? That table makes absolutely no sense whatsoever to me.
It’s based on graduating with £45k of debt. I don’t know the RPI or salary % annual increase assumptions but they tend to be fairly conservative. I’ll write out the first few lines.

A graduate with a starting salary of £20k will now pay back £7,207 under the new rules instead of £0 under the old rules. This is because their salary will increase during their 40yr work life...so that they eventually go over the also gradually increasing repayment threshold.

So far so, good. Still a good deal to borrow £45k and only pay back £7k of it. The same for £25k starting salary, repayment will be less than total borrowed.

But once you hit £30k starting salary it gets sticky. A graduate will pay back £71,518 over the forty years...a lot more than they borrowed. Even worse for the starting salary of £35k the repayments will be approaching twice what they borrowed at £86,936.

But someone with a starting salary of £50k (which is minority of graduates), will only pay back £61,744

Now what is median starting salary in U.K. for graduates? £35k
explore-education-statistics.service.gov.uk/find-statistics/graduate-labour-markets

Coincidence that the starting salary for the middle earner is also the starting salary where you’d pay back the most under the new rules...almost double what you borrowed..., and that the new system conveniently slashes what the high flying, high earning upper classes starting salaries...well let’s say I have my suspicions that it’s the Tories once again sticking it to the average working person.

Blossomtoes · 17/03/2022 17:14

Am I being really stupid? That table makes absolutely no sense whatsoever to me.

EmpressCixi · 17/03/2022 16:56

@Blossomtoes
Exactly. However new rules makes the difference even more stark.

In this scenario, does it make sense to pay uni fees upfront?
Blossomtoes · 17/03/2022 16:50

Under the new rules a graduate earning £30k per year will pay thousands more back than a graduate earning £50k per year and tens of thousands more back than a graduate earning £100k per year

I’d have thought that was obvious to anyone with half a brain. Any loan will cost you more the longer you take to repay it. It’s basic economics.

EmpressCixi · 17/03/2022 16:45

@BookkeeperBobby

Well obviously if you're all guaranteed mega high earning guaranteed mega high achievers, even those of you still in school, it's different op. The rest of us ie pretty much the entire rest of the population who can't predict what their kids will earn all the way through adulthood will obviously make different decisions.
Did you miss the IF calculations? Under the new rules a graduate earning £30k per year will pay thousands more back than a graduate earning £50k per year and tens of thousands more back than a graduate earning £100k per year.

The new rules penalises the low middle earners...which is where most graduates incomes will be. Martin Lewis advice is based on the old rules, not the new ones. And the government trend is obvious..,new rules every several years that make it worse deal for middle earners to take on the debt.

And I cannot emphasise enough how much losing 9% of income over threshold impacts long term savings for house deposits and retirement. It’s essentially going up an income tax bracket.

That’s even before we consider the numerous scandals of graduate paying off their loans in full but the student loan company records being faulty and still taking money out of their pay packets and the sheer stress of having to fight for years to stop the deductions and then fight to be refunded.

WombatChocolate · 17/03/2022 07:16

The key is whether the young person can fund a property purchase without parental help. Can they build a sufficient deposit and earn enoughto g et a mortgage?

It is the fact that most hugely struggle with this, that means the money is better spend providing that deposit.

It’s not that the student loan is welcome or the internet on it good. It’s just that in most cases there’s only sufficient mo et to help with one of these major costs. The student loan is the lesser evil of being stuck in rented well into your 40s. And that’s the reality for large numbers who live in expensive areas of the country…even with their graduate jobs.

Fabtasticfanatic · 16/03/2022 22:39

I would if I could. The government have changed the rules before and will probably change them again. I wouldn't risk the debt being sold on or the repayments being made less favourable in future.

BookkeeperBobby · 16/03/2022 22:07

Well obviously if you're all guaranteed mega high earning guaranteed mega high achievers, even those of you still in school, it's different op. The rest of us ie pretty much the entire rest of the population who can't predict what their kids will earn all the way through adulthood will obviously make different decisions.

fallfallfall · 16/03/2022 21:50

i had 230K in an investment account.
i have since last august been withdrawing 2k a month.
the account is still invested but with very little trading and lower fees and today i still have over 227K.
i'm using this 2 k to pay down a loan.
the bank which deals with my investments and my loan were not at all thrilled with my plan (as they are loosing money on the trading, and loosing money on the interest the loan is generating).
maybe a similar plan would be available to you that will allow the best of both worlds helping reduce the burden on the children and maintaining a certain chunk.

enseehammer · 16/03/2022 21:34

those loans may never need to be paid back

I think, in the case of my sons, they will be paid back. I know them well enough to bet they will get reasonably well paid jobs, probably in London or the South East. I think Martin Lewis quite reasonably aims his comms at the average student, or at those from low income families that might be put off going to uni, rather than to people like us who have a sudden lump sum and need to decide how to spend it.

Someone mentioned up thread that Martin Lewis once wrote a blog on scenarios where paying the fees upfront might be the best option - I haven't been able to find it, so if anyone knows it, please post it here.

OP posts:
katienana · 16/03/2022 21:27

I wouldn't use the money on uni, I'd get the loans and then see where things were a couple of years after graduating. I know someone who paid all the fees for their dc 10 years later and they're still living at home!
You have no idea what's round the corner, illness, pregnancy, mental health, change in career ambitions etc but having the cash gives you options at least.

Blossomtoes · 16/03/2022 21:24

The year fees went up to £9k was 2012. The average UK house price then was £162k, it’s now £253k. So someone choosing to use £50k to buy a house then would have had a 200% return on their investment and a roof over their head for ten years. Whereas if they’d paid off their student loan, there would be no return and they’d have been trying to save a deposit while throwing money away on rent. No brainer.

Bunnycat101 · 16/03/2022 21:02

“If someone won £50K on a lottery ticket, and put it down as a deposit on a £200K house, and left their £45-50K student debts and loans owning (for which they'd be paying for 40 years, and have hanging over them everywhere they went, and which would increase to potentially £60K to £70K or more,) I'd think they were batshit.”

And I would take the opposite stance on the basis that those loans may never need to be paid back but putting the money into the house would provide security and stability, avoid the need for rent payments and would likely appreciate in value.

NeedleNoodle3 · 16/03/2022 20:26

I think keeping the money as a lump some makes more sense than paying than paying the fees which may never even need to be paid back.
Think how difficult it is to save up a lump sum. I think most people in their 20’s/early 30’s would prefer 40k towards a home compared to not having to pay a monthly amount in student loans.

MurmuratingStarling · 16/03/2022 20:22

[quote fluffedup]@MurmuratingStarling

I agree with you. All those parameters (interest, length of payment, minimum amount earned) can be changed by the government. And why does it have to be a greater rate of interest than a mortgage? It's not like the graduate can escape paying it. Young people are signing up for this because they think they won't be screwed. I don't have that faith.

And it's a terrifying amount of debt. And unlike buying a house, you can't sell the house to pay it off. I am advising my children to go for degree apprenticeships unless they want a career that requires a degree and no substitute would do, and only then if it is a relatively well paid career.[/quote]
Thank you. Smile Some logical common sense posts are starting to appear on here at last! From you AND several other posters over the past few hours. 100% agree with your post too. Smile

And it's a terrifying amount of debt. And unlike buying a house, you can't sell the house to pay it off.

Very good point, and one I was trying to make earlier but couldn't seem to find the right words!

As you say, you can sell a house and potentially makes 10s of 1000s of extra £££ - (even 100s of 1000s in some cases.) There is nothing a post grad can do to pay off their student debt quickly (themselves.) Unless they have the good fortune to start earning a very high salary (close to a six figure sum,) in their 20s, and live with their parents until they pay off the student debt! That's just not going to happen though is it?! Not to 99.9% of post grads anyway!

And I agree with you that I worry they will be fucked over in the future.

As I said, just like with the insistence that everyone changes bloody energy firms every year and we were all stupid if we didn't; Martin Lewis is not correct about this. Many young people would benefit massively if they had £45-50K, and they paid off their university debts with it.

If someone won £50K on a lottery ticket, and put it down as a deposit on a £200K house, and left their £45-50K student debts and loans owning (for which they'd be paying for 40 years, and have hanging over them everywhere they went, and which would increase to potentially £60K to £70K or more,) I'd think they were batshit.

The best thing a parent could do for their adult DC when they have graduated, is pay off their university debt. (If they can afford it, with no detriment to themselves obviously..)

Bunnycat101 · 16/03/2022 19:56

I think it’s interesting to see some of the emotive language used around the student loan- millstone around the neck etc. I think this is partly what Martin Lewis has been getting at by trying to reframe it as a graduate tax.

In reality, it is a different sort of debt in that there may be periods where you don’t have any obligation to pay it. When I was on maternity leave I didn’t pay a penny. If I’d never gone back to work I might never have paid it off. I was laying a lot off each month and I was relieved I paid it off but the monthly payment wouldn’t have made a debt in mortgage savings.

Eg I have the example above of someone on £50k probably paying back around £2100. If they saved that payment instead they’d be taking years and years to acclimate the equivalent £27k for a deposit- maybe 13 years.

Scenario 1: no loan- use loan money for deposit. After 13 years accumulating £175 a month at 3% growth could end up with £33k.

Scenario 2: start with £27k and get 3% growth over that same 13 year period end up with £39k or £51k if 5% or £76k at 8%.

If earning a flat £50k for those 13 years would have paid £27k of loan (16k interest) and would still have debt of £16k and likely another 10 year of payments.

I’d personally rather be in scenario 2 for the possibility of high gains on the lump sum and lack of certainty that the child would use the loan money to save instead but that wouldn’t be for everyone. Lots of people would look at those scenarios and be much more comfortable with scenario 1. It’s a very personal risk tolerance calculation.