Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

This is just shocking (trigger warning -racism)

659 replies

iloverock · 15/03/2022 18:19

www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/department-for-education-metropolitan-police-services-scotland-yard-hackney-b988292.html

Please read the formal review.

Essentially the teaching staff called the police because a black 15 year old girl smelt of cannabis. She was taken to a room and strip searched. She was on her period. Her mother wasn't notified. She was not given the opportunity for an appropriate adult to be present.

OP posts:
Bergamotte · 17/03/2022 15:55

@WrongWayApricot

I'm really struggling with how this series of events even started. She was in an exam, presumably silent room full of people. Teachers/supervisors walking up and down. They get to her and stop to sniff or something? Then go and tell another. They discuss this. Then, what, approach her and make her walk out with all heads turning. My heart would be pounding, thinking I was being accused of cheating or there was a family emergency. Then horror unfolds. I don't expect much kindness or empathy from the police anymore, especially after the selfies incident. The teachers though, and school nurse. I don't know how people can sleep at night really. I hope they lose their jobs, teaching and nursing is clearly not for them.
Yes, it's just so awful. I mean she should ABSOLUTELY NOT have been stripped searched in the first place. That was ridiculous and disproportionate and even IF it had been necessary, of course they should have contacted her mum, or at least a chaperone if they couldn't get hold of the girl's parents.

But all the details just make it worse.
They pulled her out of an exam- how is anyone to be expected to concentrate, going back into an exam after even a non-strip search? Why not just wait until the end of the exam? (Could have taken her out when the time is up, but just before everyone has been allowed to leave)

And not being allowed to go to the toilet afterwards- what purpose does that serve? They've already searched her. If if not on my period I would want to go to the toilet after such an ordeal to collect myself, wash my hands to try to get rid of the feeling of violation etc. Not to be allowed to put on a fresh pad is just awful.

I could think that maybe the teachers stayed outside the door thinking they were giving her privacy, but that seems misguided at best. As they didn't even ask her how she was afterwards, or offer a drink of water or a chat or anything... welI can't even imagine.

ScreamingMeMe · 17/03/2022 15:52

Sadiq Khan letter urges IOPC to investigate Met officers who strip searched ‘Child Q’ for gross misconduct

The mayor of London has called for sanctions imposed by a police watchdog on the cops involved to be increased from misconduct to gross misconduct, LondonWorld can reveal.

Horrific details of the “degrading” search of the teenager - who was removed from a mock exam, made to remove her sanitary pad, and bend over - emerged in a safeguarding report.

Teachers at her school in Hackney in December 2020 called the police after believing the girl smelled of cannabis - after a search of her bag, coat and shoes revealed no drugs present.

The search took place without an appropriate adult present, with teachers outside the room.

The search took place without an appropriate adult present, with teachers outside the room.

Officers were aware the girl, who was not permitted to use the bathroom, was menstruating.

It comes just weeks after former Met commissioner Dame Cressida Dick admitted more “embarrassing - or disgusting” police scandals would emerge in a BBC interview.

The report, published by the City and Hackney Safeguarding Board heard from Child Q and her relatives that she “can’t go a single day without wanting to scream, shout, cry or just give up”, was often found “screaming in her sleep”, and was “self-harming, traumatised and requires therapy”.

Her aunt said: “She is now a shell of the bubbly child she was before this incident.”

Yesterday the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) confirmed it was looking into the incident, and three officers had been served notices of misconduct investigations.

Speaking today (Thursday, March 17), Mr Khan said: “I am disgusted and angered by the account of what a 15-year-old black schoolgirl from Hackney was subjected to.

The investigation by the board found racism likely played a part in the decision to conduct the search, which has understandably been extremely traumatic for the child and her family.

“Now we have this new report I have written to the IOPC asking them to look at it as a case of gross misconduct by the officers involved.”

In the letter to the IOPC director general, Michael Lockwood, Mr Khan wrote: “I read the report with dismay and disgust.

“I am writing to urge you to consider in detail the report by the Local Safeguarding Practice Review, particularly its finding that racism had a role in the decision to conduct the search.

“I understand that in line with statutory guidance, allegations of discrimination would normally be considered at the level of gross misconduct rather than misconduct.

“I’d be grateful if you would confirm that this case will be considered as one of gross misconduct.”

News
Crime
Sadiq Khan letter urges IOPC to investigate Met officers who strip searched ‘Child Q’ for gross misconduct
The mayor of London has called for sanctions imposed by a police watchdog on the cops involved to be increased from misconduct to gross misconduct, LondonWorld can reveal.

By Jessica Frank-Keyes
Thursday, 17th March 2022, 3:33 pm

Officers who strip searched a 15-year-old black schoolgirl who was on her period should have their actions treated as gross misconduct, Sadiq Khan has said.

The mayor of London has written a letter to the police watchdog calling for sanctions imposed on the cops involved to be increased from misconduct to gross misconduct, LondonWorld can reveal.

Sign up
to our LondonWorld Today newsletter
Enter your email
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Horrific details of the “degrading” search of the teenager - who was removed from a mock exam, made to remove her sanitary pad, and bend over - emerged in a safeguarding report.

Teachers at her school in Hackney in December 2020 called the police after believing the girl smelled of cannabis - after a search of her bag, coat and shoes revealed no drugs present.

London mayor Sadiq Khan. Photo: Getty
London mayor Sadiq Khan. Photo: Getty

The search took place without an appropriate adult present, with teachers outside the room.

Officers were aware the girl, who was not permitted to use the bathroom, was menstruating.

It comes just weeks after former Met commissioner Dame Cressida Dick admitted more “embarrassing - or disgusting” police scandals would emerge in a BBC interview.

The report, published by the City and Hackney Safeguarding Board heard from Child Q and her relatives that she “can’t go a single day without wanting to scream, shout, cry or just give up”, was often found “screaming in her sleep”, and was “self-harming, traumatised and requires therapy”.

Her aunt said: “She is now a shell of the bubbly child she was before this incident.”

Yesterday the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) confirmed it was looking into the incident, and three officers had been served notices of misconduct investigations.

Speaking today (Thursday, March 17), Mr Khan said: “I am disgusted and angered by the account of what a 15-year-old black schoolgirl from Hackney was subjected to.

Metropolitan Police Commissioner Cressida Dick makes a statement outside of the Old Bailey, following the sentencing of Wayne Couzens (Photo by DANIEL LEAL/AFP via Getty Images)

Metropolitan Police Commissioner Cressida Dick makes a statement outside of the Old Bailey, following the sentencing of Wayne Couzens (Photo by DANIEL LEAL/AFP via Getty Images)
The investigation by the board found racism likely played a part in the decision to conduct the search, which has understandably been extremely traumatic for the child and her family.

“Now we have this new report I have written to the IOPC asking them to look at it as a case of gross misconduct by the officers involved.”

In the letter to the IOPC director general, Michael Lockwood, Mr Khan wrote: “I read the report with dismay and disgust.

“I am writing to urge you to consider in detail the report by the Local Safeguarding Practice Review, particularly its finding that racism had a role in the decision to conduct the search.

“I understand that in line with statutory guidance, allegations of discrimination would normally be considered at the level of gross misconduct rather than misconduct.

“I’d be grateful if you would confirm that this case will be considered as one of gross misconduct.”

He said the case had caused “widespread concern amongst the public” and that incidents such as Child Q’s experience “foster distrust” and “hamper any efforts to police by consent”.

And he asked the director general to keep him “updated on this case as a matter of priority”.

The mayor, who recently announced he had lost confidence in Met commissioner Dame Cressida Dick, sparking her high-profile exit from the force, said: “Confidence in our police is almost at an all time low.

“I am determined that the next commissioner must have a plan to tackle the serious cultural issues within the Met Police and regain the trust of Londoners.”

However, the mayor has also faced criticism today for his previous suggestion that police should be stationed in schools reopening post-lockdown, to avoid a surge in violent crime.

Mandu Reid, leader of the Women’s Equality Party (WEP), wrote on Twitter: “Like so many black women I’m still reeling from learning what happened to Child Q.

“And then I remembered this. I can’t say loudly or clearly enough: NO!

“Sadiq Khan - the police have no place in our schools. Especially this version of the police… we cannot trust them.”

ScreamingMeMe · 17/03/2022 15:43

Pleased to see Sadiq Khan stepping up

Officers who strip-searched 15-year-old girl should face gross misconduct, Khan says

f7td5.app.goo.gl/eLHoFP

TooBigForMyBoots · 17/03/2022 15:32

Love and strength to you all.💕Sad

WrongWayApricot · 17/03/2022 14:51

I'm really struggling with how this series of events even started. She was in an exam, presumably silent room full of people. Teachers/supervisors walking up and down. They get to her and stop to sniff or something? Then go and tell another. They discuss this. Then, what, approach her and make her walk out with all heads turning. My heart would be pounding, thinking I was being accused of cheating or there was a family emergency. Then horror unfolds. I don't expect much kindness or empathy from the police anymore, especially after the selfies incident. The teachers though, and school nurse. I don't know how people can sleep at night really. I hope they lose their jobs, teaching and nursing is clearly not for them.

phishy · 17/03/2022 13:57

One more thing for black/brown people to file away in their minds on what to be prepared for.

The mental load is immense.

DysonSphere · 17/03/2022 13:47

@IDontWanna

It doesn't matter how strong they are when people in authority want to ignore them.

I guess not. You're completely right. You know what? I am tired. I am soooo tired. It's caught up with me all at once. A huge slump.
The huge obvious disparity in how brown people fleeing war are treated and those who are not....the disparity in majority black countries getting covid vaccines, the little everyday lowering of expectations, having to tell my kids they have to be better or they'll be judged twice, the difference in reporting of crimes...now this. All of a sudden it's become too much.

My mental health is starting to suffer and I'm usually quite robust and pragmatic about the inequalities I, my children, and my community suffer in the world. I'll usually go out of my way to see things in as unbiased a light as possible. I reject simple rhetoric. But no. It's too much for me. I need to return to Jesus or something for my sanity, because I'm not sure I can take anymore and remain a nice person who believes in the inherent good in all people.

WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 17/03/2022 12:25

@Afan

When the George floyd killing was discussed many black British people stated on this and other forums that the racism in America is not unique to that land but continues to flourish here. This is not a surprise to those same people. Maybe it is to those that shouted them down. Black children are not protected in this country - the adults run the gauntlet each day and try to equip their children to run that same gauntlet - we know schools are not a safe space - it’s common (and exhausting) for black parents to be in correspondence with head teachers and local MPs on a regular basis fighting for equal treatment of their children. It’s disgusting and those concerned in this case should be placed on the sex offenders register at the very least. They are depraved and racist. We have to fight for our children EVERYDAY. Wether it be to stand up to security guards that follow them around Tesco to school teachers trying to downgrade their university predications because of a single c grade WHEN THEIR GRANDMOTHER DIED amongst a plethora of A GRADES beforehand. It’s constant and I’m scared and will continue to fight. this poor girls family Are dealing with one of our worst fears and I pray for their recovery.
It is exhausting 😔 Every bloody week I have a conversation with myself about the next eventually that I have to prepare my child for. Constant mental exhaustion.
Thedogscollar · 17/03/2022 12:08

All involved should be sacked and charged with sexual assault and child abuse. No safeguarding displayed at all.

All defenders on here are openly racist.

There is no defence for this. Absolutely disgusting that poor kid. I hope she can get some seriously good counselling to help her with what she suffered. I hope her life will not be ruined by these cruel bastards.

Afan · 17/03/2022 11:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MarshmallowSwede · 17/03/2022 11:28

The Met is really determined to make sure the r public don’t trust them.

In one year we have a met office kidnapping, raping and murdering a young woman. Multiple Met officers accused of rape, Met officers snapping pics of murdered women and sharing them in a WhatsApp group and making jokes.

Then a child being stripped searched at school. When is enough enough?

Pemba · 17/03/2022 10:54

This is just awful and horrible. That poor kid. I was so shocked when I heard about it and I didn't realise something like this could happen in the UK. Sheltered life, maybe?

And to think it could be something as innocent as her walking past someone who had been using cannabis, or sitting next to them on public transport! But actually even IF she'd been in possession of cannabis, the intimate search was wholly out of proportion and a human rights violation, surely? What the fuck were the school thinking?

The girl and her family need huge compensation, and heads need to roll at the Met and the school. Not holding my breath though....

ldontWanna · 17/03/2022 07:24

@DysonSphere

I'm going through a very sad time in my family at the moment and due to events in Ukraine, the news has been even more grim than usual so I've been on a media blackout and not tuning in beyond highlight grazing.

So I'm only just learning of this now.

I cannot put into words how sickened I am. I feel like crying. The humiliation that child suffered. The utter humiliation. She'll never get over it, because it was sanctioned abuse by everyone in authority. Everyone she should gave been able to trust.

It's like something from the pre-civil rights era.

To be honest, I am somewhat surprised something this bad ocurred in the UK. I thought safeguarding protocols were pretty strong in terms of procedure.

It doesn't matter how strong they are when people in authority want to ignore them.
Quirkyme · 17/03/2022 00:24

We all need to write to our local MPs about this.

This happened 2 years ago, and they think they can just write it off with a review saying that racism was a factor.

It's not enough and now is the time now it's of public interest to get action and justice for this child.

As a black woman, like others on here, I was not shocked by this unfortunately.

My heart still breaks for her.

DysonSphere · 16/03/2022 23:21

I'm going through a very sad time in my family at the moment and due to events in Ukraine, the news has been even more grim than usual so I've been on a media blackout and not tuning in beyond highlight grazing.

So I'm only just learning of this now.

I cannot put into words how sickened I am. I feel like crying. The humiliation that child suffered. The utter humiliation. She'll never get over it, because it was sanctioned abuse by everyone in authority. Everyone she should gave been able to trust.

It's like something from the pre-civil rights era.

To be honest, I am somewhat surprised something this bad ocurred in the UK. I thought safeguarding protocols were pretty strong in terms of procedure.

Maggiethecat · 16/03/2022 23:00

Just had the below response back. I would encourage people to still complain although it will not be registered as a public complaint.

Thank you for contacting us in relation to school girl stop and searched.

We are sorry to learn of your dissatisfaction and of any frustration that this may have caused you.

When complaints are received, one of the first things we do is to consider how they should be handled. We refer to legislation that governs police complaints and consider whether you:

• Witnessed the incident – for example, you were present when an incident took place or were close enough to see or hear the incident.

• Were directly affected by the behaviour of our police officers, special constables, members of police staff, volunteers or contractors.

• Have been adversely affected by an incident – this means that the actions of the police have indirectly affected you.(for example you have suffered any form of loss, damage, distress or inconvenience as a result of the matter complained about).

• Are acting on behalf of someone in any of the people listed above – for example, a family member, friend, legal representative or any other person of their choosing. You must have their written permission unless you are the parent or guardian of a child and wish to complain on their behalf.

If you have watched the incident on television or social media, you won’t be regarded as a witness or adversely effected.

Unfortunately, we are not able to record your concerns as a public complaint because you do not fall into one of the categories listed above. We will however consider if there are any lessons that can be learnt.

We understand that the outcome of your complaint to us may not be to your satisfaction, but we would like to thank for taking the time to raise your concerns.

For further information, please see:

The IOPC Statutory guidance at www.policeconduct.gov.uk
The Police Reform Act 2002 (amended 2020) at www.legislation.gov.uk

Thank you again for taking the time to contact us.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 16/03/2022 22:55

Since when is being groundlessly suspected once before and knowing a kid who did use a drug grounds enough to search you?

Yep. What 15 year old doesn't know someone who does weed? And it's worse than cigarette smoke. You just need to be jammed up against someone on the tube who smokes, and your own hair and clothes stink.

canary1 · 16/03/2022 22:30

To complain

Go to Met police site, you can click on making a complaint

I included link to newspaper article and a brief summary. It then asks if you are complaining about a Met officer and I said yes. I had to leave blank the parts where it asks for names etc but that was no problem

It says what would you like Met to do and I clicked criminal investigation etc

It takes your details - name, address, email and phone number also

It took about 5 mins

I think it can only be of some help if there were lots of complaints. Horrified that no one has been punished for assaulting this poor teenager, that they are all still working.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 16/03/2022 22:19

This was a sexual assault on a child by policewomen aided and abetted by teachers. Every adult involved should be charged with child sexual assault and the school needs closing down. As soon as the name of the schools known every parent will want their child removed anyway. I’d feel sick to know people capable of this level of disgusting behaviour were teaching my child.

Poor girl. I hope she gets the justice she deserves and can rebuild her life and trust in others.

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 16/03/2022 22:06

Can anyone share a letter that they used to complain? Be good if we can use it.

billy1966 · 16/03/2022 22:02

I honestly cannot believe how broken, corrupt, criminal and utterly lawless the Met have been shown to be.

I am, and my family are very blessed historically, but I am absolutely chilled to my bone to read that the Met are so institutionally racist, to such an extend, that they will sexually assault a child, in a school, in broad daylight, with two teachers and a nurse outside.

England is truly, truly fxxked as a country.

CharlieParley · 16/03/2022 21:05

Heartbreaking. I cannot believe that not a single person involved has been disciplined.

The child was victimised by teachers singling her out and the review goes into detail to explain that this appalling cascade of failures in safeguarding a child happened because of racism. I'm gobsmacked at the repeated attempts on this thread to question this verdict or throw doubt on it.

Even if you object to generalisations about racism, this was a long and detailed review of an individual case with the reviewers coming to this conclusion from a lot more information than what was published (as the review states). How can you honestly think you know better?

There was no justification for the strip search whatsoever. The guidelines don't just state that this is only warranted where Class A drugs are involved, of which there was no suspicion here, the review also highlights that:

Searches involving exposure of intimate parts of the body must not be conducted as a routine extension of a less thorough search, simply because nothing is found in the course of the initial search.

So there was no grounds for a strip search arising from what the child was accused of carrying. There was in my opinion also no grounds from the previous incident - and I don't even understand how they can get away with calling it an incident as the child was then also searched and nothing was found on her. Since when is being groundlessly suspected once before and knowing a kid who did use a drug grounds enough to search you?

And then after willingly allowing her possessions to be searched which found nothing, there was no justification to move onto a strip search anyway just because nothing was found.

Which involved more violations: Not calling supervisors for permission. Not consulting with an appropriate adult, not registering informed consent from the child to search her without an appropriate adult (police officers claimed "she indicated" "she seemed" - that's an admission they did not get explicit consent). Not carried out by qualified person. Not carried out in appropriate location.

Refusing to let the girl use the toilet afterwards is an incomprehensible cruelty heaped upon the cruel treatment she received.

And this child did nothing wrong - she requested her mother be notified several times, she protested her innocence but allowed her possessions to be searched. She complied with the police and cannot be expected to know that what she was subjected to was in violation of school safeguarding standards and police protocol.

I'm heartbroken for her and her family and beyond disgusted with the adults involved.

And how fucking cowardly to send her home alone in a taxi.

RedWingBoots · 16/03/2022 20:46

@endofthelinefinally

The Met are absolutely rotten to the core. So corrupt. It has been the same for decades. They do not care because they can do what they like.
You are allowed to call them institutionally corrupt as the report into the murder of Daniel Morgan gave the force that label. Dick was personally involved in obstructing the investigation.
Norgie · 16/03/2022 20:34

This is absolutely sickening and appalling in equal measure.
That poor girl. How the hell will she ever even begin to recover from it!
Can anyone of us here, as grown women, imagine being put through that humiliating ordeal, much less if you were that poor girls age!
Her poor mother too, having to deal with her daughter's ordeal. Horrendous.
Each and every person involved in this should hang their heads in shame and lose their jobs.
The met, and many coppers aren't fit for purpose.
Despicable behaviour by all concerned.

Lunde · 16/03/2022 20:20

Can the teachers who stood by also have their registration suspended - given that their excuses to the inquiry team were that they didn't know anything about laws and safeguarding of vulnerable children?

Swipe left for the next trending thread