Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

This is just shocking (trigger warning -racism)

659 replies

iloverock · 15/03/2022 18:19

www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/department-for-education-metropolitan-police-services-scotland-yard-hackney-b988292.html

Please read the formal review.

Essentially the teaching staff called the police because a black 15 year old girl smelt of cannabis. She was taken to a room and strip searched. She was on her period. Her mother wasn't notified. She was not given the opportunity for an appropriate adult to be present.

OP posts:
Testingprof · 15/03/2022 20:40

@Deadposhtory

I'm surprised anyone is surprised. This happens on a daily basis. Any non white person will confirm
But they aren’t to be believed and anyway it once kind of happened to someone who was white so there.

/sarcasm.

WonderfulYou · 15/03/2022 20:38

I'm (unfortunately) not surprised that it happened, btw. I'm only questioning the racist element. One of my own children had a horrendous experience, but because she is white, it goes below the radar.

FFS!!! Read the link before posting!!!

It says in black and white that race played a part!!

It weird that you’re so desperate to think that race didn’t play a part when it says it multiple times!!

Your child is not this child.
If you would like to start a thread and post the review and gp report then do - but don’t minimise what this poor girl went through as you’ve got some sort of weird issue with it.

Deadposhtory · 15/03/2022 20:37

I'm surprised anyone is surprised. This happens on a daily basis. Any non white person will confirm

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 15/03/2022 20:36

Absolutely horrendous. I would be beyond devastated as an adult, but for a child how do you get over something like this? I can't describe this as anything other than a sexual assault.
I'm going to explain to my dc what their rights if they or their friends are ever in this situation. I strongly suspect though, as white kids, they won't be the ones targeted. They wouldn't have treated a white girl like this.
My dc are at senior school and even in a nice area there are loads of kids who smell of cannabis. If they suspect you carrying anything you get a bag search, shoe search, pocket turn out. That's appropriate and that's enough.

StillWeRise · 15/03/2022 20:35

this surely counts as assault and the officers should be prosecuted, never mind sacked

poor poor girl

kittensinthekitchen · 15/03/2022 20:35

I did consider name changing for this, because I know what type of response it will get, but I've decided to own it.

On reading the OP and the link in the OP, I thought the same as I've seen a few others ask while scanning down the thread - "Why is this a racist incident?" "Is it always racist, just because the victim is black?"

Then I read the full report, as kindly linked further down the thread. Only 8% of those under 18 who were 'further searched' during 2020/2021 were white. That's not a coincidence. There are references in the report about the victim's "extreme large head of locks".

While to question the response was my initial reaction, I would have trusted in the report anyway, as they have all the information that I don't have, but the report makes it very clear that it should be obvious to anyone in possession of the information that this was a racist incident, and that similar incidents are happening on a regular basis.

I'm white. I have no known ancestry of anything but white. I'm not likely to ever understand or instinctively recognise every time a person is racially targeted or discriminated against, as I'm privileged enough to not live that life. As a white person, though, it's my responsibility to keep striving to recognise this racism - whether conscious or not - as it is completely unacceptable.

Thank you for posting this.

Testingprof · 15/03/2022 20:35

@JennyHogon

I'm (unfortunately) not surprised that it happened, btw. I'm only questioning the racist element. One of my own children had a horrendous experience, but because she is white, it goes below the radar.
Can you just stop. It’s not going under the radar because your child is white. If you have an issue deal with it and know that your child is better off due to being white and not having racism also affect their treatment. White children are not disadvantaged due to racism. Also do not quote the statistics on outcomes broken down by race as that shows outcomes not what causes them. Having been a teacher I can tell you what causes them and it’s not racism towards white students.
ScreamingMeMe · 15/03/2022 20:34

Oh give over. Questioning things doesn't make you a racist apologist.

Not reading the full thread and the linked information before giving your opinion makes you a bit of an idiot though.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 15/03/2022 20:34

@WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo

I found out the hard way (through my role in a school) that according to legislation, schools don't have to inform parents if they "have reason to believe" that a child needs to be searched by the police. I don't know what the law is regarding the police and strip searching minors (i assume they should have an appropriate adult but very little surprises me these days so I could be wrong) but the fact that the school requested the search and didn't inform the parents does not shock me in the slightest. It's an appalling practice and it needs to be changed.
Searching a student’s bag and pockets, maybe. Strip searching? Absolutely not.

If my child (admittedly white so I am aware this is unlikely) endured this, I wouldn’t rest until I felt the people responsible had faced sufficient consequences for their actions.

WyfOfBathe · 15/03/2022 20:34

I’ve worked in schools where cannabis is an issue, where students sometimes smelled of cannabis and certain students were known to be caught up in county lines. Not once did this result in a strip search at school.

It’s horrifying to think that there are police officers who think this is in any way okay. Sadly, after other stories we’ve seen from the Met, it hardly surprises me any more.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 15/03/2022 20:34

I know I can’t declare exactly how I would react in this situation but I really hope I’d realise this was unacceptable and do something to stop it.

In the review, the teachers' accounts of why they didn't intervene are very dispiriting. Section 5.28:

As a learning point, this has been fully accepted by the school staff involved. Many reflected their sadness and disappointment at what Child Q had experienced, with comments made as part of the school’s Stage 2 investigation report echoing these feelings: [The comments included here are worth reading.]

This leads to section 5.39

In terms of the strip search of Child Q, practice that day appears to have been far too weighted towards a criminal justice response. This may be explained in part by the deference of school staff to the police. It might relate to the relative junior police staff involved or the fact that officers didn’t seek the advice of their supervisor. It might also relate to elements of disproportionality and racism leading those involved to make certain assumptions about Child Q and what response was required.

DeeCeeCherry · 15/03/2022 20:34

2 teachers thought they smelled weed on this girl so they called the police.

She didnt have weed on her and I dont see this as grounds for calling police anyway. But those teachers knew very well that calling the police on a Black child could result in devastating consequences for her.

But that the school found it acceptable that 2 police officers could come into the school, strip a girl completely naked when they also knew she was menstruating, and without a responsible adult present, is a damning indictment of the racism assault and adultification Black girls experience all the time.

How is it that the school didnt even think to themselves that a responsible adult and/or the child's parents, needed to be in that room?

The police officers who found it appropriate to carry out this sexual assault are abhorrent. They asked her to remove her sanitary towel, then put hands inside her.

I like Hackney Council's strongly worded response to this outrage in terms of safeguarding concerns and review. But this will likely be kicked into the long grass of 'lessons will be learned', never to be heard of again. The school and the police will get away with this.

Adultification of Black girls is a known issue; anyone with awareness of or has no will to understand, isnt truly interested in the rights of girls and women.

@babywalker56 very well said but at times its just not worth explaining. Not in these times.

The person that's mostly publicising this is a White man. I knew nothing about it until he hifhlighted and opined on this. Then I looked into it further.

He understands and has explained the issues and dangers clearly and concisely, not least in terms of the inhumanity of it.

You don't have to be Black to know right from wrong in situations such as this.

Makeitsoso · 15/03/2022 20:33

@BeingATwatItsABingThing

*In the famous Milgram study the majority people electrocuted other innocent people (actually actors) to life threatening levels because they were told to by an authority figure. Even higher ‘compliance’ was found if the environment was more prestigious or official. I think the command and control nature of these schools/academies and the erosion of personal freedom probably contributed to the teachers blindly accepting what the police said and of course to the bizarre decision to call the police in the first place.*

@Makeitsoso

I remember learning about this in college. I know I can’t declare exactly how I would react in this situation but I really hope I’d realise this was unacceptable and do something to stop it.

Me too. But if we’re right we are in the minority.
Twentyn1ne · 15/03/2022 20:33

@JennyHogon

I'm (unfortunately) not surprised that it happened, btw. I'm only questioning the racist element. One of my own children had a horrendous experience, but because she is white, it goes below the radar.
Indeed.

As I said above I was strip searched as a child of a similar age, by police, with no appropriate adult present. I'm not a person of colour.

Whilst I respect the findings in this particular case, it's not something that only happens to people / children of colour.

superdupertruper · 15/03/2022 20:32

@LakieLady

Wtf is it with the Met? Why can't they just behave appropriately?

This is a shocking way to treat a child.

And the school and the teachers and the nurse obviously. Or are they ok?
Testingprof · 15/03/2022 20:31

@WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo

It really is quite something that even when a poster provides documentation from a review that clearly evidences that race is a factor, some MN posters will stand firm in their denial of racism. How embarrassing to admit that your understanding of the world we live in is so incredibly narrow.
Doesn’t it show how pervasive racism is and how it isn’t enough to not simply be not racist though? To me it highlights it, these people are so brazen to say this didn’t happen because they ‘know’ they won’t really be called out on their own racist views.

I’m fed up of the view that unless you are called the N word or black prefaces an insult it isn’t racism. Racism is so much worse and quieter than that, it’s being ignored while all of your white colleagues are greeted. Its being told your uppity. It’s being told you don’t sound (enter ethnicity). It’s being told your smart for (enter ethnicity). Its being asked where are you really from. It’s being told time and time again racism doesn’t exist while all of the above happens.

Mumsnet doesn’t help as it allows clearly dogwhistle posts to stand ‘in the spirit of discussion’.

JennyHogon · 15/03/2022 20:30

I'm (unfortunately) not surprised that it happened, btw. I'm only questioning the racist element. One of my own children had a horrendous experience, but because she is white, it goes below the radar.

HikingforScenery · 15/03/2022 20:29

The fact that a school invited the police in to come and treat a pupil like this is beyond words. Where’s the safeguarding?

ruthlangmore · 15/03/2022 20:29

This so disgusting. The poor girl, I can't imagine how terrifying and humiliating this ordeal was for her. Every adult involved should be thoroughly ashamed and should be sacked. The Met Police are an absolute disgrace.

VladmirsPoutine · 15/03/2022 20:29

I'm hoping there'll be some sort of fundraiser for her family to hire the best legal team in the land. I would happily donate.

WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 15/03/2022 20:29

I found out the hard way (through my role in a school) that according to legislation, schools don't have to inform parents if they "have reason to believe" that a child needs to be searched by the police. I don't know what the law is regarding the police and strip searching minors (i assume they should have an appropriate adult but very little surprises me these days so I could be wrong) but the fact that the school requested the search and didn't inform the parents does not shock me in the slightest. It's an appalling practice and it needs to be changed.

StScholastica · 15/03/2022 20:29

Appalling, that poor girl.
I have always supported the Police but my two boys, both uni students, were followed home by two Police women a couple of years ago, after I made them walk the dog in the dark (the lazy buggers had been promising all day Hmm).
The two officers asked them who they were, why they were on a country lane (err.....they're walking their dog) then asked them to go home so they could check they lived where they said they did, and drove behind them.
I opened the door to two officers on the drive wondering what the hell had happened.

My lads are mixed race.

Police were VERY apologetic but said they'd never seen my sons around here before (they've lived in this village their entire lives) and they looked suspicious. Said there had been a spate of crime.
The last crime here was a burglary in 1996.

I'm sure they made racist assumptions that night. I'm just glad that my boys remained calm and didn't argue with them.

JennyHogon · 15/03/2022 20:28

[quote Testingprof]**@ParsleySageRosemary* @JennyHogon*

More racist apologists enter chat

Of course it happened and of course it was racist. How many police officers have been caught taking selfies with dead white women? How many reports of white girls getting strip searched in schools have you come across? The police weren’t even called the times kids were suspected of having drugs during my time teaching (99% white and white students suspected of having drugs)[/quote]
Oh give over. Questioning things doesn't make you a racist apologist.

UsernameInTheTown · 15/03/2022 20:28

WTAF?

HikingforScenery · 15/03/2022 20:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ for repeating a deleted message. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.