Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

This is just shocking (trigger warning -racism)

659 replies

iloverock · 15/03/2022 18:19

www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/department-for-education-metropolitan-police-services-scotland-yard-hackney-b988292.html

Please read the formal review.

Essentially the teaching staff called the police because a black 15 year old girl smelt of cannabis. She was taken to a room and strip searched. She was on her period. Her mother wasn't notified. She was not given the opportunity for an appropriate adult to be present.

OP posts:
HikingforScenery · 16/03/2022 00:30

[quote Katya213]@Testingprof.

Go google it, it happened to a white girl too. BBC news. You cannot go round saying what you like to people, the way you treated that previous poster was actually quite shocking.

It shouldn’t happen to anybody, it’s totally wrong and they should pay for it![/quote]
Can you share the link of the girl this happened to? I’ve had a look and not found anything on bbc.

I’ve found the one about 24 year old woman, Dr Duff, who was taken in and horrifically strip searched and spoken about in a disgusting manner. I remember there was a thread on her case a few weeks ago.

RandomBasic · 16/03/2022 00:27

@WonderfulYou

Unfortunately this is what black kids are told to do in order to avoid further abuse specially from the police or authorities.

I agree.

She did not have the luxury of standing up for herself or refusing as if this is how she was treated when complying and innocent, imagine how she’d be treated if they thought she was resisting or had something to hide.

That's why pp's post of "I wouldn't have let them do that to me" really ticked me off.
ScrollingLeaves · 16/03/2022 00:16

@oakleaffy
I am very sorry for what happened to you💐

caringcarer · 16/03/2022 00:14

It always seems to be the Met involved in these atrocious abuses of power. This must be gross misconduct which is stackable offence. I hope the poor girl gets a massive compensation claim and sees teacher who allowed this to happen sacked too. How dare they treat a child like this.

Silversprinkles · 16/03/2022 00:06

@RichPetunia

Seems extreme. Where’s the evidence this happened?
Can't you read? Try the official safeguarding review that's been published and linked on the thread HmmConfused
ScrollingLeaves · 15/03/2022 23:53

The police should also be banned from language that uses the term ‘further search’ to obfuscate the reality of a strip search, and even strip search can have two different meanings the very worst being orifice search.

The report distinguished between two possible motives on the part of the school and the police for concern over the girl smelling of cannabis.

  1. The wrong one - but the one influencing their behaviour - which was to criminalise her.
  1. What it should have been - but wasn’t- the need to investigate her possible vulnerability and need for safeguarding.
londonmummy1966 · 15/03/2022 23:49

Utterly horrific.

It is deeply worrying that the child now tries to sleep in a bath full of water. Beyond the obviousl safety issues it suggests that she feels dirty as a result of the incident and has PTSD.

The poor child.

Tubs11 · 15/03/2022 23:46

This poor child and those officers should be jailed!

Comefromaway · 15/03/2022 23:37

Whilst highlighting the disparity of ethnic origin in those intimately searched in Hackney across that period of time it does also say that the number of searches in general was overly high and 80% of them found nothing/no further action with the conclusion they were uncessary/unwarranted

ScrollingLeaves · 15/03/2022 23:34

I meant oakleaffy did not have a home to go back to.

ScrollingLeaves · 15/03/2022 23:32

“Testingprof

oakleaffy
I was a white girl {Now a woman} and was homeless as a teenager.
I can assure you police stripped searched me in a really humiliating way on a several occasions, simply as I was thin {hungry} and they assumed I must have been on some sort of drug.

Being taken to the police station {Vine Street, London} was awful.

Is there any ''Nice'' way to be strip searched?

I think not.

They didn't find anything.

As a girl, I felt powerless, I doi wonder if they did it to keep numbers of people they searched up?

They did seem to strip search a number of young women who were also homeless.

Police Women did the actual searching, but if one made a fuss, it was ''Do you want me to call the Sgt. in?''

As a teenager, with no idea, I just blindly complied.”

“Genuinely what are you trying to gain from posting your experiences other than minimising the racism that was involved in this case. Why would you want to minimise the racism?“

Maybe Testinptof posted her horrible experience of police the police strip searching her as a homeless teenager to show the widespread bullying by the police of anyone vulnerable they can lay their hands on.

Testinprof did not have a home to go back to. She evidently wasn’t in school either. She might have been living in hell at home before or she wouldn’t have been homeless at that young age. She too needed safeguarding not ‘legal’ assault.

This awful act on the young girl in the OP was racist. But the crime against her was not excluded to racism.

Katya213 · 15/03/2022 23:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 15/03/2022 23:19

Adultification is threaded all the way through this.

It is not that long ago that I was at school/college. Ethnic mix: predominantly white, British-Pakistani, British Asian. Yes, people were suspected to smoke cannabis behind the bike sheds and so on. No, the staff weren't happy about drug taking on the premises and suspensions happened.

But hell would have iced over before they called police in to do a strip search for suspected concealed cannabis on the day the student was taking an exam. It would have been put on the back burner to discuss the next day.

No-one cared about what this did to Q, or how this would disrupt her exam chances. She was seen as a grown up who could deal with it.

And for what. Because someone thought she smelled of cannabis. I spent my entire schooldays stinking of fag smoke. I've never smoked, and if anything, cannabis is far more pungent than tobacco. You only have to walk through an alleyway where someone has been smoking to get the smell in your hair.

Testingprof · 15/03/2022 23:15

[quote Katya213]@Testingprof

There are no words to describe how cruel that sounded.[/quote]
It wasn’t cruel. What happened to @oakleaffy was wrong but I’m highly suspicious of the posters who are clamouring to say they are white and have had similar happen to them especially in the face of posters claiming it didn’t happen or it’s not racist because it could have happened to a white girl.

Doodar · 15/03/2022 23:11

this was 2 years ago, they're only apologising now. Whats happened to that poor girl in this time?

Mariposista · 15/03/2022 23:10

@Tortabella

Poor child. Devastating. She deserves more than an apology.
Literally every person involved who stood by and watched it happen should face consequences. That poor child, how will she ever trust anyone in authority again?
Katya213 · 15/03/2022 23:10

@Testingprof

There are no words to describe how cruel that sounded.

ScreamingBeans · 15/03/2022 23:09

They sexually assaulted a child.

Jesus. The police are awful.

Comefromaway · 15/03/2022 23:08

From the review

Over the same period, 25 children under the age of 18 were subject of ‘further searches’. 19 were male and 18 were handcuffed during the process. The reasons for search primarily related to suspicions about drugs (20), followed by weapons (4) and stolen property (1). 22 (88%) of the searches were negative with an outcome of no further action recorded in 20 (80%) of the cases. In terms of ethnicity, (as per the codes used by the police), 15 (60%) of the children searched were Black, 2 were White, 6 Asian and 2 Arab or North
African.

“further search” means strop search

60% of those children under 18 who were strip searched by the police were black

8% only were white.

Nnique · 15/03/2022 23:08

She was sexually assaulted, IMO, and the TW could cover sexual assault of a child as well as racism.

Yes absolutely. There was NOT legitimate reason for the action taken. They violated that young girl for no good reason.

HomeHomeInTheRange · 15/03/2022 23:05

This is sickening.

The Review is good. But I read through it looking for a question which I did not see asked or answered: why the hell would they make her remove her ST, spread her legs etc because of a report that she smelled of cannabis? I honestly have never heard of anyone carrying weed for immediate use in their vagina or rectum… drug mules with capsules or condoms of heroin or cocaine maybe, but not school children FFS.

She was sexually assaulted, IMO, and the TW could cover sexual assault of a child as well as racism.

I am sickened by all the abuse of police power reported in this thread, and outraged for all of it. It does matter that police abuse ANY woman like this. However The fact that police have abused their powers to strip search white women does not mean that racism was not at play in this case.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 15/03/2022 23:00

I think @EthelTheAardvark has nailed it, the police officers went against standard procedure, on the very shaky grounds that someone, a teacher, believed they smelt cannabis on the girl, ( post covid dysosmia, anyone ? ) remember they had already done a 'normal' search which produced no evidence of drug use or possession. Instead of contacting their superior officer for advice about how to procede ( who would have probably/hopefully have said 'are you having a laugh, the four of you get back out there' ), they decided to take the child into a room and strip search her.
When that highly degrading and intimate strip search also produced no evidence of drugs, the child was sent home without the school or the police officers informing the parents of what had happened ?

To put it into context, DS didn't do their Maths homework for two weeks and we got a phone call from his teacher !

Doodar · 15/03/2022 23:00

Surprisingly for the mail the comments are all of support, what I've seen anyway.
That poor girl and her family. They need to sue, I'm sure many people would help to fund it, knowing what the police use to deter people from doing so.

Bromse · 15/03/2022 22:58

This is just so distressing. The poor girl was abused by the police, it was an outrage.

I don't think much of the school calling the police just because somebody thought the girl smelled of cannabis.

Young people should feel they can trust adults, especially those in charge. I say 'should', they often can't and this awful case illustrates that.

I can remember similar things happening when I was a teenager in the 1960s; I would have hoped society had moved on since then - obviously there is still a long way to go.

RoseslnTheHospital · 15/03/2022 22:58

When there is such a clear cut condemnation of the police officers and the teachers/staff at the school then it should be immediately the case that there will be sackings and an immediate OFSTED inspection on the grounds of child safety. But there won't be, will there? Just more trauma for this young girl and her family, as people minimise and brush it under the carpet. The police involved will be probably just be given a note on their record, and I can't see any of the teachers being officially sanctioned either. There will just be lots of waffling about procedures and blah blah blah, then hope that everyone forgets about it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread