Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

This is just shocking (trigger warning -racism)

659 replies

iloverock · 15/03/2022 18:19

www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/department-for-education-metropolitan-police-services-scotland-yard-hackney-b988292.html

Please read the formal review.

Essentially the teaching staff called the police because a black 15 year old girl smelt of cannabis. She was taken to a room and strip searched. She was on her period. Her mother wasn't notified. She was not given the opportunity for an appropriate adult to be present.

OP posts:
Katya213 · 16/03/2022 09:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

RishiRich · 16/03/2022 09:04

That's appalling. The poor girl. How many adults failed here?!

  • Her teacher
  • School leadership
  • 3 policemen
  • 2 policewomen
  • the school nurse

Didn't one of those adults think, 'Hang on a minute, we need to call her mum/stop this, it's going too far'?

SpikeySmooth · 16/03/2022 09:01

When I saw the post on Twitter, I was shocked and appalled. Child Q was the same age as my DD is now. I will admit, if my DD smelled of cannabis she would not undergo the same trauma because she is white. She goes to a London school with a high proportion of black girls attending and, when I was telling her about this, she remarked how her black friends would be treated differently to herself. She knows she has that privilege. She is also appalled. It's beyond comprehension.

We had a chat again about consent, abuse of power, her rights and about safeguarding because every girl needs to know that this is abuse and should resist.

PinkCheetah · 16/03/2022 09:00

I'm not surprised but incredibly sad. I'm a black woman with a black daughter and if it were me I know I'd be going to jail because every adult involved would be set on fire.

Pennox · 16/03/2022 08:57

Poor girl. What a terrible thing to happen tona 15y old. I really hope she can turn it around and continue to do well academically and prove those arseholes that profiled and degraded her wrong.

LotusCheesecake · 16/03/2022 08:55

@MotherofTerriers

The Met Police, this is pretty much the level of treatment of women and girls I expect from them. It’s shameful, the organisation is rotten and far too many officers are not fit to be in any position of authority. I hope action is taken against the officers involved but there probably won’t be. But the school….. her teachers…. It wasn’t a police officer who reported her, who pulled her out of an exam hall, who waited in the corridor knowing what was being done to her, who decided not to phone her mum…. Her teachers allowed her to be sexually assaulted and humiliated,. What was the point in any of their safeguarding training if they thought this was ok? For the school to be whining that being seen as complicit has been difficult for them! The teachers should be sacked, the school should be placed under new management. And that won’t happen either. The name of the school will be kept quiet if they possibly can. I don’t know how those teachers can walk into a classroom knowing what they did
The report says that at the time of the incident the school was rated good by ofsted and that safeguarding had been deemed effective. It also refers to the school as an academy. I think that narrows the number of schools it could be right down and it won't be long before it's out.

Agree school staff need to be held to account to, however is very possible the staff who were there at the time are no longer there...

MotherofTerriers · 16/03/2022 08:46

The Met Police, this is pretty much the level of treatment of women and girls I expect from them. It’s shameful, the organisation is rotten and far too many officers are not fit to be in any position of authority. I hope action is taken against the officers involved but there probably won’t be.
But the school….. her teachers…. It wasn’t a police officer who reported her, who pulled her out of an exam hall, who waited in the corridor knowing what was being done to her, who decided not to phone her mum…. Her teachers allowed her to be sexually assaulted and humiliated,. What was the point in any of their safeguarding training if they thought this was ok? For the school to be whining that being seen as complicit has been difficult for them! The teachers should be sacked, the school should be placed under new management. And that won’t happen either. The name of the school will be kept quiet if they possibly can. I don’t know how those teachers can walk into a classroom knowing what they did

LotusCheesecake · 16/03/2022 08:40

[quote HeadPain]mobile.twitter.com/PortiaAntonia/status/1503828061992722434?cxt=HHwWhIC55fPp1d4pAAAA[/quote]
Good. I just hope this story doesn't get lost by the media. It is absolutely appalling.

Unpopular37 · 16/03/2022 08:06

@RichPetunia

Seems extreme. Where’s the evidence this happened?
Read the fucking report...
bellabasset · 16/03/2022 08:00

Heavens above yet another incident to demonstrate the lack of support for women and young girls by the Met. Absolutely appalling and I hope the school governors and the MP will get involved in investigating how this could have happened. Girls of that age are sensitive to start with and I hope she'll get some compensation for this so she knows it should never have happened.

phishy · 16/03/2022 07:48

@oakleaffy

I was a white girl {Now a woman} and was homeless as a teenager. I can assure you police stripped searched me in a really humiliating way on a several occasions, simply as I was thin {hungry} and they assumed I must have been on some sort of drug.

Being taken to the police station {Vine Street, London} was awful.

Is there any ''Nice'' way to be strip searched?

I think not.

They didn't find anything.

As a girl, I felt powerless, I doi wonder if they did it to keep numbers of people they searched up?

They did seem to strip search a number of young women who were also homeless.

Police Women did the actual searching, but if one made a fuss, it was ''Do you want me to call the Sgt. in?''

As a teenager, with no idea, I just blindly complied.

Why do you feel the need to assure us of anything? This thread isn’t about you. I am sorry for what you went through and I believe you but you are in danger of hijacking the thread.
Testingprof · 16/03/2022 07:19

[quote Katya213]@Testingprof.

Go google it, it happened to a white girl too. BBC news. You cannot go round saying what you like to people, the way you treated that previous poster was actually quite shocking.

It shouldn’t happen to anybody, it’s totally wrong and they should pay for it![/quote]
I’m not saying it didn’t happen but that by posting about it on a thread which is about racism that you are trying to detract from racism by saying it’s happened to someone who is white. It’s a ploy straight out of the apologists (racists) playbook.
On another thread discussing how using strip searches are wrong in cases outside of prison and very specific circumstances I’d have supported @oakleaffy however, on this thread it’s sounds very much like NAMALT especially in the context of other posters pretending that we can only tell racism exists is if a white person and a black person are skipping down the road together in exactly the same clothes and only the black person is affected.

I notice you haven’t challenged those posters who have suggested it didn’t happen at all…

carefullycourageous · 16/03/2022 06:54

@ClaudineClare

I don't know if I misunderstood, but the BBC report seemed to indicate that the Met is taking no action against the officers involved. I hope the backlash will be strong enough to force the Met to do something, hopefully sacking the officers. They assaulted that child.

The Met is not fit for purpose, it is rotten and racist to the core.

Yes this was the impression I got.

This is one of the worst things I think, that the Met is so broken/dreadful that no meaningful action is ever taken. However I am not sure whether action should be taken against just the officers, somehow it is the whole Met that is at fault. The officers were wrong, I think there should be action taken against them, but that lets more senior people off somehow.

Recently we have learned so much more about how toxic the whole institution is.

I agree this is shocking in how dreadful it is but not surprising that it happened. Black people have been telling the world for decades what the Met is like and how it treats them.

PearPickingPorky · 16/03/2022 06:52

@londonrach

Why did they even strip search her..she's 15 and on her period. That poor girl. I'm tbh shocked the school and teachers allowed this to happen. Why didn't they call her mum.
To humiliate her.

There are a lot of people who get a bit of a thrill about humiliating women and girls.

It was the male police officer who was the school's Safe Support officer (poor choice to have a man in that role anyway) who decided she needed strip-searched. Then said to call 101 for two female officers.

I also think that's significant.

madbadrad · 16/03/2022 06:51

This is appalling. Even if they did suspect her of having weed it doesn't justify a strip searched. This poor girl, her privacy has been completely violated.

Unpopular37 · 16/03/2022 06:47

The Met were appalling, but the school has hardly covered itself in glory either. The poor girl apparently merely 'smelt' of cannibis ffs. It is smoked openly in many places, so she could easily have walked passed someone smoking it (even possibly, a teacher). But of course, this would not be reported if she was white

RedWingBoots · 16/03/2022 05:12

@EmbarrassingHadrosaurus

I’ve found the one about 24 year old woman, Dr Duff, who was taken in and horrifically strip searched and spoken about in a disgusting manner. I remember there was a thread on her case a few weeks ago.

That case is mentioned as part of the context in the review.

I heard an interview with Dr Duff. She was stripped searched because she kept telling black teenagers their rights when they were stopped by the police. She is aware she is privileged for being white and middle class which is why she fought for the truth. She also said if she was black she would have had no chance in getting the outcome she got.
givethatbabyaname · 16/03/2022 03:37

All these posters professing to be shocked, appalled, disgusted. Throwing hands up and asking why it doesn’t stop. When are people going to understand? How many incidents, reports, reviews, commissions will it take for people to understand that there are white people who actively believe in their superiority over black people, who gravitate towards or seek out like-minded people, who laugh at the law, get a kick out of flouting it while wearing a uniform and soaking up the respect and glory of upholding it, who enjoy and value their racist beliefs, and find employment and succour and friendship and affinity and people just like them in the Met where they are given power over these black people?

You ask how could those female officers not realise how awful this was? How could they not have remembered the procedures and policies they’re bound to follow? Of course they did. They wanted to humiliate and degrade. It’s normal to them to do so. You can’t accidentally strip search someone, especially not in this way. It may not have been premeditated, but by god it was deliberate. They are racist. The made a choice to do this to a black girl. They wanted to. It wasn’t a lapse or an oversight. Are YOU capable of such a lapse or oversight?

It’s always been this way. This is institutional racism. It’s not bad apples. The Met is the natural home for many, many white people who are racist. They’re surrounded by, supported, protected by people like them. It’s in the culture of the Met. That’s what institutional means.

What will it take for people to let go of the fairy tale that the Met police are all goodies?

PinkSyCo · 16/03/2022 03:06

God this is fucking awful! Poor girl. Sad

MistySkiesAfterRain · 16/03/2022 02:52

FFS she is a child, that should never have happened. Serious let down. I used to work in the borough and I am saddened and disappointed that happened. It was getting better 10-15 years ago.

hannahmontana00 · 16/03/2022 01:15

@MintyFreshBreath in the statistics posted in the report, no white females under 18 had been strip searched within the same time period. The only female who was strip searched was black. Beyond that, only 2 out of dozens of males under 18 who were strip searched were white. So essentially the conclusion is that strip searches are more prevalent in under 18s that are not white

Bagadverts · 16/03/2022 00:40

Whatever happens can never be enough or put things right for that violation- at minimum
Compensation and immediate ongoing support through any services necessary for this girl, her family and any of the other children at the school who need it.

To know the disciplinary action taken and results

To know what lessons have already been learnt and how implemented, independent continuing overview of whether they are happening - both school and police

Ongoing statistics on use of searches, breakdown on basis of ethnicity, sex, sexual orientation, disability, age, religion.
We need this for all police forces.

Metropolitan police are the biggest force but there are other parts of the country where these factors including racism will be at play at any time.

For those saying it could happen to other ethnicities. 13.3% of Londoners identify as black. Puts 60% of searches in very stark perspective.

www.ethnicity-facts-figures.service.gov.uk/uk-population-by-ethnicity/national-and-regional-populations/regional-ethnic-diversity/latest#areas-of-england-and-wales-by-ethnicity

bracebrace · 16/03/2022 00:38

I'm horrified by this. Black or white this is totally unacceptable. I can't actually believe that a school would report a smell to the police or that police would choose to investigate by strip search. All the adults involved in this should hang their heads in shame. Poor girl.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 16/03/2022 00:36

I’ve found the one about 24 year old woman, Dr Duff, who was taken in and horrifically strip searched and spoken about in a disgusting manner. I remember there was a thread on her case a few weeks ago.

That case is mentioned as part of the context in the review.

Swipe left for the next trending thread