Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask who should pay?

166 replies

howtomoveforwards · 15/03/2022 18:10

I have a son who lives most of his time with his dad - this is a recent thing. He lived with me full time prior to this, with EOW at dad’s. Dad’s girlfriend’s’ daughter has sat on his glasses and broken them. This happened a week ago now. Nothing has been said to me and no one has taken son to look at either fixing them or getting a new pair. Son needs the glasses sooner rather than later - he can manage but he really does need them in school.

I have told son I will sort it one way or another at the weekend - my job is such that I finish after the optician closes or I would have taken him during the week. I pay no maintenance to ex for this child but ex equally pays nothing for the other child that lives with me (and never has paid).

Should it be me who does this and who should be paying?

OP posts:
Thatsplentyjack · 16/03/2022 22:10

Well this thread is a fucking grim read.
I feel so angry on your behalf OP not only because of the glasses situation but because of this thread and the utter fucking shite being spouted on it. Of course you shouldn't have to pay or be the one responsible for sorting the glasses, and everyone one idiots piling on you here would feel the same if they were in your situation.

PussInBin20 · 16/03/2022 21:52

If it happened at Dad’s and he lives with him, why did your son not go to his Dad to sort it? How come it has become your problem?

Did you have any agreement about costs for each child? Otherwise, what happens when the next problem arises?

I think you need to discuss with your ex and come to some arrangement - or you will be in this position a lot. In the meantime, tell him to sort out his son’s glasses.

TokenGinger · 16/03/2022 21:49

I would happily place a wager on the foul women kicking you down here, questioning your parenting abilities and making snide remarks about why your son doesn't live with you are the same women that post "empowering women" and women supporting women posts on their social media posts.

She's paid for everything for 13 years. No support at all from ex. Glasses have broken in ex's care. She has not yet seen DS or been available at the time the opticians is open. And yet people think that she is the lazy parent, rather than the one who lives with the child and who is self employed so likely has a little more flexibility in their working hours to get it sorted.

TokenGinger · 16/03/2022 21:45

Sweet Jesus, this thread is horrendous.

Why is it a mother gets torn apart, but the dad is getting away Jack free? Either people can't be arsed to RTFT, or people really do enable men to do as little as possible when it comes to parenting.

If you have two children, and one lives with each of you, it only makes sense that you each cover the living costs of the child with you. Otherwise you'd be paying him what he pays you back.

He's lazy. There's no way your son should have gone this long without glasses that he needs.

Jamboree01 · 16/03/2022 21:17

@howtomoveforwards

Because most people including kids have a spare pair

You don’t perhaps think that 13 years of paying for absolutely every last thing might have taken its toll? I am very much a middle income earner with no entitlement to benefits and have had to keep a roof over our heads. Most people might have two pairs. I don’t and neither do my children because that is money I don’t have.

The rest of your post is utter bollox. Perhaps have a look at your need to kick someone who is very obviously down?

Thanks to those who have experience of this and understand the complexity of the bigger picture.

I have experience of this. That’s one of the reasons I know you can get two pairs with one voucher at optical express.
RealBecca · 16/03/2022 20:47

am just annoyed that once again, it is me that has to be inconvenienced when child no longer lives with me.

that comes across really badly.

Moreover, my children have just defended ex and girlfriend saying they were obviously busy at the weekend

^why did they feel the need to defend them? What were you saying? It sounds like you're moaning about them to your child.

howtomoveforwards · 16/03/2022 20:38

Because most people including kids have a spare pair

You don’t perhaps think that 13 years of paying for absolutely every last thing might have taken its toll? I am very much a middle income earner with no entitlement to benefits and have had to keep a roof over our heads. Most people might have two pairs. I don’t and neither do my children because that is money I don’t have.

The rest of your post is utter bollox. Perhaps have a look at your need to kick someone who is very obviously down?

Thanks to those who have experience of this and understand the complexity of the bigger picture.

OP posts:
BeHappy91818 · 16/03/2022 20:26

@howtomoveforwards

I said right at the beginning I would get them fixed. How is that playing games?

I have no intention whatsoever in arguing with my ex. To do so would be pointless. He simply doesn’t consider putting his hand in his pocket for his children is his responsibility. I am beyond frustrated that is the case and that my children consider it the same way. My glasses-less boy has actually just asked me why he doesn’t have a spare pair. I don’t have a bloody spare pair cos I can’t afford them. Beyond me why he thinks he should!!

Because most people including kids have a spare pair.

You don’t sound like you even like your son very much. No wonder he lives with his dad.

ChiselandBits · 16/03/2022 18:42

please stop telling the OP to get them done. She said on page 1 that she would be.

caringcarer · 16/03/2022 18:30

Yes his Dad should have replaced them, but no he did not care enough to do so. Your DS is not stupid. He will remember who went the extra mile for him. Get the glasses done for your son.

ichifanny · 16/03/2022 18:05

At the end of the day he needs glasses but his dad should have sorted it by now , to be honest I’d be wanting full time custody of him if his dad isn’t bothered his arse about sorting out something as important as his glasses he needs .

TeeBee · 16/03/2022 18:00

@howtomoveforwards

Oh it will be me that sorts it and my ex won’t be putting his hand in his pocket, I feel quite sure of that. I am just annoyed that once again, it is me that has to be inconvenienced when child no longer lives with me. And annoyed that if it was one of my children that had broken an essential ,piece of equipment, I’d have apologised and said how can I help sort it. Moreover, my children have just defended ex and girlfriend saying they were obviously busy at the weekend but see no reason why I might also not have the time to deal with it and seem utterly unable to comprehend that I have shit to do at the weekend too! Bah!
I've had years of this shit from my ex. Trust me, the kids know. The kids learn. The kids see who is there for them. And you will have him on your doorstep in years to com moaning about his lack of relationship/contact with them and you can choose to laugh in his face or to yourself. What goes around comes around. And yeah, you should be able to get them replaced for free.
Quartz2208 · 16/03/2022 17:59

@howtomoveforwards

I said right at the beginning I would get them fixed. How is that playing games?

I have no intention whatsoever in arguing with my ex. To do so would be pointless. He simply doesn’t consider putting his hand in his pocket for his children is his responsibility. I am beyond frustrated that is the case and that my children consider it the same way. My glasses-less boy has actually just asked me why he doesn’t have a spare pair. I don’t have a bloody spare pair cos I can’t afford them. Beyond me why he thinks he should!!

Did he decide to do the move OP, because at 13 he should be able to understand there are consequences.

I think you do need to say that he now lives with his Dad and you cant afford them and to ask him.

Jamboree01 · 16/03/2022 17:41

Vision express do 50% off second pair

howtomoveforwards · 16/03/2022 17:32

I said right at the beginning I would get them fixed. How is that playing games?

I have no intention whatsoever in arguing with my ex. To do so would be pointless. He simply doesn’t consider putting his hand in his pocket for his children is his responsibility. I am beyond frustrated that is the case and that my children consider it the same way. My glasses-less boy has actually just asked me why he doesn’t have a spare pair. I don’t have a bloody spare pair cos I can’t afford them. Beyond me why he thinks he should!!

OP posts:
Jamboree01 · 16/03/2022 17:24

@howtomoveforwards

Stop playing games

Could you point out exactly where I have played games?

It’s strange to me that getting your son’s glasses fixed would be the point where you put your foot down. He needs them. They are not a luxury. I don’t think anyone is blaming you for being p**d off and frustrated about getting the glasses repaired/ replaced when it should be his dad (god only knows my ex is beyond selfish and wouldn’t lift a finger to do anything for his kids) - it’s the fact that you just haven’t done it that’s a bit shocking. Your son will be struggling without them. The voucher will cover all/ or part of the cost. Pick some other bone of contention to argue with him over- I’m sure there will be many to come sadly.
ChiselandBits · 16/03/2022 17:22

@Blossomtoes no - you're not more sensible, just that some of us have had to deal with this shit for so long from our exes we get where the OP is coming from. At no point has she said she won't sort them out, or tell her ex one thing and do another, or send messages via her son or anything else. What the OP is really about is yet another male parent doing fuck all in terms of actual parenting and leaving the tedious, annoying, inconvenient bits to the other parent, who always ends up doing them / paying because they HAVE to. This is about the unequal approach to parenting. I think, 5 pages in, that we have established the OP WILL sort it. This is about the frustration of trying to co-parent with a lazy selfish fuckwit.

And FWIW I have frequently had to pay something toward my DCs glasses when they have broken them before the annual review and ex has never contributed in time, money or anything else, regardless of how or where they were broken.

Blossomtoes · 16/03/2022 17:15

@Dawnofthefed

I don't think it matters as long as he gets glasses and as long as whoever buys them can afford to do so.
Me too but we’re way too sensible for MN! 😂
howtomoveforwards · 16/03/2022 17:13

Stop playing games

Could you point out exactly where I have played games?

OP posts:
Quartz2208 · 16/03/2022 14:35

@Quincythequince

Whatever quartz! You keep posting extreme non-examples and Inaccuracies (your first post included) and so stands to be corrected.

Is said kids glasses are free, you said they weren’t!
You are wrong!

But engaging with you is like playing chess with a pigeon so I will not post back to you further.

Ok I think that is best as I am not sure it helps the OP arguing about it
  • who paid towards the glasses as the voucher did not cover it all.

But that said she should still go to the Opticians and asked for them to be fixed as unless it has snapped off it should be fairly easy to do (as a glasses wearer)

Pyewhacket · 16/03/2022 11:40

@SafelySoftly

He’s your child!! I’d walk through fire for them. Your son is missing out, just pay for them!
Agree totally. Stop playing games.
AllOfUsAreDead · 16/03/2022 11:37

@WutheringHeights66

I can’t get over dad and SM not automatically replacing them. It’s his child FFS too that was under his care at the time and I would imagine if you had stood on them you wouldn’t look for him to pay?

I wouldn’t leave my child with a sight impairment but what is dad and his wife doing about it since they broke them?

Common sense says if someone breaks the property of someone else they repair or replace surely?

This. Amazing how many people are calling op a bad mum, but the dad is getting let off with it. Hmm

Just get them sorted op, it should be him, but he's clearly a useless dumbass twat who couldn't find his own arse with a map, so can hardly expect him to be useful. Your kids will eventually see the truth when they are older, and if they don't, more fool them.

Quincythequince · 16/03/2022 11:32

Whatever quartz! You keep posting extreme non-examples and Inaccuracies (your first post included) and so stands to be corrected.

Is said kids glasses are free, you said they weren’t!
You are wrong!

But engaging with you is like playing chess with a pigeon so I will not post back to you further.

Quartz2208 · 16/03/2022 11:29

I really don't know why you are arguing with me here. As you have said we are both arguing over semantics and both being pedantic. My initial statement that you picked up on wasn't incorrect either. I don't understand why you are posting so much here.

@howtomoveforwards as you seem to have been the one who paid for them - I think the best course is to see what the opticians can do. I have plastic frames I slept on and the arm was wonky. I was sure they would be unfixable and cost. But they were easily fixed.

Because you are the one though who did pay I think that probably does mean it is easiest for you to do it Im afraid. Things like this do perhaps need to be ironed out now he has moved to his Dads. Because at some point I think you are going to have to let his Dad take responsibility for these things