Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest that if you have been disinherited

110 replies

Beedance · 15/03/2022 17:35

You should consult a lawyer.

OP posts:
CrowUpNorth · 16/03/2022 13:39

Yes if you think they are being coerced or otherwise taken advantage of, or if you are a dependent - otherwise no, its up to them what they do with their money even if they are being mean.

Brefugee · 16/03/2022 13:38

I think anyone leaving any kind of will, estate or legacy should be aware that if they don't treat their children the same (or all their grandchildren the same as one another, or even treat nephews and nieces the same as other nephews and nieces or whatever, though less significant than own direct descendants) there is an incredibly high chance of destroying relationships between the people they leave behind.

meh Why should they care? they'll be dead.

I think that not enough people think about wills so that with blended families, you can have someone die, and their new spouse and their children inherit the family home, jewellery and so on and the biological children of the deceased get nothing, and it hadn't been intended like that.

Open and frank discussion while you are alive and in posession of all marbles is esential.

Stillfunny · 16/03/2022 13:27

I took an elderly relative to live with and care for her. When she needed to make a new will as people in it were now deceased or elderly themselves , the solicitor, in front of me , told her that he thought I should inherit her house. I think this is done.
I know my sister will kick off as she might have expected equal shares . She had done occasional shopping and meals- which she was paid for . But that was before I took this relation in . I know and I think most people know that I do deserve this . And she will get some cash . But I fear her sense of entitlement will cause a huge rift between. Unfortunately due to divorce , I won't be in a position to give her anything and even then , there may be other cousins seeking money.

Thoosa · 16/03/2022 13:16

People who say it's cruel or manipulative tend to miss out the massive back story.

Sometimes children are poisonous. Sometimes parents are poisonous. You can’t generalise, and it’s quite hard to guess from the outside.

Often in dysfunctional dynamics, an awful lot of masking goes on, presenting a public front to the world. Folly to imagine other people’s families are easy to understand.

DetailMouse · 16/03/2022 13:14

My Dad has always said you need to leave everything equally because no matter how much the disinherited child deserves it, you leave all the aggravation and upset to the ones you intended to favour.

girlmom21 · 16/03/2022 13:11

@housemaus

(I'm sorry to those of you who were disinherited out of cruelty or for manipulative purposes, of course - that is horrible. But I hate the common perception that it's always wrong or unfair - it's not!)
People who say it's cruel or manipulative tend to miss out the massive back story.
housemaus · 16/03/2022 12:58

(I'm sorry to those of you who were disinherited out of cruelty or for manipulative purposes, of course - that is horrible. But I hate the common perception that it's always wrong or unfair - it's not!)

housemaus · 16/03/2022 12:57

Having been involved (peripherally) in a 'sibling disinherited' situation - I can't think of anyone who deserved it more, to be honest. And the lawyer he attempted to engage presumably said the same, between tears of laughter, as after he announced he had an appointment with a lawyer to discuss it, we've not heard anything since.

Nobody 'deserves' inheritance, but some people absolutely do deserve to see the consequences of their actions.

It's not always clear cut.

Thoosa · 16/03/2022 12:55

I’m glad you’re free of her poison @QuebecBagnet

QuebecBagnet · 16/03/2022 12:53

It was definitely the intention when my mother died. And just in case I hadn’t got the message she sent me a letter after her death saying how much she hated me and she wished me unhappiness and suffering for the rest of my life. 😂😂

Thisisawfuliknow · 16/03/2022 12:44

@Nicholethejewellery

Unless you're a dependant or have evidence of illegality there's probably no point contesting a will in England or Wales no - but people leaving "unfair" wills should be reconciled to the fact that doing so might very well permanently destroy any relationship between the descendants they leave behind.

This exactly. A will is basically someone's last communication with their relatives. Doing anything other than being very obviously fair is a big "Fxxx You" to the person who is being treated "unfairly". Some people will want to do that of course, they enjoy the power of being able to cause distress even after they die, but it's not very nice.

That is exactly it - the spite and meanness that a person can deliberately use to try to cause irreparable splits between those left behind. In DH case, it hasn't worked, but both DH and I believe that was the intention.
thinking123 · 16/03/2022 11:36

Is this inspired by a recently deleted thread

Manekinek0 · 16/03/2022 11:25

The only reason I would be in my mother's will is because she would worry how others would perceive her if she left me out. I wouldn't be surprised nor would I care if she left me nothing. She has already told me she wishes I had never been born. I wouldn't give her the satisfaction of wasting my time and money to contest her will.

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 16/03/2022 10:51

@Supersimkin2

In the UK and US you can do what your want with your money.

Disinheriting someone is cruel. Some people like being cruel especially when unlike most forms of cruelty this is legal.

Do you know that there is more to the UK than just England?

Have you heard of Scotland? You cannot disininherit your children in Scotland. So no, you cannot do whatever you want everywhere in the UK.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 16/03/2022 10:46

@MissAmbrosia @JellybeansJelly
It reminded me of Zeebruge too. But not as skilful!

notanothertakeaway · 16/03/2022 10:46

@DetailMouse

As I understand it in England there are only grounds for challenge if you were financially dependent.

In other countries (France, Scotland?) you can't disinherited your children.

Out of interest, does anyone know what children have to do to prove their claim? An unacknowledged child, for example

I would assume DNA test would be required to establish parentage
notanothertakeaway · 16/03/2022 10:44

@girlmom21

If you don't want someone contesting a will give them a smaller inheritance. If you've got £100,000 to split between two give them £10,000 and leave the rest to the other person.

Most judges won't overrule a will if everyone is left something, even if it's not their 'fair' share.

That's advice we've been given by a solicitor.

@girlmom21 Yes, I've heard that before

I think the logic is that it makes it clear that the testator had all three children A, B & C in mind when the will was prepared. Makes it harder for B & C to argue that the testator must have had dementia and forgot about them

Nicholethejewellery · 16/03/2022 10:42

Unless you're a dependant or have evidence of illegality there's probably no point contesting a will in England or Wales no - but people leaving "unfair" wills should be reconciled to the fact that doing so might very well permanently destroy any relationship between the descendants they leave behind.

This exactly. A will is basically someone's last communication with their relatives. Doing anything other than being very obviously fair is a big "Fxxx You" to the person who is being treated "unfairly". Some people will want to do that of course, they enjoy the power of being able to cause distress even after they die, but it's not very nice.

Thoosa · 16/03/2022 10:41

Not much point unless it’s a French will.

Inheritance nastiness is foul, though. I have no idea why anyone would want upset as their legacy.

StopStartStop · 16/03/2022 10:40

My parents were cunts, and told me my brother was to get everything. Presumably because he has a penis.

I later discovered that my father thought he was not my biological father. He is, but my mum must also have had her doubts.

notanothertakeaway · 16/03/2022 10:39

@LemonViolets

I’m genuinely interested to know why?

Inheritance isn’t guaranteed and there is no legal entitlement to inheritance.
A person can legally leave their entire estate to whomever they please.

Not in Scotland...........

People should be very careful of offering / taking legal advice from well-meaning strangers on the internet

ThatsNotItAtAll · 16/03/2022 10:37

Whilst I completely agree that as Slippy78 and others say nobody should expect an inheritance and elderly parents (or anyone else) should spend freely to make their own lives and old age especially comfortable and enjoyable, or indeed donate/ leave a legacy freely to well established, transparently accountable reputable charities ... I think anyone leaving any kind of will, estate or legacy should be aware that if they don't treat their children the same (or all their grandchildren the same as one another, or even treat nephews and nieces the same as other nephews and nieces or whatever, though less significant than own direct descendants) there is an incredibly high chance of destroying relationships between the people they leave behind.

If you leave your house to your son and nothing to your daughter, or leave one set of grandchildren 10k each and the other set a piece of jewelry without value each then no matter how ungrabby those people are they'll feel that you didn't love them equally.

Inheritance destroys relationships between family left behind where it's ostensibly very unfair, because it usually looks like a continuation of life long favouritism and rejection.

Sometimes manipulation and coercion is done by aslow drip over a year or a decade and could never really be proved.

Unless you're a dependant or have evidence of illegality there's probably no point contesting a will in England or Wales no - but people leaving "unfair" wills should be reconciled to the fact that doing so might very well permanently destroy any relationship between the descendants they leave behind.

snoozeysleepy · 16/03/2022 10:34

I'm a solicitor and I speclialise in challenging wills and making claims for reasonable financial from estates.

There are many cases where, with modern family set-ups, second marriages etc, a cohabitee or young children don't inherit. What if you've been living with someone in their house, not married, have young children, and they die without a will? You get nothing.

What if an elderly relative, who is reliant on neighbours for help, is coerced into changing their will?

What if you gave up a job, and moved in with a parent/grandparent to care for them on the understanding that you would inherit their house but the will doesn't say this?

For as many people that say they/their partner won't take any action, there are those that need help.

It's always worth having an initial chat with a solicitor.

GabriellaMontez · 16/03/2022 10:27

I agree. Especially if the deceased has young children and deliberately avoids providing for them.

JellybeansJelly · 16/03/2022 10:21

@SpiderinaWingMirror

The other thread was the plot of a very poorly written novella. It reminded me of the writer in After Life.
Were there any more updates before it was taken down? On one hand I could see it happening but on the other, it was unbelievable!
Swipe left for the next trending thread