Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest that if you have been disinherited

110 replies

Beedance · 15/03/2022 17:35

You should consult a lawyer.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GnomeDePlume · 17/03/2022 21:05

@ancientgran I wrote favouring in the sense that you would be treating him differently from your other DGCs.

In the circumstances you have described it seems that there is a certain level of estrangement from his parents. If you were to die while he is still in childhood should you consider leaving the majority of your estate to him? Possibly in some sort of trust? This could then be used to ensure he still keeps a roof over his head.

Are you able to have open and honest conversations with your DCs? If they can see your reasoning they may be supportive of seeing this DGC being the majority or sole beneficiary of your will. Effectively you would be treating him as a dependent child.

JudgeJ · 17/03/2022 20:56

@thecatsthecats

My mum ended up falling out with her siblings when they jointly contested and won their dispute against the other sibling.

Only now none of them are talking, and most of the money was unreclaimable and went on lawyers.

I can acquire money in plenty of ways that don't damage my mental health or that of others. But then I think that about a lot of MN threads where people wind up the OP to pursue what is right, mindless to the damage that they cause in the process.

Unless there is a huge estate then the only winners in contested wills are the lawyers, see Jarndyce v Jarndyce!

When parents remarry they should take advice on their will however to protect the interests of their children's future, especially where there is an imbalance between the new couple's finances.

JustLyra · 17/03/2022 20:52

I think it does depend on circumstances. I'm struggling with it. I have 4 children, 6 GC. I suppose the logical thing (fair thing?) would be to split majority between kids and something for each GC but one GC is very close to me, lives with me and in some ways feels more like my son than my own sons do. Do I leave him more than the other GC? Do I reduce what his parent gets? Do I just leave him the same as the other GC? I'm finding it quite difficult.

That would depend on the circumstances of him loving with you and if he always has.

My paternal GP’s split (in a complicated way) my father’s share between my siblings and I as they cared for his after his abuse came to light.
My maternal grandparents cut my mother out for the same reason, but opted just to split their estate between their two other children. My mother and one of their other children predeceased them and they chose to leave their other child’s share to their children, but not my mothers.

ancientgran · 17/03/2022 20:50

[quote GnomeDePlume]@ancientgran IMO remember that this will may be in place long beyond the time when your DGS is still living with you.

While favouring the DGS may seem right now, in a few years time it may seem a lot less fair especially if DGS' relationship with you has changed as life happens to them and you.

To an extent it depends on the age of DGS and the reason why he is living with you. Is he dependent on you?[/quote]
I don't see it as favouring him. He feels like my son so should I treat him like my son? I do now, sort out school issues, wash his clothes, make sure he has enough to eat and sleep etc. I love all my GC but the others are GC, I didn't give birth to him but then if I'd adopted a child he'd be mine even if I hadn't given birth to him. Of course the other thing is the others have parents who are caring for them, they don't see me as a parent in the way he does and they shouldn't.

It is difficult but his parents aren't together, neither of his step parents are exactly welcoming. He has always spent the majority of his time with me since he was a toddler until he moved in completely, changed schools to our local school.

I can always change a will if things change between us but then again would I change a will if life changed my relationship with the children I gave birth to?

I think it is complicated and I'm not sure what the answer is but I don't see it as being as straightforward as everyone gets an equal share.

GnomeDePlume · 17/03/2022 20:37

@ancientgran IMO remember that this will may be in place long beyond the time when your DGS is still living with you.

While favouring the DGS may seem right now, in a few years time it may seem a lot less fair especially if DGS' relationship with you has changed as life happens to them and you.

To an extent it depends on the age of DGS and the reason why he is living with you. Is he dependent on you?

ancientgran · 17/03/2022 16:23

@Brefugee

I think anyone leaving any kind of will, estate or legacy should be aware that if they don't treat their children the same (or all their grandchildren the same as one another, or even treat nephews and nieces the same as other nephews and nieces or whatever, though less significant than own direct descendants) there is an incredibly high chance of destroying relationships between the people they leave behind.

meh Why should they care? they'll be dead.

I think that not enough people think about wills so that with blended families, you can have someone die, and their new spouse and their children inherit the family home, jewellery and so on and the biological children of the deceased get nothing, and it hadn't been intended like that.

Open and frank discussion while you are alive and in posession of all marbles is esential.

I think it does depend on circumstances. I'm struggling with it. I have 4 children, 6 GC. I suppose the logical thing (fair thing?) would be to split majority between kids and something for each GC but one GC is very close to me, lives with me and in some ways feels more like my son than my own sons do. Do I leave him more than the other GC? Do I reduce what his parent gets? Do I just leave him the same as the other GC? I'm finding it quite difficult.
ancientgran · 17/03/2022 16:17

@GnomeDePlume

I do know of a will where the beneficiaries had to prove by DNA that they were the DCs of the parent who had died.

If the beneficiaries decided not to do the test then the estate would go to the charity named in the disaster clause. The charity forced the issue so DCs did their tests. One DC was not the biological offspring of the parent.

The will had been written shortly after a messy divorce, possibly with the intention of getting back at the ex wife.

Fortunately the DC who inherited split the inheritance 50/50 with the disinherited sibling.

Well done to them. I know people say you have to respect the deceased's wishes but once the money is yours it is your wishes that count.
Giggorata · 17/03/2022 15:40

My adoptive parents made their wills in the seventies when they retired and basically left everything to my brother, on the understanding that he would be the one living locally and looking out for them, especially if my father predeceased my mother, which is what happened.
My sister and I were left some money each which probably seemed substantial in the seventies. When DM died in 2001, it wasn't. So DB and SIL ended up living in a million pound house with grounds and my DS bought a posh sofa with her inheritance. I think I bought a long case clock with mine.
Fair enough, as DB had been there for them.
I could wish though that my brother had given me something personal of my mother's as a keepsake. I asked for one of the rings that she wore daily but was told no.

Supersimkin2 · 17/03/2022 15:10

I’ve also known of DNA demands on wills. Filthy behaviour cos the beneficiaries didn’t know they were donor eggs.

GnomeDePlume · 17/03/2022 12:02

I do know of a will where the beneficiaries had to prove by DNA that they were the DCs of the parent who had died.

If the beneficiaries decided not to do the test then the estate would go to the charity named in the disaster clause. The charity forced the issue so DCs did their tests. One DC was not the biological offspring of the parent.

The will had been written shortly after a messy divorce, possibly with the intention of getting back at the ex wife.

Fortunately the DC who inherited split the inheritance 50/50 with the disinherited sibling.

LimoncelloMadness · 17/03/2022 11:35

@girlmom21

If you don't want someone contesting a will give them a smaller inheritance. If you've got £100,000 to split between two give them £10,000 and leave the rest to the other person.

Most judges won't overrule a will if everyone is left something, even if it's not their 'fair' share.

That's advice we've been given by a solicitor.

Not true at all. I successfully disputed a will and had been left a five figure sum already.
veevee04 · 17/03/2022 11:23

It depends for instance if a father ends up leaving everything to a step mother and she tries to cut the children out of the will. I would challenge as I know my dad intended money would be shared between the children.

LetsGoCrazyPurpleBanana · 17/03/2022 11:16

My dad told me he wanted to disinherit my brother as he had caused him nothing but heartbreak. Unfortunately he never got to change his will before he died.

5128gap · 17/03/2022 10:47

An unfair will is not the cause of ruined relationships between descendents, thats down to how those people behave afterwards. No one forces a beneficiary to keep all the money and not share, and no one forces the disinherited to take out their resentment on their more fortunate relatives if they don't. If getting or keeping hold of the deceased's money is more important to people than their relationships with their remaining family, that's on them.

WetLookKnitwear · 17/03/2022 10:27

@girlmom21 I said it was manipulative (only sometimes obviously). My BIL was threatened with being disinherited because he was in a relationship with someone of a different race. Another one of my teenage relatives was threatened with being written out of a will because she left a room in a real mess after staying over. No deep backstory either time.

Obviously some people will feign innocent disbelief when they find themselves disinherited after years of being a shit to the person who’s gone, but sometimes it is a matter of someone lashing out.

Beedance · 16/03/2022 19:01

I apologise for a badly worded OP. You are all completely right and as this is, carefully but incompetently, not a TAAT IABU.

On the other hand if it was a TAAT IWNBU but by definition IWBU so U either way.

I do hope that anyone who was a child when losing a parent would get good legal advice if it subsequently emerged a relative had misappropriated their parent’s estate.

OP posts:
dottypencilcase · 16/03/2022 16:07

@ElementalIllusions

When my mum dies I will only be inheriting 1/5th of the estate she has worked her entire like to build up (with no help from family and as a single parent) instead of the half I should have and would have gotten up until last year. That’s because my mum decided to marry a man she has only known for a few years who has no estate at all, but does have three children he barely sees who he wants to inherit half of ‘what is now half his’.

I’m sad that everything my mum worked her whole adult life for is mostly going to strangers she doesn’t know, but it is her decision, and it’s her money and assets to leave how she wants.

Did you have a thread about this recently? I remember thinking it'd never happen. I'm sorry to hear it has/will.
JustLyra · 16/03/2022 15:46

but people leaving "unfair" wills should be reconciled to the fact that doing so might very well permanently destroy any relationship between the descendants they leave behind.

They also need to be aware, sadly, that even if an unfair looking will is actually fair it’ll still likely cause trouble.

When my Grandad died I was 12 and lived with my Nana. She was acutely aware that I could end up homeless if she died. So she moved us to a small flat that was willed to me. She divided up everything else between two of her children and my siblings (my siblings and I were to get our father’s share as he’d been disowned by GP’s for abusing us). They all agreed, I’m the youngest of my siblings by almost 8 years, as the amounts were almost the same. Aunt & uncle used the money to upsize, siblings used it as a deposit.

Despite the fact that when she died my signing away my share to the other bits meaning the difference was less than a few hundred pounds, and I offered to balance that, I’m still the one that “got everything”.

Inheritance brings out the worst in many people sadly. Fair, unfair or otherwise.

Movinghouseatlast · 16/03/2022 15:36

Yes, I agree it may have changed nothing. I feel so sorry for him; as he lost everything. The stepmother inherited around 7 million all told, the 'loan' was £300,000 and she knew it was a gift dressed up as a loan to avoid tax. People can be so unbelievably horrible.

notanothertakeaway · 16/03/2022 14:44

@Movinghouseatlast

I agree.

My friend was disinherited by his dad who left everything to his wife, my friends stepmother who was 40 years younger than his dad, a 5 year marriage.

His dad had leant him money to buy a flat- it was only a loan for tax purposes but after the dad died the stepmother took my friend to court and won the flat.

My friend and his wife and child were left homeless. He had a breakdown and was sectioned. His wife divorced him. He should have disputed the will.

@Movinghouseatlast

What a tragic outcome for your friend

But, disputing the will might not have led to a better outcome. You say "it was only a loan for tax purposes", but a loan is a loan

I know a couple of families where parent A dies, parent B remarries, B leaves everything to their new spouse and the child(ren) of A&B receive nothing. It's a terrible outcome, but really the onus is on B to ensure they provide for their children

Fatgalslim · 16/03/2022 14:20

My brother will be getting nothing when my mum dies, she hasn't been cruel or unfair, he's a complete scumbag who for reasons I won't go into, doesn't deserve anything.

I'm reassured by this thread that he won't be able to make a claim

ExConstance · 16/03/2022 13:51

I certainly think you should get legal advice as opposed to asking random internet strangers on Mumsnet about it. The "change the locks" standard of knowledge of the law usually comes out in force for the inheritance threads.

Movinghouseatlast · 16/03/2022 13:47

I agree.

My friend was disinherited by his dad who left everything to his wife, my friends stepmother who was 40 years younger than his dad, a 5 year marriage.

His dad had leant him money to buy a flat- it was only a loan for tax purposes but after the dad died the stepmother took my friend to court and won the flat.

My friend and his wife and child were left homeless. He had a breakdown and was sectioned. His wife divorced him. He should have disputed the will.

Mydoghealsmyheart · 16/03/2022 13:42

@ThatsNotItAtAll

Whilst I completely agree that as Slippy78 and others say nobody should expect an inheritance and elderly parents (or anyone else) should spend freely to make their own lives and old age especially comfortable and enjoyable, or indeed donate/ leave a legacy freely to well established, transparently accountable reputable charities ... I think anyone leaving any kind of will, estate or legacy should be aware that if they don't treat their children the same (or all their grandchildren the same as one another, or even treat nephews and nieces the same as other nephews and nieces or whatever, though less significant than own direct descendants) there is an incredibly high chance of destroying relationships between the people they leave behind.

If you leave your house to your son and nothing to your daughter, or leave one set of grandchildren 10k each and the other set a piece of jewelry without value each then no matter how ungrabby those people are they'll feel that you didn't love them equally.

Inheritance destroys relationships between family left behind where it's ostensibly very unfair, because it usually looks like a continuation of life long favouritism and rejection.

Sometimes manipulation and coercion is done by aslow drip over a year or a decade and could never really be proved.

Unless you're a dependant or have evidence of illegality there's probably no point contesting a will in England or Wales no - but people leaving "unfair" wills should be reconciled to the fact that doing so might very well permanently destroy any relationship between the descendants they leave behind.

Well said, it’s our bitter experience of exactly this happening.
SirGawain · 16/03/2022 13:42

Contesting a will is likely to wind up like Jarndyce versus Jarndyce.