Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect DH to take shared parental leave if he wants a second child

138 replies

FeministBadger · 15/03/2022 17:04

Over the weekend, DH raised the question of when we'd start trying for a second child. DH wants to start trying sooner and I want a bigger gap particularly as I found maternity leave difficult.

I said I'd be happy to have a smaller gap if DH took shared parental leave which he said wouldn't work with his job. However his company is really generous with SPL and he could get full pay for 6 months even if I'd taken 6 months too so the only problem would be the same issues any woman in his role would face. His solution is we could get a nanny.

This has really annoyed me - I accept DH can't share the pregnancy and birth parts but it seems he doesn't want to do anything that could impact on his career even though he is the one wanting a second kid sooner. Aibu to make him taking SPL a requirement for us ttc?

OP posts:
Teeturtle · 15/03/2022 21:21

But at the same time I am so angry that he can have it all still and that he doesn’t want to share the impact and it doesn’t even occur to him to do so, because obviously maternity leave is for women

I got your point initially, but as I read on it feels like you seem to be blaming your husband for all the inequality in the world and you want to punish him. If it were the case that one of you had to take leave, I would see your point about sharing it, but that isn’t the case, there is the nanny option. Your seem to have the attitude that you didn’t like maternity leave and therefore he should have to do it and you are hoping he will dislike it as much as you did.

AtLeastThreeDrinks · 15/03/2022 21:11

@FeministBadger

Serious question though - what's wrong with getting a nanny when the baby is 6 months if you can afford it If?

Well see this is where I think I may be being unreasonable because really there isn't anything wrong with it except it's him not wanting to take the same hit that I can't avoid.

I don’t think is unreasonable. It sounds like you want another child and you want them to bond with a parent as their primary carer, not a nanny. And at another level, you want your husband to understand what it’s actually like looking after a child full-time.

I get it, I feel the same. We could get a nanny for a second, but I actually think my partner and I would really benefit from switching roles for a time. There’s been a lot of “you don’t understand what it’s like” from both sides!

Kite22 · 15/03/2022 21:09

@MintyFreshBreath

YABU to make it a requirement for TTC. It seems a bit like you’re cutting your nose off to spite your face tbh, given that you want a baby at some point anyway. You’re a more experienced mum this time so maybe you won’t find it as hard. Also, does he have to take the full 6 months? Do you think you actually want him to take the full 6 months or do you just like the idea of it? Maybe, you should just talk to him and set out your expectations of what he HAS to do if he chooses to only take the bare minimum of leave. That could be anything. Examples I can think of..fair share of night feeds/lie ins/housework. I’m just trying to be devil’s advocate with the questions by the way. Whatever works well for you is best so good luck ❤️
I'm inclined to agree with this. Obviously, if you have a 2nd child then you are the one who has to be pregnant and give birth, but if you didn't enjoy maternity leave with dc1, then don't take so long with dc 2 would seem to be the answer - which you seem to be 100% okay with. But I don't see what you would be gaining by insisting on him taking paternity leave, when he doesn't want to Confused. You've already discovered that not everyone considers looking after a tiny baby 24/7 to be a fun way to spend your life, so I don't understand why you would want to impose it upon someone else who doesn't want to either, when you could go back to work and your little one could go to a childminder, a Nursery or a Nanny could look after them. It comes across as you trying to make a point rather than there being any logic behind it. Many parents love their children with all their heart, but it doesn't mean they want to spend24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 52 weeks a year looking after them, when they have a choice, which you both do.
StyleDesperation · 15/03/2022 21:01

Does he take an equal share of jobs that can't be outsourced? For example night wakings with DC, laundry, cooking etc. If he does, then maybe hiring a nanny isn't such a bad idea, if he doesn't then it just smacks of I'll pay someone to do the bits I don't want to do, and if I can't pay someone, my wife will do it for free.

Have you discussed with him the hit your career has taken and how you would like him to make a similar compromise with DC2 so that you can rebuild your career? How he responds to that would also tell you a lot.

FeministBadger · 15/03/2022 20:40

Serious question though - what's wrong with getting a nanny when the baby is 6 months if you can afford it If?

Well see this is where I think I may be being unreasonable because really there isn't anything wrong with it except it's him not wanting to take the same hit that I can't avoid.

OP posts:
FeministBadger · 15/03/2022 20:35

@UpToMyElbowsInDiapers that is what I would ideally want DH to do. I think he lacks the guts to take a stand against his company and yes, it does impact on my respect for him.

I'm certainly not going to be jumping to ttc any time soon until this question is resolved.

OP posts:
ForeverSingle881 · 15/03/2022 20:35

If he wants another child, he needs to accept it will impact his career (something women learned a long time ago!). I would be reluctant to agree to a 2nd child as he might make the right noises and then change his mind.

Serious question though - what's wrong with getting a nanny when the baby is 6 months if you can afford it If?

DPotter · 15/03/2022 20:27

his company is really generous with SPL and he could get full pay for 6 months

Now you see the cynic in me thinks - yes, the company offers full pay for SPL, but then promotes a culture where no one will take it, so they can look good, and it not cost them a bean.

You're not wrong - he steps up to do his bit so you can re-build your career.

AliceW89 · 15/03/2022 20:09

YADNBU at all OP. I struggled massively on maternity leave. It didn’t help that a lot of it was lockdown…but I think it would be similar even in normal times. My head felt completely full yet somehow completely empty at the same time. Even if DH turned round and said he’d take the whole year off it’d still be a no until I’m ready for everything another pregnancy and baby comes with. In your circumstances it be a hard no until DH realises your career/finances/health matter just as much as his. Stand firm, because I can’t even imagine how hard an unplanned 2 under 2 would be.

Moancup · 15/03/2022 20:03

I’d be fuming. YANBU.

Companies that pay generous SPL are as rare as hens’ teeth. They only do it because of some level they recognise it’s the right thing to do. I really doubt a company that introduces six month paid leave has a culture that is incompatible with senior men taking it!

If a toxic culture does exist he is part of the problem promoting it. Deeply unattractive.

If he wants a child he helps care for it.

BarbaraofSeville · 15/03/2022 20:00

As I said, in order to make it the norm, more men need to stick their necks out. And make HR cases if this then affects their promotion prospects etc

Exactly. The biggest boost for equality in the workplace would be for men to take equal responsibility for child rearing and the domestic mental load. To be equally likely to take extended parental leave, time off in the school holidays, adjust their working day or leave work on time to do pickups rather than hiding at the office until DC are in bed, have to take time off at short notice for sick days etc etc.

Because if men are doing half of it, promotions and opportunities are less likely to go to the ones who can work late, travel, take less time off, etc etc, which is disproportionately men who leave all the child and home responsibilities to their female partners then they're the ones who get ahead and so the cycle continues, because they see the committed/reliable ones as those who are able to put work first more.

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 15/03/2022 20:00

My DH was a high performer in an engineering company. In his department there were 35 people, of whom exactly zero were women. His VP had actually admitted to him that they don’t hire women “because they’re a liability”. Men whose wives had just given birth would be back in the office 2 days later. They had no parental leave policy beyond what is required by law... and no one ever took that.

When we had our DC1, I took 9 months off and then DH took 3 months when I went back to work. A LOOOOOT of eyebrows were raised and some less than supportive comments were made. But: he developed a thick skin. I earned 3x what he did at the time, and my mat leave top up only covered 4 months, so we were taking a massive financial hit for every additional month I was off. Also, he was excited to be a dad and wanted to have some meaningful time one on one with our DC.

I swear he’s a more competent dad and supportive partner now than most of my friends’ DHs, and I credit his dedicated pat leave to quite a lot of that. I think some studies from Sweden support that.

And - 5 other young dads at work took several weeks or months off when they had kids, and thanked my DH for making them feel like they could.

DH’s direct managers were still super impressed with him and promoted him shortly after he returned from time off with DC1, and again after time off with DC2.

The VP was not impressed. But who cares? This same VP said to all 35 engineers near the end of the first COVID lockdown “stop f**ing babysitting and get back to the office”. DH quit shortly thereafter, as did 20% of the department, and he’s landed a great new job.

All this to say - other men have taken the plunge even when it’s scary, and it’s been worth it to support their partner and develop a bond with their babies!!!

oblada · 15/03/2022 20:00

I wouldn't want another child with a man who wouldn't jump at the opportunity to take 6months on full pay to be with his newborn. Who either actually thinks he is so important he cannot be away from work for that time (deluded and arrogant) or unable to challenge the status quo in his company if they are genuinely that backwards (lacking in guts and morals)... If his company is that bad who doesn't he move to somewhere better? Take the 6m off and find a better place. Why would he want to contribute to the success of a misogynist machine??

mintbiscuit · 15/03/2022 19:56

Until men do shared parental leave we have no chance of fixing the gender pay gap (which contributes massively to the gender savings gap).

But of course they won’t in any meaningful numbers…Hmm

BulletTrain · 15/03/2022 19:55

TBH people make it pretty obvious to mothers how inconvenient it is. Mothers are just used to be treated like that.

Of course. But the real shitheads about working parents just don't hire women in their 30s in the first place. I don't know if you've ever looked for a job as a 34 year old woman with a one year old, but it was hard.

GabriellaMontez · 15/03/2022 19:49

It's absolutely your choice. But I think his suggestion of getting a nanny is quite good.

Luredbyapomegranate · 15/03/2022 19:42

@BulletTrain

I meant "in fairness" to him, a lot of employers are not up on shared parental leave and are at great pains to point out to male employees what an inconvenience it is. Basically, the attitude of the boss is the same as it is to picking up sick kids from school at 11am. "Why can't mum do it".

As I said, in order to make it the norm, more men need to stick their necks out. And make HR cases if this then affects their promotion prospects etc.

TBH people make it pretty obvious to mothers how inconvenient it is. Mothers are just used to be treated like that.

However, the attitude to fathers taking parental leave or doing 4 days a week, or leaving early for pick ups has changed a lot in 10 years - so don’t let him over egg that OP. It’s handy for him isn’t it ? I doubt they are quite as clueless as he says - especially not if they are a company of any size. Insist he talks to HR and don’t take any nonsense.

PriestessofPing · 15/03/2022 19:20

No, i’d not have another child with someone who expected my career to take a double hit while they risked nothing in theirs. Not to mention actually having to carry the pregnancy and the aftermath. No way.

FeministBadger · 15/03/2022 19:15

@BulletTrain

I meant "in fairness" to him, a lot of employers are not up on shared parental leave and are at great pains to point out to male employees what an inconvenience it is. Basically, the attitude of the boss is the same as it is to picking up sick kids from school at 11am. "Why can't mum do it".

As I said, in order to make it the norm, more men need to stick their necks out. And make HR cases if this then affects their promotion prospects etc.

Yes this is basically his office. That's what frustrates me so much. I know there's quite a realistic chance that if he does do this he'll be the poster boy for how progressive the company are, and then quickly sidelined into a diversity role where he won't impact on customer deliverables.

But at the same time, I am so angry that he can have it all still and that he doesn't want to share the impact and it doesn't even occur to him to do so, because obviously maternity leave is for women.

OP posts:
stimpyyouidiot · 15/03/2022 18:54

My husband would absolutely JUMP at the chance if he got full pay. It's a total no brainer.

BulletTrain · 15/03/2022 18:53

I meant "in fairness" to him, a lot of employers are not up on shared parental leave and are at great pains to point out to male employees what an inconvenience it is. Basically, the attitude of the boss is the same as it is to picking up sick kids from school at 11am. "Why can't mum do it".

As I said, in order to make it the norm, more men need to stick their necks out. And make HR cases if this then affects their promotion prospects etc.

Luredbyapomegranate · 15/03/2022 18:52

Absolutely. And I’d really call him out on this - he doesn’t want to do it because he CBA or thinks it will damage his career. So how is that supportive to you or women in general?

The schedule is yours to set.

M0RVEN · 15/03/2022 18:51

He doesn’t want his career to be affected, he wants yours to be doubly affected instead.

What a prince among men Hmm

Rodedooda · 15/03/2022 18:46

It may actually help his career.

Wait until you're physically and emotionally ready regardless, agree that he may say yes to get you to agree.

Nothing wrong with not having any more children at all.

BrinksmansEntry · 15/03/2022 18:46

Sorry, he gets 6 months full pay?! That is amazing and I would expect him to have fully justified reasons not to take that up. Any parental leave is for the benefit of the baby and family, and if one party is able to take advantage of a cracking offer like that, most parents would jump at the chance.

If he doesn't want to be side tracked or put on a slow lane then the solution is for him to take that out with his employer, not make you take full maternity leave and be disadvantaged. His solution can't be that he gains at your loss.

Swipe left for the next trending thread