Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect DH to take shared parental leave if he wants a second child

138 replies

FeministBadger · 15/03/2022 17:04

Over the weekend, DH raised the question of when we'd start trying for a second child. DH wants to start trying sooner and I want a bigger gap particularly as I found maternity leave difficult.

I said I'd be happy to have a smaller gap if DH took shared parental leave which he said wouldn't work with his job. However his company is really generous with SPL and he could get full pay for 6 months even if I'd taken 6 months too so the only problem would be the same issues any woman in his role would face. His solution is we could get a nanny.

This has really annoyed me - I accept DH can't share the pregnancy and birth parts but it seems he doesn't want to do anything that could impact on his career even though he is the one wanting a second kid sooner. Aibu to make him taking SPL a requirement for us ttc?

OP posts:
AlexaShutUp · 16/03/2022 07:40

He sounds incredibly sexist. That would be enough to put me off having a second child with him tbh. And I would tell him why.

2DogsOnMySofa · 16/03/2022 07:34

I'd be seriously considering if a second child is what you want. And let's face it, if he's not prepared to share mat leave, and you'll be the one responsible for it, plus taking the hit to you mental health and career, then it's no longer a joint decision, it's YOUR decision

Donotgogentle · 16/03/2022 07:10

@collieresponder88

I don't think it's ever good to start trying to make a baby when you are already arguing over who will look after it ! Your obviously not ready for this commitment. Not nice to bring a life into the world when neither of you want to make the sacrifices required to raise it
No, the op just doesn’t want to make all of the sacrifices.
girlmom21 · 16/03/2022 06:59

It's very telling that his 'very important job' that offers 6 months full pay (most women don't get that!) if he takes paternity leave might be impacted but he's happy for you to take that impact twice over.

collieresponder88 · 16/03/2022 06:56

I don't think it's ever good to start trying to make a baby when you are already arguing over who will look after it ! Your obviously not ready for this commitment. Not nice to bring a life into the world when neither of you want to make the sacrifices required to raise it

ThinWomansBrain · 16/03/2022 06:47

If he can't be bothered to take responsibility for a second child beyond financial, then maybe it's better not to have a second?

Donotgogentle · 16/03/2022 06:43

@FeministBadger

I'm certainly not hoping he'd have a miserable time of parental leave but I do think I am feeling aggrieved that he gets the easy option.

I have a lot of thoughts flying around that I'm trying to understand and this thread is really helping. The ones that feel fair are:

  • I want him to understand what it is like to be primary parent
  • He can get 6 months of full pay when I'd then be on zero pay, or we'd be paying for a nanny
  • He is expecting me to take maternity leave at a cost to my career when he is, at a minimum, very reluctant to do the same
  • He is the one actively pushing to have a second child sooner

Where I'm probably being unfair is:

  • I feel like our lives and his choices are the gender pay gap come to life
  • I feel like if men in general don't step up to take SPL nothing is ever going to change
  • I'm losing respect for DH for not wanting to be the one to challenge it in his workplace
  • I'd already be doing the pretty serious work of growing and birthing the baby so he could take a heavier load
Actually I don’t think your second set of bullet points is “unfair”, just that they’re broader points relating to sexism in society, rather than being individual to your DH.

Your DH’s attitude to challenging that sexism is still an important part of your relationship and how you view him.

I would be very wary of having a second child when your DH has said he doesn’t want childcare to impact his career. It’s not just about the SPL and deciding whether to outsource his parenting to a nanny. It will be days your child is sick and off nursery/school, or the pre school and after school care, etc. Or looking after the DC when you’re on holiday because your DH is busy working as god forbid he should disappoint his customers rather than his wife and child.

As they say on the Relationships board, he has shown you who he is, listen.

There are many women who are happy stepping back professionally when they have a baby leaving their DH to concentrate on his career. This is what you’re being asked to do, either that or accept a nanny will be your co-parent. You need to think very carefully about having another DC in those circumstances. There is nothing wrong with stopping at one and it may well save your relationship.

Dexy007 · 16/03/2022 06:42

Yes yes yes I wish so much that legislation would firstly force equalise parental leave provisions to match whatever companies offer women. And then yes, there should be 6 months for each parent - use it or lose it.

ThatsNotItAtAll · 16/03/2022 06:11

YANBU

I actually think men who father a baby should legally have to take 6 months parental leave... it's the only way the gender i.e. biological sex not gender - the maternity pay gap) will ever come meaningfully close to closing...

Simonjt · 16/03/2022 06:03

So he wants another baby, but he doesn’t actually want to raise his baby, instead he wants either you or a nanny to do that on his behalf. In that case, why does he want another baby?

UncomfortableBadger · 16/03/2022 05:57

YANBU OP - Currently pregnant with our first & prior to that I was firm with DH that it was 50:50 SPL or no children. He’s taking 6 months SPL. No enhanced pay above statutory but that’s not the point; it’s a question of principle, with a 50:50 work division being expected (and agreed) from the very outset.

bluedodecagon · 16/03/2022 05:50

Just don’t have another baby. You don’t want one and your DH has no intention of stepping up.

timeisnotaline · 16/03/2022 04:30

*get me ready

timeisnotaline · 16/03/2022 04:29

Imagine having a baby with someone who has spelt out they can take time to parent, but actually they won’t. My Dh has paternity leave available for the first time this baby (dc3) so he’s taking it, there’s no way I’d have a baby with him if he had this option and chose not to do it. He did start to cavill about the best time to start it for his work but I said I too chose the best time for my work- no wait I didn’t have any choice at all. You’ll take the time that works for us like I did, and you can empathise with all the women out there if anyone says anything.
I’m so looking forward to going back to work with Dh home! I can get up in the morning, get me read, and swan out the door, instead of my previous returns to work where you get children up and fed and dressed, try to make sure you aren’t wearing toothpaste and sprint out the door with stress levels skyrocketing. (Dh starts work early, he’s never usually around in the morning at all) I might pour some cereal on the floor as I walk out just to give him the full experience, before I go be professional Grin

Dexy007 · 16/03/2022 04:00

Sorry OP I’m being a bit strident but I’m just so shocked by this. Most of my male (and female!) friends are professionals earning well in excess of 6 figures at top firms in London - magic circle law firms, the Big 4 etc. They are by definition high flyers whose career really does suffer if they take SPL. But they also ironically work at places where full pay is available for both men and women (I agree with PP the firms are probably hoping their employees don’t take it up!) But without exception all of these men have taken SPL - in many cases for the full 6 months and in many cases for both kids.

They recognise their wives are not handmaidens - there to birth them a baby who they can admire at bathtime and high holidays.

My friend is married to a banker who didn’t take any SPL (on full pay) with either child. She resented it hugely and I’ve lost a lot of respect for her, particularly because after her first baby he was made redundant and it was her (very large) salary and esteemed career holding the fort until he got back on his feet. And yet she had another baby with the prick, because -exactly like your husband - he believed himself and his banking career to be so much more important than her career as a very well respected lawyer at an elite NY litigation boutique.

Dexy007 · 16/03/2022 03:48

I wouldn’t have a baby with him at all, even when you are feeling more ready yourself. His has literally told you neither you nor your children (present and future) are as important to him as his job. Yes people need to keep a roof over their heads but he would not be out of pocket financially AT ALL. I’m actually shocked. What a rat. He would rather incur 6 months of nanny fees than pitch in. No way. Not now and not ever - not fit to be a father, sorry.

Unless you are going to tell us some massive backstory about how he is within touching distance of making partner at a law firm where partners make £1m a year until they retire I think your husband’s attitude is awful.

When someone shows you who they are - listen!

Scottishskifun · 15/03/2022 23:49

Definitely not unreasonable. My DH takes SPL of 3 months even being a very hands on dad it was an eye opener for him and changed his whole approach to family time and why I wanted a bit of downtime occasionally child free! He suddenly got the 24hr nature of maternity leave!

2 under 2 is ridiculously hard if you want a second then as you say wait. Would he not even go for a compromise of 3 months?

I'm also quite concerned to hear that your company has sidelined you this is completely illegal!

SarahProblem · 15/03/2022 23:39

What it boils down to is you probably just shouldn't have a second child with him. He's not prepared to step up

violetbunny · 15/03/2022 23:39

I think a lot of posters are missing the bit where the OP said that in her last maternity leave her DH left all the decisions and responsibilities to her.

The bigger issue here is not just that he doesn't want to take paternity leave for a second child, it's that he sees child rearing as his wife's responsibility.

OP, even if you somehow get him to agree to take paternity leave, unless he changes this deep rooted belief you are going to find yourself stepping in to take responsibility anyway. How would you feel if he took paternity leave but still left most of the mental load to you? That could very well happen, and if so you might find yourself with a husband on leave who can't be trusted to actually care for two kids properly on his own.

TigerMTV · 15/03/2022 22:42

Come to think of it, I don’t know anyone who has taken paternal leave beyond about a month…

busyeatingbiscuits · 15/03/2022 22:21

It's important for him to take a significant chunk of parental leave because:
It will save you money as a family (the nanny will be, what? £3k a month?)
It's good for the baby to be cared for by a parent in their early months
It's good for both of you for him to be the "default parent" for at least a while and cover all the child admin, night wakings etc so you end up being equal parents

jeaux90 · 15/03/2022 22:20

He's got to be in tech right? Wall to wall male egos with no one possibly being able to manage without them.

The hilarious thing is HR will love him for taking it.

My previous tech firm take up was less than 2%

busyeatingbiscuits · 15/03/2022 22:16

@FeministBadger

Serious question though - what's wrong with getting a nanny when the baby is 6 months if you can afford it If?

Well see this is where I think I may be being unreasonable because really there isn't anything wrong with it except it's him not wanting to take the same hit that I can't avoid.

Take 3 months leave each and then nanny from 6 months?
TigerMTV · 15/03/2022 22:12

If you really don’t want to have mat leave- not sure it’s fair to force your OH to take it. However - he should surely take SOME PL. maybe a couple of months… to support you?

Then get a nanny… ?
(Assuming you can afford the nanny?)

I admit it would be hard to feel you are in a true partnership if he refuses to take any, and it might put me off too. Is he a hands on parent?

FeministBadger · 15/03/2022 21:34

I'm certainly not hoping he'd have a miserable time of parental leave but I do think I am feeling aggrieved that he gets the easy option.

I have a lot of thoughts flying around that I'm trying to understand and this thread is really helping. The ones that feel fair are:

  • I want him to understand what it is like to be primary parent
  • He can get 6 months of full pay when I'd then be on zero pay, or we'd be paying for a nanny
  • He is expecting me to take maternity leave at a cost to my career when he is, at a minimum, very reluctant to do the same
  • He is the one actively pushing to have a second child sooner

Where I'm probably being unfair is:

  • I feel like our lives and his choices are the gender pay gap come to life
  • I feel like if men in general don't step up to take SPL nothing is ever going to change
  • I'm losing respect for DH for not wanting to be the one to challenge it in his workplace
  • I'd already be doing the pretty serious work of growing and birthing the baby so he could take a heavier load
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread