Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect DH to take shared parental leave if he wants a second child

138 replies

FeministBadger · 15/03/2022 17:04

Over the weekend, DH raised the question of when we'd start trying for a second child. DH wants to start trying sooner and I want a bigger gap particularly as I found maternity leave difficult.

I said I'd be happy to have a smaller gap if DH took shared parental leave which he said wouldn't work with his job. However his company is really generous with SPL and he could get full pay for 6 months even if I'd taken 6 months too so the only problem would be the same issues any woman in his role would face. His solution is we could get a nanny.

This has really annoyed me - I accept DH can't share the pregnancy and birth parts but it seems he doesn't want to do anything that could impact on his career even though he is the one wanting a second kid sooner. Aibu to make him taking SPL a requirement for us ttc?

OP posts:
GabriellaMontez · 17/03/2022 08:15

Childcare for a 6 week old baby and the family unnecessarily spending £3k a month because dad wants a baby without having to do any parenting or impact his career

Many women make this choice and see it as an investment. Even though it costs for a short time. Is that OK? Or should those women be scorned for their choice?

billy1966 · 17/03/2022 08:05

@FeministBadger

Thanks for the input everyone.

I think actually a PP has it right, right now I cannot imagine having a second if it requires the same sacrifices as the first time round.

I had hoped DH would be willing to step up and take on an equal share next time but if that is in doubt I am happy stopping at one.

I am so glad to read your conclusion.

In your situation you should not consider another baby.

I don't think you want one at all, which is your choice.

A toddler and a new baby is relentless, there is no avoiding it.

Your husband is not in it with you if it impacts him at all.

He is quite happy for you, your life and career to take the full load of child bearing.

Not a chance should you even consider it.

An only child sounds just perfect.

Stick to one.

Protect yourself and enjoy what you have.

Flowers
Moancup · 17/03/2022 07:34

There is no evidence that taking parental leave does harm men’s careers. There is a huge motherhood penalty. Men actually get paid more when they become fathers. SPL still has appalling take up but you don’t hear men who take it complain about being ‘daddy tracked’.

He’s turning down an extremely generous paid leave policy because he wants to swing his dick around the office instead.

busyeatingbiscuits · 16/03/2022 21:39

@GabriellaMontez

What if you took 6 weeks off. Then got a full time nanny? Would you both be happy with this?
Childcare for a 6 week old baby and the family unnecessarily spending £3k a month because dad wants a baby without having to do any parenting or impact his career Hmm
GabriellaMontez · 16/03/2022 17:52

What if you took 6 weeks off. Then got a full time nanny? Would you both be happy with this?

Totallyanonymousplease · 16/03/2022 16:54

This is crazy - he would literally be working 6 months for free if his company offers it and he doesn’t take it. Does he not take holiday days? What would happen if he got ill and had to go off for a prolonged period of time? What would happen is would go off and come back and all would be fine.

It’s it even like being a woman as the men that go off for 6 months are treated like heroes when they come back!

His stance is rooted in social conditioning not reality. He needs to really think about where his prejudice comes from that’s it’s ok for a woman to take 6 months off but not a man. And if he thinks he would get fired/ not be promoted etc because of 6 months off he must not be very good at his job!

timeisnotaline · 16/03/2022 16:32

@collieresponder88 how do you read one parent contemplating pregnancy, birth and 6 months maternity leave, with the other parent considering doing none of these things as neither are prepared to make sacrifices? One parent is, and one parent isn’t. Why you read the woman’s position being as I refuse to do 100% of the work as the same as not prepared to make any sacrifices I can’t imagine- deep seated internal misogyny? If you were moved to a team of 2 at work, and on arrival the other team member said actually I’m not doing any of the work, how would you feel? I went into marriage with an expectation of sharing the family load, if my husband refused it would be a betrayal. It’s very sensible of the op to decide these are not circumstances to have another baby in.

JassyRadlett · 16/03/2022 16:08

I didn't say it was fair. I said neither of them are willing to make the sacrifice which seems as though it's true !

It isn't quite, though.

OP, having already made all the sacrifices the first time around, is willing to make her share of the sacrifices the second time around.

It's her husband who isn't willing to make any sacrifices, but still wants a second baby now.

SpinsForGin · 16/03/2022 16:00

I didn't say it was fair. I said neither of them are willing to make the sacrifice which seems as though it's true !

But the OPs husband is expecting her to make all the sacrifices.... that the point she's making. So of course it's about fairness

collieresponder88 · 16/03/2022 15:53

@SpinsForGin

Not nice to bring a life into the world when neither of you want to make the sacrifices required to raise it

The issue here is that the OP is expected to make all the sacrifices. That's hardly fair.

I didn't say it was fair. I said neither of them are willing to make the sacrifice which seems as though it's true !
Chasingaftermidnight · 16/03/2022 14:22

YANBU.

Even if you only look at the financial aspects of it, it makes sense for him to take the leave!

DarkShade · 16/03/2022 13:44

I don't think I'll have another child because at the minute I feel how I imagine your DH feels: sure, I would like a bigger family and another child in my life. But I am not prepared to sacrifice more career, go back to the drudgery of a year of childcare, part time hours, all the mental load. I just don't want to do it.

If someone else volunteered to raise my kid for me, say, 70% of the time I'd have a second one right now. Since I'm a woman, I'm unlikely to find a volunteer. Well done OP for not letting your husband push you into it.

Brefugee · 16/03/2022 13:17

Stick to your guns, OP, and make sure you have all the best contraceptives available and doubled up.

I loathed being on maternity leave so much it left me with depression and had an awful awful time. Lucky i live in a country where my DH could take the 2nd part of leave, 18 months, which covered us until the DCs could both go to nursery. It was brilliant.

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 16/03/2022 13:13

“ Where I'm probably being unfair is:

  • I feel like our lives and his choices are the gender pay gap come to life
  • I feel like if men in general don't step up to take SPL nothing is ever going to change
  • I'm losing respect for DH for not wanting to be the one to challenge it in his workplace
  • I'd already be doing the pretty serious work of growing and birthing the baby so he could take a heavier load”

This is not unfair at all. It’s spot on. For all the PPs saying not to lay the blame for all of society’s ills on this DH - nonsense! Thousands of people like this DH are the folks who create and shape our society. And it takes lots of individuals stepping up in their own small way to make a change.

My DH was very resistant initially to taking leave exactly because he didn’t want to stick his neck out in his work culture. I pretty much told him that if he wants me to find him in the least bit attractive, he needed to be brave. And being brave isn’t showing off jumping from the higher diving board at the pool, or picking a fight with a body builder. Being brave is leaning in to support and prioritize your family, even if your boss promises to railroad your career and makes snide comments about babysitting.

We had a lot of arguments about it - really pretty heated arguments - but ultimately he agreed to take 3 months of parental leave and he did not end up regretting it for a single minute.

TigerMTV · 16/03/2022 09:38

@FeministBadger

Worth bearing in mind of course that a second baby means looking after baby and toddler, which was much, much more demanding than looking after a baby! Sorry if PP have already mentioned this and I’m sure it’s probably obvious anyway.

I think I would always feel a bit resentful if my OH refused to take SPL - yet was happy for my career and sanity to take such a big hit.

My friends with a single child have much more freedom and leisure time and a less frenetic lifestyle than those of us with 2+ children. So there would be other benefits to stopping at one!

GabriellaMontez · 16/03/2022 09:20

@Simonjt

So he wants another baby, but he doesn’t actually want to raise his baby, instead he wants either you or a nanny to do that on his behalf. In that case, why does he want another baby?
Wtf? Lots of couples use a nanny, nursery or only have one parent at home.

The problem is that the op wants him to use his paid paternity so they both take the career hit this time.

FeministBadger · 16/03/2022 09:06

Thanks for the input everyone.

I think actually a PP has it right, right now I cannot imagine having a second if it requires the same sacrifices as the first time round.

I had hoped DH would be willing to step up and take on an equal share next time but if that is in doubt I am happy stopping at one.

OP posts:
VestaTilley · 16/03/2022 08:59

Do not have a second child until you are ready. Your body, your choice.

You’re the one who’ll do pregnancy, birth, recovery, possibly breastfeeding, and - let’s face it - the bulk of the care in the first year at least.

Leave it now until YOU want a second.

I’d also be wary in case he says he will take SPL, you get pregnant, then when the time comes he changes his mind. Keep an eye on your contraception.

SpinsForGin · 16/03/2022 08:39

Not nice to bring a life into the world when neither of you want to make the sacrifices required to raise it

The issue here is that the OP is expected to make all the sacrifices. That's hardly fair.

Lalliella · 16/03/2022 08:17

@FeministBadger

His argument is that his work isn't compatible with a long period of leave as he has customers who expect him to be at their beck and call.

He wants to try sooner as it took us 3 years and 2 mmc to conceive DS so we could end up with a bigger gap anyway but I honestly don't think I'd manage if we ended up with 2 under 2 or something like that.

I think with the difficulties you had it would be a good idea to start trying sooner rather than later. Speaking as someone who had similar difficulties and would have preferred a smaller gap than the one we ended up with.

Can’t really comment on the SPL as I wouldn’t have wanted DH to take any of my leave off me! But I know that’s not the same for everyone.

SpinsForGin · 16/03/2022 08:16

@FeministBadger

I'm certainly not hoping he'd have a miserable time of parental leave but I do think I am feeling aggrieved that he gets the easy option.

I have a lot of thoughts flying around that I'm trying to understand and this thread is really helping. The ones that feel fair are:

  • I want him to understand what it is like to be primary parent
  • He can get 6 months of full pay when I'd then be on zero pay, or we'd be paying for a nanny
  • He is expecting me to take maternity leave at a cost to my career when he is, at a minimum, very reluctant to do the same
  • He is the one actively pushing to have a second child sooner

Where I'm probably being unfair is:

  • I feel like our lives and his choices are the gender pay gap come to life
  • I feel like if men in general don't step up to take SPL nothing is ever going to change
  • I'm losing respect for DH for not wanting to be the one to challenge it in his workplace
  • I'd already be doing the pretty serious work of growing and birthing the baby so he could take a heavier load
All of these are perfectly reasonable. Even the ones you think are unfair.

We only have one child for similar reasons. I'm not prepared to take another hit on my career, I didn't have a great maternity leave the first time around and DH isn't prepared to take SPL.

Therefore we're not having another.

HardyBuckette · 16/03/2022 08:05

@blueluce85

YADNBU...Problem here though is that he may agree, then when you are pregnant, rescind it....and there will be nothing you can do about it.....what then?
This is what I thought. Once you're pregnant, you'll have no way of enforcing it. For that reason, I'd wait until you're ready to TTC again regardless of what he says about parental leave.

That does mean you might end up waiting ages for number two, just like if you start early expecting it to take a while you could get knocked up on the first try, but that's an innate part of the process really. Just a risk you take.

stuntbubbles · 16/03/2022 07:57

YABU to make it a requirement for TTC. It seems a bit like you’re cutting your nose off to spite your face tbh, given that you want a baby at some point anyway. You’re a more experienced mum this time so maybe you won’t find it as hard.
This is some of the worst advice I’ve ever read on here! It’s her body and time, of course she can put requirements on TTC, she’s not a brood mare.

JassyRadlett · 16/03/2022 07:53

@AlexaShutUp

He sounds incredibly sexist. That would be enough to put me off having a second child with him tbh. And I would tell him why.
It would put me off having sex with him full stop, tbh.

He's being so transparent. He wants the thing he wants, but only if you take all the risk.

What a charmer.

Thatsplentyjack · 16/03/2022 07:41

YABU to make it a requirement for TTC

Fuck off

Swipe left for the next trending thread