Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I'm right and the doctors are wrong?

360 replies

Rabbitpoop · 15/03/2022 15:40

DD is 13yo and has had really bad nausea and stomach ache for 10 days. Shes been off school the whole time and very little appetite. GP thought it was appendix related so sent us to hospital. First surgeon admitted us and said seems like appendix as she only has pain in the exact area of the appendix. Put us on the list for surgery.

Saw another surgeon who said he wanted an ultrasound first. Fair enough. They couldn't see her appendix during the scan but no obvious signs of anything else wrong so surgeon passed us to paeds.

Paediatrician came in and said it is constipation before he even examined her. She isn't constipated at all and the pain is only on the bottom right side in a specific area. I questioned him and pushed back quite a lot as I'm 100% sure this is not constipation. She's had no change in her bowel movements. Paeds said there's no sign of appendicitis in her blood tests so it's unlikely to be appendicitis.

I looked up the NICE guidelines and it says that you can't rule out appendicitis by blood test or ultrasound and that it can present differently in different people. It seems the only real way of telling is laparoscopy/surgery but the surgeons won't do it as she's not writhing in pain.

I don't know what to do. I'm sure it's not constipation and that it's something to do with her appendix. They said they wouldn't give antibiotics either as there's no sign of infection.

I'm worried they're just going to tell us to go home and she'll continue to be off school, feeling sick, barely eating and with a stomach ache.

Any advice?

OP posts:
Littlegoth · 17/03/2022 08:04

I’m coming in from the other side of the coin. When I was 11 this happened to me. Scans, blood work all fine. My mum insisted that it was my appendix as we had a history of appendicitis turning nasty pretty quickly. The doctor said ‘there is nothing wrong with that appendix, she is trying to get out of school’. 8 days later, 2 days into the summer holidays (so wouldn’t have got me out of much school!!) it burst, I nearly died, I was in hospital for 10 days and in a wheelchair for weeks after.

Appendicitis is often missed. White blood cells aren’t elevated in up to 30% of people. Scans are good for detecting but still miss around 4%. Lots of doctors on here commenting - I think the NHS is amazing, and our doctors are good at what they do, but you aren’t always right.

Hope all goes well today and your daughter is feeling better soon OP!

RosesAndHellebores · 17/03/2022 08:03

OP have you asked to speak with the Consultant. In your circumstances I would request that. They are unlikely to say no but if they do simply say neither you nor your daughter can consent to anything, even leaving, without that discussion. In my experience there is absolutely no point trying to establish accurate clinical facts with nursing staff.

olympicsrock · 17/03/2022 08:01

OP sounds like you are having a dreadful time with all this uncertainty.
She wasn’t being asked to isolate as this is only for planned ( non urgent ) surgery.
The reason they said constipation is that the caecum ( the largest bit of colon) is next to the appendix and this is what dilates the most and is tender .

The other things it could be include that she has had an ovarian cyst that burst (so no cyst to see) . The fluid irritates things and can cause pain in the lower abdomen.

Could also be mesenteric adenitis. Swollen lymph glands due to a viral infection.

Or Blood from her period can sometimes bleed backwards into the pelvis and irritate bowel.

I hope you get to the bottom of things soon x

NotNotNotMyName · 17/03/2022 07:59

If it is her appendix, trust me, you will know. She will be in a LOT of pain (think labour). It does sound like you’re overthinking it. She doesn’t need an op now, no way.

If it does progress and is appendicitis they can deal with it then.

There is also a nasty tummy bug going round with more pain than vomiting.

You do sound a bit over anxious about this OP

parboil · 17/03/2022 07:38

OP I had an almost identical experience a couple of years ago. DS had pain and nausea for days, eventually acute enough that we went to A&E. Pain started central on tummy button then moved to lower right quadrant, just like appendicitis. No changes in bowel movements, wind, bloating etc. Absolutely nothing to suggest constipation or digestive issues. Doctors suspected possible appendicitis but tests didn't show it up. They then suspected constipation. It just didn't add up. I felt like you - that I was screaming and no one was listening.

Turns out it was - constipation. They were right. DS had a build up of small lumps of impacted poo, probably caused over months or years, which had never been large enough to affect his bowel movements, but had eventually started causing pain. He was put on a (very unpleasant) two week deimpaction regime, taking laxatives 10 times a day to fully clear the bowel. It worked - problem cured.

Of course, your doctors could be wrong. But just bear in mind that even if what they're saying seems to make no sense to you, that doesn't mean it doesn't make sense. They're doctors, and although they're not infallible, they know a lot more than their patients. I truly don't mean that in a nasty way, because initially I felt exactly the same as you do. (Incidentally, the most senior doctor we saw put a lot of faith in the old fashioned 'hopping test'. If a child with stomach pain hops on one leg and the pain doesn't instantly become much, much worse, then it's probably not appendicitis.)

Schmz · 17/03/2022 07:27

[quote Sickofthesoapbox24]@GirlOfTudor

In response to your comment, mainly cos my knickers get in a bit of a twist about imaging modalities.

Sorry but you’re not quite right.

  1. Ultrasound is actually very useful in children in diagnosing appendicitis and excluding appendicitis. Less so in adults.

In addition CT carries a radiation (therefore future cancer risk) that is often deemed unacceptable in many cases with children that’s why they get an US and in some centres an MRI if the US is equivocal.

Although CT can be helpful if the diagnosis is unclear as it’s a good modality to pick up the mimics of appendicitis.

  1. A number of large studies have now shown that a negative CRP and WCC 24 hours after symptom onset is at least 97% (some even cute 100%) negative prognostic value for appendicitis I.e it’s pretty good at excluding it.

But obviously everybody worries about the tiny percentage that will be missed particularly if the patient isn’t understanding as nobody wants to get sued.

  1. During the pandemic many people of all ages with uncomplicated and complicated appendicitis were treated with just antibiotics and no appendicectomy with good outcomes and lower complication rates. The omentum is pretty good at it’s job even in perforated appendicitis.

This is obviously not the population that have appendicitis secondary to appendiceal/cecal tumour which tends to be the older population.

  1. Although complication rates of appendicectomy are low, many studies only look to one year out comes which largely misses people coming back many years later with adhesions secondary to surgery that can cause big problems. Obviously, there’s an argument for the inflammation alone to cause adhesions so it’s tricky to unpick that argument.

However, there’s a reason many doctors including surgeons say ‘avoid the surgeons knife and you’ll live a long and healthy life’.

In conclusion, appropriate clinical assessment, blood results and ultrasound combined are very good for assessing appendicitis likelihood in children. People are often scared of missing the tiny percentage that can’t be ruled out by these as nothing is ever gaurenteed hence the super high negative appendicectomy rate when the sample is sent to histology.

P.S in the UK we call it an appendicectomy not an appendectomy.[/quote]
Great post @Sickofthesoapbox24

OP
I get that u are a frightened parent
But you need to start building rapport with the health care team
You don’t want them making clinical decisions based on the path of least resistance from you as opposed to what is clinically indicated for your daughter

You are tired stressed and scared and angry
But you sound like an absolute nightmare to communicate with
Regulate your emotions and you can start thinking more logical

Mango101 · 17/03/2022 07:18

@Sickofthesoapbox24

YABU

She has had an assessment by the correct sub-speciality, negative relevant blood tests and imaging. NICE are exactly what they say they are GUIDANCE not a strict rule book.

The clinical suspicion is this is not appendicitis and that’s based on clinical assessment and relevant clinical investigations.

There are many meta-analysis out there on the predictive negative value of normal WCC and CRP in acute appendicitis especially this far on I. The clinical course. NICE guidance is often quite far behind the evidence.

The doctors are comfortable adopting a watch and wait approach which sounds completely reasonable in the context. They want to avoid giving your child an unnecessary operation. Negative (I.e. unnecessary) appendicectomy rates are still around 15%!

The rate should be zero. UK's really bad at imaging.
Maray1967 · 17/03/2022 07:01

Persist. I had appendicitis as a child a long time ago . GP insisted it was, hospital doctor said constipation. GP insisted I was kept in. The next morning I was in the operating theatre.

Benjispruce5 · 17/03/2022 06:47

DD had appendix out aged 4. She was very poorly within 48 hrs. Temperature, severe pain,that meant she couldn’t stand, high pulse rate.

Ireolu · 17/03/2022 06:37

When things r not clear and the person still has abdominal pain they shd be given a laproscopy. it is the only way to confirm what is happening.

sazzy5 · 17/03/2022 05:52

Your poor daughter, you must be so tired and fed up.
I had a grumbling appendix, undiagnosed and told it was IBS for about 18 months. I was like your daughter and didn’t make much fuss, I was so embarrassed when I got intense pain as I thought I was dealing with IBS. My bloods showed nothing either but my appendix was up by my belly button when they did the CT scan. They also looked for diverticulitis as that is similar with sickness etc.
I hope you get some answers soon.

Itsallok · 17/03/2022 05:37

hope it all goes well

OutlookStalking · 17/03/2022 05:12

Good luck

Soulstirring · 17/03/2022 04:40

Fingers crossed for the morning, hope you both managed to sleep

lunar1 · 17/03/2022 04:20

My DS had exactly these symptoms with the exception that there was significant inflammation on his scans exactly where the appendix is. All his blood work was mostly normal though.

He was admitted for three days and prepped for surgery twice but because of the blood tests he never went for the op.

They diagnosed adenitis, which is disappointing as you just have to wait it out. It did resolve and has never come back.

WTF475878237NC · 17/03/2022 04:03

Please do not consent to this surgery without asking that they test for h pylori. You really need to advocate for this child. Have you spoken to PALS? Phone them from the ward if you don't want to leave her. Ask to speak to the matron etc.

Peanutssuck · 16/03/2022 23:17

Calprotectin is the test they do on the faeces. The normal marker is 51. Anything over that shows infection. I'm really sorry you're going through this

GabriellaMontez · 16/03/2022 22:52

You've been really let down. Very poor communication.

Honestly they haven't inspired confidence and I wouldn't trust them. If they were happy to discharge her in the morning I'd take her home then make a plan that didn't involve this hospital.

Tiddlesthecat · 16/03/2022 22:29

Well hopefully you will get to the bottom of it. Unfortunately Drs often fail to explain their reasoning behind their decisions and what they have considered and ruled out. I'm sure that there will have been evidence and logic behind their decision making, but they have failed to properly explain things to you. Sadly this is common due to understaffing/shift changes and changes to surgery schedules due to priorities shifting. Hope that you at least get some rest now and that all goes to plan tomorrow.

fairgame84 · 16/03/2022 21:34

I doubt you will see the surgeon until the morning now when they come to mark and consent her. Get her something decent to eat because if she's on the emergency list tomorrow, she might be waiting all day if more urgent cases come in.

Rabbitpoop · 16/03/2022 21:30

I haven't been able to leave the room as I haven't wanted to miss the doctor coming as has been promised all day. I have got her some biscuits and crisps from the healthcare assistant or whatever they're called. I'm sure she's dehydrated after 48hrs mostly nil by mouth and I've got jet some water but she's not drinking much of it. There is no change in the pain having not been eating so I don't think it can be anything food related. The pain hasn't moved at all in at least 7 days, it's in the exact same place, exactly where the appendix is.

OP posts:
seperatedmum · 16/03/2022 21:27

just to add my good wishes @Rabbitpoop love to your DD I'll be thinking about you both

ISmellBurnings · 16/03/2022 21:15

If she’s not going until tomorrow then she should be able to eat and drink tonight. If she’s being kept nil by mouth she should have a cannula and some fluids. You should be able to nip off and get some food. Depends what their rules are. We currently allow one parent in and they can go off the ward. Still no visitors due to covid.

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 16/03/2022 21:14

My Dd had a similar issue just before Xmas. She kept collapsing in school with stomach pain. Gp checked and she had none of the classic appendix symptoms and we were at a complete loss. Then (it was Xmas time) she forgot to eat her chocolate behind the date on her advent calendar and for the first time in ages she had no stomach pain on the bus to school. Over the next week or so she cut out more dairy and is now dairy free and no more stomach pain. She had a lot of colic as a baby too.

whatisheupto · 16/03/2022 21:12

Personally at this stage I'd be giving her food and drink regardless. I bet surgery won't be magically taking place tomorrow morning. At least you're admitted now but I'd be prepared for another day of tests etc. before any surgery. So get some food and drink in her now and then start the fasting. I wouldn't bother asking.... sounds like no one has a clue and they have probably admitted you without anyone really knowing exactly what your path of care is yet.

Swipe left for the next trending thread