Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I'm right and the doctors are wrong?

360 replies

Rabbitpoop · 15/03/2022 15:40

DD is 13yo and has had really bad nausea and stomach ache for 10 days. Shes been off school the whole time and very little appetite. GP thought it was appendix related so sent us to hospital. First surgeon admitted us and said seems like appendix as she only has pain in the exact area of the appendix. Put us on the list for surgery.

Saw another surgeon who said he wanted an ultrasound first. Fair enough. They couldn't see her appendix during the scan but no obvious signs of anything else wrong so surgeon passed us to paeds.

Paediatrician came in and said it is constipation before he even examined her. She isn't constipated at all and the pain is only on the bottom right side in a specific area. I questioned him and pushed back quite a lot as I'm 100% sure this is not constipation. She's had no change in her bowel movements. Paeds said there's no sign of appendicitis in her blood tests so it's unlikely to be appendicitis.

I looked up the NICE guidelines and it says that you can't rule out appendicitis by blood test or ultrasound and that it can present differently in different people. It seems the only real way of telling is laparoscopy/surgery but the surgeons won't do it as she's not writhing in pain.

I don't know what to do. I'm sure it's not constipation and that it's something to do with her appendix. They said they wouldn't give antibiotics either as there's no sign of infection.

I'm worried they're just going to tell us to go home and she'll continue to be off school, feeling sick, barely eating and with a stomach ache.

Any advice?

OP posts:
Migrainesbythedozen · 17/03/2022 10:46

OP please give us an update on what happens. I was initially thinking gallstones but not sure sure would have it that young.

Rabbitpoop · 17/03/2022 10:46

I'm not pushing for surgery I just want a doctor to examine her and listen to her history and make an informed decision on what is best to do. Not decide its constipation without even physically examining her, then tell us she needs surgery, then leave us in a busy waiting room nil by mouth for 9 hours during which time we're told to go home twice by nurses, then admit her, tell me a doctor is going to come and talk to me so I wait up until midnight and no one comes, all of which time I can't leave my DD to get food or drinks, no rest and no sleep. I have been polite and patient with all staff but I am understandably frustrated, exhausted and stressed so was looking for some support here.

Thank you to those who have been compassionate.

The surgeon has at last come to see her. He said a CT scan is too risky for her age and that while the bloods dont indicate appendicitis, medicine isn't an exact science and the fact that she has a few indications of appendicitis (something called McBurneys point pain? And another test I can't remember where if they press on her left side it hurts on her right) means that it is sensible to take it out. They don't think there are any other tests or treatment options so it's either leave it or take it out. The surgeon says best to take it out as she's had same symptoms for so long and unlikely to get better if we leave it.

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 17/03/2022 10:43

DH went to the GP in 1994; GP sent him straight to A&E with a letter about suspected appendix. Registrar reviewed him and asked his occupation. He said Barrister and the Registrar's response was "oh as you're a lawyer, I'll send you straight up to theatre as an emergency". He arrived at 10.30, his appendix was out by 12.30. He was told he was lucky to have arrived when he did because it wasn't far off rupture. He hadn't felt nauseous, he just had a bad tummy ache. He walked to the Dr's and got the bus to A&E.

What was worse was that I arrived at the hospital at 9am because he wanted to be brought home. His discharge had been signed. The nurses said he couldn't go until he had been given his painkillers. I asked when that would be "oh by about 2pm". I then asked why I couldn't take him home and come back for them and got a cat's bum face in return.

As I packed up DH I overheard the nurses complaining at the nursing station that the man in bed x and his wife were insistent on him leaving which meant they had to change the bed and get ready to receive another patient before their shift change. Presumably some poor sod on a trolley in A&E.

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 17/03/2022 10:34

There’s clearly a lack of understanding of appendicitis on this thread. I know of no-one who has had it that have presented clinically textbook.
3 days I was fobbed off for with mine…because I’d just had a baby and it must be gynaecological -why? Because I wasn’t being sick/had no nausea. My blood tests were also normal. When they finally took the fucking thing out it was hours away from rupture!
Appendicitis does not always follow a textbook clinical pattern.

Oddbobbyboo · 17/03/2022 10:30

Please keep fighting. I had this exact thing with my daughter… they didn’t think it was appendicitis. Luckily for us the surgeon wanted her seen by gynae. They decided to remove her appendix and investigate. Turns out she had a burst cyst and endometriosis. Keep going and ignore the idiots being nasty. You know your child better than anyone… mothers instinct has a lot to answer for x keep us updated xx 😘

Legalconundrums · 17/03/2022 10:19

Hang on in there OP.
If I hadn't insisted my son was admitted to hospital when he was a toddler he wouldn't be here now.
I carried him in unconscious into A and E after 10 days of being fobbed off by an inept Dr. He had sepsis and was seriously ill.

If my drunk GP, who was later suspended and struck off, had listened to me 4 years earlier I wouldn't have required 2 major open surgeries to remove a fibroid the size of a melon.

Trust your instincts, don't be derailed in ensuring your daughter is properly and thoroughly investigated.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/03/2022 10:15

@Rabbitpoop

I'm so sorry for how you've been treated. You've been clear that you're not pushing for one particular course of action but that you want clear communication and demonstration of effective management of your DD's condition.

Asking you to fast and come back for surgery, then leaving you for hours with no food / drink, only to tell you do go home! (And then reverse that) is appalling.

You must be exhausted. I hope you've got some better treatment & answers now.

And please try to ignore @Schmz deeply ignorant & offensive posts

StaplesCorner · 17/03/2022 10:11

Frightening - how must this poor kid be feeling now having been refused food and water for so long; I’d be scared out of my wits if it was my DD - can you trust the hospital, will the op be ok, will withholding food and water bake it worse etc - my heart goes out to OP and her DD and I wish she’d got the support she’d needed on here 😡

BlingLoving · 17/03/2022 10:03

OP I've read all your posts. I think you've had an awful time and you're being treated appallingly. Also, please don't listen to the anti surgery types. I had a grumbling appendix. But in my case, the doctors decided to remove it relatively quickly and all was fine. It's not major surgery and frankly, rather minor surgery that may well be the problem than her sitting around in pain indefinitely. I hope today is the day!

wombleflump · 17/03/2022 10:00

Why are you pushing for surgery? What if it is negative. No inflammatory markers I presume in blood.

Bromse · 17/03/2022 09:56

Rabbitpoop, please do come back. I for one want to know how things are with your daughter and I know that is true for other posters.

You've communicated your concerns on here extremely well.

Doctors are not always right, if they were there would never be conflicting second opinions. Sometimes it is difficult for them to decide on a course of action based on a patient's symptoms.

I do hope your daughter's problems are soon resolved.

Our role is to be supportive of anxious fellow posters, we are not personally in their situation. Of course we don't know all sides but we do know when someone is anxious and needs a hand hold.

Zilla1 · 17/03/2022 09:54

The problem with 'Trust your instincts' is the self-selected sample and other biases. Most posters will talk about how they knew they were right and how it took far too long for a diagnosis and effective treatment.

For those that want to consider an alternative perspective, IME what % of serious, non-obvious undifferentiated presentations do you think the patient and Dr Google are right and in which the above sample might sit? Anecdata as I can't find rigorous research but c1%. And IME a greater proportion of patients with serious, undifferentiated presentations would end up dead if the HCP had done what the patient initially wanted rather than a robust diagnosis and treating the actual condition?

In this case, how many healthy patients would have had the risk of a GA and surgery to remove a healthy appendix for each time the patient had an appendicitis requiring surgery and the patient just knew? For how many is it a different problem entirely? How many times does the appendicitis settle and the medic's advice turn out to be correct (btw it did for my family in similar circumstance)?

I'm not saying that HCPs always get it right nor that parents shouldn't advocate for their children.

Hotpinkangel19 · 17/03/2022 09:51

Not seeing the appendix on a ultrasound is not uncommon so don't worry about that.

JaneyJimplin · 17/03/2022 09:48

Hope you've made some progress op

CinematicNightScenes · 17/03/2022 09:40

@RosesAndHellebores completely agree, I think a lot of complaints against the NHS could be resolved simply with better communication.

We found in hospital (for very serious condition) that people just sort of randomly turned up, did something and left - and if you asked what would happen next they wouldn't know. Then someone else would turn up and do something and on it went. No time frames given.

It would be so much better if they at least provided an outline of what would happen - even if they said 'it could be several hours time etc'

People would then at least know. It is the endless sitting, waiting around with no idea of what is going to happen next or when it will happen.

RosesAndHellebores · 17/03/2022 09:35

The problem with blaming poor communication on uber busy and overwhelmed staff is that poor communication has been ever thus. The communication needs to Improve.

comfortablyfrumpy · 17/03/2022 09:34

I hope you and your DD get some answers soon, you must be worried sick. Flowers

RantyAunty · 17/03/2022 09:31

I really feel for you and your DD. I hope they get it sorted out soon. Flowers

It's a perfect example of how women and girls are fobbed off by health care.

Stroppypeople · 17/03/2022 09:30

@Schmz

99.9% of posts here are very supportive to the OP

A very few have pointed out another perspective

As far as I can see I’m the only one voicing the opinion that OP comes across as a nightmare to communicate with

And on the basis of that, OP threatens to flounce off …

This is what I mean -
If she doesn’t get a unanimous agreement
Which you won’t get in healthcare -
Then she’s all riled up !!

The OP’s understand histrionics are unhelpful and in my opinion will be driving health care professions to think what is going to head off a complaint as opposed to what their clinical judgement suggests …

OP flounce on that !! You DO sound a bloody nightmare !!

I think you are reading the wrong thread ! Where has op been a nightmare to communicate with ?!!! Everything she has said makes complete sense . Am guessing you are a HCP…you come across as very defensive!
DomesticatedZombie · 17/03/2022 09:24

Really feel for you, OP. Hope you're okay and your daughter is seen soon and you get a good outcome.

Waiting in a hospital when you're tired, stressed, hungry and frustrated is hellish. Flowers Brew

CinematicNightScenes · 17/03/2022 09:17

The best outcome would be that all investigations find nothing - there is some benign or unknown cause for the pain and symptoms.

If the medical and surgical teams were of the view that there was no cause for concern at all (panic over nothing) then I don't think Op's daughter would have been admitted (I am not a medical professional).

My recent experience in a very large hospital is that everything takes AGES. Communication is poor and/or delayed. No criticism of staff as clearly run off their feet and overwhelmed and seemed to be working on a fire fighting basis.

I found it is case of being quietly persistent and endlessly patient. You will get seen and will get answers.

Stroppypeople · 17/03/2022 09:17

@Rabbitpoop

I think I'm going to step back from this thread as being told I'm a nightmare to communicate with when nobody has communicated with me at all and that I'm over anxious and that I'm not advocating enough for my child is making a bad situation worse and not helping.
Bless you . I have just read your whole thread and you do not sound tricky or hard to communicate with! I could have written this about my 17 year old son a few years ago. Months of RIF pain that would come and go ,nausea and he like your daughter very stoic and not a drama lama . He eventually was admitted right in the middle of his A levels mocks! He sat on the ward revising and I thought he would be sent home because he was so calm . Anyway he did go to theatre and had a manky,infected appendix removed! So good for you for advocating for your daughter…I hope she is better very soon 💐
Bobbins36 · 17/03/2022 09:14

We had a v similar thing when DS was around 7/8. We all thought appendicitis, GP sent us packing to hospital QUICKLY and all a bit fraught and he was in a lot of pain. Turned to be mesenteric adenitis - inflammation of the membrane covering the abdominal cavity, so very close to the appendix and presents with similar symptoms. Worth ruling out both tbh.

Good luck, it’s horrid when they are poorly x

Schmz · 17/03/2022 09:07

As @Sickofthesoapbox24 points out it is very clear that a breakdown of communication has occurred-
OP’s understandable distress could corner the health care professions into factoring her distress into clinical decisions ….
Which is why I suggested trying to regulate the distress and build rapport with the team -
They are all on the same side - wanting a good outcome

badger2005 · 17/03/2022 09:06

@badger2005 you should not be advising the op to take her daughter home!
That could end extremely badly.
A doctor wouldn't "agree" to surgery on a whim, and your opinion on whether he should have agreed is redundant when you are not a surgeon.

Sorry - of course I don't mean to over-ride the medical advice! But if I've understood right since they have come in several medical professionals have told the OP that she can take her daughter home. So in her shoes I think I would do that.