Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I'm right and the doctors are wrong?

360 replies

Rabbitpoop · 15/03/2022 15:40

DD is 13yo and has had really bad nausea and stomach ache for 10 days. Shes been off school the whole time and very little appetite. GP thought it was appendix related so sent us to hospital. First surgeon admitted us and said seems like appendix as she only has pain in the exact area of the appendix. Put us on the list for surgery.

Saw another surgeon who said he wanted an ultrasound first. Fair enough. They couldn't see her appendix during the scan but no obvious signs of anything else wrong so surgeon passed us to paeds.

Paediatrician came in and said it is constipation before he even examined her. She isn't constipated at all and the pain is only on the bottom right side in a specific area. I questioned him and pushed back quite a lot as I'm 100% sure this is not constipation. She's had no change in her bowel movements. Paeds said there's no sign of appendicitis in her blood tests so it's unlikely to be appendicitis.

I looked up the NICE guidelines and it says that you can't rule out appendicitis by blood test or ultrasound and that it can present differently in different people. It seems the only real way of telling is laparoscopy/surgery but the surgeons won't do it as she's not writhing in pain.

I don't know what to do. I'm sure it's not constipation and that it's something to do with her appendix. They said they wouldn't give antibiotics either as there's no sign of infection.

I'm worried they're just going to tell us to go home and she'll continue to be off school, feeling sick, barely eating and with a stomach ache.

Any advice?

OP posts:
hopeful777 · 16/03/2022 00:24

Appendicitis is a diagnosis that looks at the history/clinical examination/ observations and blood tests.

As previous posters have said, a 10day history with normal bloods has a very low likelihood of being an appendicitis.

A large percentage of ultrasound scans don’t pick up a ‘normal’ appendix (usually size of patient’s little finger and can be hidden but if inflamed is very obvious or you would see free fluid in the abdomen/pelvis)

If she hasn’t got a fever/fast heart rate/bloods staying normal- I would agree with surgical team that this is more likely to be a mesenteric adenitis (have they had a recent cough/cold symptoms) or a medical/psychosocial cause of anxiety.

Pain at McBurney’s point may be because lots of doctors have been pressing hard on it when examining her.

If her symptoms continue, it may make sense to repeat bloods or an ultrasound scan in 2-4 weeks but I think simple pain killers and ensuring they are eating small amounts and keeping hydrated would make sense in this scenario. I would also keep a note of pain and it’s relation to periods and I’m sure it’s been done but in this day and age, I have to ask.. have they got a negative hcg test?

channelislander · 16/03/2022 00:18

Obviously I don't know about your daughter's exact case, but my brother had appendicitis recently and his appendix didn't show up on ultrasound scans at all, because it was positioned behind his intestine and therefore blocked from view. Thankfully they took his symptoms to mean it was appendicitis regardless of the scan, because they managed to remove his appendix right as it ruptured. I believe retrocecal was the word they used for his case, as it took longer than normal in surgery also and he took quite a while to recover

MichelleScarn · 15/03/2022 23:59

@Rabbitpoop

The GP said grumbling appendix but hoped it would go on its own.

Interesting to say retrocecal as that is the type that matches his symptoms according to NICE guidelines.

Sorry to be pedantic but is the 'his symptoms ' above a typo?
ReturnfromtheStars · 15/03/2022 23:49

Sorry haven't read all posts just wanted to add another story of my boyfriend having appendicitis not being believed (not in enough pain). Ended up with emergency surgery appendix nearly burst. Take care OP ❤️

Littlemissmuffetttt · 15/03/2022 23:37

I have experience in health care and worked alot in hospitals and variety of settings. I would urge you to say something along the lines of " the pain she is experiencing is affecting her day to day activities and she can't function normally! She needs extra help where she is normally independent and it is affecting her mood and mental health. She can't study and her appetite is reduced. I'm not leaving until I get a second opinion. I'll report you and your team for negligence and your acts of omission."

wfrances · 15/03/2022 23:32

Ds just had his appendix removed
He didn't have any of the text book symptoms
He had an uncomfortable ache (for 24 hrs ) around his belly button and
Was eating fine
But his temp and heart rate were up
And down
Gp said it was probably a urine infection so asked to see him
Said it couldn't be appendix as he wasn't in agony and he still had an appetite
After him doing some moving tests and his temp was now 39
Gp changed his mind
We were sent to hospital
Ds was still complaining he was starving and now nil by mouth
Surgeon saw him and said he's fine if he's hungry
But did bloods just incase
He came back an hour later
And said his bloods were very worrying and they were going to do a ct scan
Turns out he did have acute appendicitis and they operated within a few hours

SmudgeRolls · 15/03/2022 23:32

Are you admitted to hospital atm?

Psuedoshoes · 15/03/2022 23:23

GPs can be and sometimes are 100% wrong. I'd get a 2nd opinion OP. A GP once incessantly diagnosed my brother with a 'cold' even though it went on for 6 months with no cold symptoms - turns out he was simply in dire need of a heart operation Confused I'm sure your DD will be fine but GPs are human and human error is common

QS888 · 15/03/2022 23:12

Recent experience here of appendicitis with DD13. Textbook symptoms back in the summer - couldn't see the appendix on the scan. Got dismissed with antibiotics.

Further sickness periodically up to Christmas - when she had further major pain and sickness and was admitted. If they had operated in the summer - would have been keyhole.

Ended up as open surgery as she had a gangrenous appendix and they had no idea how she was still alive with what they saw inside her plus other complications. Lots of post op infections over the following month and several further stays in hospital. Thank goodness she is fine now but she had an awful time (unnecessarily) and it cost the NHS far more than had they treated her properly in the first place.

Suggest you ask for a second opinion from the local specialist childrens hospital if you are in a general hospital (wish I had done this back in the summer)

Sending best wishes xx

NameChChChChanges1 · 15/03/2022 23:11

Trust your gut. Read what happened to the mother in this case - her concerns were disregarded and her daughter died.

Doctors can be fallible. And worse, careless.

www.theguardian.com/society/2022/mar/04/girl-13-likely-to-have-survived-if-moved-to-intensive-care-coroner-rules

WinterCarlisle · 15/03/2022 23:09

Would mesenteric adenitis cause pain only in the appendix area (can't remember the fancy word they used, sounds like someone's name)?

Was it mittelschmerz pain that the dr mentioned, @Rabbitpoop? All the very best to your DD. I hope you get some answers soon

www.nhs.uk/conditions/ovulation-pain/?

Mariposista · 15/03/2022 23:09

Bless her, she must be exhausted and feeling awful. I hope they find out what’s wrong with her soon. If it is her appendix in a way it’s good, whip it out and she will soon be back to normal.

Grumpycatsmum · 15/03/2022 23:08

We've been there with this. Along with very severe pain and vomiting. She was admitted for overnight observation. It wasn't appendicitis. Two years later still hospital outpatient and no discernable cause. She may have appendix out eventually as this has been known to resolve the issue.

All surgery has risks and GPs often refer for suspected appendicitis as it's hard for them to diagnose and consequences of getting it wrong are severe
Suggest you ask is she can be admitted for observation.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 15/03/2022 23:01

There are many meta-analysis out there on the predictive negative value of normal WCC and CRP in acute appendicitis especially this far on I. The clinical course. NICE guidance is often quite far behind the evidence.

It's probably one of the reasons that they're finally moving to the living guidelines approach. Given how common the issue of appendicitis or not is, so to speak, I'd hope that this is among the first batch to be converted to a living guidelines approach rather than the usual quite lengthy update schedule.

JacktomyDaniel · 15/03/2022 23:01

My son aged 4 was hospitalised for a week in sick kids with this exact scenario. He was constantly vomiting bile, very pale, temp and drowsy. I was convinced appendix as were the Dr's. Ultrasound didn't see appendix (meaning small and healthy!) and nothing else of concern. I remember crying to a Dr because I was so sure it was appendicitis. They were amazing and said it was mesenteric adenitis wich I disputed and fully expected him to be back within days with a rupture. Turns out... 18mths later. They were right and I was wrong!

Maverick66 · 15/03/2022 22:55

Dd has Polycystic ovaries.
She took her period very young (9)
She has this pain every month due to multiple cysts.
May be worth pushing this idea an ultrasound will show them.

Sickofthesoapbox24 · 15/03/2022 22:48

OP I hope you daughter is okay and you get a diagnosis and quick recovery soon Flowers

Sickofthesoapbox24 · 15/03/2022 22:47

@GirlOfTudor

In response to your comment, mainly cos my knickers get in a bit of a twist about imaging modalities.

Sorry but you’re not quite right.

  1. Ultrasound is actually very useful in children in diagnosing appendicitis and excluding appendicitis. Less so in adults.

In addition CT carries a radiation (therefore future cancer risk) that is often deemed unacceptable in many cases with children that’s why they get an US and in some centres an MRI if the US is equivocal.

Although CT can be helpful if the diagnosis is unclear as it’s a good modality to pick up the mimics of appendicitis.

  1. A number of large studies have now shown that a negative CRP and WCC 24 hours after symptom onset is at least 97% (some even cute 100%) negative prognostic value for appendicitis I.e it’s pretty good at excluding it.

But obviously everybody worries about the tiny percentage that will be missed particularly if the patient isn’t understanding as nobody wants to get sued.

  1. During the pandemic many people of all ages with uncomplicated and complicated appendicitis were treated with just antibiotics and no appendicectomy with good outcomes and lower complication rates. The omentum is pretty good at it’s job even in perforated appendicitis.

This is obviously not the population that have appendicitis secondary to appendiceal/cecal tumour which tends to be the older population.

  1. Although complication rates of appendicectomy are low, many studies only look to one year out comes which largely misses people coming back many years later with adhesions secondary to surgery that can cause big problems. Obviously, there’s an argument for the inflammation alone to cause adhesions so it’s tricky to unpick that argument.

However, there’s a reason many doctors including surgeons say ‘avoid the surgeons knife and you’ll live a long and healthy life’.

In conclusion, appropriate clinical assessment, blood results and ultrasound combined are very good for assessing appendicitis likelihood in children. People are often scared of missing the tiny percentage that can’t be ruled out by these as nothing is ever gaurenteed hence the super high negative appendicectomy rate when the sample is sent to histology.

P.S in the UK we call it an appendicectomy not an appendectomy.

DixonD · 15/03/2022 22:43

@incognitoforthisone

I think I'd be inclined to reiterate the NICE guidelines, firmly, or get an emergency appointment with the GP for another referral. Or go straight to A&E with her. You must be really worried and she must be feeling rotten.

There is just one more thing I might consider ... Is it possible your DD is having some kind of anxiety re. school or friendships, by any chance? Stomach pain and nausea without any obvious cause are a classic symptom of anxiety. And it's also very easy for a 13-year-old to Google 'symptoms of appendicitis' if there's some reason they're scared to go to school. I'm not in any way trying to disparage your DD here, but she's only a kid and sometimes when kids are really, really worried about something they will resort to quite desperate measures. It is just an idea though and frankly I'd feel as much sympathy for her if this were the case as I would if she has appendicitis, poor thing.

I had this as a teenager- started at 13 and didn’t completely go until I was 19. I didn’t even know it was anxiety; I was (and my family were) convinced I was very unwell.

I hope you get to the bottom of this.

curlymom · 15/03/2022 22:40

They have reasons for every decision. My daughter had big digestive problems and we were confused too. But she was constipated and had impacted faeces . This is a big deal and must be treated before moving forward. Do mention your findings to the decontrol though. Might be of some help. Good luck. Teenage years can be so difficult x

Ottolin3 · 15/03/2022 22:39

I would put it down to stress. Appendix issues are quite specific in terms of the location of the pain, and if symptoms were presenting your dr would offer further tests.

ratsratsratsagain · 15/03/2022 22:35

I had an emergency appendectomy a few years ago. My daughter got bad stomach pains a few months later and was vomiting. She was 9. We hung about in hospital for a few days until we saw a different consultant.

She asked my daughter to stand on the floor and do 3 quick jumps as high as she could in quick succession. She could do it so the consultant discharged her. She was fine after a few days.

When I had appendicitis any movement was agony and I had to hold my stomach to protect it from the vibrations so it made sense. The consultant said if she had appendicitis she wouldn't have been able to do the jumping.
Hope she's better soon.

Lougle · 15/03/2022 22:32

It's really difficult, I think. I had several admissions to hospital as a teen with ?appendicitis. They eventually decided to remove it and said that it was perfectly normal. The strange thing is that I never got that pain again.

It may be appendicitis but if the infection markers aren't high and it has been going on 10 days, then they do have to weigh up what is the most sensible course of action.

Monstermasher · 15/03/2022 22:28

I think mesenteric adenitis would be excluded by the ultrasound?

WTF475878237NC · 15/03/2022 22:24

Bacterial gastroenteritis?