Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I'm right and the doctors are wrong?

360 replies

Rabbitpoop · 15/03/2022 15:40

DD is 13yo and has had really bad nausea and stomach ache for 10 days. Shes been off school the whole time and very little appetite. GP thought it was appendix related so sent us to hospital. First surgeon admitted us and said seems like appendix as she only has pain in the exact area of the appendix. Put us on the list for surgery.

Saw another surgeon who said he wanted an ultrasound first. Fair enough. They couldn't see her appendix during the scan but no obvious signs of anything else wrong so surgeon passed us to paeds.

Paediatrician came in and said it is constipation before he even examined her. She isn't constipated at all and the pain is only on the bottom right side in a specific area. I questioned him and pushed back quite a lot as I'm 100% sure this is not constipation. She's had no change in her bowel movements. Paeds said there's no sign of appendicitis in her blood tests so it's unlikely to be appendicitis.

I looked up the NICE guidelines and it says that you can't rule out appendicitis by blood test or ultrasound and that it can present differently in different people. It seems the only real way of telling is laparoscopy/surgery but the surgeons won't do it as she's not writhing in pain.

I don't know what to do. I'm sure it's not constipation and that it's something to do with her appendix. They said they wouldn't give antibiotics either as there's no sign of infection.

I'm worried they're just going to tell us to go home and she'll continue to be off school, feeling sick, barely eating and with a stomach ache.

Any advice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ireolu · 21/03/2022 06:59

It is not unheard of to have normal bloods with appendicitis. It happens and that is why you treat the patient and not the test results. Your child had clear symptoms of appenciditis her operation was delayed and if delayed further may have been a serious problem. I am glad she is better but I would definitely complain so no other family has to push so hard to be heard.

Horcruxe · 19/03/2022 14:24

Glad shes feeling a lot better!

RachelGreeneGreep · 19/03/2022 08:30

@picklespark

Just read this thread and OP, I think you’re incredibly brave and a brilliant advocate for your DD. So glad she is on the mend and thank God you pushed for her to get the right care.

Appendicitis nearly killed me when I was 5. I was sick and had stomach pain at school, my mum took me to the GP in the morning who said it was nothing. My mum was still concerned and I was getting feverish so she took me back to another GP in the evening. They realised what it was right away and called the children’s ward to have me admitted immediately. My appendix turned out to have ruptured and I had severe peritonitis which would have shortly led to sepsis and death. I was operated on that night and recovered well thankfully. I think my poor mum is still traumatised by it 28 years later.

It’s admittedly harder to diagnose in very young children but shocking that at her age, your DD’s symptoms weren’t taken seriously.

Exact same thing happened with a sibling, years ago, as a child, around that age too. It was a close thing, appendix had burst. Doctor had dismissed all concerns.

OP, I hope that both of you are taking it easy. I agree with pp, about writing things down in a clear and crisp timeline when the dust has settled and sending it to the relevant areas. Lessons might be learned, hopefully.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 19/03/2022 04:45

I saw @LookItsMeAgain thanks. I felt stupid enough the first time.

Kennykenkencat · 19/03/2022 02:14

And the consultant refused to listen to me.

Kennykenkencat · 19/03/2022 02:12

The idea that doctors should listen more to patients is dear to my heart

I think that if doctors did actually listen to their patients it would save the NHS huge amounts of money. But unfortunately most doctors won’t listen and fanny around testing you for 1 thing then another thing, then another until they have tested you for everything under the sun apart from what you know you actually have wrong with you.
Then they begrudgingly test you for what you know you have wrong with you and only then they start treatment.

I kept telling my doctor from age 11-14 that I thought I had a stomach ulcer.
I was treated for anorexia. Told not to be a silly girl. Eventually allowed to go for a test where they found I had several stomach ulcers and could have died.

My grandfather went to the doctor on a Friday evening to ask about sudden vomiting and nausea and pins and needles in his left arm
He thought he was going to have a heart attack. But the doctor dismissed him and prescribed him Renee’s for his nausea.
He had a heart attack less than 6 hours later.

Dh had all the symptoms of bowel cancer. His dad had died of it. after 6 months of going back and forth to the doctors multiple times, being tested or diagnosed with a variety of issues

He was eventually diagnosed with terminal bowel cancer in A&E. I had almost had to carry him in as he had got so ill he could barely stand.

The costs for listening is negligible compared to the amount of time off work and the impact on people’s lives from the pain or physical restriction

I know I cost the NHS probably in the region of at least £250,000 over one issue I had.
I couldn’t work, I couldn’t sleep (the pain was constant and excruciating) i was off work for 7 years.
All because they wanted to save £300 for an mri.

Theyulelog · 18/03/2022 22:34

This happened to me.
They did a laparoscopy to explore and my appendix looked normal but removed it anyway. They found free fluid around it though.
The pain was gone straight away and I had suffered for months.
The surgeon called it a grumbling appendix. Normal bloods and scans but I did have a temperature.

Mischance · 18/03/2022 22:09

The idea that doctors should listen more to patients is dear to my heart.

I had a dreadfully painful foot fracture - an avulsion fracture where you sprain your ankle so badly that the tendons rip the bones apart - not great. Was in plaster for 12 weeks and when it came off I was in great pain and could not weight bear - I told them this and they just said it was uncomfortable where the -plaster had been.

Having had fractures before I said I was sure it was not that. They fobbed me off and sent me home - I still could not weight bear. At follow up they still did not believe me.

I went private and the consultant gazed at the x-ray and said "Well, I am not surprised you cannot weight bear, you have another unhealed fracture that has been missed." So back in plaster for another 12 weeks; or complicated surgery - I chose the former. I have never walked normally since and use a stick.

Now I know mistakes happen and everyone is human. I have no problem with that. But if they had just listened .........

Lisad1231981 · 18/03/2022 21:23

We complained to PALS about how DH bloods were dealt with. They lost or delivered bloods too late on 5 occasions, one after the after! By the time they got them sorted his cancer levels were high and they had missed he had developed resistance to his chemo.
After that they changed the whole way it was done and they call the courier as soon as he turns up. That was 10 years ago and they still do it that way (his cancer isn't curable and he has regular bloods)

ComDummings · 18/03/2022 19:44

Definitely complain. The next child in your DDs position may not be so fortunate. Well done on being such a strong advocate for your DD and pressing with your concerns.

EarringsandLipstick · 18/03/2022 19:41

Someone said that doctors on this thread including me should listen to the patient/ parent more.

I'm not sure if you are referring to my post Olympic but if so I didn't include you intentionally, as I recognise you did indeed encourage further communication between OP & the doctors re possible diagnoses. 🙂

WaspRelatedEmergency · 18/03/2022 19:36

Great news the naughty appendix is out.
I'm another vote for a complaint. It's important that procedures are looked into when things like that happen.
I had a piece of wood embedded in my cornea that A&E missed as I wasn't checked properly. I put a complaint in because I don't want that to happen to someone else.

olympicsrock · 18/03/2022 18:06

Wow - OP I am really glad that they have got to the bottom of what was causing your daughter’s pain.

It is incredibly rare to have appendicitis without any rise in inflammatory marker bloods at 10 days.

Someone said that doctors on this thread including me should listen to the patient/ parent more.

I discussed alternative diagnoses but did not say that OP should accept that there was nothing wrong.

One final point OP - please do make sure that you have been told what the histology report from the appendix shows. Usually available 2 weeks after surgery.
Suggest you call the consultant’s secretary in 2 weeks to chase that result.
Very occasionally it shows an usual diagnosis and this happens most commonly in cases where things have not been routine.

I wish your daughter a speedy recovery

Theluggage15 · 18/03/2022 16:31

Well done OP. Great to hear your daughter is feeling so much better. And yes they always cover for each other. Did the same with me when I was misdiagnosed. I wish I’d complained formally about my treatment but just wanted to put it behind me. Might be worth you contacting PALS though, things could have been a lot worse if it wasn’t for you.

ISmellBurnings · 18/03/2022 16:05

Some appendixes do go home in 24 hours if they recover well, pain is controlled and the op was uneventful. Especially if they do it laparoscopically.

Ljmumun · 18/03/2022 14:54

Sorry for the typos on my phone!

Ljmumun · 18/03/2022 14:53

Discharge in 24 hrs os normal for young fit person . TBH she less likely to get a wound issue at home as you sound like a very sensible Mum. As a health professional I would contact PALS and ask for a review of how the causeway handled. This is a complaint still buy sound less critical. Maybe emphasise you want it to be a learned from incident to teach staff how to handle thing better next time. Sometimes this actually helps staff with issues such as lack of resources or staff. Glad your DD is on the mend.

picklespark · 18/03/2022 14:52

Just read this thread and OP, I think you’re incredibly brave and a brilliant advocate for your DD. So glad she is on the mend and thank God you pushed for her to get the right care.

Appendicitis nearly killed me when I was 5. I was sick and had stomach pain at school, my mum took me to the GP in the morning who said it was nothing. My mum was still concerned and I was getting feverish so she took me back to another GP in the evening. They realised what it was right away and called the children’s ward to have me admitted immediately. My appendix turned out to have ruptured and I had severe peritonitis which would have shortly led to sepsis and death. I was operated on that night and recovered well thankfully. I think my poor mum is still traumatised by it 28 years later.

It’s admittedly harder to diagnose in very young children but shocking that at her age, your DD’s symptoms weren’t taken seriously.

randomuser2020 · 18/03/2022 14:39

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn at the poster's request due to privacy concerns.

milkyaqua · 18/03/2022 14:25

God! They could have killed her! Well done for sticking to your guns, trusting your instincts, refusing to be bamboozled by their illogic, and advocating for you daughter.

Pawtriarchal · 18/03/2022 14:18

I wonder why he did do the surgery then, if all signs pointed to not being needed. He’s not making sense.

GabriellaMontez · 18/03/2022 14:16

Typical mumsnet anybody with an opposing view however valid is cast as a villain.

One poster called the OP 'hysterical' amongst her other uninformed comments. I don't think that's valid, it's certainly not helpful and I'm happy to say so. In the context of such a poorly child it's a disgusting comment.

EarringsandLipstick · 18/03/2022 13:17

I didn't say they were rude, other than Schmez.

I do think Sickofthesoapbox was dismissive. She told OP she was UR, and said that the 'wait & see' approach was merited - but this wasn't really OP's concern, it was that a different doctor had insisted on it being constipation with no exam / evidence to support it & she felt she was not being listened to

You're right they didn't say they were a medic, I assumed that from the detailed posts.

Also I didn't say they were a villain! Just that they didn't really hear the OP's concerns, even tho she explained them clearly.

Everybodypretendtobenormal17 · 18/03/2022 12:54

@EarringsandLipstick

It's really interesting that the rude posters like *@Schmz* and the dismissive ones, which while medics, weren't willing to hear OP's points, like *@Sickofthesoapbox24* didn't come back to acknowledge that sometimes situations present differently, and OP had a strong sense as a parent that her DD wasn't being treated correctly.
I don’t think these particular posters were rude apart from one comment from *@Schmz that upset the OP. @Sickofthesoapbox24* merely pointed out the evidence behind how the doctors were reacting and why a child shouldn’t have a CT scan…. Which considering the surgeons who operated have said they’re also baffled it isn’t really surprising.

They also both stated that the OP should sit down and talk with the consultant in charge of her daughters case for answers as there was clearly a breakdown in communication?? I also don’t think that they claimed to be a medic?

Typical mumsnet anybody with an opposing view however valid is cast as a villain.

I’m glad your DD is okay OP.

Honeypickle · 18/03/2022 12:40

So pleased all is well x