Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send this text to my SIL..

207 replies

Myfootfeckinghurts · 15/03/2022 15:23

I am very angry at my SIL.

I’ll try and keep the explanation brief.. She ruined a very rare, child free night out with a large group of friends who I hadn’t seen in ages for mine and a good friends birthday. We are at a comedy club in an local city. She got wankered, refused to just sit and enjoy the comedy without an alcoholic drink so got kicked out. I wasn’t drinking, my night cut very short to take her home.

She has a ‘secret’ drinking problem (will drink vodka and coke in a from a coloured water bottle she keeps in a her handbag so no one suspects) and jokes about being an alcoholic- most infuriatingly, she will never own her shit. She just forgets stuff because she gets shit faced and no one brings her up on it because they don’t want to hurt her feelings- she has depression.

I was just going to leave it as a ‘oh just another stupid thing SIL has done whilst under the influence’ and sweep it under the rug but I can’t. I’m upset, I’m angry and I need to let her know so she can take accountability for her actions.

I was going to send this message to her:
SIL,

I wasn't going to say anything and just 'sweep it under the rug', you know I'm not one for confrontation.

But, I'm sorry but I can't. I've had a few days to try and let my feelings die down a little and see how I felt. My feelings haven't died down and they're still as, if not more intense.

I need you to know how much you've upset me. That night out was the first night out I've had with that group of friends for years, I was so looking forward to it. It was also for my birthday as well after all. And you ruined it for me.

You wouldn't have realised as you were asleep but I was crying most of the way home. I was disappointed that my night ended abruptly. I was annoyed I had paid money for a ticket which wasn't used as I had to leave early. I'm angry at you that you drank yourself into such a state you got asked to leave, and that you insisted on leaving instead of just joining us back the at the table to just have soft drinks.

And honestly, I don't think you would have even text to apologise had it not been that you left my phone in my car.

I am upset, I need time. Don't worry about replying. I just needed to let you know how I am feeling.

Is this too harsh?

OP posts:
PutinIsAWarCriminal · 15/03/2022 16:28

I'm sorry she ruined your night. She was selfish and behaved badly, and if it helps you to send the text then absolutely do it, but please remember something sent in writing can never be unsaid, so choose your words wisely. I am personally too emotional to do this sort of thing face to face, so prefer the written word.
I think you were very generous and very responsible in ending your night to take her home. You put your concern for her safety above your own happiness. We all know what could potentially happen to a shitfaced woman staggering around alone at night.
Going forward she can't be expected to be part of another social event until she gets help for her alcohol abuse. All the family can do is acknowledge the problem and not facilitate her drinking.

caringcarer · 15/03/2022 16:28

Next time don't invite her.if she turns up snub her. If she gets drunk, bundle her into a taxi and go back in to your friends or better still phone her DH and make him collect her.

Maraa · 15/03/2022 16:28

I have the same kind of issues with my mother in law. She ruins everything and then because she’s drunk she’s not made accountable for it at all. The amount of messages I’ve wrote out and deleted because it isn’t worth the hassle. I then finally snapped and messaged her and told her, for her to turn around and play the victim. It’s hard because some people who struggle with alcohol addiction genuinely do not see their behaviour and how it affects others. If it makes you feel better, send the message but be prepared that she won’t see her behaviour! I really feel for you, and for what it’s worth, id have took my mil home too. You sound like a lovely person!

OhMygodddd · 15/03/2022 16:27

Send it…but so what? Until you learn not to be a people pleaser and be a bit more selfish for your own good, things like this will keep happening.
She’s not your responsibility, I would have left her to make her own way home.

nitsandwormsdodger · 15/03/2022 16:26

I have absolutely no idea why you left your birthday night out to take her home ? Why ? she is a grown woman waking up in a ditch maybe is what she needs

Pllink · 15/03/2022 16:26

OP has said she just wants to let SIL know how she feels so I'm not sure why people are giving her grief about "this won't change her". She's not trying to change her!! (Correct me if I'm wrong OP)

If that text is how you feel no-one can tell you it's wrong. They're your feelings. I understand just needing to get things off your chest sometimes. If sending that text will do that then go for it, I'm sure it'll feel like a relief and even if other people say its weak, expressing your feelings is always empowering.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 15/03/2022 16:24

@MadeForThis

I would send a shortened version of the message. But I would add that you will not be in her company again if she's drinking.

Be prepared for her to ignore it.

This Also
I know poor MIL would end up footing the bill for the friend I think that you should have let that happen. It might make MIL take more of a stand and get SIL some help. (you could reimburse MIL at a later date if you felt bad about it) but mainly I think you should take a step back and don't let SIL ruin any more events.
I agree with pp who said Reorganise another one it will help you feel less fed up about this one.
ESGdance · 15/03/2022 16:24

I understand your logic that you didn’t want your MIL to foot the bill for a taxi again - but this is also inadvertently enabling your MIL to enable your SIL.

Your MIL needs to reach the end of her rope as well - otherwise you are all just facilitating and adapting and accommodating the alcoholic.

Gonnagetgoing · 15/03/2022 16:22

[quote Myfootfeckinghurts]@Gonnagetgoing she works, has a new partner, that’s very early days. We are the same age. I believe there is a longing for husband/baby etc.

@Justkeepon yes sorry my mistake, definitely came out wrong. I mean as it not looking after her in sole charge as she always implies she wants to do.[/quote]
@Myfootfeckinghurts - well that's good.

I'd be inclined to cut her some slack but speak seriously to her and MIL etc and say she risks losing her partner and what she wants if she continues to drink irresponsibly.

Xpologog · 15/03/2022 16:22

@Thursday37

I’d be sending

“You ruined my birthday and haven’t even tried to apologise. You are an embarrassment and I want nothing more to do with you. Do everyone a favour and get some help with your alcoholism.”

Why on earth you left early is beyond me though. I would’ve just disowned her.

^ This. She needs something short and sharp. I’m afraid similar will happen over and over unless she engages in help for her drinking, you could find the local AA meeting place and time and add that to the text.
whumpthereitis · 15/03/2022 16:21

I would tbh, but then admittedly I am confrontational when I’ve had the piss taken out of me.

Is it likely to get her to change her behavior? Probably not, but rug sweeping doesn’t either. I see nothing wrong with having her face how you feel. You’re not likely to get any sort of meaningful response, but if it makes you feel better for expressing yourself as opposed to swallowing it then that’s something achieved in itself.

Dotdotdotdashdashdashdotdotdot · 15/03/2022 16:21

@Luckingfovely

It's too long and too emotional.

You need to edit, heavily.

You're not in the wrong, she is. Most of the text sounds like you're apologising to her.

Tell her what she did wrong, and that you are furious.

I agree.
Myotherusernamesafunnyone · 15/03/2022 16:20

@Thursday37

I’d be sending

“You ruined my birthday and haven’t even tried to apologise. You are an embarrassment and I want nothing more to do with you. Do everyone a favour and get some help with your alcoholism.”

Why on earth you left early is beyond me though. I would’ve just disowned her.

This Your message is way too long
Derbee · 15/03/2022 16:20

I wouldn’t send that text. It’s too waffling, and focuses on your feelings rather than her behaviour.

I’ve had a few days to reflect on the other night, and I feel it’s important for you to hear how your behaviour affects others.

That night out was the first night out I've had with that group of friends for years. I was so looking forward to it, and you ruined it for me.

You must be aware that you have a drinking problem. We all sweep it under the carpet and don’t mention it, but it’s time to understand that your actions have consequences for people.

I cannot and will not be inviting you out again, until you learn appropriate behaviour around alcohol, and stop putting yourself in a position where other people have to look after you at the expense of their night out.

I’m sorry if this sounds harsh, but I’m hurt and angry, and I think for your benefit you should address your issues with alcohol

Juniper68 · 15/03/2022 16:18

@ESGdance

Yes it is your “fault” you took her home. If you listen to Al Anon they say that all addicts need to feel the full consequences of their behaviour - so lie in their own piss, wake up in their own shit in a doorway - get bollocked by the venue or arrested by the police.

You saved her from experiencing those consequences. You made life comfortable for her. She wouldn’t have a clue what happened - just she had a great night and must have been ferried home, tucked up in bed where she awoke snuggly the next morning.

Then you also ruined your own evening and are left with raging contempt.

Both of these could have been avoided.

It’s not blaming you - but you need to be accountable to see your contribution to “enabling” her alcoholism - by putting in a safety net, making her comfortable so she has zero consequences and can’t remember anything.

It’s a hard lesson to learn. Been there, done that.

Expect all of the ILs to turn on you to avoid dealing with her.

Send the text if it makes you feel better. But know that it will have zero impact on her and likely will trigger issues with your ILs.

But your ACTIONS are much more important now. Forget dialogue - maybe one simple message to them all “I’m done. Go get help”

And block.

With IL make her a non conversation topic. “I don’t want to talk about her. She needs professional help. I am not involved in her life . Change topic”

I am sorry this is in your family. The only way through it IMHO is to turn your back - have consequences with actions.

Spot on
Noisyprat · 15/03/2022 16:17

The problem is this - you are all enabling her behaviour. Why did you take her home? You could have called DH or called a taxi to take her.

I would either send a very short text or tell her to her face that she, yet again, ruined your night out and you won't be going out again with in future and you won't be picking up the pieces for her. Everyone pussy footing around her is not helping her.

Mummyoflittledragon · 15/03/2022 16:15

You are emptying your heart and pain. This is the sort of text I have sent in the past. Trust me, it really won’t help. This will be used against you. She is unable to hear it.

If you want to send something, let it be devoid of emotion. Eg ‘Do you remember last x day? And x venue asking you to leave? I also left with you to keep you safe and ensure you got home. This was the last time. I will no longer accept my plans and birthday treats to be ruined by your drunken behaviour.’

This is a boundary. You have something to push against whereas your message will be twisted to you winging and moaning.

Womeninblack · 15/03/2022 16:12

OP you sound lovely and I definitely don’t think it’s your phone fault for taking her home
That’s a ridiculous statement to make. Your SIL was drunk therefore vulnerable and of course you felt like you had to take her home.
I think you did what any responsible adult would do.
Sorry your night out was a mess. Not sure if messaging her will make you feel any better because she probably just ignore it.

Hankunamatata · 15/03/2022 16:11

I would send it

theveryhungrycatapillar · 15/03/2022 16:11

Send it she needs to be held accountable

MadeForThis · 15/03/2022 16:11

I would send a shortened version of the message. But I would add that you will not be in her company again if she's drinking.

Be prepared for her to ignore it.

ESGdance · 15/03/2022 16:11

Yes it is your “fault” you took her home. If you listen to Al Anon they say that all addicts need to feel the full consequences of their behaviour - so lie in their own piss, wake up in their own shit in a doorway - get bollocked by the venue or arrested by the police.

You saved her from experiencing those consequences. You made life comfortable for her. She wouldn’t have a clue what happened - just she had a great night and must have been ferried home, tucked up in bed where she awoke snuggly the next morning.

Then you also ruined your own evening and are left with raging contempt.

Both of these could have been avoided.

It’s not blaming you - but you need to be accountable to see your contribution to “enabling” her alcoholism - by putting in a safety net, making her comfortable so she has zero consequences and can’t remember anything.

It’s a hard lesson to learn. Been there, done that.

Expect all of the ILs to turn on you to avoid dealing with her.

Send the text if it makes you feel better. But know that it will have zero impact on her and likely will trigger issues with your ILs.

But your ACTIONS are much more important now. Forget dialogue - maybe one simple message to them all “I’m done. Go get help”

And block.

With IL make her a non conversation topic. “I don’t want to talk about her. She needs professional help. I am not involved in her life . Change topic”

I am sorry this is in your family. The only way through it IMHO is to turn your back - have consequences with actions.

Squeezita · 15/03/2022 16:11

Why on earth did you invite her?

OP, you need have to agency in your own life, you can't be a martyr to maintaining good relations with in laws if it involves ruining own enjoyment in your own life.

Don't call SIL.
Don't text SIL.
Don't invite SIL out.
Don't accept SIL's invitations.
Don't be responsible for SIL ever again.

rwalker · 15/03/2022 16:09

It will solve nothing but cause massive drama just learn for next time

JudgeJ · 15/03/2022 16:08

@TheUndoingProject

She’s an alcoholic. Telling her she hurt your feelings isn’t going to get her to change her behaviour. Just don’t invite her to events.
And also make sure that all your friends and family know of her drinking.
Swipe left for the next trending thread