Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make a complaint about a GP?

81 replies

BowsandBaking · 15/03/2022 15:06

I called the surgery to request a routine appointment for my 3yo who has been having increasing joint pain and headaches for the past month and a half.
I explained he has been struggling to climb the stairs over the past week and recently fell down from half up when his legs gave way. The receptionist and she told me to call back at 2pm for a same-day appointment. She said “I’m not medically trained but I feel this should be dealt with today”.

I called back at 2pm where a very harsh, second receptionist told me calls after 2pm are for medical emergencies. I told her that her colleague told me to request a same-day appointment. She reluctantly issued one.

The GP was fuming from the start. Sarcastically reminding me around four times during the call that the afternoon service is for emergencies only. I explained that I tried for a routine appointment but she’d made up her mind by then - she clearly felt I was an over-anxious first time mum. She suggested maybe I had traumatic birth.

She wouldn’t let me go into any detail. I tried to explain that he started new medication around the onset of symptoms and she cut me off. I tried to explain he cannot use his language to fully explain his symptoms as he has additional needs. She was questioning what I define as “additional needs”. I tried to explain that he’s under multiple of consultants for various complex medical needs and is awaiting an MDA for the additional needs.

She kept sighing. She ended up giving him an appointment to be seen tomorrow in such a way that it was very clear it was extremely unnecessary in her eyes. I felt so belittled.

The most important thing is that DS will be seen tomorrow, but AIBU to complain to the practice manager? I think this kind of belittling could prevent somebody seeking medical advice.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EthelTheAardvark · 18/03/2022 19:30

All of the keyboard warriors on this thread need to reflect on the reality of the NHS at the moment vs. the amazing gold rimmed experience you are being told you deserve.

Why Is basic politeness a "gold-rimmed experience"? I had a bit of an emergency recently and, over various visits to GPs and hospitals in the course of two weeks, dealt with a total of 9 doctors and nurses. All of them were pleasant, polite and professional. I must be exceptionally lucky.

MissyB1 · 16/03/2022 18:21

@MauveMavis

You are all aware aren’t you that the NHS is facing the biggest staffing crisis it has ever seen following a major pandemic response?

Staff are stressed, tired amd burnt out. There aren’t enough of us to provide the care we want to give (which as a clinician is stressful). Such stress enhances the burnout rate which increases the staffing pressures on the remaining staff smd so the cycle continues.

Yes, sounds like your interaction wasn’t that great but does it really merit a complaint? You got an appointment.

All of the keyboard warriors on this thread need to reflect on the reality of the NHS at the moment vs. the amazing gold rimmed experience you are being told you deserve.

Quite frankly as a frontline clinician I feel like I’m being ritually sacrificed by the govt/my employer. There is not enough time /resources for me to give the care my patients have been led to believe.

This is having horrendous consequences in my personal life. But even worse for the first time ever all my colleagues and I feel the same. No one has anything left in reserve it’s all been used up over the past two years.

Look I hear you but my dh (hospital Consultant) is also under immense pressure - but would rather poke himself in the eye than be rude or nasty to a patient! As he always says "it's not the patient's fault". Yes this Government are shitting over all NHS staff and have been for years. But patients and their relatives still need kindness and courtesy.
NapoleonSolo · 16/03/2022 11:54

I think this is complaint-worthy but my advice to you is to wait until you've made some progress with this episode of illness, in the sense of having some idea what the problem is and a care plan going forward.

At the moment your complaint is that receptionist #2 and the GP were hostile and that had an emotional effect on you that you think other patients should be spared. While you and I might think that's a valid position, the only learning point likely to be taken from it is an advanced eyerolling practice session.

I think your complaint will have more effect a week or a month or more down the line when you're more likely to be able to say something like: she was dismissive of my concerns and if I had been put off from insisting on an appointment, we would have missed X diagnosis and the situation would now be Y.

I hope your DC improves soon. Flowers

TroysMammy · 16/03/2022 10:46

I'm a GP Receptionist with no medical training but I listen and retain information. Our GPs have always said a child who can't weight bear especially with no trauma would be an emergency appointment, usually advised to attend A&E to rule out a serious illness.

cranberryhaddock · 16/03/2022 10:42

@MauveMavis

You are all aware aren’t you that the NHS is facing the biggest staffing crisis it has ever seen following a major pandemic response?

Staff are stressed, tired amd burnt out. There aren’t enough of us to provide the care we want to give (which as a clinician is stressful). Such stress enhances the burnout rate which increases the staffing pressures on the remaining staff smd so the cycle continues.

Yes, sounds like your interaction wasn’t that great but does it really merit a complaint? You got an appointment.

All of the keyboard warriors on this thread need to reflect on the reality of the NHS at the moment vs. the amazing gold rimmed experience you are being told you deserve.

Quite frankly as a frontline clinician I feel like I’m being ritually sacrificed by the govt/my employer. There is not enough time /resources for me to give the care my patients have been led to believe.

This is having horrendous consequences in my personal life. But even worse for the first time ever all my colleagues and I feel the same. No one has anything left in reserve it’s all been used up over the past two years.

'Amazing gold rimmed experience'? Crikey. All the OP was asking for was basic common courtesy and for her concerns to be taken seriously. It doesn't take any more time to speak to a patient politely than rudely. Sighing as the OP's GP did, in front of a patient, is inexcusable.

Also, what about the impact on hospitals if people are too scared to go to the GP for fear of getting their head ripped off, so wait until their condition becomes serious/life-threatening to seek help?

BeKind1981 · 16/03/2022 10:39

This infuriates me, they have a duty of care to all patients at all times. This dismissive behaviour is why I left troubling symptoms with my DD go on for much longer than I should have. This is also the reason I ended up helpless at A & E with a child admitted immediately with sepsis. My GP had no experience identifying the symptoms on mixed race skin and told me it was just a virus and stop calling the surgery. Thankfully she is OK after 4 nights in hospital but this behaviour could quite literally kill someone!

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 16/03/2022 10:24

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

olympicsrock · 16/03/2022 10:20

Wow this GP was really dismissive. Yes do make a complaint. I am a doctor . You did the right thing and this was very much below the expected standard of care.

MNchicken · 16/03/2022 10:14

You are all aware aren’t you that the NHS is facing the biggest staffing crisis it has ever seen following a major pandemic response?

Staff are stressed, tired amd burnt out. There aren’t enough of us to provide the care we want to give (which as a clinician is stressful). Such stress enhances the burnout rate which increases the staffing pressures on the remaining staff smd so the cycle continues

I think you’d have to have been hiding in a cupboard to not know this. It must be a bloody nightmare. Nevertheless, at the GP practice I go to (which has also been a covid vaccination hub), no matter who you speak to - reception, nurse practitioners, GPs, admin , pharmacist - are always helpful, polite, caring. They’re amazing and I’ve made sure to let them know how grateful I am to be a patient there. The government is a disgrace when it comes to systematically neglecting the NHS but it’s not ok to ‘kick the cat ‘ and take that out on patients.

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 16/03/2022 10:10

Problematic GPs and doctors have existed long before the latest government neglect of the NHS. It's a problem with culture, training and doctors believing they're something they're not. Who is encouraging and facilitating these beliefs? Who addresses the behaviour of GPs? Who are they accountable to? Their patients? No. Who addresses the massive amount of misdiagnosis that goes on?

Notanotherwindow · 16/03/2022 10:08

Oh as soon as she cut me off and rolled her eyes, I'd have given it to her both barrels. That's disgusting behaviour even if you were a bit anxious.

I would have been very alarmed at a sudden deterioration like that, especially his legs giving way and intense headache. What if he was having a stroke or some kind of neurological event?

Seeing the doctor same day was necessary imo, if not A&E. I don't understand why people are saying yabu. I doubt that would be the case if it was their child.

MauveMavis · 16/03/2022 10:02

Ps: and if all of you think you could do medicine better please go to medical school and try!!

MauveMavis · 16/03/2022 10:00

The govt increased the number of medical school places but failed to increased the number of junior doctor positions that the new graduates need to get full registration with the GMC.

Come August there will be around 800 unemployed medical graduates who wanted to be doctors in the uK but there wasn’t an available list for them to make the first step towards this (rightly or wrongly this has never happened before).

Ask yourselves if this is the actions of a government who want to promote the nations health or that of a government who want to force down medical pay , reduce services, sell the NHS to their US cronies and give everyone a much more expensive less good health service….

I know what I think and what I vote for (clue it’s not BoJo and his corrupt privileged mates).

MNchicken · 16/03/2022 10:00

Realistically what are you expecting the Gp to do? Not being arsey but just aware how little knowledge GPs often have when it comes to medically complex people (no dig at GPs they are after all general practitioners)

I’d expect them not to tut and sigh and suggest that her concerns might be a result of a traumatic birth. That’s just misogynistic, minimising crap. If they felt the worsening symptoms were something they should check then I’d expect them to see OPs DS , and if not to advise OP who she should g speak to.

RockinHorseShit · 16/03/2022 09:56

I've been in a very similar situation with a patronising assed dismissive GP. Mine turned out to have double pneumonia.

Definitely complain, crank that complaint up if you get a significant diagnosis too. I did & as a result forced some child aware retraining for that particular GP, so he didn't get to do it again to anyone else, he apologised in person too

Pyewhacket · 16/03/2022 09:56

I wouldn’t waste your time making a complaint. Nothing ever happens.

HoppingPavlova · 16/03/2022 09:52

I’m not medically trained enough to know which consultant to go to about a completely new, unrelated problem. I have always been advised to go to the GP as the first point of call with a new medical issue

You don’t need to be medically trained. You are saying these new symptoms coincide with a new medication. The consultant who prescribed the medication will know if what is being experienced is likely due to the new meds or not. If not, they are savvy and will be of more use than the GP in telling you which of your other consultants would be the most appropriate for what’s being experienced. No need for you to have any training or try and work it all out!

Also, does your child have a coordinating paed? If so, they would also be of more use in assessing the new med and cross-referring as required than the GP.

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 16/03/2022 09:52

Instead of whining, doctors need to address the problem of staffing shortages......like the BMA did when they voted to restrict doctor training places back in the 2000s because they didn't want the profession devalued.

The public deserve better.

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 16/03/2022 09:50

@MauveMavis speaking with a bad tone to a patient can have very bad consequences. It adversely impacts people with mental health difficulties, neurodiversity, anxious people, older people and people with learning disabilities. It is absolutely not okay to speak to patients with a bad tone. Impacted people will stop seeking healthcare because of it. I expect that's okay though, because, fewer patients to be forced to see 🙄

Blue4YOU · 16/03/2022 09:49

IP - I have a DD with severe disabilities. Her GP is outstanding in terms of care (he intervened when she needed an ambulance but the ambulance refused to come - during the “petrol crisis”) but his general manner is somewhat cold. I hear you - it’s not about manner/grumpiness etc.
GPs ARE meant to be the first port of call - not the prescribing consultant and the symptoms you described are very concerning. It’s not for the general public to decide if it’s medication causing very worrying symptoms.
As for frontline staff blah blah - GPs haven’t been having face to face consultations frequently.
Paediatric wards have been empty during the pandemic- I have heard that directly from NHS staff - and nurses were redeployed to ICU care (perhaps as children weren’t mixing etc at school or doing activities that caused injuries and few having covid/serious covid). So those of you banging the poor NHS drum - stop.
I’d have lost any job I’ve ever worked in if I behaved like this GP (professional or “unskilled”).
She isn’t obliged to work as a GP if she’s burnt out etc. there are plenty of jobs in other areas.
I’d suggest you write to the Practice Manager Op - be clear what outcome you’d like (I’ve we’d had serious complaints to make to the NHS - and be because of the ambulance issue I mentioned and one because I was sexually assaulted by a paediatric consultant).
Does your DC have “open access “ to their local CAU?
Could that be arranged?
Pm me if I can help at all. I’m 4.5 years into learning all the ins and outs of which consultant for which problem etc.

MayMorris · 16/03/2022 09:39

@MauveMavis

You are all aware aren’t you that the NHS is facing the biggest staffing crisis it has ever seen following a major pandemic response?

Staff are stressed, tired amd burnt out. There aren’t enough of us to provide the care we want to give (which as a clinician is stressful). Such stress enhances the burnout rate which increases the staffing pressures on the remaining staff smd so the cycle continues.

Yes, sounds like your interaction wasn’t that great but does it really merit a complaint? You got an appointment.

All of the keyboard warriors on this thread need to reflect on the reality of the NHS at the moment vs. the amazing gold rimmed experience you are being told you deserve.

Quite frankly as a frontline clinician I feel like I’m being ritually sacrificed by the govt/my employer. There is not enough time /resources for me to give the care my patients have been led to believe.

This is having horrendous consequences in my personal life. But even worse for the first time ever all my colleagues and I feel the same. No one has anything left in reserve it’s all been used up over the past two years.

Ok, I get that. But it sounds like the gp took their frustration out on the OP. that isn’t ok. If someone is close to burn out they aren’t going to be able to help patients- they need to take time off. Yep, all sorts of reasons why they can’t - but they’ll be taking more off if they get full blown mental health problems with stress

Question? What are GPS doing to sort this isssue out? Where is the union (so to speak) in protecting the well-being of GPs ? Who did you vote for and who did other GPS generally vote for. There are things that health care workers who are ranting at the state of the services can do- taking it out on patients isn’t one of them.

MayMorris · 16/03/2022 09:33

@Nelliephant1

No need to complain, why on earth would you create more work and unnecessary hassle for a hugely overstretched service just because someone was a bit grumpy?! People have off days, you've got no idea what she was dealing with before your phone or what was heading her way after you finished call so chalk it up to experience and remember that you wanted an appointment and that's what you got. I'm sure you have days too when you're not a sparkling ray of sunshine.
Complete bollocks. Normally I agree that people so,et I,es get caught on hop and express frustration. But this gp didn’t do this once then correct herself, the whole appointment was like this. They are professional. They are paid to listen to peoples whinges and moans and potential time wasting as ,yes, occasionally a potential time waster actually turns out to be a serious medical emergency. That is their job. If their bedside manner is rude and partronising they need to be told this and check themselves. If they are stressed out, I’ll and tired themselves they need to take some leave to get back to a better disposition for a job that is overwhelming demanding and frustrating much of the time.
MauveMavis · 16/03/2022 09:31

I’m not saying don’t complain.

I am saying think about what you complain about. Seriously poor care which contravenes National guidance. Game on. I’ll help you write the letter.

A difficult consultation where a patient didn’t like the doctors attitude but got the outcome they desired. …maybe not.

If everyone complains about the latter the threads about GP practices closing will be even more frequent.

HereComesTheSum · 16/03/2022 09:23

[quote BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation]@MauveMavis great, so we should just have to suck it up and accept bad behaviour? Talk about race to the bottom. How long before clinicians can't be bothered - sorry, are under too much stress - to even look or speak to patients anymore? Where are people supposed to go then? Doctors have been being rude and obnoxious to patients since time immemorial and they should always be called out on it. They're in the wrong job if they can't even be civil and listen to patients. They get away with it because they can.[/quote]
👏

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 16/03/2022 09:21

@MauveMavis great, so we should just have to suck it up and accept bad behaviour? Talk about race to the bottom. How long before clinicians can't be bothered - sorry, are under too much stress - to even look or speak to patients anymore? Where are people supposed to go then? Doctors have been being rude and obnoxious to patients since time immemorial and they should always be called out on it. They're in the wrong job if they can't even be civil and listen to patients. They get away with it because they can.

Swipe left for the next trending thread