Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

All male colleagues have a Teams channel I'm not on.

113 replies

Choux · 15/03/2022 14:30

My manager is male and all his other direct reports are male. Male dominated industry trying hard to improve the gender balance. Lots of sport esp football talk but generally my colleagues are ok, family oriented blokes.

We wfh most days but go into office together Weds. My manager mailed this morning to all of us to say he wasn't coming to office tomorrow as he was going to the football tomorrow night and couldn't get there in time from the office. (He has a long commute)

Another colleague replied to all to say 'I am coming in still but you all know that as I sent a Teams chat on the subject'. I am not on the Teams chat. It's not clear if my manager is on the Teams chat or not or how often chat is happening on there and what topics are being discussed.

Maybe it's mainly football talk but I'm annoyed at being excluded, him not realising I am excluded and I'm even thinking about all the times over my career I have felt excluded eg hearing the men i sat next to every day in a previous role often went for a beer after work but didn't invite me.

AIBU to start my reply on whether I am going to office tomorrow with 'Which Teams chat is that???'

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Choux · 19/03/2022 14:43

@burnoutbabe

but your boss could well be in the "football chat" channel. We have plenty of social channels in our work place for people to come together (as all WFH) about various things - wordle is a big one now.

As well as the normal ones that are for particular work teams as well.

But how are those social channels joined? Are they open to everyone or do people just set them up with friends?

I don't know what the facts are re the chat I was not a part of but a football chat channel that's been set up by someone that includes all my peers but not me is a way for them to bond about any and every topic. And I am excluded from that bonding. And, if they have added my manager to that chat and are excluding me then that's worse.

Three guys having a private football chat during work time on Teams is one thing. Five (which is all of peers) guys plus my manager having a private channel that only I am not on would be quite another. The chat might be 90% football and 10% other social stuff but I'm not being given the option to participate in the other 10% because no one added me to it.

As I said I'm going to ask about it when we are next in the office together and hopefully find out if I am being excluded.

OP posts:
AlisonDonut · 19/03/2022 14:16

@burnoutbabe

but your boss could well be in the "football chat" channel. We have plenty of social channels in our work place for people to come together (as all WFH) about various things - wordle is a big one now.

As well as the normal ones that are for particular work teams as well.

And it appears that the OP is not in any of them.
burnoutbabe · 19/03/2022 13:25

but your boss could well be in the "football chat" channel. We have plenty of social channels in our work place for people to come together (as all WFH) about various things - wordle is a big one now.

As well as the normal ones that are for particular work teams as well.

Choux · 19/03/2022 12:51

Placeholder update:

I posted during the week that I'm going to ask the person who posted about the teams chat about it when we are next in the office so I can see his reaction. He seems like a nice enough guy so I am not sure he would be deliberately excluding me and I think will be horrified and apologetic in equal measure if I said I felt I was being.

I didn't say anything on Tuesday as
a) I have no proof an ongoing channel exists - it could just have been a quick 4 or 5 way chat in response to my manager's email.
b) my reaction felt like more than a reaction to that particular message. It was a 'oh no not more evidence of the work boys club' reaction coming from 20 plus years of working in a mostly male environment. By the time I spent some time figuring out why I felt that way the moment to reply had somewhat passed.
c) the channel won't be about work or, if it is it will be largely irrelevant to my work. I get that not everyone needs to be included in every interaction that happens at the work place especially if it's not work related.

But I will be asking questions to find out if there is an ongoing channel and, crucially for me, if my manager is on it. Then I can decide if I am going to ask to be added.

OP posts:
Annette32123 · 17/03/2022 21:19

Luckily with men you don’t need to be subtle.

Reply to the message from your manager saying ‘I hadn’t seen your message on of Teams chat - can you add me if I’m not on one of the groups?’

No need to elaborate or overthink. Just shove in - it’s what men do and they don’t think twice about it.

AlisonDonut · 17/03/2022 20:56

@burnoutbabe

Do you need to know this colleague is off -surely he needs to tell his boss and put it through the holiday system.

So him mentioning it on the football chat does not matter . Heck I may say I am having tomorrow off to people to play a new game in my work "what games are you playing" chat but that doesn't make that chat group a work chat that everyone needs to be in.

I have got my day off booked and told those Who need to know via the correct channels (which work colleague did -hence why the op knows about it, it was raised in a work chat too)

Discrimination basics.

If a dominant group has private work chats that under-represented groups are excluded from, that is discrimination.

It doesn't matter if all they chat about is football. If it is on a work system, and it is an all male group, and the only person not included is a female (under-represented group, in a work situation, excluded from work chats) that is discrimination.

Even if all she wants to talk about is chickens and flower arranging, it does not matter. Because she will never ever know what the fucking chat is about because she is being excluded.

Honest to god I thought people knew this by now? How are so many people completely ignorant of basic work practices?

burnoutbabe · 17/03/2022 20:49

Do you need to know this colleague is off -surely he needs to tell his boss and put it through the holiday system.

So him mentioning it on the football chat does not matter . Heck I may say I am having tomorrow off to people to play a new game in my work "what games are you playing" chat but that doesn't make that chat group a work chat that everyone needs to be in.

I have got my day off booked and told those Who need to know via the correct channels (which work colleague did -hence why the op knows about it, it was raised in a work chat too)

whatisforteamum · 17/03/2022 20:29

I would mention it.
I work in a male dominated team and we had a work group chat.
Tbh most of it was silly memes,football references and it got on my nerves to be in contact after a 12 hr day.
They forgot it was a work group and posted disgusting things too.
Luckily for me some of them left so no one posts unless it is important work stuff.
You are probably not missing anything but it is nice to be asked if u would like to be included.

Feelingoktoday · 17/03/2022 19:43

It could be a group for football? Or some other crap like F1. Not sure I could be bothered but raise it anyway.

beinggreen · 17/03/2022 19:43

It's normal to have private Teams chats. However, this guy has posted in the wrong one, which is the problem.

Do you have an existing channel/chat for your whole team to post these kinds of updates in? Does it actually get used?

I think you just need to remind them that if they're posting these kind of things on Teams, they need to make sure they post in the right place. That's it.

SergeiL · 17/03/2022 19:37

You need to call this out. How about:

Hey all. Didn’t realise there was a Teams Chat. I need to know peoples whereabouts too so please add me. Thanks.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 17/03/2022 19:32

@LaChanticleer

I'm just sick of 20 plus years of occasional discoveries I've been excluded, paranoia that working relationships were being built when I wasn't around, jobs, promotions etc were being discussed and people were being helped into them because they were mates etc. I feel compared to the majority of my male colleagues from twenty years ago I have underachieved. Maybe part of it is that they were more driven but I think a part of it is that the workplace is still stacked against women.

I hear you @Choux. Ask about it - put them on the spot.

And rehearse a statement you can make without sounding upset, which points out that this could be seen as exclusionary and workplace bullying.

She'd have a job to do that.
LaChanticleer · 17/03/2022 19:31

I'm just sick of 20 plus years of occasional discoveries I've been excluded, paranoia that working relationships were being built when I wasn't around, jobs, promotions etc were being discussed and people were being helped into them because they were mates etc. I feel compared to the majority of my male colleagues from twenty years ago I have underachieved. Maybe part of it is that they were more driven but I think a part of it is that the workplace is still stacked against women.

I hear you @Choux. Ask about it - put them on the spot.

And rehearse a statement you can make without sounding upset, which points out that this could be seen as exclusionary and workplace bullying.

AlisonDonut · 17/03/2022 19:22

@Besttobe8001

I work in a senior role in this kind of environment and strongly suggest you don't go to HR! Terrible move.
Yes stick to making the men some tea. Don't rock the boat!
LondonWolf · 17/03/2022 19:10

At the end of the day my manager just got up and left to go to the other building for drinks and didn't even ask if I was going. Maybe the others had told him I was on the fence / didn't want to go but it didn't feel very inclusive.

Maybe he didn't feel like trying to persuade you if you were umming and ahhing all day about going?

As for the Teams thing, yes I can see why that's annoying and I think I'd ask straight out if it's work related or more of friends chatting kind of thing. You should totally be on it if they're discussing work related issues.

lljkk · 17/03/2022 19:08

I wonder what OP did, seems like she hasn't posted in > 48 hours.

Having to wade thru lots of boring footie chat doesn't appeal to me, I'd assume I was informed what I need to be when relevant.

Besttobe8001 · 17/03/2022 19:04

I work in a senior role in this kind of environment and strongly suggest you don't go to HR! Terrible move.

user1471453601 · 17/03/2022 18:58

Whatever they are talking bout, they are deliberately excluding you.

I worked on an otherwise all male team. They tried the football chat to exclude me. Tough shit, I've watched football since 1969. I can out talk most people on football.

In fact one bloke told me I clearly knew more about football than the lot of them out together. And he was a season ticket holder at a premiership club. We had some good "banter" (in its truest form) between us, as the club I support was not the one he supported.

So even if the Teams thing is "just" for football chat, it's still a deliberate attempt to isolate you.

Complain to HR. I personally wouldn't bother going to your immediate boss. Isn't one of the definitions of bullying being to deliberately exclude someone?

JustLyra · 17/03/2022 18:42

@slimshady18

But if a male was making this thread about women who had a Teams chat without him, he would be absolutely flamed on here! Come on Mumsnet, double standards much?! And I am a woman!
If they were sharing work information then he’d get the same reply.
JustLyra · 17/03/2022 18:41

@lljkk

We have some 'social' teams (or Yammer) chat on some of my employers sites. I don't see a problem with purely social teams channels/chat on work platforms. Some of them are supposed to be work related, but all people ever talk about is their pets & pretty garden pictures.

I'm not sure that OP ever clarified that she actually needed to know in advance who was or wasn't in the office that day.

Even if she didn’t need to know that specific fact how does she then find out anything else that’s in there?

Work groups should include everyone necessary. If they don’t then no work info should be shared there at all. Once that starts being the work group it’s only a matter of time before the OP is left out of something important.

slimshady18 · 17/03/2022 18:32

But if a male was making this thread about women who had a Teams chat without him, he would be absolutely flamed on here! Come on Mumsnet, double standards much?! And I am a woman!

lljkk · 17/03/2022 18:29

Long thread, so someone tell me where OP asked to join the group -- she did ask, right?

AlisonDonut · 17/03/2022 18:26

@lljkk

We have some 'social' teams (or Yammer) chat on some of my employers sites. I don't see a problem with purely social teams channels/chat on work platforms. Some of them are supposed to be work related, but all people ever talk about is their pets & pretty garden pictures.

I'm not sure that OP ever clarified that she actually needed to know in advance who was or wasn't in the office that day.

Just wondering how she would know whether or not the info shared in the man group would be relevant to her at all. Being that she is just a female and as such, only interested in shiny things and doing the washing up.
lljkk · 17/03/2022 18:12

We have some 'social' teams (or Yammer) chat on some of my employers sites. I don't see a problem with purely social teams channels/chat on work platforms. Some of them are supposed to be work related, but all people ever talk about is their pets & pretty garden pictures.

I'm not sure that OP ever clarified that she actually needed to know in advance who was or wasn't in the office that day.

AlisonDonut · 16/03/2022 20:30

@Birdy474

They're entitled to their single sex space 🤷‍♀️
Work teams chats are not toilets.

Works teams chats are works teams chats.

Where teams chat about work.

They don't need privacy to expose their genitals. They are talking about work.

Hence telling them all that he won't be in, you know, work.