Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they should vet people offering home to refugees?

82 replies

youllneedthisfish · 15/03/2022 12:47

All morning I’ve heard people being interviewed about the Ukraine refugee scheme. Even interviewers are minimising the risks of not vetting people taking refugees in.

I think this is going to be a great risk to vulnerable children and adults.

Even dogs who need a home are lucky enough to get their new homes vetted under quite infamously strict criteria.

I know nearly all people offering this help will be genuine but I can’t help think a tiny few will be nasty in quite a few different ways.

I really hope that it works out well and that the charities with resources to vet before recommending a named family will step in and gatekeeper this - but perhaps that’s why they asked for you to name someone.

I haven’t a spare room currently or I’d be on the list- but you do need a car where I live not to be isolated - how will that works out for people

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Turningpurple · 16/03/2022 09:11

@Firefliess

I think single men hoping to house attractive young women and lure them into bed is decidedly creepy and abusive of the power dynamic in this situation. But it's not illegal, and the men wouldn't necessarily be barred via any kind of background check. Even a home interview they'd be unlikely to fail (as I assume they'd have the sense not to let on their aspirations!) So ensuring that there's support and an option to help young women move on somewhere else if they find themselves in a difficult situation seems to me much more valuable than vetting itself
I do think this is a risk.

Mainly, because there are a lot of men who feel entitled to sex with women. Especially where they have shown a shred of kindness to the women OR they feel the women owe them.

Though I don't think it will be single men.

Though I do agree with pp that couples could also be a risk.

DetailMouse · 16/03/2022 09:07

@Firefliess

I think single men hoping to house attractive young women and lure them into bed is decidedly creepy and abusive of the power dynamic in this situation. But it's not illegal, and the men wouldn't necessarily be barred via any kind of background check. Even a home interview they'd be unlikely to fail (as I assume they'd have the sense not to let on their aspirations!) So ensuring that there's support and an option to help young women move on somewhere else if they find themselves in a difficult situation seems to me much more valuable than vetting itself
I don't actually think this is big the risk anyway.

The risk would be men (and women) looking for essentially slave labour and children to abuse.

I also think there's quite a risk to those taking them in. Again, the vast majority will be completely genuine and grateful for the kindness, but there will also be criminals amongst them.

Firefliess · 16/03/2022 09:04

I think single men hoping to house attractive young women and lure them into bed is decidedly creepy and abusive of the power dynamic in this situation. But it's not illegal, and the men wouldn't necessarily be barred via any kind of background check. Even a home interview they'd be unlikely to fail (as I assume they'd have the sense not to let on their aspirations!) So ensuring that there's support and an option to help young women move on somewhere else if they find themselves in a difficult situation seems to me much more valuable than vetting itself

SartresSoul · 16/03/2022 08:38

Totally agree, they could be entering the home of a paedophile with their children or complete psychopath. It’s unlikely but always possible.

Underhisi · 16/03/2022 08:25

"On the other hand, vetting would be at most background checks. It wouldn't show up some of the concerns raised above, e.g. people hoping to house females that they can have sex with, unless they've been convicted of an offence in the past."

Yes I think there are concerns about putting woman and children in all male households.

DetailMouse · 16/03/2022 08:20

I suppose it's all in the badus that people are desperate and need somewhere to stay quickly, but I certain that some of these poor people will be exploited and badly treated, not to mention the risk to children of living with unvetted strangers.

Lots of people supporting the scheme will have entirely good motives but surely we know that there will be lots more in it for what they can gain. For example we know that single mothers are targeted by paedophiles, why wouldn't we expect that displaced women with young children wouldn't be targeted in the same way?

It will be hard to find the balance between enough checks and making the scheme to cumbersome

Firefliess · 16/03/2022 08:14

@DesertStorms

I just heard a government minister saying the vetting system isn’t in place yet and will be a ‘light fingered approach’ . Hmm.
I do hope you misheard that and they actually said light touch. Light fingered is a euphemism for being a thief!
Travelledtheworld · 15/03/2022 23:37

The charity Refugees at Home were recruiting people who could carry out home suitability checks. They were particularly interested in people who were or had been Social workers, district nurses etc i.e. People who were used to assessing people's homes.

DdraigGoch · 15/03/2022 23:35

@Bananabutter

YABU. Beggars can’t be choosers.

It’s a silly scheme that we can’t afford anyway so no need to add anymore red tape on.

"Beggars" should be able to choose not to be raped. That OK with you?
BoldMove · 15/03/2022 23:32

How can the refugees possibly be vetted? And yes, agree, its a scheme we can't afford, uk is already in debt and heading for a recession.

DdraigGoch · 15/03/2022 23:30

@AchillesPoirot

They are vetting people though?
How on earth do you practically vet this many people to a level of detail sufficient to eliminate risk?

You can conduct criminal records checks, but that's only of any use if they've actually been caught.

ClareBlue · 15/03/2022 23:12

We have community meets for all our families which stops them being isolated. Also they have buddies outside their host families who they can turn to and have to meet them regularly. The children have after school clubs supervised by non family volunteers. All these things help reduce risks of exploitation. But it needs to be ongoing and visible. We even have police talk to our refugees to try and build some trust in authority. All this helps, but you cannot be 100 perc, unfortunately.

ScreamingBeans · 15/03/2022 23:06

Absolutely not unreasonable.

There will undoubtedly be predators and exploiters lining up for this, as well as decent people who want to help.

The stories about the kids who were evacuated from the cities during the war only to find themselves being used as cheap labour or sexually abused, should be borne in mind. Of course host families should be vetted

Househogger · 15/03/2022 23:00

I hope there will be organisations offering support both to refugees and to people offering accommodation in the case of any difficulties. I do think there should be some attempt at vetting.

ClareBlue · 15/03/2022 22:54

But these are exceptionally vulnerable and traumatised people and we must ensure we do everything possible to ensure they are not exploited because of their circumstances.

Buttercup54321 · 15/03/2022 22:53

You are unreasonable because the government said people offering homes will be vetted.

ClareBlue · 15/03/2022 22:52

Having read some comments on TicTok about housing good looking young Ukrainian women I think we need to be extremely cautious here. Also the impact it has on your housing dynamics should not be underestimated along with sharing space with trauma victims. We work with Syrian refugees in our community and these aspects can not be dealt with by everyone and should not be underestimated. Impact on existing children in a family can be profound.
Saying that, I'm in Budapest at the moment and the scenes at the railway station today are actually heart breaking and you can see why people want to just try and help.

DesertStorms · 15/03/2022 22:49

The govt is making it up as they go along. They have no idea how people will be vetted yet is my guess. Who is going to carry out this vetting? Social workers?

LightSpeeds · 15/03/2022 22:47

@Mamamia7962

I wish people would do a quick Google search before starting threads like this. OP people taking in refugees will be vetted
HOW will they be vetted?
Echobelly · 15/03/2022 22:33

I think some vetting will happen, some will be missed. But yes, I fear there will be some individuals seeing an opportunity to get some 'unpaid help' at home or worse. I would hope they will be extra careful about anyone taking in women or children.

Thewindwhispers · 15/03/2022 22:10

Well, let’s see. When female travellers were housed in UK quarentine hotels, they got sexually harassed by the security guards.

I wonder what will happen when traumatised vulnerable women and children with no money or local family or place to run to are housed with any random creep with a spare room.

😭

Siepie · 15/03/2022 20:17

@Bananabutter

YABU. Beggars can’t be choosers.

It’s a silly scheme that we can’t afford anyway so no need to add anymore red tape on.

So you’re happy for young girls who have escaped from a war zone to be raped or sexually exploited? I assume you wouldn’t be happy for that to happen to you or your daughters? But it’s okay for Ukrainians because what, they were born somewhere else and write with a different alphabet?

I volunteer with refugees and I’d rather live with any of them than with someone with views as vile as yours.

Chasingaftermidnight · 15/03/2022 20:12

I agree. The scheme sounds like an absolute magnet for perverts - want some vulnerable women and children in your home? Sign up here!

Akire · 15/03/2022 19:58

It’s not ready to go live yet we should have them over in sports halls and like until checks can be done for non family. At very least we need a link person with each family who know where they are and regular contact so they know if anyone disappears and if reports abuse and know be airlifted out the situation in an instant.

These people need money or be relying on other for food clothing and shelter until benefit claims kick in. That takes mim 5 weeks best of times and that’s if you have every paperwork and ID going. Goodness knows how DWP going slot them into system and make it work without serious issues.

Bunnyfuller · 15/03/2022 19:51

If you don’t check the address you let you kids go to on a sleepover (because, quite rightly you can’t) then don’t use ‘they’re Ukrainian’ as an excuse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread