Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to be concerned about Ukranian refugees entering the country in large numbers?

220 replies

MaMaLa321 · 15/03/2022 11:03

I think that we have done the right thing, as a country, to allow Ukranian refugees to enter the UK. But does anyone else have concerns about how this will pan out?
For a start, we've spent 2 years in Lockdown, but the vaccination rate for Ukranians (for double vaccination) is only 34%.
What's the effect on our Social Services going to be?
FWIW, we have applied to house a refugee. It's just that I'm worried about the knock-on effects.
Also, will many Ukranians want to come here?

OP posts:
Iggly · 15/03/2022 16:27

CRB checks mean nothing as they only catch those who’ve been caught! Not those with intent.

As for numbers - we have no qualms about letting oligarchs in who bring little to the country except marginally.

There are 66,000,000 people in the UK. A few more won’t make any difference and I strongly suspect they’ll want to go home as soon as they can!

DrManhattan · 15/03/2022 16:23

@MarshaBradyo
What I mean is that if we as UK citizens had to flee the UK and seek refuge in Europe, I don't think we would be very welcome because of the horrible way we (as a collective) treat refugees. I know there are amazing exceptions to this but the country as a whole has a terrible reputation.

Alexandra2001 · 15/03/2022 16:02

What I'm worried about is the safety and wellbeing of traumatised, vulnerable women and children in British homes. Will those offering a spare room be vetted? What's stopping some sickos taking advantage of the scheme? Could become a modern slavery scenario

House hold members will have to have a CRB check... which takes many weeks....

shinynewapple22 · 15/03/2022 15:59

@SafferUpNorth

What I'm worried about is the safety and wellbeing of traumatised, vulnerable women and children in British homes. Will those offering a spare room be vetted? What's stopping some sickos taking advantage of the scheme? Could become a modern slavery scenario.

I also wondered that .

Enzbear · 15/03/2022 15:49

FWIW, we have applied to house a refugee
Yes of course you have Hmm

NewModelArmyMayhem18 · 15/03/2022 15:48

Vaccination status is neither here nor there really, is it?

Most of those who can make it as far as the UK, will likely be the better off Ukrainians, I'd have thought. Unless they're being funded to travel by friends and family already over here. So they may not really be wanting to do manual labour (nor should we expect them to!).

I was watching the BBC this morning. One Ukrainian mother interviewed, bound for the UK with her young daughter (they have already been paired with a British family to house them), is very much a Middle Class professional with a surgeon DH.

anotherotherone · 15/03/2022 15:39

“We will gain people to work in the fields, factories and hospitality industry as well as presumably a number of highly skilled and experienced professionals across a range of industries.”

Why would these people be anymore likely to “work in the fields” then the next person? Confused These are women fleeing with their children and the elderly. Are you going to “work in the fields?” Confused These people are refugees. They are NOT to be confused with the economic migrants from Eastern European countries that gained EU membership in 2004 - who CHOSE to come here to fill specific gaps in the U.K. labour market (which surprise surprise the U.K. is now struggling to fill). These refugee women are no less likely to be “highly skilled and professional people” than the next person. And if the average British person won’t “work in the fields” why the bloody hell would a Ukrainian?

TyrannosaurusRegina · 15/03/2022 15:24

@Wilfulchaos

God, I am so glad I am not the sort of person who looks at the images coming out of Ukraine and thinks "but what about poor me?"
But she isn't simply saying what about me. She's recognising that there will obviously be a knock on effect on the demand on public services. You do know that's how (or supposed supposed be how) society and public services work - by recognising a potential or actually demand in said services, discussing how to best address it and then taking action? Nothing would ever be done if it wasn't discussed.

The OP has also signed up to host Ukrainian family, so I'm not sure where you're getting that all she cares about is herself?

Lubeyboobyalt · 15/03/2022 15:22

No I'm not at all concerned. Poland have taken 1.5m

The extreme need of the refugees is more important

TyrannosaurusRegina · 15/03/2022 15:15

@chocolatesaltyballs22

Not sure why you've applied to host if that's your opinion to be honest.
You're not sure why the OP has applied to be a host if she is able, willing and eager to help but at the same time, recognising that thousands of people coming into the country and using already stretched services will create even further stretch on those services? I really do not understand this mindset that some folk have of either blindly for or against something. Why can't people objectively voice concern about an issue? The OP hasn't said 'no, do not let Ukrainians in, we are too full already' She has said that she is eager and willing and has actually put her name forward to open her home up to people, but at the same time, recognises that there will be knock on effects effects public sevices that need to be discussed. That's a hell of a lot more sensible than just ignoring issues and allowing them to fester until services are at breaking point.
Carpy899 · 15/03/2022 15:06

Oh god they might bring in a mild illness with them. Whatever will we do

Alexandra2001 · 15/03/2022 14:58

@oakleaffy do you know that so far the govt has welcomed in over 100,000 Chinese HK citizens this year alone!

2.8m are entitled to come here.

These people are NOT fleeing war and prior to a change in the law had no right to come here.

No concerns on public services have been raised.

Alexandra2001 · 15/03/2022 14:55

@Cyw2018

We will gain people to work in the fields, factories and hospitality industry as well as presumably a number of highly skilled and experienced professionals across a range of industries, I'm sure, if we let them, they will settle in quickly and be an asset to the country and maybe some of the professionals (particualrly in healthcare) will be persuaded to stay permenently.
Lovely! So they can have the jobs we wont do and instead of hoping that they can return and rebuild their healthservices and indeed their country, you want them to stay here and help us out?

I hope they can get themselves back on their feet, maybe learn a new language, earn some money and God willing, be able to return to the country they love very much.

Badnightguaranteed · 15/03/2022 14:52

I’m concerned that some of the areas of the uk with the largest Ukrainian populations currently, (so presumably where refugees will gravitate to under family connections rules) are areas with the poorest social care and housing resources. I really fear for Ukrainian women and children being exploited by slum landlords who are looking to line their pockets further.

oakleaffy · 15/03/2022 14:52

OP, You aren’t the first to have voiced concerns over pressure on services, Poland have been inundated, and even volunteers have said they need greater help.
Its an unprecedented disaster.
Unlikely anyone fleeing will ever return to what was once their homeland.

Housing is in short supply here, so goodness knows where families will be housed.

Covid variants are the least of the worries.

adriftabroad · 15/03/2022 14:51

@Porcupineintherough

...aaand we're off! I always said 2 weeks of sympathetic noises were all we'd be able to muster as a nation.

Hope this reassures all those who were worried that the Ukrainian refugees were getting preferential treatment in the minds of the public.

Who has been unsympathetic? Nobody, Not one poster.
Wilfulchaos · 15/03/2022 14:49

God, I am so glad I am not the sort of person who looks at the images coming out of Ukraine and thinks "but what about poor me?"

Porcupineintherough · 15/03/2022 14:49

...aaand we're off! I always said 2 weeks of sympathetic noises were all we'd be able to muster as a nation.

Hope this reassures all those who were worried that the Ukrainian refugees were getting preferential treatment in the minds of the public.

Nicholethejewellery · 15/03/2022 14:48

@HerArtMaterials

Our country and services having been degraded over the past 12 years are the problem, not the refugees.
12 years? Try 40 or 50, maybe more.
ExConstance · 15/03/2022 14:45

some positive experiences of offering a home to a Syrian refugee from a guardian article today.

HerArtMaterials · 15/03/2022 14:44

Our country and services having been degraded over the past 12 years are the problem, not the refugees.

Viviennemary · 15/03/2022 14:43

No I'm not concerned. I am concerned about Putin starting World War III. Which he might if he gets away with this.

MarshaBradyo · 15/03/2022 14:41

[quote DrManhattan]@marshabradyo
That's not what my comment is about.[/quote]
Ok
What did you mean? Can you expand

adriftabroad · 15/03/2022 14:41

@jytdtysrht

This is going to sound petty and the example is indeed petty - but it’s indicative of what is going on with our basic services.

Yesterday I tried to get a hygienist appointment and was told the wait is 3 months. Now, I am quite well aware that it isn’t going to kill me and it is extremely petty - BUT - this is the state that our basic services are in. They are maxed out and have no chance of even meeting the current demand, without even more people. That was yesterday but a few years ago…

My mum has cancer and had a mastectomy. Went in 8/9am for surgery. Operated on 12 hours later. The poor surgeon had done several ops back to back. The hospital had no bed when she was finished. She was on a trolley being moved a couple of times during the night post surgery to wherever there was staff. I put her in a wheelchair and took her home 12 hours after surgery, dragged a bed downstairs in my house to nurse her myself. The hospital had NOTHING for her. No bed no doctor. When the cancer came back, the test results were lost for 5 months. This country is in crisis and anyone stating that obvious fact is treated as a racist xenophobe.

FGS we can’t even run bin collections effectively!

I was on the council website looking at a secondary school and it received 4 times as many applications as there were places. In 2021.

We are utterly fucked. And it’s nothing whatsoever to do with xenophobia.

At last someone spells it out very clearly. I am very sorry about your mother.

The OP is expresssing genuine concerns, nothing more and nothing less. It does NOT equal Xenabloodyphobia FGS.

The hypocrisy around Covid is outstanding. I don't give a damn about vaccines and have not had any. But the abuse on here to anyone that admitted that. Bloody hell.

ExConstance · 15/03/2022 14:41

I'm sickened today that all the major Care Associations are debating how best to attract the Ukranians to be care workers. Another example of the fat cats trying to get vulnerable people to work on zero hours contracts for peanuts. These people will be arriving having experienced trauma, homeless and missing their partners and Care Home bosses are thinking Yippee, a good source of cheap labour for us. Utterly disgusting that once again we want those from abroad to do the work where the pay and conditions are so poor they do not attract applicants here.