Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Help ! Colin Caterpillar cake broke in two !

57 replies

PoAhOh · 15/03/2022 09:36

My DC asked for a Colin Caterpillar cake for their birthday, carefully brought it home but it's broken in 2 😱
I'm crap at any type of artsy, bakery stuff, what can I do ?
Your help would be much appreciated !!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Toddlerteaplease · 17/03/2022 22:04

@TheSpottedZebra

Buy a bag of baby colins and declare with a straight face that they're his babies.
Or do this!
Toddlerteaplease · 17/03/2022 22:03

It freezes really well so I'd slice him up then freeze and have a slice occasionally. Then buy a new one for your DD.

Doodar · 17/03/2022 21:55

great result op

PoAhOh · 17/03/2022 20:55

Sorry if I've disappointed anyone but I decided to take Colin back to M&S to see what they'd say, what was the worst they could say anyway !

A lovely lady offered replacement immediately 🙂

There were loads of broken Colins on the shelf so beware if you get one, I wiggled him on the cake board to make sure he didn't move !

Thanks for the fab ideas though 🎂

Help ! Colin Caterpillar cake broke in two !
Help ! Colin Caterpillar cake broke in two !
OP posts:
LucyAutumn · 15/03/2022 15:33

Show us a pic of the broken Colin so we have a before and after!

EinsteinaGogo · 15/03/2022 15:11

@EvilPea

Is it a clean break? It’s only chocolate topped. So a hot knife might melt and smooth it together. Or melt some more chocolate and use it as glue

@EvilPea

Don't know why, but 'is it a clean break' really tickled me!!

lemonnandliime · 15/03/2022 14:52

@PoAhOh

I carefully chose Colin as there were some broken ones, I think he wasn't iced to the board well enough so when the bag moved so did Colin 🥺

He cost £7 which I can't really afford again and I'm not a huge fan of chocolate cake !
I'll go shopping again tomorrow and try fixing him on Thursday. Don't worry I'll show you how he looks 😁

You've really made my day, haven't laughed so much in ages 😍

Thank you again, really great ideas. I'll see if I can buy him an extra head and make 2 or whether it will be easier sticking him back together ! I've been worried about totally spoiling him, might still happen 😂

Honestly if you genuinely didn't do anything to damage it you have good reason to ask to exchange it. If it wasn't firmly iced to the board and therefore not boxed correctly that's not your fault. A cake shouldn't break in two being carried carefully in a bag.

Obviously if you dropped it on the floor or whacked the bag of something that's different, but you've nothing to lose taking it back and asking if they will swap it.

There will be loads of fragile items like this damaged in transit, or through customers messing with them and putting them back on the shelf.

PoAhOh · 15/03/2022 14:44

I carefully chose Colin as there were some broken ones, I think he wasn't iced to the board well enough so when the bag moved so did Colin 🥺

He cost £7 which I can't really afford again and I'm not a huge fan of chocolate cake !
I'll go shopping again tomorrow and try fixing him on Thursday. Don't worry I'll show you how he looks 😁

You've really made my day, haven't laughed so much in ages 😍

Thank you again, really great ideas. I'll see if I can buy him an extra head and make 2 or whether it will be easier sticking him back together ! I've been worried about totally spoiling him, might still happen 😂

OP posts:
youngestisapsycho · 15/03/2022 14:43

I've asked twice how it broke... OP hasn't been back and replied for a while...

Bananabutter · 15/03/2022 14:24

@lemonnandliime She didn’t buy it with a hole in. She’d have noticed it.

SoupDragon · 15/03/2022 14:22

Where did the OP say she damaged it herself?

She said she "didn't have the nerve" to take it back which kind of implies it was fine when she bought it and then it got broken on the way home.

SartresSoul · 15/03/2022 14:09

They’re only £7 aren’t they? I’d just buy another to save the hassle of melting chocolate to try fix it. Either that or I’d return it claiming it broke when you opened the box, I’m sure they’ll replace it.

TyneTeas · 15/03/2022 14:00

Re the suggestions of a bandage, you could make it look like he was going into a cocoon?

lemonnandliime · 15/03/2022 13:55

[quote Bananabutter]@lemonnandliime They didn’t sell it to her broken; she wouldn’t have chosen it.

So it’s broken because she didn’t transport it home carefully enough. Therefore it’s her issue to deal with.

If you walk out of a shop with a crockery set and drop it on the floor, they’re not going to replace it because you dropped it. It was in tact when sold.[/quote]
Where did the OP say she damaged it herself?

I asked in one of my posts whether it was bought that easy or she damaged it, and I said if it was bought that way she should exchange it.

Bananabutter · 15/03/2022 13:42

@lemonnandliime They didn’t sell it to her broken; she wouldn’t have chosen it.

So it’s broken because she didn’t transport it home carefully enough. Therefore it’s her issue to deal with.

If you walk out of a shop with a crockery set and drop it on the floor, they’re not going to replace it because you dropped it. It was in tact when sold.

lemonnandliime · 15/03/2022 13:07

@Useranon1

I would go back and exchange it

On what basis?!

Erm

If the op has bought a product that's not fit for purpose on opening it (a smashed in half birthday cake) why would you not exchange it?

Honestly Mumsnet fries my brains at times.

dizzydizzydizzy · 15/03/2022 12:46

Aww OP. I feel your pain. So sorry. Although I think it'll be fine - some great suggestions from PPs.

Ncwinc · 15/03/2022 12:45

Could he be a Very Hungry Colin the Caterpillar?

Colin’s front bit, a wedge of something he’s ‘eating’ his way through and Colin’s back bit?

youngestisapsycho · 15/03/2022 12:41

I still wanna know how it broke so bad? Must have dropped it?

x2boys · 15/03/2022 12:06

Tell him you have got him a special edition "Clumsy Colin ,the Caterpillar?

wildthingsinthenight · 15/03/2022 11:45

@WellThatsATurnipForTheBooks

Glue together with melted chocolate and give him a "belt" of Smarties to hide the join
This
Useranon1 · 15/03/2022 11:44

I would go back and exchange it

On what basis?!

Thewindwhispers · 15/03/2022 11:35

Shove it back together and pour smarties all over the join and tell dc it rained a birthday rainbow

DysmalRadius · 15/03/2022 11:16

Only the section with the head lives on. {Not that this applies to Two Colins}

It can, depending on where it's cut, but usually it's just as dead as the other end.

lemonnandliime · 15/03/2022 11:02

@PoAhOh

I did think about taking it back but I don't think I've the nerve 😕 It's a messy break, chocolate chipped off but completely severed in the middle. Thank you so much for all of your ideas I completely panicked. I'll buy chocolate, smarties & ribbon to see what I can do. Unfortunately my DC notices everything but they'll be upset for me worrying about it !
Did you damage it accidentally or was it like that when you opened the box and no way your fault?

If you didn't drop it or anything I would have no problem about taking it back.

Why you make a mess of a cake by drizzling chocolate on it and shoving it together with sweets and sticks if you bought it and it's not fit for purpose?