Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Free from items shouldn’t be replaced on shopping

136 replies

LimeSupper · 14/03/2022 21:20

We get a weekly home delivery from a major supermarket. We order free from items because there are allergies in the house, as well as coeliac disease. Last week our Birdseye Free from fishfingers were replaced on the weekly shop by home brand free from fishfingers. It was said hurriedly at the door and we said that’s fine. I’ve been SO ill this week, just happened to be looking at the packet and realised the fishfingers are Free From FISH! So they’re vegan fishfingers, not gluten free. AIBU to think that supermarkets should not be just substituting free from items with any other substitutes?? I just think it’s so bloody irresponsible. Yes I accept fully that I should’ve checked it and not trusted the word of the driver who probably didn’t know the difference anyway - lesson learnt. It’s the way it’s called Free From, it’s a range that’s usually fine and now it seems to just be free from anything at all. You’d think there’d be some sort of check?? If someone orders a product without an allergen in it (gluten or milk or nuts or whatever it is) then don’t send them a replacement with that one just say sorry we don’t have the item or anything similar.

OP posts:
AtomicBlondeRose · 14/03/2022 21:52

I agree that they can’t possibly know why you bought a particular product - the Free From ones were gluten free but maybe you choose them because they don’t contain soya or whatever. Same with the vegetarian Mac and cheese - it’s usually vegetarian so it doesn’t mean you bought it specifically for that reason. Plenty of biscuits are vegan by accident - some vegans might buy them but a picker wouldn’t know which other brands also happen to be vegan or that it was important. I just don’t think they can possibly please everyone, what seems like common sense to one person is a stupid choice to the next.

BooksAndHooks · 14/03/2022 21:48

@dudsville

I agree. I think it's a hard task, I wish they'd allow us to comment about suitable replacements. I ordered a posh vegetarian mac and cheese and was offered one with pancetta instead. Same thing happened with a pizza.
I can do this on Tescos you can add notes to any items including what substitutes you’ll accept.
Bogiesaremyonlyfriend · 14/03/2022 21:45

I'm guessing the people saying you should check dont actually have food allergies and understand how relentless it is to have to check every single thing every single time you eat. When you order gluten free it should be gluten free or nothing!! Hope you feel better soon. 💐

Hankunamatata · 14/03/2022 21:42

You can request to not have substitutions when ordering

hunder · 14/03/2022 21:41

Last week my GF self raising four was replaced with GF beer. DH was home when they delivered and happily accepted the substitution. I'm still trying to work out how I could replace flour with beer in a recipe!

AHungryCaterpillar · 14/03/2022 21:40

Just click no substitutes it’s not hard

nodogz · 14/03/2022 21:39

YANBU - free from shopping is becoming really hard. All the gluten free stuff is getting stored next to all the vegan stuff (which is always full of wheat) with the same branding

They should be separate or branded differently.

Yes, you should check but that's a crap substitution. I like sainsburys as you can see what they've subbed with (it's usually not that great) so you can reject at the door.

MartinMartinMarti · 14/03/2022 21:39

We have specific dietary needs, and I’ve always been able to add a general note to my orders to make sure we don’t get subs we can’t use.

For products that are likely to get subbed for products we can’t use, I choose to have no subs at all.

And then of course you get told at or before drop off that there are subs.

What else do you want the supermarkets to do OP?

Finally, I always, always check if it’s not a product I’m not familiar with.

LimeSupper · 14/03/2022 21:39

@UghFletcher that’s even worse then - if there’s a computer system there should be an easy way to ensure it doesn’t select an item that contains gluten if you’ve ordered a gluten free item. Especially one called “free from”. Call it something by else?? Call it vegan if that’s what it is??

OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 14/03/2022 21:39

They don't get it I had a picker override the reccomend substitution gluten free bread and replace it with linseed bread which is wheat bread with added linseed I felt guilty getting them into trouble but ffs it clearly states GLUTEN FREE ONLY in my subs box and they overrode the system to give me an improper sub the driver was pissed at me constantly sending things back

pepsirolla · 14/03/2022 21:38

I wonder how thorough they shop anyway. I ordered a click and collect shop at sainsburys. I wanted currants for a cake I received an email at 9am saying currants our of stock.Went to collect it at 10am and popped into shop too for other bits, there was a shelf full of currants! Doubt it had just been restocked.

Pyri · 14/03/2022 21:38

@Poppins2016

I get it.

If I was to order a gluten free cake, I wouldn't turn off substitutions just because I require gluten free... I'd simply expect a different gluten free cake if it was substituted!

Sometimes there seems to be a serious lack of common sense when pickers choose substitutions.

But in that instance - let’s say you ordered a gluten free lemon cake. How does the picker know it’s gluten free you’re after and not lemon? How does he know you haven’t chosen it cos you’re allergic to nuts and if he picks a gluten free nut cake that’s wrong? Maybe he picks a regular lemon cake as he thinks lemon is the most important bit
JudgeRindersMinder · 14/03/2022 21:37

I think if I had food allergies I wouldn’t allow these items to be subbed, but would rather go without, as allergies aren’t about preference

UghFletcher · 14/03/2022 21:37

@Poppins2016

I get it.

If I was to order a gluten free cake, I wouldn't turn off substitutions just because I require gluten free... I'd simply expect a different gluten free cake if it was substituted!

Sometimes there seems to be a serious lack of common sense when pickers choose substitutions.

The pickers don't decide on the subs. A computer system tells them what to sub with.
shiteheart · 14/03/2022 21:36

But you accepted the sub? The driver probably told you and it would have been on your invoice. Surely it's your responsibility to check what your eating is suitable for your diet?

Carbiesdreamhouse · 14/03/2022 21:36

I agree although the line between free from and vegan is tricky. We have severe dairy allergy and I ordered vegan babybels from Sainsbury's. They subbed them for normal babybels. I did get an email but I was at work, busy and didn't check my personal email. The driver didn't mention any subs and they were hidden in the basket. The packaging is very similar, I'm very very lucky I clocked it before giving one to my DC.

TheFlis12345 · 14/03/2022 21:36

Echoing what others posters have said. With Tesco you can tick no subs and add comments to each item. They also email you your receipt a few hours before your delivery, highlighting any missing items or subs, so you’re aware in advance and don’t have to rush to check subs while trying to unpack. Sounds like it might be better for you if you have various allergies to deal with.

Poppins2016 · 14/03/2022 21:36

I get it.

If I was to order a gluten free cake, I wouldn't turn off substitutions just because I require gluten free... I'd simply expect a different gluten free cake if it was substituted!

Sometimes there seems to be a serious lack of common sense when pickers choose substitutions.

IstayedForTheFeminism · 14/03/2022 21:34

Yanbu.
A "free from" range usually means Free from gluten/lactose.
Not Free from fish.

We've had Free from cakes substituted with cream buns. I did reject that one.

We also had spinach and ricotta tortellini substituted with a sausage meat filled one in lockdown when you had to accept substitutions. Luckily there are meat eaters in the house although veggie DS was a bit miffed. I only order it for him Grin

Itloggedmeoutagain · 14/03/2022 21:34

Your allergies are your responsibility.
Choose no substitutes when doing your order or check what the sub is before accepting it. Free from doesn't mean the same thing to everyone

MsSquiz · 14/03/2022 21:33

Most supermarkets that I've done online orders with have the option to tick "no substitutions" or write a note for the picker, eg "only sub for semi skimmed milk" or "only sub for vegan option"

You chose to accept the substitution, and also didn't check the pack before you cooked or ate the product. I don't think you can blame the picker/supermarket for that

RedHelenB · 14/03/2022 21:33

Surely you'd double check at the time and then again when you get them out to cook them? Best thing would be to say bo substitutions as others have already said.

LimeSupper · 14/03/2022 21:32

I do take responsibility and haven’t complained to them because I accepted the substitution. However, I really do think they are irresponsible for not being more clear with those items too.

OP posts:
CeeceeBloomingdale · 14/03/2022 21:31

The shop don’t know what your allergic to, don’t like or choose to avoid. A suitable substitute for one person is inappropriate for another person. It’s on you to check yourself.

NewYearCalavicci · 14/03/2022 21:30

Where do you shop ?
I shop at tesco and you can pick 'no substitutions' and / or leave a note with each item .
I buy Alcohol free cider and always note a note saying if X brand is not available only sub with other alcohol free cider .

I have a friend that reacts badly to egg so he puts it on almost every note, 'must not contain egg in any form' .
But all that said the pickers must have to deal with 1000s of shoppers and multiple subs for each one so i am not surprised they make the odd error .
You need to take responsibility for what you cook and eat too