Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Free from items shouldn’t be replaced on shopping

136 replies

LimeSupper · 14/03/2022 21:20

We get a weekly home delivery from a major supermarket. We order free from items because there are allergies in the house, as well as coeliac disease. Last week our Birdseye Free from fishfingers were replaced on the weekly shop by home brand free from fishfingers. It was said hurriedly at the door and we said that’s fine. I’ve been SO ill this week, just happened to be looking at the packet and realised the fishfingers are Free From FISH! So they’re vegan fishfingers, not gluten free. AIBU to think that supermarkets should not be just substituting free from items with any other substitutes?? I just think it’s so bloody irresponsible. Yes I accept fully that I should’ve checked it and not trusted the word of the driver who probably didn’t know the difference anyway - lesson learnt. It’s the way it’s called Free From, it’s a range that’s usually fine and now it seems to just be free from anything at all. You’d think there’d be some sort of check?? If someone orders a product without an allergen in it (gluten or milk or nuts or whatever it is) then don’t send them a replacement with that one just say sorry we don’t have the item or anything similar.

OP posts:
SookieHouseboat · 15/03/2022 08:04

@Questiontellme

No the pickers just need to engage a braincell....or be given better training we've had so much of this, I have a gluten intolerance DC CMPA, we're constantly getting gluten versions, I.e nairns oatcakes, today's was the best, vegan croisssnts substituted for All Butter Croissants 👌🤣
Nope, subs are YOUR responsibility to check. Something else has been provided, it’s up to you to either reject or accept.

I sometimes think customers need to engage their brains and realise shoppers don’t toddle around the shop wondering what you might like instead of that item that’s out of stock. They’re doing 7 other people’s shopping too.

As has been said, go yourself or hush. 🤫

SookieHouseboat · 15/03/2022 07:47

@pepsirolla

I wonder how thorough they shop anyway. I ordered a click and collect shop at sainsburys. I wanted currants for a cake I received an email at 9am saying currants our of stock.Went to collect it at 10am and popped into shop too for other bits, there was a shelf full of currants! Doubt it had just been restocked.
Your shop would have been picked way before you even woke up. The delivery of raisins probably wasn’t even in the shop at that point.
Clymene · 15/03/2022 07:10

If it's that important, go and get your own shopping.

ifoundthebread · 14/03/2022 23:35

@Tomnooktoldmeto

I use Asda as we’re all coeliacs, vegetarian and have allergies too so life it fun!

I always untick every single box for substitutes. In the information box it informs the picker we’re coeliac, vegetarian and have allergies

Regularly get substitutes Hmm what else can I do? At least Asda refund without quibble if they slip one through

We get an email so I know what’s coming or not and I always screenshot changes for DH if I’m not there so he should refuse them but he’s autistic and sometimes forgets. I just request a refund but it is irritating

Just so you know, it doesn't inform the picker of anything. We don't see any notes or additional information given on the order. We don't see a name for who's orders we are picking.
Mummy1608 · 14/03/2022 23:22

Yabvu for cooking it without reading the label first. I have an unusual allergy (not a common one which would be in bold or have its own range like free from) and i have been reading food labels basically since I could read. It's not a hardship, it takes two seconds.

Even brands I use often can change recipe- Pret recently changed their bread so I can't have most of their sandwiches. I read the labels every time before I take a bite even if I've bought the same thing before. It's your responsibility to take care of your own health as an able bodied adult who can read, sorry to be blunt

Talipesmum · 14/03/2022 23:11

It would be good if there was a clearer flag for that type of substitution, but I guess they don’t want to take that responsibility for ensuring - with non expert v rushed pickers - that they are exactly right on the allergens.

I know it’s not the same thing at all and has no health implications, but I once had a packet of birthday balloons substituted with a sturdy plastic water bottle with nice bicycle patterns all over it. I can usually see how the subs minds were working, but this one really threw me!

Loyaultemelie · 14/03/2022 23:11

I agree with the idea of there being some sort of prompt for the pickers from substitutions, if it's a vegetarian/vegan item don't replace it with anything not plant based. If it's a gluten free "free from" avoid anything gluten based. Lactose free the same that way at least any allergy sufferers won't spend weeks or months suffering if we accidentally don't notice or someone else accepts the item at the door (DH accidentally did this once with a gluten free instead of meat free and I ended up needing hospital treatment).

ElephantandGrasshopper · 14/03/2022 23:08

I've had meat sausages substituted for veggie ones (looking at you Morrisons).

Randomgal28 · 14/03/2022 23:02

I get it OP! I once had a free from pudding and was given a gluten containing burrito instead 🥴

findingsomeone · 14/03/2022 23:01

I'm lactose intolerant and I often get given goats milk instead of lactose free milk. It's annoying because an oat or nut milk would be OK, but not goats!

SoupDragon · 14/03/2022 22:59

I agree that they can’t possibly know why you bought a particular product - the Free From ones were gluten free but maybe you choose them because they don’t contain soya or whatever.

Well, it's unlikely she chose them because she didn't want fish so why substitute something that is absolutely not what she ordered?

Clymene · 14/03/2022 22:54

@Questiontellme

No the pickers just need to engage a braincell....or be given better training we've had so much of this, I have a gluten intolerance DC CMPA, we're constantly getting gluten versions, I.e nairns oatcakes, today's was the best, vegan croisssnts substituted for All Butter Croissants 👌🤣
No. They don't. They are on massively tight schedules to pick your shopping as fast as they possibly can and a lot of them work on zero hours contracts.

If you don't want or can't eat certain foods, you tick no subs.

Don't blame the minimum wage workers. It's shitty behaviour

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 14/03/2022 22:53

All the information you need will be on the packaging so all you need to do is read it if you have an item you haven't used before. The picker really does not have time time to check things like this. They will not know what it is you are trying to avoid only that the item is not on the shelf. Also they get less than 20 seconds to find pick and pack each item and sub it if it's not available. I know, I was a picker until a fortnight ago. There is certainly no time to read packaging. The driver has the same information you have on your email. The charge you pay for the online service does not cover all the extra staff time and delivery costs as it is, extra staff time would result in higher charges for everyone.

TokyoTen · 14/03/2022 22:50

YABU just tick no substitutions. Job done.

LimeSupper · 14/03/2022 22:49

@Talipesmum I think you’re right. I for some reason just didn’t notice, I think of it hadn’t been said to me like that at the door, I would’ve seen it differently. It’s like I accepted it because I was told the words “free from” which I trust, I obviously saw the word “free” and something just didn’t click. I’m totally clear that it was my responsibility to check them and I feel like a prize idiot, so angry with myself. I wish it hadn’t been allowed to be presented to me like that though as I don’t think I’d have made that mistake in store. Could there be a prompt when an item is replaced containing an allergen that wasn’t ordered for example? So the delivery driver has a red note on the paper to say “the substitute contains milk/ gluten/ nuts by the way”.

OP posts:
AnnesBrokenSlate · 14/03/2022 22:48

You have to tick the 'no substitutions' box. People buy 'free from' products for different reasons. The supermarket can't guess what those reasons are so they can't judge like for like.

We have lots of allergies between DH and the DC. I still check every label every time. Supermarkets change ingredients regularly and there's no big announcement on the website or the front of the packaging so something that was fine one week can include an allergen the next.

QuebecBagnet · 14/03/2022 22:46

Which supermarket is it? Because sainsburys free from fishfingers are gluten free. As are Asda.

Tesco doesn’t have any free from fishfingers, only fish free fingers.

Thecurtainsofdestiny · 14/03/2022 22:46

I just add a note saying "only dairy free substitutions please" ( since it's dairy we need to avoid). You could do the same for wheat/ gluten.

Questiontellme · 14/03/2022 22:46

No the pickers just need to engage a braincell....or be given better training we've had so much of this, I have a gluten intolerance DC CMPA, we're constantly getting gluten versions, I.e nairns oatcakes, today's was the best, vegan croisssnts substituted for All Butter Croissants 👌🤣

Talipesmum · 14/03/2022 22:44

I think the delivery driver misled you, but it doesn’t look like the fish free fishfingers are part of the tescos “free from” range at all. They look like they’re part of the “plant kitchen” range - totally different. I don’t think it’s really misleading on the packets, and the free from range looks pretty clear. Best turn off subs for that sort of thing, or go through the email before hand - so annoying for you!

DysmalRadius · 14/03/2022 22:42

The tesco free from range has always incorporated items that are free from a range of different allergens, including eggs and dairy. I don't remember a time when it only referred to wheat free items so, although I think their labeling could be easier to navigate, I don't think this is necessarily a new issue. I specify substitions for this reason, and they are usually pretty good at my local store.

LimeSupper · 14/03/2022 22:37

@QuebecBagnet I’ve genuinely not come across those products (obviously this week has been enlightening 😅).

OP posts:
QuebecBagnet · 14/03/2022 22:36

[quote LimeSupper]@QuebecBagnet which products are those? Not being goody, genuinely interested.[/quote]
Can’t think of any off the top of my head as obviously I don’t buy them. But every week on my various coeliac fb groups someone will post a photo of a various “free from” item moaning it’s not gluten free. And every week people point out that “free from” does not mean gluten free.

LimeSupper · 14/03/2022 22:36

But surely we could start by only suggesting products that don’t contain the same allergen that the original product doesn’t contain?

OP posts:
Clymene · 14/03/2022 22:35

Just don't accept subs.