Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Free from items shouldn’t be replaced on shopping

136 replies

LimeSupper · 14/03/2022 21:20

We get a weekly home delivery from a major supermarket. We order free from items because there are allergies in the house, as well as coeliac disease. Last week our Birdseye Free from fishfingers were replaced on the weekly shop by home brand free from fishfingers. It was said hurriedly at the door and we said that’s fine. I’ve been SO ill this week, just happened to be looking at the packet and realised the fishfingers are Free From FISH! So they’re vegan fishfingers, not gluten free. AIBU to think that supermarkets should not be just substituting free from items with any other substitutes?? I just think it’s so bloody irresponsible. Yes I accept fully that I should’ve checked it and not trusted the word of the driver who probably didn’t know the difference anyway - lesson learnt. It’s the way it’s called Free From, it’s a range that’s usually fine and now it seems to just be free from anything at all. You’d think there’d be some sort of check?? If someone orders a product without an allergen in it (gluten or milk or nuts or whatever it is) then don’t send them a replacement with that one just say sorry we don’t have the item or anything similar.

OP posts:
AKissOrAGunfight · 15/03/2022 14:26

You say the free from brand is one you use and trust? Then you know what the packaging looks like and that that it states clearly on the label what the item is free from? (Gluten, wheat milk etc)
You were given plant chef fish fingers. The packaging looks nothing like the free from branding and label. When the the driver said it was own brand free from you should have realised the packaging was different and therfore not the brand you trust. So why did you just eat them without looking at ingredients?

Pythonesque · 15/03/2022 12:55

Those who are suggesting that "free from" doesn't automatically mean gluten-free, are perhaps not accustomed to shopping for a coeliac diet. Over the 20 years I've been in the UK, I've seen the massive rise in availability of gluten-free food, and the evolution in what is available.

Supermarkets absolutely HAVE trained shoppers to expect "free from" to almost always mean gluten-free. I agree, it varies a lot whether it is dairy free or not and the presence of soya and egg is unpredictable. (I am coeliac and only tolerate a small amount of dairy, and had to have my son on a dairy-free diet for many years).

In the last perhaps 10 years or so, use of "gluten-free oats" has become widespread so I know to always check products for them, and have given up biscuits (make my own ginger ones occasionally!) - both my mother and sister have bad reactions to them and my reactions are such I won't risk even trying them.

Judging from the OPs posts, there may be two issues here slightly in parallel. One is the substitution that was completely inappropriate in the first place. The other is terminology - did you write that the product turned out to be "Fish free" but was described on the doorstop to you as "Free from"? Or, did you probably mishear? (possibly impossible to tell I appreciate!). Both these aspects of what happened need to be flagged up as dangerous, ask what will be done to prevent a similar incident in the future.

I'd probably be unable to work for several days if I ate vegan gluten-containing fish fingers. [the amount of gluten in protein-substitutes can be substantial all by themselves]

MsSquiz · 15/03/2022 12:42

[quote LimeSupper]@MsSquiz oh I see what you mean. Well I mean I use the free from brand a lot for other items so I know and trust the brand, it didn’t immediately prompt me to check. Yes I’m well aware I should’ve checked and have said that all the way along my posts. I also think it should’ve been pointed out clearly that’s all. It was presented to me as a like for like swap which is isn’t.[/quote]
@LimeSupper but that's the point I'm trying to make. You essentially had a new product from a new brand and you just cooked and served it without checking anything - yours subs or the product packaging.

Surely as a family with allergies, that is the first thing you do when using/choosing a different brand than your norm?

How "clearly pointed out" can the make it for you? It would have been listed on your substitutions and the packaging. You made the choice not to check either...

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 15/03/2022 12:10

Yeah I didn't want to go into lots of detailed possibilities for an entirely fantasy-based system that'll probably never happen Grin All I'm saying is that we have plenty of entirely-technologically-feasible stuff, that wouldn't require any new information or technology, which would make a minority of people's lives easier, but which we don't do, only because there's not enough money in it, not because it's not doable.

That felt like too many commas.

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 15/03/2022 11:46

@ClumpingBambooIsALie

This is really an industry-wide information technology failure. It should be entirely possible for every single SKU to have a flag against it in the database of which allergens or other ingredients of concern it definitely contains or may contain, all updated, all completely computer-readable. From there, it should be possible to simply register an online shopping account as a no-gluten/no-crustacean/no-celery/no-whatever account, and for pickers to be suggested only subs which comply with the requirement. The fact we don't have this is not a consequence of lack of feasibility, it's a consequence of lack of will.
But many households have one member who need the free from item whilst the other members don't so often a shop will contain both free from and standard products. The packaging always states the ingredients so in my opinion it is much better that the customer who actually knows what the intolerance is does the checking and the item can then be rejected if it is not suitable.
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 15/03/2022 11:41

Sorry, UPC, not SKU — it would then just need to be one more thing a manufacturer needs to do when they make a product — to upload its allergy profile to a database used by sellers.

CapMarvel · 15/03/2022 11:37

@ClumpingBambooIsALie

This is really an industry-wide information technology failure. It should be entirely possible for every single SKU to have a flag against it in the database of which allergens or other ingredients of concern it definitely contains or may contain, all updated, all completely computer-readable. From there, it should be possible to simply register an online shopping account as a no-gluten/no-crustacean/no-celery/no-whatever account, and for pickers to be suggested only subs which comply with the requirement. The fact we don't have this is not a consequence of lack of feasibility, it's a consequence of lack of will.
Yeah, it's possible.

As no such database exists though, it would cost a shitload of money to set up and so it's not going to happen.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 15/03/2022 11:34

This is really an industry-wide information technology failure. It should be entirely possible for every single SKU to have a flag against it in the database of which allergens or other ingredients of concern it definitely contains or may contain, all updated, all completely computer-readable. From there, it should be possible to simply register an online shopping account as a no-gluten/no-crustacean/no-celery/no-whatever account, and for pickers to be suggested only subs which comply with the requirement. The fact we don't have this is not a consequence of lack of feasibility, it's a consequence of lack of will.

Doublechocolatetiffin · 15/03/2022 11:27

[quote LimeSupper]@MsSquiz oh I see what you mean. Well I mean I use the free from brand a lot for other items so I know and trust the brand, it didn’t immediately prompt me to check. Yes I’m well aware I should’ve checked and have said that all the way along my posts. I also think it should’ve been pointed out clearly that’s all. It was presented to me as a like for like swap which is isn’t.[/quote]
I'm slightly confused. Free from ranges in supermarkets aren't always gluten free. I wouldn't pick up any free from item and expect it to be free of all allergens. I've been diary and soya free and frequently can't have free from branded stuff as they have diary or soya in. I do get what you are saying, but I think allergens are very hard to buy for and expecting the supermarket to tell you that the substitution contains a specific allergen is hard. That would place a huge burden of responsibility on them and would require a massive investment in infrastructure to get it correct. Imagine if they got it wrong? I think we're stuck with having the check the packet yourself especially with subs. Don't expect the delivery driver or supermarket to tell you correctly.

hoorayandupsherises · 15/03/2022 10:31

I am obviously not in the majority, but I would write to customer services (not complain but) politely to say that they should look into whether they can set up their computer system so that products containing allergens can't be substituted for the allergen-free product. Yes, it's your responsibility to check, but it is also a life-threatening issue, I'd have thought they could look into it.

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 15/03/2022 10:07

@pepsirolla

I wonder how thorough they shop anyway. I ordered a click and collect shop at sainsburys. I wanted currants for a cake I received an email at 9am saying currants our of stock.Went to collect it at 10am and popped into shop too for other bits, there was a shelf full of currants! Doubt it had just been restocked.
Picking in my store starts at 2am with the frozen items as the nightshift who replenish have already worked those aisles by then. It then moves on to the ambient aisles, which are being worked simultaneously by nightshift and pickers ,then the chilled and fresh aisles start to be picked around 5.00am as we try to pick after that nights delivery has been put out and it usually arrives at some point between 4am-6am. Bread tends to be last as that comes directly from the manufacturers rather than the stores own warehouse and arrives between 4am-7pm. The instore bakery have a deadline of 5.30am to get all online orders baked, cooled and packed so that is the earliest they can be picked, it can be pretty tight getting them picked for morning orders which are due out on vans departing at 6am. So your order is not all picked in one go just before your email is sent out. It will have been picked in bits throughout the night with frozen, ambient and chilled being picked totally separately then stored in the appropriate temperature storage area. Although the store do try to pick in an order which means they are following a pattern of a particular section being delivered, unloaded, worked by the nightshift then picked. If a delivery is slightly delayed or nightshift are short staffed it can often work that picking has to start in an area that hasn't yet been replenished. There have been many mornings where I have started my shift picking the last of a particular item then spent the next couple of hours subbing it before finding by the end of my shift that the shelf has been restock and I am able to pick the item again. It is also true that not all stores have space for an online department so their click and collects will be brought in from another store. The state of a store at 10am does not reflect how things might have been throughout the night.
CapMarvel · 15/03/2022 09:28

Ultimately it's up to you to control what you eat.

Either don't accept substitutions or ensure that if you do get subs then you check them to make sure they are suitable. It's not up to min wage staff on incredibly tight timescales to do this for you.

SartresSoul · 15/03/2022 09:24

You probably should have checked that they were gluten free first but I agree it’s thoughtless to swap with a vegan item. I once had quorn nuggets subbed for real ones, it was the first and last time I shopped with Asda.

Calandor · 15/03/2022 09:18

You can select 'no substitutions'.

WhatHaveIFound · 15/03/2022 09:02

I think in the way that it was presented at the door I would probably have accepted the subs too. It's rare that you get the time to check ingredients at the time but I probably would have done before cooking them.

Tesco will normally refund something which you later find to damaged or unsuitable. I've found them to be quite good that way.

nearlyspringyay · 15/03/2022 08:46

@pepsirolla

I wonder how thorough they shop anyway. I ordered a click and collect shop at sainsburys. I wanted currants for a cake I received an email at 9am saying currants our of stock.Went to collect it at 10am and popped into shop too for other bits, there was a shelf full of currants! Doubt it had just been restocked.
They don't necessarily pick the order in the store you collect from.
LimeSupper · 15/03/2022 08:45

@TheHaveN0tsnot everyone who can’t do their own shopping in store is a “lazy moo” 😂

OP posts:
LimeSupper · 15/03/2022 08:43

@MsSquiz oh I see what you mean. Well I mean I use the free from brand a lot for other items so I know and trust the brand, it didn’t immediately prompt me to check. Yes I’m well aware I should’ve checked and have said that all the way along my posts. I also think it should’ve been pointed out clearly that’s all. It was presented to me as a like for like swap which is isn’t.

OP posts:
TheHaveN0ts · 15/03/2022 08:29

Or do your own shopping you lazy moo 🤣

MsSquiz · 15/03/2022 08:29

[quote LimeSupper]@MsSquiz well it isn’t a different brand, I’ve used Free From for years, it’s a safe brand for me. Now they’re changing my it to include vegan products - it wasn’t clear to me.[/quote]
@LimeSupper you said "Birdseye Free from fishfingers were replaced on the weekly shop by home brand free from fishfingers."

So it was a different brand to the one you had ordered

TheHaveN0ts · 15/03/2022 08:28

YABVU
I have allergies and would check anything I knew a teenager / someone else would have picked and packed!!!
On the other hand, I may try the vegan fish fingers if you couldn't tell they didn't have fish in them!!! 😋😋😋

Meandthesky · 15/03/2022 08:21

If you have food allergies it’s your responsibility to check that any subs are appropriate before accepting but certainly before eating them. Why wouldn’t you check that a product you’ve never had before is suitable for your allergies?

There should also be an option to select “no substitutes” either for your whole order or particular items.

steppemum · 15/03/2022 08:19

sorry but I do tink you are being unreasonable.

you can check receipt before it arrives.
you can refuse subs at the door
with Asda, if I then complained that the free from item was not suitable (even having accepted it at the door) they would refund it.
you can choose no subs, and even no subs on certain items.

You really cannot expect the picker or driver to know what it is you want or need. How do they know that you are buying an item because it is vegan, or because you have a particular allergy?

Even if you could mark your order as eg Vegan only, many pickers wouldn't know if something fitted that.

Glittertwins · 15/03/2022 08:19

I've spoken to Tesco about this kind of substitution before and suggested that they sort out their computer programming to cater for this as they told me the pickers only go on what they are told by the handset.
This I can believe as I have gone immediately to the shop after getting a delivery that was missing stuff and found it on a different shelf - if the picker had used common sense, they'd have seen it.
We can always tell if a parent or older person has picked our stuff because the computer subs are overridden and we get a sensible change

RealRaymondReddington · 15/03/2022 08:09

With the Tesco app you can tick substitute or do not substitute for each item once in the basket. For example, I always do this for shampoo as my dd can only use a certain brand. Next time just tick this box for all the free from items so you know you will only get what you ordered.