Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask how anyone else copes being overcrowded?

295 replies

Lemontree1 · 14/03/2022 20:12

I am in an overcrowded very small 2 bed privately rented flat with 3 children.
The bedrooms are tiny.
To envisage how small the bedrooms are, a double bed can fit but nothing else maybe a bedside table, but no chest of drawers, or any other furniture.
According to the council, My 3 children are expected to share one of these bedrooms and myself in another room.
I can’t make them all share, as there physically isnt enough room to fit 3 beds in one room with all their toys, or any other furniture. (We don’t have vast amounts of stuff but 3 children combined do have a significant amount, and I am constantly decluttering)
So, I sleep downstairs on the sofa.
we are all on top of each other there is no where for me to escape and my mental health has been deteriorating for years now.
I have been told that I am not a priority and that there are bigger families in a one bed flat.
I don’t want anything fancy, just a room and a bed to myself and somewhere I can have time to myself.
I can’t get anywhere else privately as I can’t afford it, I work,but rent prices are high and I just can’t afford more than I already pay. I can’t work full time at least until my youngest boys are in school.
I am so claustrophobic and although I try my best this affects my parenting.
Also, for reference I have twins and a singleton. My children’s ages are 3,3 and 12. All boys, so apparently can all share until they are 16.

Is there anyone else in a similar situation? How do you manage to cope? I just feel like I can’t cope much longer, but have no idea how to get out of this situation.

OP posts:
LadyPropane · 15/03/2022 20:50

I'm taken aback that a PP has referred to three brothers sharing a bedroom as "appalling cramped conditions". I know it's nice for kids to all have their own room if you have space for that, but it's totally normal for siblings to share a room. MN is painfully snobby at times. People do the best with what they have, and if you honestly think that 3 boys sharing a bedroom is "appalling" then you really need to get out more.

Lemontree1 · 15/03/2022 20:36

@Cookiecrumble22

Its almost impossible to find a landlord that will take people on who need help with their rent. Even if op could find a home . She's then got to fund a month's rent and the months deposit then moving costs on top . If she then had to give up her job due to moving to far she would then end uo on full benefits. Its not that easy to just find another job.

I'm in zone 3 . I have more children than the op. When I was working I got quite alot of help.

Thank you! Finally someone said it, i mention I get help with my rent, single mum 3 kids and I’ve honestly seen so many agents facial expression change and dismiss me. Suddenly their tone will change. I’ve had so many agents/ landlords tell me they will call me back, which has never happened, and if I’ve ever tried to chase anyone I’ve been made to feel like I’m aggravating them. I’ve even had one agent tell me they’ve had more important people to deal with. It’s soul destroying and you start to give up, because you think it’s impossible and you feel like a piece of shit, being looked down on.

I work as much as I physically can right now, I have no extra childcare so have to stay within nursery hours.
I pay all rent on time and keep my property nice.
I didn’t think things would turn out the way they have, I didn’t think I’d become a single mother.

But if we all didn’t do things because certain people might change their minds or certain things could happen then we wouldn’t do anything.

OP posts:
Cookiecrumble22 · 15/03/2022 18:51

Its almost impossible to find a landlord that will take people on who need help with their rent. Even if op could find a home . She's then got to fund a month's rent and the months deposit then moving costs on top . If she then had to give up her job due to moving to far she would then end uo on full benefits. Its not that easy to just find another job.

I'm in zone 3 . I have more children than the op. When I was working I got quite alot of help.

carefullycourageous · 15/03/2022 18:47

@AHungryCaterpillar we are repeating ourselves now, I accept the OP can move - that is why I suggested if she is going to to get on with it - my overall position remains the same that UK housing policy is shite and it is not right that people are priced out of inner London. Those areas are where people grew up too.

AHungryCaterpillar · 15/03/2022 18:38

[quote carefullycourageous]@AHungryCaterpillar it is very hard for people if they move away from their support networks. I personally do not think people should be forced out, but accept this country is shite when it comes to housing policy.[/quote]
Again she doesn’t have to leave London but a cheaper area will work better, it’s up to the op to decide whether a cheaper area will be better and more space or a more expensive area with less space.

AHungryCaterpillar · 15/03/2022 18:37

But your making assumptions. She has not said she lives in London. Also making assumptions about his London councils work. They are all different. I live in London and I know other people in London. That are on low wages and get help with their rent so they can stay in London. Say for example say the rent for a 3 bed is 1400 most, possibly all. would get paid for the person who gets the help depending on their earnings. If a person moves out of London a bit and the rent is 1000. That would also get paid by benefits. The person does not get to keep the 400 extra that the London rent used to cost. So she would be no better off.

I’m making assumptions? erm no I’m not, Croydon council state you need to be lacking 2 bedrooms to be considered as Overcrowded, I’m not “making assumptions” I said certain parts of London are very strict on what they consider over crowded as there is such a shortage of housing, the op has chosen to ignore and hasn’t denied that it’s London so I believe it is.

carefullycourageous · 15/03/2022 18:37

@AHungryCaterpillar it is very hard for people if they move away from their support networks. I personally do not think people should be forced out, but accept this country is shite when it comes to housing policy.

Sceptre86 · 15/03/2022 18:36

You've done the right thing by giving your eldest his own bedroom I would suggest bunk beds with storage underneath and storage you can mount on the wall rather than use precious floorspace eg, bookshelves. I've got storage solutions that hang off the back of doors that I use to hold my kids eczema creams but you can use them to hold art and craft supplies, shoes or socks and underwear.

It's really tough and I feel for you. The only other suggestion I have is trying to partition your living room if you can and be strict about toys and books, when they get new stuff you donate the older, less played with toys to charity.

AHungryCaterpillar · 15/03/2022 18:34

@carefullycourageous

If you are going to move then try to do it sooner rather than later given your elder child's age.

But poor people should be able to live in London too, if it is their home.

No one is saying she can’t live in London, I live in London but zone 2 is extremely different to zone 5.. there are cheaper areas of London.
PeacheyPeach · 15/03/2022 18:34

What a lovely mum you are OP giving up your bedroom for your son 🥰 I think this seems to be the only option in terms of room allocation. So what I would suggest is you keep your clothes in the bigger bedroom, and making the living room area into your bedroom, make it a lovely space with a good quality sofa bed or a nice day bed . Maybe it needs to be decorated in a style that you can still keep it as living room but once kids go to bed you can reclaim it as your bedroom. Maybe get your twins bunk beds so they have a bit more floor space in their room. Facebook market place and freecycle can be really good for picking up bargains and things for free so it doesn't have to cost you a fortune

Cookiecrumble22 · 15/03/2022 18:33

@AHungryCaterpillar

She could move to a cheaper part of London, and if she does live in London it will explain why she isn’t priority to the council as London has much stricter housing policies than other areas, there are councils in London where you can’t even join the housing list, there are other ones where they will only consider you overcrowded if you need 2+ rooms. So yes it does make a difference where she lives.
But your making assumptions. She has not said she lives in London. Also making assumptions about his London councils work. They are all different. I live in London and I know other people in London. That are on low wages and get help with their rent so they can stay in London. Say for example say the rent for a 3 bed is 1400 most, possibly all. would get paid for the person who gets the help depending on their earnings. If a person moves out of London a bit and the rent is 1000. That would also get paid by benefits. The person does not get to keep the 400 extra that the London rent used to cost. So she would be no better off.
carefullycourageous · 15/03/2022 18:29

If you are going to move then try to do it sooner rather than later given your elder child's age.

But poor people should be able to live in London too, if it is their home.

Lemontree1 · 15/03/2022 18:27

I have thought about moving to a different area.
That is of course an option, and I would definitely consider it and may have to do that if I can’t find anything else in my area.
I want my kids to be happy and want my mental health to improve, so if that’s the solution then of course I would do it.

OP posts:
AHungryCaterpillar · 15/03/2022 18:15

She could move to a cheaper part of London, and if she does live in London it will explain why she isn’t priority to the council as London has much stricter housing policies than other areas, there are councils in London where you can’t even join the housing list, there are other ones where they will only consider you overcrowded if you need 2+ rooms. So yes it does make a difference where she lives.

TristramBrandy · 15/03/2022 18:04

I think people are saying she should move from a more expensive area-if she lives in such an area-to one that is less expensive.

The trouble is that she can't have everything-a spacious home for three children-in an expensive area where she has a job and where the children may be settled.

So she has to decide what is the most important factor to her. As the twins are small and the older boy hasn't yet started exam courses, I would move to a less expensive area. It would mean looking for another job and leaving family behind but another job can be found and another support system built.

If she chooses not to move and stays in cramped accommodation then that is only going to become more difficult. The twins will not stay 3 for ever and at some point she will have two 8 year olds and a 17 year old. The eldest boy will have the shit end of the stick-no where to study, no privacy and no bringing friends around.

The choice is up to her but to me it would be a no brainer. I'd go where my children weren't in appalling cramped conditions. No matter what the council say, common sense says it is overcrowded.

I have asked if the dad is paying towards his children and there has been no answer. of course, she doesn't have to answer but it makes me think he isn't, so shaking him down for what he owes would be a good move. Chase him through the courts. He wasn't a dead beat three years ago or the OP wouldn't have chosen to get pregnant by him, so he must have something and she needs to do her best to try and get it.Unless he is dead or in prison, make the fucker pay up.

Do think about moving to where you can get more space for your money. There are schools, hospitals and jobs all over the country and you might even prefer living somewhere else!

wearingtheT · 15/03/2022 17:42

I feel for you OP, but it's not the councils responsibility to house you. Anyone that suggests it is, is living in a fantasy, pre Thatcher world.

if I was you I'd sleep in the lounge and give the children a room each. Ikea do a lovely l shape sofa that converts really quickly.

Cookiecrumble22 · 15/03/2022 17:41

@AHungryCaterpillar

Yes I’ve noticed op has avoided answering where she lives, I’m guessing London and that’s why as she doesn’t want to be told to move somewhere cheaper. Also avoiding answering if the father(s) pay maintenance
It does not matter if op lives in London or not. I don't get why people think London is just for the rich and everyone else should move out. Is London the LHA will be heigher than if op was outside of London. So her rent can still get covered when living in London. Also If ops work is local to her. Then she could loose her job or end up spending more money on travel. Also maybe she feels her children are settled in school/nursery.

(please note op has not said she lives in London)

Yes op has missed a couple of questions but that could be due to being stressed or that people on the thread will use it to have a go at her

Op you said there was a reason your child can't do 30hrs at nursery. I know you don't want to say but if your child has Any special needs look into getting dla as that will give you some extra money . It may also give you some push to get onto the housing list .

MVision · 15/03/2022 17:29

I do feel for you OP and particularly for your 12 year old - he/she has GCSEs around the corner. Are they able to find anywhere to do homework etc.

Bethieboo · 15/03/2022 17:12

www.homehunt.co.uk/what-is-homehunt I hope this helps.

AHungryCaterpillar · 15/03/2022 17:08

Yes I’ve noticed op has avoided answering where she lives, I’m guessing
London and that’s why as she doesn’t want to be told to move somewhere cheaper. Also avoiding answering if the father(s) pay maintenance

NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/03/2022 17:02

@Lemontree1

Also, one of my children can’t go for 30 hours at nursery. I don’t want to go into why not, I’m keeping some information to myself because the reason I started the post was to seek advise, recommendations and talk to others in a similar situation.
I'd like to tell you about the possibility of being accepted onto the register by the council due to needing another bedroom for medical reasons (if you provide them with evidence from the professionals involved in that child's care), but if you wish to keep that information to yourself, I suppose you don't want to know about that.
loislovesstewie · 15/03/2022 16:52

Do you know the measurements of each bedroom? I am wondering if you might be statutorily overcrowded. If you have been to Shelter they may have asked that.

shinynewapple22 · 15/03/2022 16:46

I don't know where you live but is it possible that housing availability is easier in a neighbouring authority ?

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 15/03/2022 16:42

I’ve read your replies, no need to be hostile, not once have you said IM doing X, Y and Z, you’ve said you’ve visited CA and Shelter etc… when posters are asking what your next steps are you’ve been quite defeatist. (Understandably but you need to be proactive in achieving your goal)

Council housing avenue isn’t an option for you, so what’s your next steps in improving your families mental health and housing needs.

Are you on any HA waiting lists? EA lists?

Have you looked into moving out of your area into other council/ HA properties?

Are you saving to improve your housing needs, I previously said this may take years but it’s a goal you can aim towards in seeking to improve your housing needs.

There is loads of working from home data entry jobs for evening work, loads of university students are currently doing this, including my 16 year old son and 19 year old single parent SIL (she’s also n a tiny office studio) and goes to university during the day, however she knows this is only temporary until she finishes her studies.

You have options OP, you just need to want them and be proactive in achieving your goals which will ultimately benefit your mental health and families needs.

Cookiecrumble22 · 15/03/2022 16:40

@Lemontree1

I will explain this once more for anyone who keeps telling me I had more children in an already small flat. I was well aware when I fell pregnant that it would be a squeeze but ow oils have obviously shared with baby until however many years old and then split the biggest room, I have one side and toddler the other. It would have been small but do- able. I don’t want a lot and this would been fine for us all. But, I had twins and I can’t split the rooms with a partician wall and have two children on one side. It’s far too small. I have looked endlessly and still do for a bigger private rent. I can’t realistically afford anything bigger, and if I happen to have found something I know I am judged for my situation, and landlords are not keen to have a single mother on some benefits with 3 children. So, I can’t seem to find anywhere else privately so have asked the council for their assistance, which I think most mothers in my situation would do. I’m not expecting the council to give me a house, I just asked their assistance. They’ve told me the rules and regulations and I am now at a loss of what to do, so asked others advice who may be in a similar situation. I don’t think I’m the only person in my situation, as others have suggested. I know this not to be true, but am desperate for a solution and some sleep. I work all the hours that my boys are at nursery, I have 2 hours to myself in the week.
Please don't think I'm trying to be difficult. I'm just trying to help. I'm in a similar situation. I have 5yr old and 6yr old and my 15 year old all in one room. I know your said you could have divide a room if you had not had twins . Now that you do it's harder as there 2 little ones rather than 1 plus your older child so 3 children in all.

My set up is this. I have floor to ceiling room dividers that are removable. One side where the 5 and 6 year old sleep they have bunk beds. Which are narrow than the standard 3ft beds . They are 2.5 wide instead. Between the side of the bed and the wall is around 2 foot. So they literally just have room to get in and out . They do not spend any time in the room . They just sleep in there. Their clothes are kept in a separate cupboard on the landing. Their toys are kept in the living room in a large box. The 15 year old has the other side his side is a typical teen room. I do have other rooms but my other children are in them rooms. I sleep in my living room on a sofa bed. But in your case you could have a bedroom for yourself if you could divide the bedroom. Sadly there's not a perfect solution.

Because you now have 3 children and not just one you would get more help towards the rent . But I totally understand about how landlords /estate agents will hardly ever take people who Need help with their rent. Have you tried open rent?

I hope you manage to find a way that works for you . Flowers

Swipe left for the next trending thread