Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect 4 year to go toilet alone

38 replies

Yumchips · 14/03/2022 18:54

Just wondering if it's developmentally still normal for 4 year to refuse to go toilet alone at home? 4 year old is fully potty trained, never had poo anxiety etc no accidents since 2.5 years old. Just wondered if I'm expecting too much of her. She expects me to drop everything when she needs the loo and feels like a waste of time when I'm busy making dinner etc. I know probably seems to trivial but grates on me as 8 months pregnant atm and a bit grumpy with her constant demands over various stuff. She will refuse to go if I don't accompany her and proceed to cry/tantrum.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RealBecca · 16/03/2022 13:10

Can you take her and wander off? Like oh I just need to get more loo roll...oh dear mummy needs to pop out to turn the oven on....just see how she reacts and increase the time.

Or ask her to come with you everytime you need to go Wink

Snowisfallinghere · 16/03/2022 13:08

Mine does this too, I don't think it's fear of something in the bathroom, because once he's on the loo he wants me to leave and give him privacy! I think he just finds it hard pulling his own trousers down, especially because he will only go to the loo if he has them completely off and not just pulled down, and he has this psychological block against doing it alone, he seems to genuinely think he needs my help.

TBH I am of the 'pick your battles' mentality and I don't think it's worth having a big battle with them over this. It's easier to just go along with it, they grow out of it sooner or later. I save the battles for more serious things like bad behaviour.

Dahlietta · 16/03/2022 13:05

Mine says "I don't want you to come when I need a poo, but I do want you to come when I need a wee" Yeah, great. He doesn't need my assistance at all, just wants me there. I do usually get a post-wee cuddle though so that's something.

Wilkolampshade · 16/03/2022 11:57

Oof @NameChanged15729 that's REALLY tough, you have my sympathy. No advice, (sorry) but I can't imagine he'll be doing it when he's 18 though, so if it's any comfort at all I guess it'll pass....

DockOTheBay · 16/03/2022 11:41

Could you give her something to do while she's on the loo so she doesn't get bored/lonely. Like listening to the radio or reading a book?

FateHasRedesignedMost · 16/03/2022 11:40

My 6 year old often wants me to accompany him to the loo because he’s scared of spiders, monsters etc. We usually compromise by me checking the loo is ‘safe’ (no spider in sink etc). If I’m busy I put light on, quick check and reassure him I’m nearby.

I’ve noticed it happens more when he’s over tired, unwell, just woken up or is worried about something. Sometimes he’ll insist I come in with him then share his worries so maybe your daughter sees it as a safe space for 1:1 time?

FreeButtonBee · 14/03/2022 21:06

My 6 yo went through a phase for about 3 months of wanting company or at Keats so when to stand outside the door. He got a fright at some point and frankly it was easier to be low key about it and say yes than fight it. It was mostly at home - school was fine - and he’d ask a sibling if we weren’t around. He’s grown out of it now. The less you comment the sooner it will pass. I found being quite boring while accompanying helped so he didn’t get used to an ‘active’ companion!

liquidrevolution · 14/03/2022 21:01

My 7 year old still likes company. She does her own wiping etc so im just needed to chatter to Confused. I think its my magnetic personality Grin Plus we dont have a downstairs loo.

seaduck · 14/03/2022 20:50

My 5 year old still wants me to come. We've managed to compromise now by me being able to stand at the bottom of the stairs (I don't know why that helps, but he seems more comfortable do I'll go with it!).

AmyandPhilipfan · 14/03/2022 20:49

My daughter’s 4 years and 9 months and it’s just in the last month or so she’s started being happy to take herself to the toilet. I think what did it for her was her best friend, who visits often, goes alone and also she went to the birthday party of a child turning 3 and that child went to the toilet alone. So I think she realised that actually she could do it too. She does still call me to wipe her if she’s had a poo and she still likes to be fully dressed by me. I’ve told her she’s got til she’s 5 and then she’s putting her own clothes on every day!

FairyCakeWings · 14/03/2022 20:36

Is there anything about your toilet that an imaginative child might find a bit creepy? Or is it quite far away from you in the house?

Just asking because I remember being little and perfectly capable of using the toilet alone, but I hated using our downstairs toilet alone. I don’t remember what it was, but there was something creepy about it in my 4 year old head!

NameChanged15729 · 14/03/2022 20:28

I’m feeling really miserable now. My ds is 6 and will not go to the toilet unless I accompany him. He wet himself three times the other day because he demanded to go when I was feeding the baby. I also have to wipe him and he won’t sit on the toilet for a poo. He stands on it and squats over it like a frog. He also fully strips to go to the toilet, all windows must be shut and the toilet needs to be flushed before he goes and after. But I have to be the one to flush it. It’s hard work.

Sorry, I needed to vent. It’s really getting me down at the moment. I’m fed up of being made to go through this palaver several times a day. And it’s always when I’ve just managed to have a sit down after hours of cleaning/laundry etc.

Whatamess582 · 14/03/2022 20:19

One of mine wanted company right up til 6 and my other was due to go alone as soon as he potty trained at 3

CatDogMonkeyPOW · 14/03/2022 19:26

Both of mine went through a phase of that age of being afraid to go anywhere in the house alone. It's when their imaginations start to develop.

JenniferBarkley · 14/03/2022 19:24

Oh, and when we wanted her to move from the potty to the toilet we bribed with chocolate buttons which was reasonably successful, you might want to try something like that if it's something you'd like sorted before the baby comes.

Yumchips · 14/03/2022 19:24

Thank you everyone - sorry ran out of steam to tag you all now! Very grateful for your responses and lots of prepare for with baby coming!!

OP posts:
JenniferBarkley · 14/03/2022 19:23

Mine is nearly 4 and goes perfectly well by herself at nursery (both a nursery school and a day care nursery, so two settings) but wants help at home. I think it's just an attention thing, we're encouraging but trying not to stress since she can actually do it.

MarchingOnTogether · 14/03/2022 19:20

It sounds like it's just her way of getting your attention, which is perfectly normal for a child of her age.
If you want her to go on her own be positive about it, tell her what a big clever girl she is and see if she can make you super proud etc etc... Kids just love the spotlight, at the moment she gets that by insisting you go with her but you just have to flip it so she gets the attention by doing it your way

NellWilsonsWhiteHair · 14/03/2022 19:20

My just-four often wants/needs me to go with her at home, although like yours she’s been easily dry for two years and manages fine at nursery etc. Sometimes she goes by herself - I think basically because she’s forgotten she’d like to bother me for company 😂

I roll with it as I think babying them when they seem to be asking for that is usually the right thing and no worse for getting to where you want to get to (ie I don’t think they actually grow out of needy phases more quickly when we put our efforts into ‘training’ them) - but she’s my second child and I’m not pregnant, so it’s easier for me to smile indulgently!

I don’t think either of you are being particularly unreasonable. It’s within the bounds of normal and it will pass, but it is annoying to be continually and urgently interrupted. Cake

negomi90 · 14/03/2022 19:17

But if she wants it that's ok. She wants you there, she wants you to look after her, especially at 4 with a lot of changes. I'm sure she's in the process of doing a lot of growing up this year, school a new baby. Lots of big things happening. She wants the security of knowing that mummy is there and mummy will look after her and make her feel safe and secure if she wants it.
There's nothing wrong with a child asking for attention or asking for care.
I know its annoying, but you have nothing to loose by taking her, and everything to gain by responding to whatever hidden needs she has which is causing her to ask for you to go.
Obviously if you are in a tricky point of cooking/doing something you really can't stop, you tell her that you can't come now, but will come in 5mins (however long it will be). But otherwise the more you respond to easy needs (which don't cost anything other than time) the more secure she'll be and the less she'll be doing it.

Yumchips · 14/03/2022 19:17

@DoloresOnTheDottedLine thank you and I know you are right - we are lucky and in the grand scheme are doing well and lucky to have no accidents. Just need to get over the slight inconvenience to me!!

OP posts:
LoveWillOvercome · 14/03/2022 19:17

We went through this with our eldest from when second was due. She wants to know she is still your baby too that you will help her and be her mum still too. It's her way of saying I'm feeling scared about this whole situation and I need to feel connected to you.

It IS bloody annoying but she's tiny and worried about losing her mum to the baby.

Welcome to the new juggle where the eldest may do this a lot if she feels less connected to you.

Good luck!

Bigoldmachine · 14/03/2022 19:16

Mine was like this and lots better now (still has her moments). It actually got a bit worse when her baby brother arrived. I think she just wanted to know I was still there for her. Of course she usually picked a wildly inconvenient moment when I was feeding or changing or comforting the baby to announce she neeeeeeded me in the loo. Many many times I held the baby with one hand, him hanging off a boob while I kept her company in the loo. It’ll all be ok. She’ll get there eventually. Up to you but I wouldn’t pick this to battle about!

Yumchips · 14/03/2022 19:14

@GetOffTheFrog sorry that made me laugh out loud for a second - cute!

OP posts:
Idontevenknow · 14/03/2022 19:14

It's developmentally normal, she just wants extra support. It'll pass. Just keep encouraging her

Swipe left for the next trending thread