Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emily Oster on Breastfeeding - minimal benefits.

822 replies

IamOvercome · 14/03/2022 13:02

I am pregnant with my first and am an economist so I was recommended books by fellow economist Emily Oster. The books don’t give advice. They review the statistical studies underlying pregnancy advice and whether they are any good or not.

It’s been such an eye opener. For example it is pushed pushed and pushed some more that breast is best. But when you review the evidence there is minimal evidence for benefits of breastfeeding for babies. The strongest evidence is actually for mothers that it can marginally reduce chance of breast cancer in later life.

Same with not introducing babies to bottle to confuse them when breastfeeding. Literally no concrete evidence for it.

Yet this is all pushed as clear cut facts by midwives and other health professionals.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
LittleGwyneth · 14/03/2022 14:32

I think what EO understands, which isn't always pointed out, is that in the Western world, especially in the US where she is based, being able to breastfeed beyond the first couple of months hinges on so much other privilege. If you you breastfeed your baby for a year it means that you've been able to take a year at home with your baby, which in turn often means that you've got probably got more money and more support.

Middle class mothers are more likely to breastfeed for a multitude of reasons, which clouded the data about outcomes for a long time.

I really enjoyed Expecting Better in the sense that I felt it was free from judgement. I understand that some parents feel that it undermines their achievement in breastfeeding but I really don't think that is the intention.

bigbluebear1 · 14/03/2022 14:32

www.nhs.uk/conditions/baby/breastfeeding-and-bottle-feeding/breastfeeding/benefits/

it’s right there:

“Breastfeeding has long-term benefits for your baby, lasting right into adulthood.

Any amount of breast milk has a positive effect. The longer you breastfeed, the longer the protection lasts and the greater the benefits.

Breastfeeding can help to reduce your baby's risk of:

infections, with fewer visits to hospital as a result
diarrhoea and vomiting, with fewer visits to hospital as a result
sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS)
obesity
cardiovascular disease in adulthood
Some studies have also found that breastfeeding for at least 6 months may reduce your baby's chance of getting childhood leukaemia.”

but yeah, cow & gate is no different right? Hmm

MrsMingech · 14/03/2022 14:32

@SnowdropViolet

Bottle-feeding involves both arms - one to hold the bottle, one to hold the baby.

Breast feeding only requires one arm, to hold the baby. Leaving the other arm free to hold a book, type one-handed, snack etc etc.

You can take a breast fed baby into a lecture, knowing that if they start to whinge you can just plug them on for instant silence, while you continue to take notes.

Breast fed babies are staring straight at your breast, so you don't need to make eye-contact or interact with them. Which lets you concentrate on good books or crap TV.

I don't think I'd have got my degree if I had bottle-fed.

I love this Grin
IamOvercome · 14/03/2022 14:29

@Bananabutter

What a load of nonsense, OP.

If you don’t want to breastfeed then don’t. That’s okay. But don’t try and feed yourself a load of rubbish to make yourself feel better about not doing so and alleviate your own personal guilt.

Again @Bananabutter please provide evidence breast is best?
OP posts:
AgathaMystery · 14/03/2022 14:29

Nipple confusion was disproved years ago. Literally about a decade ago. More even.

Bringsexyback · 14/03/2022 14:29

I would imagine that breastfeeding is quite bad for the economy on the basis that we can’t be flogged a load of rubbish we may not need in different colours God forbid a baby boy should be given a pink bottle and vice versa.

Obviously other posters are touched on the point that the mother‘s nutrition is going to be paramount. Purely from getting enough hours in the day to make sure my baby actually got fed by the time I got to number three breastfeeding was a lifesaver.

IamOvercome · 14/03/2022 14:29

@bigbluebear1

if you don’t want to breastfeed you don’t have to. you don’t have to convince yourself it’s just as good for baby to formula feed as it is to breastfeed - breast IS best, but you don’t need a book saying it isn’t to make you feel better about your choice. just do whatever you want with your baby.
Can you provide me with a peer reviewed study that shows this? One that properly controls for socioeconomic and familial characteristics. Or is it just your opinion @bigbluebear1 ?
OP posts:
GalactatingGoddess · 14/03/2022 14:28

I think it also depends on the country. If you are in a country where there aren't means of sterilising bottles properly/storing baby milk powder properly and in date or not enough money to buy enough baby milk then yes, breast is significantly better because the damage to your baby from poor hygiene and not getting enough to eat....
However in the UK and other well developed countries the benefits might be less easy to quantify.

However, anecdotally for me:

PROS:
Cuddly soft squidgy time with baby and watching their little face go sleepy on the breast is beautiful.
Easy when going out - nothing to pack except me!
Quick! In the night can just whip out the breasts.
Financially cheaper
Breastfeeding high! (It was like being all blissed out and wobbly in the head after a feed)

CONS:
Emotionally overwhelming as a first time mum to have to be the sole feeder.
Painful for the first few weeks.
Engorged boobs are a 👎🏽
The gross/outdated/sexist opinions and looks of others.

I didn't put night feeds in there as a con because actually yes, partner can help with this and DH did help by passing me baby and getting me night snacks.

Bananabutter · 14/03/2022 14:28

What a load of nonsense, OP.

If you don’t want to breastfeed then don’t. That’s okay. But don’t try and feed yourself a load of rubbish to make yourself feel better about not doing so and alleviate your own personal guilt.

Villagewaspbyke · 14/03/2022 14:28

@EarlGreywithLemon yes but often less time (especially if someone is struggling to breastfeed) and it doesn’t have to be the mother who does it all the time so she can rest.

BenjiMcSchmenzie · 14/03/2022 14:27

@Babdoc

The real benefits of breast feeding only apply in the third world, where formula is made up with dirty water from unchlorinated sources, causing diarrhoea and deaths in infants. Here in the UK, it makes damn all difference, and as a doctor I am delighted that a credible statistician has finally published this. Perhaps we can now see the end of poor depressed mothers beating themselves up for “failing” to breast feed. A mafia of midwives and breast feeding mothers has controlled the narrative for far too long, to the detriment of women. Feed your baby by whatever method best suits you, secure in the knowledge that your way is as good as any other. And don’t let anyone guilt trip or pressure you.
I think I love you
Villagewaspbyke · 14/03/2022 14:26

@Twizbe in my case, the pressure to breastfeed was from the NHS, NCT and general society. Same for most of my friends

Summerfun54321 · 14/03/2022 14:25

Who are the pool of people being researched for this? I thought it was common knowledge that pregnancy/newborn baby research is crap because so few people want to actually take part. All here raise your hands if you agreed to intrusive and continuous investigations of your child for the purpose of scientific research, anyone?!

Teastheword · 14/03/2022 14:25

@Maray1967

Makes sense to me. Ideally you’d breastfeed but I don’t have any concerns that it didn’t work out for me. What you eat in pregnancy and how you wean baby matter far more. There ought to be health benefits but there are significant downsides and if mums are exhausted then it’s not going to go well. There are a lot of posts on here about babies feeding through the night well past 6 months - I’m just incredulous. How on earth can you function normally ?
I could "function normally" as it's normal to breastfeed well past six months.
Tilltheend99 · 14/03/2022 14:23

I presume that book weighs up a range of factors to come to that conclusion and is rather biased to what the author thinks is important.

There should be no shame in however a woman wants to feed her baby but let’s not use false ‘facts’ to justify not breastfeeding. Amongst other things breastfeeding is proven to reduce the risk of SIDS by half which is quite a significant amount. www.lullabytrust.org.uk/safer-sleep-advice/breastfeeding/

EarlGreywithLemon · 14/03/2022 14:23

@Villagewaspbyke but formula feeding also takes time!

bigbluebear1 · 14/03/2022 14:23

if you don’t want to breastfeed you don’t have to. you don’t have to convince yourself it’s just as good for baby to formula feed as it is to breastfeed - breast IS best, but you don’t need a book saying it isn’t to make you feel better about your choice. just do whatever you want with your baby.

Teastheword · 14/03/2022 14:23

@Villagewaspbyke

Also something that concerns me is the nonsense that if a baby is breastfed it must be “getting all it needs”. Clearly that not true. Breastfed babies can be dehydrated or hungry like any other babies (and indeed as it’s more difficult to see what they have had, probably it’s more likely)
That's not what that means. It means that breastmilk contains all the fluid and nutrients a baby needs. But obviously not if you don't feed it often enough!

Of course It is not more likely that breastfed babies are routinely more hungry and thirsty than bottle fed babies! Yes you can more easily measure how much a milk bottle baby has had, but what does that actually tell you?

Villagewaspbyke · 14/03/2022 14:22

@sevensleeps - the point was to explain the saying about womens time being worth something. If you wanted to spend time breastfeeding and you think it was good for your mental health, go you! But it’s not free and it’s not for everyone.

EarlGreywithLemon · 14/03/2022 14:21

@sevensleeps I also found sterilising bottles stressful, time consuming and tiring so tried expressing just twice and gave up. I was lucky that breastfeeding was easy for us.
So I don’t see formula feeding as “taking the easy way out” - not at all. I think it’s harder work than breastfeeding IF the breastfeeding works well. So no judgement here on how people feed their child - but claiming breastfeeding is hard and time consuming and formula feeding is not is missleading.

Twizbe · 14/03/2022 14:19

@sevensleeps totally agree with this.

I had a nightmare with my eldest and weight gain. I was under so much pressure to formula feed and no one listened to me when I said it made him sick. It was awful until he was finally diagnosed with CMPA at 16 weeks. I'm so grateful to the support I had to keep breastmilk in his diet as that didn't make him sick.

With my second, the idea of giving her formula terrified me in case she was also allergic. For my mental health EBF was soooooooooooooooooooo much better.

SnowdropViolet · 14/03/2022 14:18

@Iamovercome

I'm not suggesting that my experience of breastfeeding wasn't primarily for my own benefit. It puzzles me that there is so much focus on the benefits to the baby and so little advice of the "breastfeeding is great if you can't be arsed with the faff of sterilising bottles" variety.

I think it may be a feminist issue - women conditioned into not considering their own needs. At the end if the day, if a baby is warm, fed and loved, the actual mechanics of feeding are secondary. But for me, breast feeding was brilliant - I could do the night feeds without switching a light on, and get straight back to sleep afterwards. I didn't have to pack bottles etc for a day out. I could, and did, feed anywhere. My periods didn't come back for over a year, which was a major win!

Maray1967 · 14/03/2022 14:18

Makes sense to me. Ideally you’d breastfeed but I don’t have any concerns that it didn’t work out for me. What you eat in pregnancy and how you wean baby matter far more.
There ought to be health benefits but there are significant downsides and if mums are exhausted then it’s not going to go well. There are a lot of posts on here about babies feeding through the night well past 6 months - I’m just incredulous. How on earth can you function normally ?

Villagewaspbyke · 14/03/2022 14:17

Also something that concerns me is the nonsense that if a baby is breastfed it must be “getting all it needs”. Clearly that not true. Breastfed babies can be dehydrated or hungry like any other babies (and indeed as it’s more difficult to see what they have had, probably it’s more likely)

IamOvercome · 14/03/2022 14:17

@sevensleeps again this is a benefit to you not to the baby.

Thanks for the book recommendations. Just downloaded them to my kindle.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread