Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emily Oster on Breastfeeding - minimal benefits.

822 replies

IamOvercome · 14/03/2022 13:02

I am pregnant with my first and am an economist so I was recommended books by fellow economist Emily Oster. The books don’t give advice. They review the statistical studies underlying pregnancy advice and whether they are any good or not.

It’s been such an eye opener. For example it is pushed pushed and pushed some more that breast is best. But when you review the evidence there is minimal evidence for benefits of breastfeeding for babies. The strongest evidence is actually for mothers that it can marginally reduce chance of breast cancer in later life.

Same with not introducing babies to bottle to confuse them when breastfeeding. Literally no concrete evidence for it.

Yet this is all pushed as clear cut facts by midwives and other health professionals.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
pantjog · 14/03/2022 16:36

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

DomesticatedZombie · 14/03/2022 16:36

@Ilostit

God this is an eye opener for me! Still feeling the guilt of not BFeeding
Flowers I'm really sorry to hear that. Women should be far better supported.
ancientgran · 14/03/2022 16:35

@RowanAlong

Where is this ‘mafia of midwives and breastfeeding mothers’? Not in my experience at all. I was a breastfeeding mother, and kept quiet about it, largely because what appeared to be a very touchy bottle-feeding ‘mafia’ around me always had something to say about it. Each to their own, but really, why do we need to be so down on breastfeeding? It’s what breasts are for!
Particularly if you feed beyond 1 yr, even more after 2 years. I could never understand why people thought it was appropriate to pull faces and make vomiting gestures.
Poppy709 · 14/03/2022 16:33

Also, as I understand it evidence doesn’t have to be statistically significant to be relevant. Just because something isn’t totally quantifiable, doesn’t mean it isn’t valuable.

DustyEarle · 14/03/2022 16:32

@beattieedny

Gonna come back once you've given birth and tell us all about statistics, yeah? Bet you end up feeding him/her until at least two and become evangelical about it. Trust me, the hormones are fucking brilliant. Best high I've had since the illegal raves of the 90s. Es don't have a look in compared to the massive dump of oxytocin you get latching a baby on.
This.
ancientgran · 14/03/2022 16:31

[quote SnowdropViolet]@Iamovercome

I'm not suggesting that my experience of breastfeeding wasn't primarily for my own benefit. It puzzles me that there is so much focus on the benefits to the baby and so little advice of the "breastfeeding is great if you can't be arsed with the faff of sterilising bottles" variety.

I think it may be a feminist issue - women conditioned into not considering their own needs. At the end if the day, if a baby is warm, fed and loved, the actual mechanics of feeding are secondary. But for me, breast feeding was brilliant - I could do the night feeds without switching a light on, and get straight back to sleep afterwards. I didn't have to pack bottles etc for a day out. I could, and did, feed anywhere. My periods didn't come back for over a year, which was a major win![/quote]
I agree. I always thought breastfeeding was so little effort once you get it established. Not to mention living on a steep hill and getting snowed in for a couple of weeks and not worrying about running out of formula.

Ozanj · 14/03/2022 16:31

Underway not underwear.

Ozanj · 14/03/2022 16:31

[quote elbea]@Ozanj you can’t ethically study breastfeeding comparative to formula feeding so we won’t ever see proper research into the issue.[/quote]
There are genetic studies being started. A former googler has already identified a specific gene associated with longevity that benefits from breastmilk in hispanic and Asian populationd - but futher studies are underwear and it’s likely the recommendation to bf will definitely be data driven in the next 5-10 years.

Sarahcoggles · 14/03/2022 16:30

And as others have said, sadly books like this sound like "defensive formula feeding mother with a chip on her shoulder, trying to justify her choices", when in fact no one needs to justify their feeding choices. Live and let live!

roarfeckingroarr · 14/03/2022 16:30

Breast is best. It boosts your baby's immune system, it's amazing for comfort and bonding, it's natural, it's free.

Why wouldn't you try it? If you can't or don't like it, stop.

Poppy709 · 14/03/2022 16:29

Haven’t read the full thread but does she discuss the research into SIDS? The lullaby trust advises that breastfeeding (doesn’t have to be exclusive) halves the risk of SIDS. Yes that is still very small numbers but it was enough for me to try my absolute hardest to breastfeed.

Bayersoak · 14/03/2022 16:29

"That quote,
*
breastfeeding is only cheaper if we don't value women's time.*

What an ugly view of motherhood, and of life generally. As if when feeding / nurturing her baby, a woman is making a bad use of her time."

Quite agree, what a sad indictment of modern society 😔

Ilostit · 14/03/2022 16:29

God this is an eye opener for me! Still feeling the guilt of not BFeeding

Ozanj · 14/03/2022 16:29

@Halllyup17

Anybody can find studies and statistics to prove anything. Doesn't mean it's true.

Breastfeeding is best for babies. End of.

Exactly. Especially when it comes to formula which is more studied than Breastmilk precisely because it can kill babies when prepared incorrectly (while breastmilk can’t).
Sarahcoggles · 14/03/2022 16:27

OP I think if you're going to try and make parenting decisions based on proven statistical outcomes you're going to have a long hard road ahead of you. Life is not stats. Babies/children are hugely complex and variable, and you have to make adjustments and modifications as you go along.

I know that's not exactly what your post was about, but I sense that you are approaching motherhood in a textbook-led manner, and I would strongly advise against that! You will set yourself up to feel a failure.

Crimesean · 14/03/2022 16:27

@MadameDragon

She’s an economist rather than in the medical field and where she’s writing on topics I have worked on she makes lots of errors so I have to assume the other chapters are similarly affected. I like the research driven approach but it should be written by someone in the field.
This. She's ok, but not a medic, and not even a very good economist.
elbea · 14/03/2022 16:26

@Ozanj you can’t ethically study breastfeeding comparative to formula feeding so we won’t ever see proper research into the issue.

Ozanj · 14/03/2022 16:25

@RowanAlong

Where is this ‘mafia of midwives and breastfeeding mothers’? Not in my experience at all. I was a breastfeeding mother, and kept quiet about it, largely because what appeared to be a very touchy bottle-feeding ‘mafia’ around me always had something to say about it. Each to their own, but really, why do we need to be so down on breastfeeding? It’s what breasts are for!
Exactly. Every anti-breastfeeding thread on MN has been started by a bottle feeder.
RowanAlong · 14/03/2022 16:24

Where is this ‘mafia of midwives and breastfeeding mothers’? Not in my experience at all. I was a breastfeeding mother, and kept quiet about it, largely because what appeared to be a very touchy bottle-feeding ‘mafia’ around me always had something to say about it. Each to their own, but really, why do we need to be so down on breastfeeding? It’s what breasts are for!

Halllyup17 · 14/03/2022 16:24

Anybody can find studies and statistics to prove anything. Doesn't mean it's true.

Breastfeeding is best for babies. End of.

2bazookas · 14/03/2022 16:22

Any relation to Ostermilk ? The baby formula manufacturer.

AliceAbsolum · 14/03/2022 16:20

What about caffeine and miscarriage please?

HereBdragons · 14/03/2022 16:19

Going from a 13% chance of a diarrhea type illness in the first year to a 6% chance doesn’t sound that marginal to me. It’s over a 50% reduction. That seems hugely significant.
When they do get sick, I find breastfeeding is hugely reassuring. A couple of times when my toddler was ill and refusing all food and all liquids other than breastfeeds, I did feel like the breastmilk was the only thing keeping us out of A&E with dehydration. I would be interested to know if breastfeeding helps avoid hospital treatment for dehydration in the case of gastro-intestinal illness or things like hand foot and mouth and tonsillitis.

Ozanj · 14/03/2022 16:18

@IamOvercome

It’s not about finding research that supports her view it’s about showing how outrageously flawed a lot of the research is and how the conclusions are not valid.

If someone came into my university/ workplace with a paper on how caffeine causes miscarriage but didn’t control for sickness which is correlated with high HCG and thus healthier pregnancies or a study on the benefits of breastfeeding v formula that didn’t match on familial charactierierics they would be laughed out of the room and absolutely slaughtered for presenting such flawed results yet somehow much of it has been accepted into mainstream.

But nobody has studied the benefits of breastfeeding in a scientific way in the same way that formula has been studied. That’s the point Emily Oster has made. She wants to see more scientific research on breastfeeding.
sHREDDIES19 · 14/03/2022 16:18

Very interesting indeed and something I have thought all along. I recall the horrid midwife calling me 'mean mummy' in the hospital with my first dc for not wanting to breastfeed at all. Good job I was confident and assured in my choice to FF as this I'm sure could have had a very negative impact on others. The whole subject is so loaded, we do need to just let women decide quietly and leave it at that.